Pixel Scroll 12/29/20 A Mime
In A Tesseract Still Has Ways To Get Out

(1) BRADBURY’S CHAMPION. The Los Angeles Review of Books hosts “Ray Bradbury at 100: A Conversation Between Sam Weller and Dana Gioia”.

COMMEMORATING THE CENTENNIAL of the great Ray Bradbury, biographer Sam Weller sat down with former California poet laureate and former chairman of the National Endowment for the Arts Dana Gioia for a wide-ranging conversation on Bradbury’s imprint on arts and culture.

SAM WELLER: The first time I met you was at the White House ceremony for Ray Bradbury in November 2004. You were such a champion for Ray’s legacy — his advocate for both the National Medal of Arts and Pulitzer Prize. As we look at his 100th birthday, I want to ask: Why is Bradbury important in literary terms?

DANA GIOIA: Ray Bradbury is one of the most important American writers of the mid-20th century. He transformed science fiction’s position in American literature during the 1950s. There were other fine sci-fi writers, but Ray was the one who first engaged the mainstream audience. He had a huge impact on both American literature and popular culture. He was also one of the most significant California writers of the last century. When one talks about Bradbury, one needs to choose a perspective. His career looks different from each angle….

(2) TUCKER ON BRADBURY. [Item by Martin Morse Wooster.] This is from “Beard Mumblings,” a column by Bob Tucker that appears in the recently published Outworlds 71, but which was written in 1986 and is about the 1986 Worldcon.

There were some very pleasant memories of the con.  One of them was when Ray Bradbury recognized me in the huge 10th floor consuite and came over to shake and talk.  Mind you, we had not met each other for 40 years.  Our last meeting was the 1946 Worldcon in Los Angeles, yet he recognized and remembered.  I was very pleased to see him again, and equally pleased to get his autograph across the page of his chapter in Harry Warner’s All Our Yesterdays.  Judging the way he examined that page and that chapter, he doesn’t have a copy.

(3) WHEN HOKEY RELIGIONS AND ANCIENT WEAPONS ARE A MATCH. Professor Louise A. Hitchcock makes a connection in “The Mandalorian and Ancient Mediterranean Societies: The Way of The Force?” at Neon Kosmos. BEWARE SPOILERS.

…Thus, like both Achilles and Gilgamesh of early epic, baby Grogu has semi-divine aspects paired with Din Djarin’s stoic sense of duty and discipline. The pairing both calls to mind Patroclus who becomes a role model to the younger Achilles as well as Enkidu who becomes humanised through his friendship with Gilgamesh. In each epic tale the pair are changed by their bond of affection which is forged through shared experience. In all of these epics, the friends are also tragically separated, our ancients by death, and Grogu by Din Djarin’s quest to return him to the Jedi to finish his training. An element of danger is added by the fact that the Empire is seeking to capture or buy Grogu to increase its power through acquiring his force sensitive blood.

The weekly quest for survival as Din and Grogu, pursue their goal operates on the basis of pre-monetary economy that is reminiscent of maritime trade in the ancient Mediterranean. Food and drink are sometimes obtained through a shared code of hospitality, exchanging mercenary acts for information or needed supplies, transporting individuals from one port to another, providing Beskar ingots in exchange for ship repairs, and even trading spices. In other words, things haven’t changed a lot since the Silk Road brought needed goods from Asia to Mesopotamia or ships transported copper from Cyprus to Crete.

(4) OWN THOSE LITTLE BLACK BOOKS. [Item by Rob Thornton.] Games Designers Workshop is doing two Bundles of Holding that together will contain all of legendary science fiction roleplaying game Traveller’s Little Black Books (LBBs). Currently, “Traveller LBBs 1” and “Traveller LBBs 2” are available. Both bundles together comprise the complete LBB collection.

Traveller! We’ve resurrected both of our 2015 offers of the classic “Little Black Books” from the Golden Age of Traveller, the original science fiction tabletop roleplaying game. Together these two bargain-priced offers give you DRM-free .PDF ebooks of all 50+ rulebooks, supplements, and adventures published as half-size manuals (with elegant black covers) by Game Designers’ Workshop, 1977-1982.

(5) BROKEN HEARTS OF A WRITING LIFE. Stephen R. Donaldson mourns the response to his latest draft.

11/12/20
“The Killing God”: progress report

                I’ve finally finished my first-pass revision of Book Three of THE GREAT GOD’S WAR, “The Killing God” (formerly known as “The Last Repository”). The text is now ready to deliver to my agent and editor. In its current form, it stands at 1100 pages, a bit more than 283,000 words. What happens next? My agent will read the book much faster than my editor will; but I won’t start on the next revision until I’ve received what are politely called “comments” from both of them. At that point, no doubt, Berkley (and Gollancz in the UK) will schedule publication. Sometimes this requires me to do my next revision in a hurry. But not always.

12/6/20 
“The Killing God”: bad news

                My agent has submitted the book to my editor at Berkley. Without reading it (!), my editor informed me that Berkley will not consider publishing the book until I cut 100,000 words. Roughly 35% of the text. On the assumption that I will not do such violence to my own work, Berkley has removed the book from their publication schedule.
Their assumption is correct. At this stage, I routinely prune my manuscripts by 10%. I may conceivably be able to go as far as 15%. But whether or not anyone likes my characters and how I handle them, my stories are very tightly plotted. Each piece relies on–and is implied by–what came before it. I can’t mutilate Book Three without making the entire trilogy incoherent.
My agent believes that where we stand now is not the end of “The Killing God.” (Never mind of my career.) He has persuaded my editor to go ahead and read the book. He hopes that seeing how strongly Book Three caps Books One and Two (which she loved) will persuade her to rethink her position. I have my doubts. I suspect that her position is corporate rather than editorial: my books no longer earn enough to make them worth publishing regardless of their intrinsic merits. Naturally, I hope I’m wrong.

When I have more news, I’ll post it here. I don’t expect to hear anything until sometime in January.

(6) NEXT NYRSF READING. Sam J. Miller will be featured on the virtual New York Review of Science Fiction reading, Tuesday, January 5, 2021 at 7:00 PM EST.

Now that the Dystopia Year of 2020 is over, we will begin 2021 with the wonderful writer Sam J. Miller to make sure we stay on our toes.

Sam J. Miller is the Nebula Award-winning author of The Art of Starving (an NPR best of the year) and Blackfish City (a “Must Read” in Entertainment Weekly and O: The Oprah Winfrey Magazine). Sam’s short stories have been nominated for the World Fantasy, Theodore Sturgeon, and Locus Awards, and reprinted in dozens of anthologies. He is the last in a long line of butchers, and he has also been a film critic, a grocery bagger, a community organizer, a secretary, a painter’s assistant and model, and the guitarist in a punk rock band. He lives in New York City, and at samjmiller.com

After the reading general series dogsbody Amy Goldschlager will interview the author, and then we’ll open up the discussion to general questions from our virtual audience. Barbara Krasnoff will be the Audience Wrangler.

Please help us keep the series going by donating to NYRSF Reading Series producer Jim Freund at PayPal.me/HourWolf.

(7) EXPANDING THE HONORVERSE. Eric Flint did a title reveal on Facebook today.

Well, it’s official. After much wrangling and soul-searching, we’ve settled on the title To End In Fire for the upcoming Honorverse novel David Weber and I are writing. It’s tentatively scheduled for publication in October.

I tried to hold out for the more exciting title of The Cabal In The Luyten 726-8b (UV Ceti) System, but David overruled me. He thinks that title is too obscure. I find that hard to believe, given that the star system is clearly identified in the Gliese Catalog of Nearby Stars, which I’m sure can be found on every literate person’s bookshelves. But, he’s got the final sayso on account of he’s the one who created this whole setting.

Titles are just window dressing, anyway. What matters is the story — which in this case is shaping up to be a dandy. If I say so myself as shouldn’t, if I subscribed to Samwise Gamgee notions of modesty. Which (clears the throat), I don’t, on account of I’m a shameless scribbler and he’s, well, a hobbit when you get right down to it.

(8) MOSS OBIT. Actor Basil Moss (1935-2020) died November 28. There’s an overview of his career in The Guardian.

Basil Moss, who has died aged 85, was a perennial character actor often popping up in popular series as authority figures, but he found his best parts in two BBC soaps.

He became a familiar face on television as the librarian Alan Drew in Compact, set in the offices of a glossy women’s magazine… 

After Compact, Moss’s other TV roles included … a doctor with the hi-tech military agency Shado, defending the Earth against aliens, in UFO (1970-71), the puppet master Gerry Anderson’s first full live-action series; and Robert Atkinson in the political thriller series First Among Equals (1986).

Uncredited, Moss was also seen as a Navy submarine officer in the James Bond film You Only Live Twice (1967).

(9) MEDIA BIRTHDAY.

  • December 29, 1967 — “The Trouble with Tribbles” first aired as written by David Gerrold and directed by Joseph Pevney,  with some of the guest cast being Stanley Adams as Cyrano Jones, Whit Bissell as Station Manager and Michael Pataki  as Korax. Memory Alpha says ”Wah Chang designed the original tribbles. Hundreds were sewn together during production, using pieces of extra-long rolls of carpet. Some of them had mechanical toys placed in them so they could walk around.” Memory Alpha also notes Heinlein had Martian flat cats in The Rolling Stones that were similar to these and Roddenberry called to apologize for these being so similar. Who remembers these?  It would come in second in the Hugo balloting to “The City on the Edge of Forever” written by Harlan Ellison. All five final Hugo nominees at Baycon were Trek episodes written by Jerome Bixby, Norman Spinrad and Theodore Sturgeon.

(10) TODAY’S BIRTHDAYS.

[Compiled by Cat Eldridge and John Hertz.]

  • Born December 29, 1843 – Carmen Sylva.  Keyboardist (piano, organ), singer, graphic artist (painting, illuminating), poet, writer in English, French, German, Romanian, she left us particularly a dozen tales published in English as Pilgrim Sorrow, one in The Ruby Fairy Book and more recently in the VanderMeers’ Big Book of Classic Fantasy (2019).  CS was a pen name, she was the Queen of Romania.  (Died 1916) [JH]
  • Born December 29, 1915 – Charles L. Harness.  A dozen novels, five dozen shorter stories; appreciation of Van Vogt in Nebula Awards 31; interview “I Did It for the Money” in Locus (but, as has often been said, fiction-writers are liars).  SFWA (Science Fiction & Fantasy Writers of America) Author of Distinction.  Best known for “The Rose” and The Paradox Men.  Three NESFA (New England SF Ass’n) Press books; here is Jane Dennis’ cover for Cybele, with Bluebonnets.  Patent lawyer.  (Died 2005) [JH]
  • Born December 29, 1916 John D. MacDonald. He wrote three genre novels of which I think the best by far is The Girl, the Gold Watch & Everything. He also wrote some sixty genre short stories, many of the genre are collected in End of The Tiger which is available from the usual digital suspects (Died 1986.) (CE)
  • Born December 29, 1924 – Art Rapp.  At his home in Michigan he welcomed fans and published Spacewarp; after two years’ Army service in Korea he married Nancy Share and moved to Pennsylvania.  Two N3F Laureate Awards (Nat’l Fantasy Fan Fed’n), later a term as N3F President.  To him was revealed the fannish ghod (naturally opinions differ on what this is for; it may indicate the shape of a cheek with a tongue in itRoscoe.  (Died 2005) [JH]
  • Born December 29, 1928 Bernard Cribbins, 92. He has the odd distinction of first showing up on Doctor Who in the Peter Cushing as The Doctor non-canon Daleks’ Invasion Earth 2150 A.D. film. He would show up in the canon when he appeared as Wilfred Mott in the Tenth Doctor story, “Voyage of the Damned”, and he‘s a Tenth Doctor companion himself in “The End of Time”, the two-part 2009–10 Christmas and New Year special. (CE)
  • Born December 29, 1945 – Sam Long, age 75.  First noted in Fred Hemmings’ Viewpoint reporting Eastercon 23, he notably published (with Ned Brooks) the Mae Strelkov Trip Report (as you can see here; PDF) after friends brought the fine fanartist MS from Argentina.  SL still appears e.g. in The MT Void (pronounce it M-T, not as an abbreviation for mountain).  [JH]
  • Born December 29, 1950 – Gitte Spee, age 70.  This Dutch artist born in (on?) Java has done lots of illustrations for us.  Here is Detective Gordon’s first case in English and in Polish.  Here is Rosalinde on the Moon(in French).  [JH]
  • Born December 29, 1961 – Kenneth Chiacchia, Ph.D., age 59.  Medical science writer at Univ. Pittsburgh, and since he is ours too, member of both SFWA and the Nat’l Ass’n of Science Writers.  A dozen stories; poems (the 2007 Rhysling anthology has this one).  Carnegie Science Center Journalism Award.  [JH]
  • Born December 29, 1966 Alexandra Kamp, 53. Did you know Sax Rohmer’s noels were made into a film? I didn’t. Well she was the lead in Sax Rohmer’s Sumuru which Michael Shanks also shows up in. She’s also in 2001: A Space Travesty with Leslie Neilsen, and Dracula 3000 with Caspar van Dien. Quality films neither will be mistaken for, each warranting a fifteen percent rating  among audience reviewers at Rotten Tomatoes.. (CE) 
  • Born December 29, 1963 Dave McKean, 57. If you read nothing else involving him, do read the work done by him on and Gaiman called The Tragical Comedy or Comical Tragedy of Mr Punch: A Romance. Brilliant, violent, horrifying. Well and Signal to Noise by them is worth chasing down as well. (CE) 
  • Born December 29, 1969 Ingrid Torrance, 51. A very busy performer who’s had one- offs in Poltergeist: The Legacy, The Sentinel, Viper, First Wave, The Outer Limits, Seven Days, Smallville, Stargate: SG-1, The 4400, Blade: The Series, Fringe, The Tomorrow People, and Supernatural.
  • Born December 29, 1972 Jude Law, 48. I think his first SF role was as Jerome Eugene Morrow in Gattaca followed by playing Gigolo Joe in A.I. with my fav role for him being the title role in  Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow. He was Lemony Snicket In Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events, Tony in The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus, Dr. John Watson in Sherlock Holmes and Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows, Remy In Repo Man and he voiced Pitch Black in one of my favorite animated films, Rise of the Guardians. (CE)

(11) KAL-EL AND LL. SYFY Wire is there when “The CW’s Superman & Lois drops first heroic trailer for new DC series”.

… While the teaser isn’t very long (or footage-heavy for that matter), it does give us our first look at the Kent family unit, while Clark talks about how the stress of life can strengthen a person beneath the surface. His use of the phrase “forged liked steel” is a nice little nod to one of Superman’s monickers: the Man of Steel.

(12) SPDIEY’S NEW THREADS. Spider-Man’s hideous new costume that looks like he tore it off a New England Patriots cornerback is revealed in Amazing Spider-Man’ #61.

Over the years, Spider-Man has donned a host of iconic costumes, from his classics digs to the black suit to the Iron Spider. Now in 2021, everyone’s favorite Wall-Crawler will get a brand-new costume to add to his legendary wardrobe! Designed by superstar artist Dustin Weaver, this vibrant new look is unlike any that Peter Parker has worn before. The mysterious look can be seen on Weaver’s incredible variant covers for AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #62 and April’s AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #63.

…  Peter Parker will wear this new suit for his face-off against Kingpin in the next arc of writer Nick Spencer’s hit run. Discover the mystery behind this top-secret costume when AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #61 and AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #62 swing into shops this March!

(13) SUPERHERO LIFTS THEATER CHAINS. Deadline reports “’Wonder Woman 1984’ Opening Boosts Movie Theater Stocks, But AMC Loses More Ground”.

The better-than-expected Christmas-weekend opening of Wonder Woman 1984 is giving most exhibition stocks a welcome boost as the misery of 2020 gives way to hope for a brighter 2021.

Shares in Cinemark, Imax, Marcus Corp. and National CineMedia rose between 3% and 7% apiece after the sequel took in $16.7 million domestically, the best bow by any film during the coronavirus pandemic.

AMC, the world’s largest theater circuit, was a notable exception to the rally. Its stock dropped 5% on ongoing investor concern about its liquidity and a potential bankruptcy filing…. 

(14) BOOGLY WOOGLY STUFF. This is great — Boston Dynamics sets its robots dancing in “Do You Love Me?” on YouTube.

(15) SPLINTERS ARE BETTER. “Japan developing wooden satellites to cut space junk” – BBC News has the story. [Via Slashdot.]

…The partnership will begin experimenting with different types of wood in extreme environments on Earth.

Space junk is becoming an increasing problem as more satellites are launched into the atmosphere.

Wooden satellites would burn up without releasing harmful substances into the atmosphere or raining debris on the ground when they plunge back to Earth….

Does this train of thought wind up with Captain Harlock’s spaceship?

(16) VIDEO OF THE DAY. [By Martin Morse Wooster.] “Batman:  The Animated Series/The Heart of Batman” on YouTube is a 2018 documentary, directed by Alexander Gray, on the 1990s “Batman: The Animated Series” which many critics, such as Glen Weldon, say is the best version of Batman.  The film shows that the immediate inspiration for the series was Tim Burton’s Batman and Steven Spielberg’s desire to build an animation at Warner Bros., including giving the budget to have a full orchestra record Shirley Walker’s imaginative score.  Creators Bruce Timm and Eric Radomski give many influences, including film noir, German expressionist films, Citizen Kane, Max Fleischer’s Superman cartoons, and the art of Alex Toth.  But Andrea Romano gets a lot of credit for coming up with superb voices, including Mark Hamill as the Joker and Kevin Conroy as Batman.  The series also turned Harley Quinn into a full-fledged, interesting character and led to Margot Robbie playing her in three big-budget movies.

As an aside, Batman:  The Animated Series discusses how earlier animated shows of the 1980s had stifling restrictions imposed by network censors.  One writer (who wasn’t identified) worked on Super Friends.  One episode had the Justice League shrunk to midgets leading to Robin fighting a spider.  The censors said the cartoon had to include a scene where the spider is seen crawling away because Robin couldn’t hurt the spider.

[Thanks to John Hertz, Andrew Porter, Michael Toman, JJ, Mike Kennedy, Cat Eldridge, John King Tarpinian, Rob Thornton, Louise A. Hitchcock, Michael J. Walsh, and Martin Morse Wooster for some of these stories. Title credit goes to File 770 contributing editor of the day Daniel Dern.]


Discover more from File 770

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

59 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 12/29/20 A Mime
In A Tesseract Still Has Ways To Get Out

  1. 16) VIDEO OF THE DAY.

    Harley Quinn was created for the series, so she didn’t exist before hand. Created by Paul Dini and Bruce Timm, she was voiced there by Arleen Sorkin who’s married to Christopher Lloyd. She’s voiced her fifty six times but only nine times on Batman: The Animated Series. Most of the voice work was on Gotham Girls which I’ve never heard of.

  2. Pre-fifth.

    (2) I looooved that consuite, an entire floor. I also drank with Bob there.

    (3) Neato.

    (5) In the age of Brandon Sanderson’s tomes, why not let Donaldson ramble on?

    (11) I do greatly enjoy the CW’s DC Universe shows. Much better overall than their big-screen attempts… possibly the complete lack of Snyderness.

    (14) Scared now.

    (15) That is… very Japanese. Less work for the “Planetes” crew.

    (16) I saw some original artwork for B:TAS before it aired (even before there was buzz about it), peeking over artists’ shoulders and in their cubicles. It was as gorgeous as you think, and decided me to watch the show some months later.

  3. (11) I really enjoyed Lois and Clark: the New Adventures of Superman when I was a kid. Superman stories are a lot more interesting when Lois is a central part of the narrative. All powerful sun gods need a little grounding. There’s a reason the most popular Greek myths include at least one important mortal character.

  4. Cat Eldridge: I thought Harley Quinn was created for Batman: The Animated Series but I wasn’t completely sure so thanks for the clarification.

    That Boston Dynamics video is indeed very cool.

  5. (14) There is some novel that has a character watching a robot ballet, but I can’t remember the title or the author. Tanith Lee, perhaps?

  6. Martin Wooster says I thought Harley Quinn was created for Batman: The Animated Series but I wasn’t completely sure so thanks for the clarification.

    You’re welcome. The series is amazing. I rewatched the entire series on DVD a decade back and was pleasantly surprised how well it stands all these years later.

    Now playing: “Love Shack” video by the B-52s

  7. 5) The obvious solution would be to split it into 2 books if one is too long. If the real reason is falling sales, why not say so? At any rate, I hope he self publishes if the editor rejects it.

  8. B:TAS is one of the series coming to HBO Max on Jan 1st. (Defintely looking forward to that.)

    As of Jan 26, they’ll be streaming an obscure series called “Babylon 5”.

  9. 9) minor edit: the words “and Lurry” should be swapped.

    14) I recall tears of joy when seeing footage of the first biped robots simply able to walk without falling over (early ’90s?). How far we’ve come…

    15) Wooden satellites won’t mitigate the Kessler Syndrome. 1) If it’s in a high/stable enough orbit to be useful, it’s not coming down any time soon. 2) If a paint flake at orbital speeds can chip a space shuttle window, an wooden splinter is just as dangerous.

  10. Jeff Warner said:

    15) 2) If a paint flake at orbital speeds can chip a space shuttle window, an wooden splinter is just as dangerous.

    Space vampires, be warned!

  11. John Lorentz notes As of Jan 26, they’ll be streaming an obscure series called “Babylon 5”.

    Oh nice. Tempting but I’ll resist for now. Rewatching that is a serious commitment given it was five years plus a handful of movies and a brief spin-off series. I’m actually finding more than enough genre audiobooks to gave me entertained these days like Brian’s Uplift series

    Now reading: Doctor Who: Time Lord Victorious

  12. 13) I have much lament about Wonder Woman, because in a non-pandemic year it would be the movie for the annual December trip the 4K IMAX for this year’s Extremely Pretty Movie that I do with a friend. Instead I still have not seen it and don’t know when I will.

  13. @Daniel Dern: Someone is working on that space vampire vs. wooden satellite idea right now, I’ll bet.

    Also, love the title. Picturing a mime in a tesseract exercised my brain for a minute or two.

    @Cat Eldridge: but if you need a good cry, nothing beats “Sleeping in Light”.

  14. lurkertype says Cat Eldridge: but if you need a good cry, nothing beats “Sleeping in Light”.

    Actually I’m feeling pretty good this week after Jenner prescribed a new anti-seizure med as it’s been bloody great at controlling the seizures and keeping my now forty month long headache at a reasonable level.

    And I’ve gotten comfortable with Firah, my personal assistant, which has turned out to be a true blessing.

  15. 4: Ah, Traveller: the mid-life crisis RPG, where if characters survive generation, they may be aged and debt-ridden. The only thing that kept me from jumping on this is because I already own all the LBB-era stuff.

    Not entirely coincidentally, Sunday’s review is of something Traveller-adjacent.

  16. 10) John D. MacDonald — Cat, I too love The Girl, the Gold Watch & Everything. The JDM sf short story collection is called Other Times, Other Worlds. His other collections might have an sf story in them (offhand, I only remember “The Annex” in SEVEN), but Other Times is all sf, all the time.

  17. The pre-order ad hints there’s a reason for the costume change in this story arc, so maybe when the arc is through, the costume will revert.

  18. Are any of you active in Reddit’s r/Fantasy group and could get me a copy of the Stabby finalists?

    I can’t access the ballot because I’m not a forum member, on top of which only forum members for a month or more can vote, so it’s not something I can solve by joining today.

    My email is mikeglyer (at) cs (dot) com

  19. @JDN: Piper or Anderson?

    (The other year I came across a Traveller tie-in novel in a used bookstore, but I’m not sure if it was from the appropriate epoch. Miller’s Agent of the Imperium pos def isn’t.)

  20. Patrick Morris Miller says The other year I came across a Traveller tie-in novel in a used bookstore, but I’m not sure if it was from the appropriate epoch. Miller’s Agent of the Imperium pos def isn’t.

    What was the name of the novel? I didn’t know that they’d done novels though I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised that they did.

  21. Ha! I didn’t know that they’d published not one but two alternate concluding third volumes to the TNE trilogy I mentioned! (The original manuscript for the third volume was lost, so a different author wrote a different concluding volume, then they rediscovered the lost manuscript and published that as well.)

  22. [10] I’m wondering how long it’s been since you re-read The Girl, The Gold Watch and Everything, because I fear the ending is pretty much a canonical example of how the Suck Fairy can attack a good author as time goes on. Our ideas of what was hilarious have changed since then.

  23. Michael J. Lowrey asks me I’m wondering how long it’s been since you re-read The Girl, The Gold Watch and Everything, because I fear the ending is pretty much a canonical example of how the Suck Fairy can attack a good author as time goes on. Our ideas of what was hilarious have changed since then.

    How long? Decades.

    And I’ll probably never re-read it as it’s a novel best kept in that set of fiction as being remembered as good and let’s keep it that way. It’s a big set really.

  24. @lurkertype–(5) Maybe the work really does need 30-35% cut from it. Maybe Donaldson’s sales have dropped, and Donaldson is difficult, or has grown more difficult, to work with, and the point of diminishing returns has been reached.

    Or, possibly, the editor is an idiot, but really, it does look like the editor isn’t worried about someone higher up being upset at potentially losing Donaldson.

  25. [5] Or maybe Donaldson isn’t as big a deal as he thinks he is, and has fallen into the “Isn’t he dead?/Didn’t he stop writing long ago?” category for many readers.

  26. 5) Donaldson seemed to hit his height of popularity somewhere around White Gold Wielder (aka Book 6 or Book 3 of Trilogy 2), and after that it seemed that mentions of his work diminished. But he has given solid blurbs to Patricia McKillip and Steven Erikson, so kudos to him.

  27. The first six Thomas Covenant books were favorites back in high school (at which point some of their more questionable elements were flying right over my head; but they have some impressive setpiece scenes that I remember to this day). I also liked Mordant’s Need when I read it. I started reading the Gap books (the SF series) but they were just too brutal even for me; and when he started the final Covenant series back in the early 2000s, I read the first … two, I think?, but never progressed beyond that, or into the new series he’s trying to wrap up.

    Having said which, I also kind of don’t understand the logic of asking for that much of the manuscript to be cut, assuming there aren’t good editorial reasons for it — would the change in length have that much of an effect on production costs, especially these days with eBooks? (I suppose the production cost of the audiobook would scale pretty substantially, though.)

  28. @Joe H–

    Having said which, I also kind of don’t understand the logic of asking for that much of the manuscript to be cut, assuming there aren’t good editorial reasons for it — would the change in length have that much of an effect on production costs, especially these days with eBooks? (I suppose the production cost of the audiobook would scale pretty substantially, though.)

    I would not assume that there aren’t good editorial reasons for it.

  29. Re (7), I’ve got my fingers crossed. Both W and F have lost a few steps over the years, although one can have some hope. Most of W’s problems seemed at least to me to come from having no real editing of his books occurring before publication. And F’s collaborations over the past 3 or 4 years seemed to have lost their oomph. In his defense, he was battling cancer, and I wondered if he was out-sourcing most of the actual writing to folks who weren’t as good at writing as he is. So with luck, F will keep W reined in on his tendency to use 3 paragraphs where 1 sentence would be better, and W will push F to deliver the plotlines and characterizations that he’s so damned good at.

  30. lurkertype said:

    Also, love the title. Picturing a mime in a tesseract exercised my brain for a minute or two.

    Thanks. This one came to me listening to this past weekend’s WAIT WAIT DON’T TELL ME reruns/outtakes episode, including inspired by WaitWaitDontTell me reruns this weekend including Don
    Cheadle
    mentioning he was in a mime troup in high school.
    Of such stuff are some Scroll titles spawned.

    As for “The Girl, etc” (which, like all John D. MacD, I’ve read many times over the decades), I sadly agree that it perhaps needs retitling, e.g. “The Woman, The Gold Smartwatch, And A Lotta Stuff”

  31. Ah, Traveller: the mid-life crisis RPG, where if characters survive generation, they may be aged and debt-ridden.

    Me in 1980 rolling a Traveller character who is age 40: Why does my character have to be so old?

    Me in 2020 doing the same: I’m only 40!

  32. (15) I don’t know about Captain Harlock’s spaceship, but Bob Shaw had a whole book about wooden spaceships.

  33. @Andrew (not Werdna): I was once at a reading Donaldson gave where the passage he read contained the word clench. I may have smiled a bit.

  34. TIL that Dave McKean is a bit more than three years younger than I am, which means he created the utterly brilliant cover art for Gaiman’s first Sandman comics when he was about 22 years old. What is the next step beyond gobsmacked? That’s where I am now.

Comments are closed.