2016 David Gemmell Awards Longlists

Longlists for The David Gemmell Awards For Fantasy — the Legend, Morningstar, and Ravenheart Awards — have been posted. The awards recognize the best in fantasy fiction and artwork. Open voting to determine the finalists has begun and will continue until midnight on Friday June 24.

Next, voting on the shortlist will open midday on Friday July 8 and close at midnight on Friday August 19. The awards will be presented September 24 at Fantasycon in Scarborough, UK.

LEGEND AWARD

The Legend Award, is presented to the fantasy title judged the year’s best by open vote.

MORNINGSTAR AWARD

The Morningstar Award honors the author judged to have made the year’s best debut in fantasy fiction.

RAVENHEART AWARD

The Ravenheart Award is given to the creator of the year’s best fantasy book cover art.

22 thoughts on “2016 David Gemmell Awards Longlists

  1. Wow. When they say “longlist”, they mean “longlist”. But how is anyone to read fifty novels between now and June 24? I mean, I read rapidly; I can usually manage two or so novels a week. I’ve read <counting> six of them already, so that’s only 44 novels to go. In 31 days. With breaks for, oh, I dunno. Sleeping. And eating. And going to work…

    I just don’t see how I can possibly give an informed vote on this award.

  2. Voting for the downselection from long list to short list seems to be “pick one for each of the three categories”. I don’t see any statement on how long the short lists will be, but I could have missed it. It may be that the administrators will use their judgement, based on the votes they get.

  3. Cassy B: At this stage they’re winnowing the field to create a shortlist — you can only vote for one item under each award anyway. The sophist’s approach to defining “favorite” might be the way to go — treat whatever you have read as eligible to be your favorite, and eliminate everything else.

  4. To be fair, if the Ravenheart Award is for “the fantasy title judged the year’s best”, then you don’t have to read the book, just the title. I’m rather fond of the title “The Flotsam Trilogy Omnibus”, myself. Dunno if the books live up to it or not….

    (edit) Ooh! Fifth!

  5. David Shallcross: Last year there were five items shortlisted for each award. Five being the magic number, I’m confident they’ll do that again…

  6. Andrew M.: It looks like the longlists are created from publisher submissions, augmented by public suggestions — see this post on Facebook.

    Self-published works are not considered.

  7. I note that the Sekrit Tor Cabal utterly failed to get any works at all on any of these longlists. Why, it’s almost as though there was no Sekrit Tor Cabal….

  8. I perceive a startling lack of titles from “the greatest living author”. Somewhither couldn’t crack the top 50?

  9. Kind of bizarre that there are only six titles on the Morningstar longlist. Were there so few debuts worthy of this award? Or at least, submitted for this award?

    The Gemmell Awards are British-based, so I suppose that could have winnowed the pool. But still . . . only six?

  10. It was a good year for Fantasy. The Fifth Season, The Mechanical, A Crown For Cold Iron, The Autumn Republic, Half a War, Shadows of Self and Uprooted were all books I found to be really great reads. I thought Son of the Black Sword’s covert art better than the usual trying too hard for nostalgia of other Baen works but I’m amazed it was considered award worthy.

  11. I’ve only read 6 of the longlist so far — but I think any one of 5 of those winning would be justified.

    It’s really nice to see Twelve Kings in Sharakhai and The Mechanical getting some love.

    But what the hell are they thinking, not having a single page with thumbnails of all the cover nominees? People are supposed to click on 39 different links???

  12. @Matt Y: I know, the thought of ANY Baen book getting a nomination for cover art made me laugh too. At best they’re serviceable. Just because the house was founded in the 1980’s is no reason for their graphic design to have remained stuck there.

    Entire list has ridiculous lack of 🐙 Especially the cover art.

  13. Well, having clicked on all 39 links now, I have to say that most of the covers are much of a muchness. Very few of them really stand out.

    I guess my favorites are Uprooted, Spinning Thorns, The Cathedral of Known Things, and The Fifth Season (which is nicely complemented by the cover for its sequel, The Obelisk Gate).

  14. Bartimaeus: I’m glad they went with the UK cover for Fool’s Quest; the US edition is a travesty.

    I wouldn’t call it a “travesty” — but it looks just like about 35 of the covers linked up there ^, nothing distinctive.

  15. Looks like site only uses cookies to determine if you have voted. Unless they are filtering and then checking based on IPs, it’s trivial to rig this vote.

    Luckily Pox doesn’t care… He only wants his Hugo.

  16. So many good choices for Ravenheart, of which I’d read half. Ember in the Ashes and Battlemage were good, but The Traitor… I’m still pissed it wasn’t on the Hugo list. I’m hoping it wins the Alfie.

    And I voted for the Warhammer cover because I thought that was the most dynamic and bad ass one.

  17. lurkertype on May 13, 2016 at 5:48 pm said:

    @Matt Y: I know, the thought of ANY Baen book getting a nomination for cover art made me laugh too. At best they’re serviceable. Just because the house was founded in the 1980’s is no reason for their graphic design to have remained stuck there.

    Entire list has ridiculous lack of ? Especially the cover art.

    Yeah how’d they miss Watchmaker for cover art? That was great.

Comments are closed.