Death Will Not Release You — From SF

Moshe Feder sends along the link to the New York Times obituary of J.G. Ballard. Ballard was a leading figure in science fiction’s New Wave of the 1960s and a breakout literary writer whose mainstream novels were made into movies. He died April 19 of cancer. Ballard’s early fame was founded on his Vermilion Sands stories, including “The Cloud Sculptors of Coral D,” the first story by him that I ever read.

Fans have expressed disgust over the too-familiar attempt by the media to deny a critically-acclaimed author’s roots in sf. It’s evident from the tone of the piece how reluctant the Times was to sully the author’s reputation by associating him with anything base or popular, excusing his early work by saying he “defied the genre of science fiction.”

Moshe particularly wanted to draw attention to the article’s closing:

The prescience of Mr. Ballard’s work and its harsh conflation of the present and the future often resulted in comparisons to writers like Huxley and Orwell. “His fabulistic style led people to review his work as science fiction,” said Robert Weil, Mr. Ballard’s American editor at Norton. “But that’s like calling ‘Brave New World’ science fiction, or ‘1984.’ “

“Oh gee, Mr. Weil, yuh think?” comments Moshe, who sighs, “Some things never change.”

And Andrew Porter has pointed out that USA Today went the Times one better, managing to run a lengthy Ballard obituary without ever mentioning SF at all.


Discover more from File 770

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

4 thoughts on “Death Will Not Release You — From SF

  1. The USA Today piece – which, btw, is from the AP, read the byline – might have been called a “sin of omission”, but once you see the longer version here: http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090420/ap_on_re_eu/eu_obit_jg_ballard it becomes a “sin of commission”.

    The irony of those proclaiming “Oh noes, he’s not a sci-fi writer” ignore the first decade or so of his career when the only places this ground breaking fabulist (etc etc) could get published were in those SF magazines.

  2. “Against the mundane media even the Gods of the field themselves contend in vain.” — Shakespeare, after seeing the news reports about his Nebula nomination

Comments are closed.