Pixel Scroll 6/5/19 En Pixel Cerrado, No Entran Scrolls.

(1) THE LAST DAY. Macmillan Publishers is moving from the Flatiron to the Equitable Building and taking Tor.com with it. Seanan McGuire commemorates the departure in her story “Any Way the Wind Blows”.

“Captain?”

I turn. Our navigator is looking over his shoulder at me. Well. One of his heads is. The other is still watching the curved window that makes up the front of our airship, crystal clear and apparently fragile. Most people who attack us aim for that window first, not asking themselves how many protections we’d put on a sheet of glass that size. The fact that it’s not a solid mass of bugs doesn’t seem to be the clue it should.

“What is it?”

He smiles uncertainly. “I think I see the Flatiron.”

Tor Books also posted a group shot taken outside the building here.

(2) PITT THE YOUNGER SEEKS PITT THE ELDER. Ad Astra comes to theaters in September 2019.

Astronaut Roy McBride (Brad Pitt) travels to the outer edges of the solar system when he finds his missing father, played by Tommy Lee Jones, has been doing threatening experiments in space. He must unravel a mystery that threatens the survival of our planet. His journey will uncover secrets that challenge the nature of human existence and our place in the cosmos.

(3) FROM DEEP IN THE FILES. Baen Ebooks is distributing the English translation of a nonfiction work Judgment in Moscow by Vladimir Bukovsky on its retail ebook site, as well as offering a selection of other ebooks from Judgment in Moscow publisher, Ninth of November Press.

Bukovsky spent years in the Soviet gulag, finally being released to the West in 1976. In 1991, Boris Yeltsin’s government asked Bukovsky to serve as an expert witness at a possible trial of the Communist Party. Bukovsky combed through the archives, scanning and copying much of the material there, and, after the trial became a dud, smuggled the material out of Russia. Judgment in Moscow is a behind the scenes look at these original documents which detail how the Soviet leadership and the Communist Party kept the Russian nation enslaved, accompanied by Bukovsky’s commentary elucidating the extent of the evil recorded therein.

Judgment in Moscow is based on the trove of Communist Party archives that Bukovsky spirited away before access was shut down. These contain elaborate details of Soviet meddling in Western politics, and it also details Western complicity in Soviet Russia’s program of totalitarian oppression. Originally written in Russian, Judgment in Moscow was seen as a major indictment of political treachery both inside and outside the USSR.

Baen’s press release says:

Western publishers, including Random House in America, backed down from publishing an English translation out of what appears in hindsight cowardice and fear of offending the emerging new Russian oligarchy. Now after years with no translation available, a new English version has finally been created with Bukovsky’s wholehearted participation.

(4) THE HITS OF SIXTY-FOUR. At Galactic Journey, Cora Buhlert details the unexpected popularity in West Germany of movies adapted from the crime novels of Edgar Wallace – someone better remembered in America as the creator of King Kong. [June 4, 1964] Weird Menace and Villainy in the London Fog: The West German Edgar Wallace Movies.

…Wallace villains are never just ordinary criminals, but run improbably large and secretive organisations with dozens of henchmen. At least one of the henchmen is deformed or flat out insane, played either by former wrestler Ady Berber or a charismatic young actor named Klaus Kinski, who gave the performance of his life as a mute and insane animal handler in last year’s The Squeaker.

The crimes are extremely convoluted, usually involve robberies, blackmail or inheritance schemes and are always motivated by greed. Murder methods are never ordinary and victims are dispatched via harpoons, poison blow guns, guillotines or wild animals. The villains inevitably have strange monikers such as the Frog, the Shark, the Squeaker, the Avenger, the Green Archer or the Black Abbot and often wear a costume to match. Their identity is always a mystery and pretty much every character comes under suspicion until the big reveal at the end. And once the mask comes off, the villain is inevitably revealed to be a staunch pillar of society and often a member of Sir John’s club.

(5) GLORIOUS COVER. Alex Shvartsman posted a cover reveal for his debut novel, Eridani’s Crown. It’s a beauty.

The full wraparound cover was drawn and designed by Tomasz Maronski.

(6) HE’S IN THE HALL. SYFY Wire reveals “Batman first inductee to Comic-Con HOF”.

Holy Hall of Fame, Batman! The Caped Crusader is robbin’ all the other comic book superheroes to seize the illustrious distinction of becoming the very first inductee into the new Comic-Con Museum’s inaugural class of honored comics characters.

The Dark Knight will hold the door for all the rest of the museum’s first, still-unannounced heroic batch, DC revealed in a press release announcing “The Gathering,” a July fundraising event for the new museum. Located near the site of San Diego Comic-Con in the city’s Balboa Park, the Comic-Con Museum (or CCM) will be a 68,000-square-foot shrine to all things heroic and villainous, drawing on decades of rich history from the pages of comics, graphic novels, and more.

“On the occasion of Batman’s 80th anniversary, a ceremony honoring DC’s most popular super hero will be the centerpiece” of the July 17 event, which is timed to help kick off this year’s San Diego Comic-Con.

(7) DARK PHOENIX. On Jimmy Kimmel Live, Sophie Turner, James McAvoy, Jennifer Lawrence, Michael Fassbender, Jessica Chastain, Nicholas Hoult and Tye Sheridan talk about making Dark Phoenix together and reveal some of their on-set antics.

(8) FINANCIAL OMENS. Our Designated Financial Times Reader Martin Morse Wooster peered behind the paywall at Dan Einav’s interview with Michael Sheen and David Tennant about Good Omens.

Stars are usually personally held accountable when a series fails to meet the expectations of the fans–and lovers of fantasy and sci-fi are often notoriously implacable,  To say that a screen adaptation of “Good Omens” has been hotly anticipated is to understate the extent of the fervour Gaiman’s devotees have for his work.

Do the actors feel anxious about a potential backlash?  ‘I read the book when it first came outm so I’m one of those fans and I’ve felt the weight of expectation,’ says Sheen.  “But Neil has said all the way through that he’s not making it for the fans, he’s making it for Terry.”

Tennant, who is no stranger to opinionated fans from his days as Doctor Who, is a little more blunt,  ‘You can’t make TV which pleases what people’s preconceived notions might be.  You just have to make something you feel proud of and works for people who haven’t read the book.

(9) WHERE IS EVERYBODY? Likewise behind a paywall, at Commentary, astrophysicist Ethan Siegel argues in “Are We Alone In The Universe?” that the likelihood there is life elsewhere in the universe is vanishingly small.

When we ask the big question–where is everybody?–it’s worth keeping a great many possibilities in mind.  Aliens might be plentiful, but perhaps we’re not listening properly.  Aliens might be plentiful, but they might self-destruct too quickly to maintain a technologically advanced state.  Aliens might be plentiful, but they may choose to remain isolated.  Aliens might be plentiful, but they might purposely choose to exclude Earth and their inhabitants from their communications.  Aliens might be plentiful, but the problems of interstellar travel might be too difficult to overcome.

But there’s another valid possibility that we must keep in mind, as well:  Aliens may not be there at all.  The probability of the three vital leaps, as described above, is enormously uncertain.  If even one of these three steps is too cosmically impossible, it may well be that in all the universe, there’s only us.

(10) BRADBURY REMEMBERED. [Item by Robert Kerr.] “Ray died 7 years ago today. I know he’d like to be remembered, but he’d like to be remembered with joy. Among Ray’s many accomplishments was writing the script for the Epcot attraction Spaceship Earth. This picture was taken in 1982 at the opening of Epcot. Ray took a bus or train to get to Florida, but he had to get back to L.A. faster than a bus or train could get there. Ray was a self-proclaimed coward who didn’t conquer fears very well. He never drove a car his entire life, and at 62 he was going to get on a plane for the first time. He said they put a bunch of martinis in him and loaded him onto the plane. To commemorate the occasion of Ray’s first time on a plane, some Disney animators drew a piece showing Ray on a plane, martini in hand, with Mickey Mouse sitting next to him. Ray kept that piece on display in his study for the rest of his life.”

(11) TODAY’S BIRTHDAYS.

[Compiled by Cat Eldridge.]

  • Born June 5, 1908 John Russell Fearn. British author and one of the first British writers to appear in American pulp magazines. A prolific author, he also published novels as Vargo Statten and with various pseudonyms such as Thornton Ayre, Polton Cross, Geoffrey Armstrong  and others. As himself, I see his first story as being The Intelligence Gigantic published in Amazing Stories in 1933. His Golden Amazon series of novels ran to over to two dozen titles, and the Clayton Drew Mars Adventure series that only ran to four novels. (Died 1960.)
  • Born June 5, 1928 Robert Lansing. He was secret agent Gary Seven in the “Assignment: Earth” on Star Trek. The episode was a backdoor pilot for a series that would have starred Lansing and Teri Garr, but the series never happened.  He of course appeared on other genre series such as The Twilight ZoneJourney to the Unknown, Thriller and Alfred Hitchcock Presents. (Died 1994.)
  • Born June 5, 1946 John Bach, 73. Einstein on Farscape, the Gondorian Ranger Madril in the second and third movies of The Lord of the Rings film trilogy. Also a British body guard on The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian. And he was the body double for shooting for Saruman in place of Christopher Lee, who was unable to fly to New Zealand for principal photography on The Hobbit film series
  • Born June 5, 1960 Margo Lanagan, 59. Tender Morsels won a World Fantasy Award for best novel, and Sea-Hearts won the same for Best Novella. She’s an alumna of the Clarion West Writers Workshop In 1999 and returned as a teacher in 2011 and 2013.
  • Born June 5, 1976 Lauren Beukes, 43. South African writer who’s the author of a number of SF novels. Zoo City won the 2011 Arthur C. Clarke Award, The Shining City, about a time travel serial killer and the woman who catches him, is being adapted as a series in South Africa, and Moxyland is a cyberpunk novel set in a future Cape Town.  Very impressive! 

(12) WHO WRITER OUSTED FROM ANTHOLOGY. Gareth Roberts has been “dropped from an upcoming Doctor Who anthology over ‘offensive’ transphobic tweets” BBC Books has confirmed.

Parent company Ebury confirmed that Roberts’ contribution to Doctor Who: The Target Storybook, will not feature….

Ebury’s decision to drop Roberts over his tweets, which it says conflicts with its “values as a publisher”, has sparked debate on social media.

Gareth Roberts defends and explains himself and the terminology he used in a “Statement on BBC Books and Transgenderism” on Medium.

(13) CURRENCY EVENTS. In “If We Told You Neal Stephenson Invented Bitcoin, Would You Be Surprised?” on Reason.com, Peter Suderman says, in a survey of Stephenson’s novels, says that in The Diamond Age and Cryptonomicon, Stephenson “described the core concepts of cryptocurrency years before Bitcoin became a technical reality.”

For nearly three decades, Stephenson’s novels have displayed an obsessive, technically astute fascination with cryptography, digital currency, the social and technological infrastructure of a post-government world, and Asian culture. His novel Anathem is, among other things, an elaborate investigation into the philosophy of knowledge. His new book, Fall; or, Dodge in Hell, pursues these themes literally beyond the grave, into the complications of estate planning and cryogenics.

(14) CALLING LONG DISTANCE. Drop by the Richard M. Nixon Presidential Library and Museum between now and January 12, 2020 to see the phone he used to call the Moon in the interactive exhibit Apollo 11: One Giant Leap for Mankind.

Artifacts and objects featured in the exhibit include:

  • Buzz Aldrin’s penlight used in the Lunar Module and Apollo 11 patch worn on the surface of the moon
  • NASA X-15 silver-gleaming pressure suit used to train Neil Armstrong and America’s first astronauts in the 1950s
  • Moon rocks from the lunar surface, acquired during the Apollo 15 and Apollo 17 missions
  • Oval Office telephone that President Nixon used to call Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin as they explored on the lunar surface
  • Presidential Medal of Freedom Award presented to astronaut Michael Collins by President Nixon
  • Original of President Nixon’s draft speech prepared in the event of a “moon disaster”
  • A 3-D printed, life-sized statue of Neil Armstrong in his space suit, as he climbed down the ladder of the Lunar Module on the moon
  • A giant, exact recreation of an Apollo mission command module

(15) HUGO CONTENDERS. Garik16 progresses with “Reviewing the 2019 Hugo Nominees: Best Short Story “.

6th Place On My Ballot:.  “The Secret Lives of the Nine Negro Teeth of George Washington” by P. Djèlí Clark (Fireside Magazine, February 2018)

This Story can be found HERE.

Thoughts:  This story won the Nebula Award, and I don’t think it’s a bad pick for the award, which is a testament to the strength of this ballot.  It’s a fantasy story about nine slaves’ lives and hopes, with the teeth taken from them as the gateway to their stories (and the effects of those teeth on George Washington) – with those slaves’ lives having various degrees of fantasy elements, all fitting the themes of those realistic slave-lives.  Still, I think it probably works the least of these six as a cohesive whole, even if the individual parts of this story are excellently done (with the final part reclaiming the supposedly noble action of Washington to free his slaves on his deathbed, in a really nice touch).

(16) NOT EXACTLY THE BURNING BUSH. NPR discusses the means of “Getting Fire From A Tree Without Burning The Wood”.

A scientist walks up to a cottonwood tree, sticks a hollow tube in the middle and then takes a lighter and flicks it. A jet of flame shoots out from the tube.

It seems like a magician’s trick. Turns out, there’s methane trapped in certain cottonwood trees. Methane is the gas in natural gas. It’s also a powerful greenhouse gas.

So how does it get inside towering trees like the ones on the campus of the Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee?

“The wood in this particular species naturally has this condition called wetwood, where it’s saturated within the trunk of the tree,” says the lighter-flicking scientist, Oak Ridge environmental microbiologist Christopher Schadt.

This wetwood makes for a welcoming home for all sorts of microorganisms.

…Some of those organisms turned out to be species of archaea that are known methane producers. So it’s not the trees themselves that are making the methane, it’s the microbes living in the trees.

…Because methane is such a potent greenhouse gas, Cregger says, it’s important to see how much of it the trees are actually producing.

This raises the surprising notion that trees could actually be contributing to global warming. Yes, these trees remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, but could the methane be making things worse?

(17) CLARKE’S FOURTH LAW? BBC wonders “Does pornography still drive the internet?”.

Consider the opening lines of The Internet is for Porn, a song from the Broadway musical Avenue Q.

Kate Monster: “The internet is really, really great.”

Trekkie Monster: “For porn!”

…Credible-seeming statistics suggest that about one in seven web searches is for porn. This is not trivial – but of course it means that six in seven web searches are not.

The most-visited porn website – Pornhub – is roughly as popular as the likes of Netflix and LinkedIn. That’s pretty popular but still only enough to rank 28th in the world when I checked.

But Avenue Q was first performed in 2003, an age ago in internet terms, and Trekkie Monster might have been more correct back then.

New technologies often tend to be expensive and unreliable. They need to find a niche market of early adopters, whose custom helps the technology to develop.

Once it is cheaper and more reliable, it finds a bigger market, and a much broader range of uses.

There is a theory that pornography played this role in the development of the internet, and a whole range of other technologies. Does it stack up?

(18) GIMME THAT REAL OLD-TIME RELIGION. Beer helps: “How Iceland recreated a Viking-age religion”.

The Ásatrú faith, one of Iceland’s fastest growing religions, combines Norse mythology with ecological awareness – and it’s open to all.

…The ‘blót’, as the changing-of-the-season ceremony is known, began with the lighting of a small fire, which flickered in the breeze as the congregation listened to Old Norse poetry and raised the beer-filled horn to honour the Norse gods. Elsewhere on the island, similar ceremonies, I was told, were taking place.

The blót had been organised by the Ásatrú Association of Iceland, a pagan faith group that is currently one of the country’s fastest growing religions, having almost quadrupled its membership in a decade, albeit from a low base of 1,275 people in 2009 to 4,473 in 2018.

The congregation, which comprised a few dozen souls, including a Buddhist and a Hindu guest, had gathered near a sandy beach on the outskirts of Reykjavik, next to the city’s domestic airport, to celebrate the first day of the Icelandic summer. It was 25 April, slightly chilly and mostly overcast. Rain looked likely….

(19) WITH WINTER COMES ICE. The whole Game of Thrones cast raps in A Song of Vanilla Ice and Fire – Game of Thrones x Ice Ice Baby.

[Thanks to Lenore Jean Jones, John King Tarpinian, Mike Kennedy, Cat Eldridge, JJ, Chip Hitchcock, Carl Slaughter, Martin Morse Wooter, and Andrew Porter for some of these stories, Title credit goes to File 770 contributing editor of the day Jayn.]

123 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 6/5/19 En Pixel Cerrado, No Entran Scrolls.

  1. The ideal is where people are free to be who they know they are

    You’re forgetting that other people can make their own judgments for themselves. Lesbians are free to not want a trans-gendered male as a sexual partner, for instance, because lesbians don’t have penises.

  2. Defending Julie Bindel is absurd, but I will not give these people more space by extending the argument.

  3. Except all this discussion of trans people is missing one very important set of data points:
    It isn’t about ‘feeling’ one way of the other. Medical research has proven that to be far more than ‘just a feeling’.

    Do you know that nearly every major medical organization in the western world and beyond has officially stated that transition is the single most effective treatment known, backed by decades of research and that no properly diagnosed person should ever be denied treatment? Since this discussion is centering on the UK, that includes the NHS and the Royal College of Physicians.

    Do you know that the DSM-V clearly categorizes gender dysphoria as non-pathological? As in, not a mental illness. Basically, hormone therapy works too well for it to be.

    And most importantly, the last ten years of medical research has proven a clear biological component to dysphoria. There is a clear and growing body of medical research saying that being trans is caused by a divergence in the gendered development of the brain and body – essentially that they are opposite genders.

    So this isn’t about feeling one way or the other – it’s about having a brain that’s mismatched to your body and the resultant distress in the brain trying to interpolate why it isn’t getting the hormones it wants and why the body doesn’t match the neurological map it expects.

    Geneticists have been trying to tell people for years that the concept of strict, 100% binary gender has no basis in reality. They even came up with a handy-dandy phrase to describe their findings: Gender is a spectrum.

    But I guess politics is more important.

  4. J Allen: You’re forgetting that other people can make their own judgments for themselves.

    … says the bigot who insists that
    men who want to be feminine believe they have to masquerade as women.

    Stop. Digging.

  5. J Allen, you clearly do not know even the bare minimum of trans vocabulary or any other related trans 101 knowledge, can I suggest doing some learning before contributing further?

  6. Actually, I’d say most of J Allen’s trans vocabulary is pretty standard TERF usage – along with the slightly creepy obsession with genitals.

    Sam, on the other hand, is following the “moderate” TERF line which denies trans women are women but generously allows us to continue existing… as long as we’re sufficiently polite.

    (You may also notice neither is talking about trans men. This is characteristic. A few TERFs accuse them of “stealing” young butch lesbians but the general view seems to be that they’re someone else’s problem.)

  7. 13) Townhall in Seattle had Stephenson in for a Q&A/Reading/Signing for the launch of FALL. I was in the crowd. One of the questioners asked about bitcoin, and the identity of Satoshi Nakamoto specifically, and Stephenson was pretty dismissive. He referred to crypto as “a solution looking for a problem” and seemed to think the security solutions (blockchain/crypto/etc.) around it were more impressive than bitcoin itself.

    So yeah, not buying what that Reason article is selling. Fun thought experiment, however.

  8. I certainly noticed J Allen’s attempt to deflect legitimate counter-arguments with the pretense that a major point of contention is something that absolutely no one has suggested. 🙄

  9. Don’t believe I mentioned either transwomen or transmen specifically in my comment. I was talking about feminists defining women as being based on female biology. I am happy to extend that to men being based on male biology- but I don’t believe men suffer sex discrimination.

    And I don’t expect anyone to be polite on the internet. Though I try to be so myself. I am very happy to say I extend the same right to live and exist peacefully to all people.

  10. Sam:

    .

    “Julie Bindel is a lifelong feminist campaigner who has spent her life fighting for justice and imprisoned women, against male violence and exploitation, and for lesbians.”

    She is also a bigot that spews her prejudices over others. Not only against transpersons, but against bisexuals that she only sees as a fashion trend and nothing that really exists. Her way of thinking has caused enormous amount if harassment against friends of mine and they still refuse to go in the Pride-parade because how they used to be treated.

  11. Sam: They do not deny transgender people’s right to exist, or to be gender non conforming, or deny their human right to live free from violence and to live full and satisfying lives the same way as everyone does in society… I am very happy to say I extend the same right to live and exist peacefully to all people.

    You just don’t extend to transgender women the right to identify themselves as women. Let’s not pretend that you’re being generous and un-bigoted here.

  12. Incidentally, while trans terminology is shifting rapidly and varies across communities, “transwomen” (noun) instead of “trans women” (adjective and noun) is another usage to note. Sometimes it’s innocent and sometimes it implies the view that “women and transwomen” are two mutually exclusive categories. I’m amused we’ve got to the point where the placement of a space is a political statement, but here we apparently are.

  13. J. Allen: Go ask a biologist who specializes in gender what a woman is. Don’t ask me; I may be a cis woman who identifies strongly with her assigned gender, but I can’t even tell you what a woman is other than that I am one, Sophie Jane is one, and my friend T, even though misassigned as one at birth, really isn’t one.

    I’m not even joking. There are so many different markers for what we consider to be a woman, biological and social, that every attempt to define a woman by any single characteristic that you think will “only” exclude trans women will result in people who are obviously, undeniably women who get excluded. (Just as anti-trans bathroom controversies have caused people to also assault cis women who didn’t look “Feminine” enough, were too tall or too big in the shoulders or had a hair on their lip.)

    Chromosomes? we know there are people out there explicitly identified as female with non XX chromosome sets.

    Hormonal levels? Vary immensely.

    Genitalia? As well as provisionally excluding some trans women, excludes women who have had them removed, women with genital defects, women born with none, and intersex people whose divergence is internal and thus invisible until later in life, and socially raised as women, or whose divergence is external and choose to identify as feminine. Secondary sex characteristics are even more laughable.

    Social cues, brain scans, and other determinants we’ve looked at vary too widely to be narrowed down. For instance, the “trans people have brains that look more like the gender they identify as than the assigned gender of their body” thing is true in many cases studied so far — but also a bit misleading, as there is a significant amount of overlap in cis male and female brains. While brain traits tend to cluster the same way external biological traits do – and trans brains tend to fit *better* in the cluster of their identified gender, not their biological – there isn’t an easy sharp dividing line, either, a place where you can take a brain whose scan is an outlier and definitively say it’s definitely masculine or feminine. And a cis woman can have an outlier brain but you wouldn’t call her not a woman.

  14. Dear Sophie,

    “… all this fuss in the UK is just standard generational conflict being amplified by a few bigots.”

    Hmmm. I dunno, and it’s complicated by the fact that it’s likely different in different places.

    Some time back, someone here commented that the TERF rhetoric was so predominant where they were that if they (properly) identified themselves as lesbian, people assumed they were a TERF.

    I hadn’t noticed that here in the San Francisco Bay Area, but there are a lot of folks here I’m not in touch with. Truthfully? Most of the 7+ million! I asked Sandy about this, because she is infinitely more in touch with what’s going on. (That would be Sandy Stone. If someone reading this doesn’t know who she is, Google her.) She hadn’t observed that misconnection, either.

    This stuff isn’t playing out the same everywhere, and it’s hard to know what’s dominant — if anything is.

    Here in the US, the radfem TERFs have not achieved the mainstream acceptance they have in the UK. The Powers That Be are way too homophobic. If they thought for a moment that by promoting discrimination against transfolk they were promoting a radfem agenda, they’d pass complete civil rights for them just so they could be sticking it (ahem) to Dem Eviel Dykes. At the power level, it’s a het movement here.

    But back to the TERFs. Sandy and I were musing about just your consideration over dinner last week. Sandy was sighing and wondering how much transbigotry had really died down in 40 years. I reminded her that at least today’s TERFs weren’t pointing guns at her and she said, “There is that.” But still…

    I honestly don’t know. I have an opinion (such a big surprise). But trying to decide if it’s reality-based? It’s like trying to decide if a loud roar is getting louder or softer, when it doesn’t even sound the same in different places.

    My take, for what extremely little it’s worth. This is coming straight out of the rhetoric of 3-4 decades ago. The whole business of True Women, Proper Sex, the vilification and erasure of transfolk (as you note, transmen are nonexistent so far as the transphobes are concerned, because they can’t make them fit their lies as well) and bisexuals. Same playbook, that whole, horrid 80s thing. I know so many women — straight, lesbian, and bi — who know full well they are feminists but can’t identify with the “movement” because they were, as one of them put it, “raised by lesbian wolves.” Or at least badly beaten up by them. They just didn’t fit that Procrustean bed and they were made to suffer for it.

    It scarred a generation. (Except for the scant minority that bought into the massive load of prejudice, because some did.) The roar subsided, as a result, and we took it as real and permanent gains. Maybe they are. But now a full generation-plus has passed and “the kids these days” have no recollection of exactly how poisonous and awful that really was. The surviving bigots have found fresh soil to plant their hatred in.

    They will lose. Just as they lost last time. That doesn’t mean they will disappear. Eventually there will be a new and fresh, unremembering generation to be subverted. I don’t think this is the last wave of TERF hatred, and I don’t think I’ll live long enough to see the last wave.

    What I would like to think is that it’s not entirely cyclic, that we’ve made gains over the decades that don’t get entirely raised by this wave of prejudice. I’m hugely heartened by the fact that a serious social issue for teens and young twentysomethings is what they call “gender fluidity,” incorporating, along with a bunch of other stuff, trans- and bi- issues. I hope they are the wave of the future and not just a passing thing.

    I have to believe things are getting better, because otherwise it’s just too impossibly depressing. I wish I had more confidence that this really is more than wishful thinking.

    I do believe it, I can argue the case for it… but is it so?

    – pax \ Ctein
    [ Please excuse any word-salad. Dragon Dictate in training! ]
    ======================================
    — Ctein’s Online Gallery. http://ctein.com 
    — Digital Restorations. http://photo-repair.com 
    ======================================

  15. I am omitting J. Allen’s further replies on this subject. People here can take care of themselves, but it pains me to read such obvious bad faith as resorting to the dictionary to prop up scientific claims.

  16. @Meredith: fascinating! I was warned (when I got some therapy after being particularly careless about my voice) that rolling the head around (encouraged by many conductors) was in fact not good — the therapist said to instead tip the head to each cardinal point, then back to center — but I’d never thought of something that sounds like a dislocated larynx. (Having read too much Dick Francis, I am sympathetic to any issues with dislocations….) Relocating easily is good; here’s hoping the voice comes back quickly.

  17. Meredith and Cat, though I’m days behind, I also want to express my wishes for quickly and permanently improved health for both of you.

    Cat, the birthdays are the one section that I always read to my roommate while she washes the dishes. We both enjoy them very much!

  18. I consider all Filers to be at least a little bit significant. 🙂

    Re: UK gender politics, I suspect that as much as anything it’s because we have more second wave-era feminists in prominent positions in the media than the USA does. Less TERF philosophy gaining influence as people who already had influence for other reasons being TERFs. Outside of that it doesn’t seem to have as solid a hold in my experience, and they rightly face enormous pushback.

    There is an international problem that young women and young trans men (and probably also young nonbinary folks who are AFAB, although I haven’t personally witnessed that one), are all being recruited via social justice-focused communities like Tumblr, though. It usually starts with anti-queer and anti-asexual/anti-aromantic rhetoric, sometimes also anti-creative expression (the “antis” in fandom, basically a purity movement), and then slowly leans into transphobic rhetoric over time. Much like how young men are pulled into the alt-right sphere. It’s a disturbing thing to watch happen, even though it doesn’t work on that many.

    @Chip Hitchcock

    It’s probably not a common thing outside of my bendy brethren, since I have a hard time imagining how you’d get that kind of injury as a non-bendy person with functional connective tissue. I’m only a little hoarse today so I’m basically fine!

    @World Weary & Hampus Eckerman

    Thanks!

  19. @Ryan McNeill and @Lenora Rose —

    If only these dratted posts had “like” buttons on them! You two win my internet award for the day. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.