Pixel Scroll 11/16/18 A Pixel May Not Scroll A Human Being, Or Through Inaction, Allow A Human To Be Scrolled

(1) DIVERSITY STARTS EARLY. The 2019 World Fantasy Convention responded to Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s criticism (see yesterday’s Scroll, item #3.) She answered in a thread that begins here.


(2) IN DETAIL. NPR’s Glen Weldon gets specific: “‘Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald’: Beasts? Check. Crimes? Check. Fantastic? Not Quite.”

The Crimes of Grindelwald is better than the first Beasts film, and not just because that turns out to be such a low bar to clear, but because it has a firmer grasp on what kind of movie it wants to be. It feels more familiarly Potter-y, in that it assumes the distinctive narrative shape of Harry Potter stories.

Once again: Structurally, it’s familiar, not, you know: good.

Can we all admit, here, that the plots of Harry Potter books and movies were always frustrating in the extreme? Rowling’s characters delighted in keeping vital information from Harry — and by extension, the reader — turning every tale into an ersatz, low-rent mystery where the goal was never to uncover whodunnit, but to eke out even the most basic understanding of whatthehellsgoingon? Inevitably, we’d discover the answers — well, “discover” is inaccurate. We’d be told, when Rowling would finally sit Harry down to have him listen to an extended monologue, filled with secret history to which neither he nor we could have been expected to be privy.

That’s the kind of plotting The Crimes of Grindelwald serves up, down to a hilariously out-of-nowhere pseudo-climactic scene in which characters who’ve spent the movie scheming to murder one another just stand around listening patiently to a series of monologues like they’re sleepy kindergartners at storytime.

(3) JUST PINING FOR THE FJORDS. In the midst of this excitement let’s not overlook that Unbound Worlds ends its life as a blog this month:

Today we’re announcing that the conversation with our readers is ready to evolve in new and exciting ways. In the new year, the articles, interviews, and lists you have enjoyed on Unbound Worlds will have a new home within penguinrandomhouse.com. That means we’ll no longer be publishing new content on Unbound Worlds after this month, but we’re excited to be able to deliver even more of the very best in science fiction, fantasy, and horror books, curated collections, and offers through our email programs.

(4) A BETTER LIGHTSABER. Don’t just sit there – spend money on Star Wars toys! “Disney Designs New Lightsaber That Extends and Retracts Just Like the Film Versions”.

For some of us out there, society’s technical advancements can all be measured by answering one question: How close are we to a real lightsaber?

While the model outlined in Disney’s newest patent application may not cut through solid steel, it will have an advantage over previous toys and replicas. Published today by Disney Enterprises, Inc., “Sword Device with Retractable, Internally Illuminated Blade” outlines a lightsaber design which allows the “energy blade” to shoot forth and retract in a way that properly mimics the iconic weapon’s use in the Star Wars franchise.

Currently, if you want to walk the path of the Jedi you’ve got two basic options. The cheaper choice involves purchasing a toy with a telescoping blade, with larger segments near the hilt and smaller segments near the tip, creating a triangular — and not very film accurate — shape. For more money you get more accuracy, so you could also purchase a fixed blade that looks closer to the movie ones when lit, but can’t extend or retract at all. Remember that iconic scene where Mace Windu stopped to screw in his purple blade before battle? Nope, neither do we.

(5) BRINGING THE HAMMER. Marvel is ready for another climactic moment —

This April, the war that has exploded across the Ten Realms finally blasts into the last realm standing…ours.


Starting in April, the award-winning creative team of Jason Aaron, Russell Dauterman and Matthew Wilson will usher in an event of unparalleled scale! And like the mega-event Secret Wars, no corner of the Marvel Universe will be untouched!

“I have been building towards WAR OF THE REALMS for the entire duration of my Thor run. So we’re talking six years and 80-something issues and counting,” teased Jason Aaron. “This is a war that covers the entire globe and involves the biggest heroes of the Marvel Universe, as you can see in this amazing promo piece by my MIGHTY THOR collaborators, Russell Dauterman and Matthew Wilson, who I’m so thrilled to be working with again on WAR OF THE REALMS.”

(6) GOING TO THE WORLDCON. The Shimmer Program announced that the winners of the Dublin 2019 Attending Funding for Chinese fans offered by Storycom are Constance Hu and Amelia Chen. Each will get RMB 10,000 for use in attending and staffing the con. They are expected to gain experience in the Worldcon organizational work and help with future Chinese bids.

Tammy Coxen & Adam Beaton, Member and Staff Services DH & DDH of Dublin 2019, and Colin Zhang, winner of Worldcon 75 Attending Funding & Hospitality DDH of Worldcon 75, worked as judges for the selection.

There are photos and introductions to the two winners at the link.

(7) DEVORE COLLECTION FOR SALE. The daughters of the late Howard Devore are selling the remainder of his collection/stock at ScienceFictionSales.com. Many interesting items going on the block, including Gene Roddenberry’s thank-you letter to 1966 Worldcon chair Ben Jason. Howard got one, too, but it’s not for sale —

Bjo [Trimble] wrote the following in honoring Howard as he received the Science Fiction World Convention Fan Guest of Honor award (posthumously) in 2006:

“How Howard helped save Star Trek”

When NBC decided to cancel Star Trek after its second season in 1967, the Trimbles decided to organize a write-in campaign to the network. “This was before computers and the Internet, so we had to rely on obtaining mailing lists. We asked but were turned down by several people who had mailing lists, but Big-Hearted Howard DeVore gave us his list to start the campaign. He also talked others into letting us use their mailing lists. He never got credit for this, though the [sic] we (John and Bjo Trimble) mentioned his name in interviews.”  So it may surprise many fans to know that without Howard, the Save Star Trek campaign might not have succeeded.

(See also the letter written by Roddenberry to thank a good friend of Dad’s, Ben Jason, for the letter writing campaign which we offer for sale in the Oddities and Curiosities section of the website. Our letter is not for sale.)

(8) FURTHER DEVELOPMENTS AT WHITE WOLF. Corporate management has taken drastic action to deal with problems at White Wolf:

My name is Shams Jorjani, VP of Business Development at Paradox Interactive and interim manager at White Wolf Publishing. I wanted to inform you of some changes that will be implemented at White Wolf, starting immediately.

Sales and printing of the V5 Camarilla and Anarch books will be temporarily suspended. The section on Chechnya will be removed in both the print and PDF versions of the Camarilla book. We anticipate that this will require about three weeks. This means shipping will be delayed; if you have pre-ordered a copy of Camarilla or Anarchs, further information will follow via e-mail.

In practical terms, White Wolf will no longer function as a separate entity. The White Wolf team will be restructured and integrated directly into Paradox Interactive, and I will be temporarily managing things during this process. We are recruiting new leadership to guide White Wolf both creatively and commercially into the future, a process that has been ongoing since September.

Going forward, White Wolf will focus on brand management. This means White Wolf will develop the guiding principles for its vision of the World of Darkness, and give licensees the tools they need to create new, excellent products in this story world. White Wolf will no longer develop and publish these products internally. This has always been the intended goal for White Wolf as a company, and it is now time to enact it.

The World of Darkness has always been about horror, and horror is about exploring the darkest parts of our society, our culture, and ourselves. Horror should not be afraid to explore difficult or sensitive topics, but it should never do so without understanding who those topics are about and what it means to them. Real evil does exist in the world, and we can’t ever excuse its real perpetrators or cheapen the suffering of its real victims.

In the Chechnya chapter of the V5 Camarilla book, we lost sight of this. The result was a chapter that dealt with a real-world, ongoing tragedy in a crude and disrespectful way. We should have identified this either during the creative process or in editing. This did not happen, and for this we apologize….

(9) SPACE COLLECTIBLES CASH IN. HA’s recent Space Exploration Auction set records:

The “star of the show” was my personal favorite piece, the Apollo 11 Lunar Module Flown Spacecraft ID Plate. When the fierce bidding was over, it had sold for $468,500 to a bidder in the room. Four lots tied for “second place” at $275,000 each: two Apollo 11 LM Flown Wright Flyer Propeller Pieces (Lot 52284 and Lot 52285); the Apollo 11 Flown Largest Size American Flag; and the Apollo 11 LM Flown Apollo 1 Fliteline Medal. This last lot was particularly poignant as Neil Armstrong and Ed White II were close friends; the medal was taken to the moon as a tribute to White who perished in the Apollo 1 training fire. A special thanks to the dedicated staff at Collectibles Authentication Guaranty (CAG) who worked tirelessly to authenticate and encapsulate or certify every single item in The Armstrong Family Collection™. Another sincere “thank you” goes out to Rick and Mark & Wendy Armstrong who were always available to help in any way needed.

This auction also featured an incredible selection of material from several dozen regular and new consignors. One thing I noted was that Gemini-flown Fliteline medals were particularly strong in the early Friday session. The examples we offered all had incredible provenance from various astronauts and many were graded by NGC. We set new price records for the following missions: Cooper’s Gemini 5 ($35,000); Schirra’s Gemini 6 ($8,750); Lovell’s Gemini 7 ($10,625); Cooper’s Gemini 8 ($30,000); Stafford’s Gemini 9 ($32,500); Young’s Gemini 10 ($5,750); Conrad’s Gemini 11 ($12,500); Lovell’s Gemini 12 Silver-colored and Gold-colored ($9,375); and Chaffee’s Apollo 1 ($20,000). Oh, by the way, the Gemini 3 ($16,250) and Gemini 4 ($9,375) records were set the previous day by lots from The Armstrong Family Collection™. That makes it a “clean sweep.”

(10) GOLDMAN OBIT. William Goldman, author of The Princess Bride, has died. Deadline has the story — “William Goldman Dies; Oscar Winning Writer Of ‘Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid’ Was 87”.

Goldman began as a novelist and transitioned to writing scripts with Masquerade in 1965. While his greatest hits were the indelible pairing of Robert Redford with Paul Newman in the George Roy Hill-directed Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, and Redford and Dustin Hoffman in the Alan Pakula-directed toppling of President Richard Nixon drama All The President’s Men, he wrote the scripts for many other great movies. The list includes the Hoffman-starrer Marathon Man (Goldman also wrote the novel, which made dentist visits even more undesirable),as well as The Princess Bride, The Stepford Wives, The Great Waldo Pepper, A Bridge Too Far, Chaplin and Misery. He also did a lot of behind the scenes script doctoring without taking a screen credit, as on films that included A Few Good Men and Indecent Proposal.


  • Born November 16, 1907 – Burgess Meredith, Actor of Stage and Screen, Writer, Director, and Producer. His two most significant roles were in Twilight Zone: The Movie as the Narrator, and in a delightful take as The Penguin in the original Batman series. Genre film appearances include Magic, Clash of the Titans, Torture Garden, The Sentinel, and Beware! The Blob. He also showed up in Tales of Tomorrow, an anthology SF series that was performed and broadcast live on ABC from 1951 to 1953, and episodes of The Invaders, The Twilight Zone, Faerie Tale Theatre (Thumbelina, with Carrie Fisher!) and The Wild, Wild West. Did I mention he voiced Puff the Magic Dragon in a series of the same name? He also narrated the documentary Debrief: Apollo 8, with footage from the historic spaceflight. (Died 1997.)
  • Born November 16, 1939 – Tor Åge Bringsværd, 79, Writer, Editor, and Fan from Norway who co-founded Norwegian fandom. He and his university friend Jon Bing were huge SF readers in a country where SF publishing did not exist, so they founded, in 1966, the still-existing Aniara science fiction club and its fanzine at Oslo University. In 1967, they produced an SF short story collection Ring Around the Sun, which is known as the first science fiction by a Norwegian author. In 1967, they persuaded Gyldendal, the leading Norwegian publisher, into launching a paperback SF line with themselves as editors. Between then and 1980, this imprint released 55 titles which included the first Norwegian translations for many authors, such as Aldiss, Bradbury, Le Guin, and Leiber. He quit university to become a full-time SF writer, and since then has accumulated an impressive array of awards, including the Norwegian Academy Award, the Ibsen Award, and the Norwegian Cultural Council Award.
  • Born November 16, 1942 – Milt Stevens, Law Enforcement Analyst, Fan, Conrunner, and Filer. Excerpted from Mike Glyer’s tribute to him: Milt attended his first Los Angeles Science Fantasy Society meeting in 1960 at the age of 17. By 1970 Milt was President of LASFS he signed my membership card when I joined. He was somebody to look up to who also became a good friend. Milt won the Evans-Freehafer Award for service to the club in 1971. He was on the LASFS, Inc. Board of Directors for a couple of decades, and was Chair for around five years. After the original LASFS clubhouse was bought in 1973 Milt dubbed himself the “Lord High Janitor,” having taken on the thankless task of cleaning the place. Milt was among the club’s few nationally-active fanzine publishers and fanpoliticians. He put out an acclaimed perzine called The Passing Parade. He coedited and bankrolled later issues of my fanzine Prehensile. For many years he was a member of the Fantasy Amateur Press Association (FAPA). He was Chair of LA 2000, the original Loscon (1975), and later the 1980 Westercon. And he co-chaired L.A.Con II (1984), which still holds the attendance record. He was made Fan GoH of Loscon 9 and Westercon 61. (Died 2017.)
  • Born November 16, 1952 – Candas Jane Dorsey, 66, Writer, Poet, and Critic from Canada whose works include poetry, fiction, television and stage scripts, magazine and newspaper articles, and reviews. Her fiction has garnered a Tiptree Award, numerous Aurora Award nominations and wins, and a Sunburst nomination. She was a co-founder of SF Canada, was editor-in-chief of The Books Collective from 1992 to 2005, and has co-edited two editions of Canadian Science Fiction’s long-running annual anthology Tesseracts.
  • Born November 16, 1952 – Robin McKinley, 66, Writer. Beauty: A Retelling of the Story of Beauty and the Beast was her first book. It was considered a superb work, and was named an American Library Association Notable Children’s Book and an ALA Best Book for Young Adults. Rose Daughter is another version of that folktale, whereas Spindle’s End is the story of Sleeping Beauty, and Deerskin and two of the stories that you can find in The Door in the Hedge are based on other folktales. She does a superb telling of the Robin Hood legend in The Outlaws of Sherwood. Among her novels not based on folktales are Sunshine, Chalice, and Dragonhaven. Her 1984 The Hero and the Crown won the Newbery Medal as that year’s best new American children’s book. She was married to Peter Dickinson from 1991 to his death in 2015; they lived together in Hampshire. They co-wrote two splendid collections of Tales of Elemental Spirits: Water and Fire. I’d be very remiss not to note her other bonnie Awards: a 1983 Newbery Honor for The Blue Sword, the 1986 World Fantasy Award for Anthology/Collection for Imaginary Lands, and as editor, the 1998 Phoenix Award Honor Book for Beauty, and the 2004 Mythopoeic Fantasy Award for Adult Literature for Sunshine. Impressive indeed!
  • Born November 16, 1958 – Marg Helgenberger, 60, Actor who played Hera in Wonder Woman. She also appeared in Conan: Red Nails, Species and Species II, After Midnight, Always, the miniseries The Tommyknockers, an episode of Tales from the Crypt, and a recurring role in Under the Dome.
  • Born November 16, 1964 – Harry Lennix, 54, Actor of Stage and Screen and Producer, who has appeared in Suspect Zero, two of The Matrix movies, Man of Steel, Timeless, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, and has provided character voices for animated features and series including Transformers: Robots in Disguise and Justice League: Throne of Atlantis.
  • Born November 16, 1967 – Lisa Bonet, 51, Actor whose first genre work was in an episode of Tales from the Darkside and as Epiphany Proudfoot in Angel Heart, a decidedly strange horror film. More germane was that she was Heather Lelache in the 2002 A&E adaptation of Le Guin’s Lathe of Heaven. She later played Maya Daniels in the Life on Mars series as well.
  • Born November 16, 1972 – Missi Pyle, 46, Actor who played Laliari in Galaxy Quest, which is one of my (and JJ’s) favorite SF films of all time. She also appeared in Josie and the Pussycats, Big Fish, Pandemic, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (which is is just plain awful), Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters, A Haunted House 2, and Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle, and episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation, Roswell, The Tick, Pushing Daisies, and Z Nation.
  • Born November 16, 1976 – Lavie Tidhar, 42, Writer, Editor, and Critic from Israel. The first work I read by him was Central Station, which won 2017 John W. Campbell Memorial Award for Best Science Fiction Novel. It certainly deserved that accolade! The next work by him I experienced was The Bookman Histories, in which Mycroft Holmes is murdered and, well, everything of a pulp nature gets tossed into alternate history England: it’s both brilliant and annoying at times. I’m reading Unholy Land, his telling of the founding of a Jewish homeland long ago in Africa, now. It’s a quieter read than much of his work. He edited the first 3 editions of the anthology series The Apex Book of World SF, an evolution of his BSFA-winning and World Fantasy Award-nominated The World SF Blog, where he posted reviews on international SFF from 2009 to 2013.
  • Born November 16, 1977 – Gigi Edgley, 41, Actor and Singer from Australia. Though her genre experiences are varied, I think she’ll be best remembered for her role as Chiana, one of the Nebari, a repressive race that she rebels against, and as a result, becomes a member of the crew on Moya on the Farscape series. Other genre appearances include a role in Richard Hatch’s robot film Diminuendo, and guest parts in episodes of Beastmaster, The Lost World, Quantum Apocalypse and the web series Star Trek Continues (in “Come Not Between the Dragons”). She is a popular guest at SFF media conventions.

(12) MISTAKES WERE MADE, INFO WAS DUMPED. Beware! Paralysis (from laughter) may ensue when you read “The Concerning Fine by Tim Catzi: Part 2 of the Colluding Umpire” at Camestros Felapton.

Chapter 5
Brunomars Nicechap stood in front of the crowd of angry looking space geologists.
“Please,” he pleaded, “you have to believe me that the whole Interminabledependnecy is going to collapse!”
“Of course we believe you,” said the scientists, “your math checks out and anyway the whole thing started to collapse in the last book. We aren’t idiots.”
“But, but, we’ve a whole chapter to fill with you guys not believing me.” said Brunomars Nicechap.
“Maybe we could just all sit here and check our emails instead?” suggested the scientists.
Which is what they did.

(13) INTERNATIONAL LIFE. Other languages have words for “10 Personality traits English Can’t Name”. Chip Hitchcock marvels, “Who knew Greek had a word for ‘schlimazel’?”

Learning other languages offers insights into the way that other cultures see the world. For someone like myself, gaining those insights can become addictive, and that fixation has led me to study 15 different languages. My recent book, ‘From Amourette to Zal: Bizarre and Beautiful Words from Around Europe’, explores some of the words that other languages have, but that English doesn’t. The following 10 words, for example, describe character traits and behaviours that may be familiar to us all, but that the English language struggles to succinctly express.

(14) HONOR ROLL. BBC snaps pics as “Tom Hardy made a CBE by Prince Charles”. (Fortunately, they didn’t blame him for the Venom script.)

Film star Tom Hardy has been made a CBE for services to drama by Prince Charles at Buckingham Palace.

The Mad Max and Venom actor is a friend of Princes William and Harry and was among the guests at Harry’s wedding to Meghan Markle in May.

(15) CURRENT AFFAIRS. It’s official: “Kilogram gets a new definition”. But Chip Hitchcock says, “I hope some other Filer can explain why this works, or what the BBC has left out. ISTM that they’re measuring weight rather than mass, which means that the same object would have different results depending on where on Earth the measurement happened — on a mountain or at sea level, at the equator vs. the pole.”

How does the new system work?

Electromagnets generate a force. Scrap-yards use them on cranes to lift and move large metal objects, such as old cars. The pull of the electromagnet, the force it exerts, is directly related to the amount of electrical current going through its coils. There is, therefore, a direct relationship between electricity and weight.

So, in principle, scientists can define a kilogram, or any other weight, in terms of the amount of electricity needed to counteract the weight (gravitational force acting on a mass).

Here’s the tricky part

There is a quantity that relates weight to electrical current, called Planck’s constant – named after the German physicist Max Planck and denoted by the symbol h.

But h is an incredibly small number and to measure it, the research scientist Dr Bryan Kibble built a super-accurate set of scales. The Kibble balance, as it has become known, has an electromagnet that pulls down on one side of the scales and a weight – say, a kilogram – on the other.

The electrical current going through the electromagnet is increased until the two sides are perfectly balanced.

By measuring the current running through the electromagnet to incredible precision, the researchers are able to calculate h to an accuracy of 0.000001%.

This breakthrough has paved the way for Le Grand K to be deposed by “die kleine h“.

(16) OTHER CURRENT EVENTS. This week’s BBC News Quiz (and closes) with a gift for Filers. A good thing, because I got the rest of the quiz wrong!

(17) COLLECTIVE MAMATAS. Fantasy Literature delivers a parallax view of Nick Mamatas’ short fiction: “The People’s Republic of Everything: An experimental collection”.

Jana Nyman —

On the whole, though, the stories within The People’s Republic of Everything often feel like they’re lacking something (narrative/thematic focus, clarification of details or character motivation, sometimes even just character voice) that would bring all of the elements together into a cohesive whole. I found myself relying heavily on Mamatas’ notes after each story in order to parse out what his goals and mindsets were for each work.

Marion Deeds —

I enjoyed Nick Mamatas’s story collection The People’s Republic of Everything more than Jana did. My experience with Mamatas’s work is his novel I am Providence, which I enjoyed very much, a few short stories, and his role as a gadfly on Twitter. I had a pretty good idea what to expect from this 2018 collection and I was not disappointed.

(18) SHARED UNIVERSE. Adri Joy makes this sound pretty good — “Microreview [Books]: Redemption’s Blade by Adrian Tchaikovsky and Salvation’s Fire by Justina Robson” at Nerds of a Feather.

Oh hey, a shared universe! In books! Perhaps I’m not reading the right things, but this feels like a pretty rare occurrence, and aside from George R. R. Martin’s Wildcards series (which I haven’t read) and the occasional posthumous series continuation, I’m struggling to think of any intentional collaborations of this kind. Redemption’s Blade and Salvation’s Fire are a sequential pair which together open the “After the War” series. Redemption’s Blade – and, I believe, the concept for the whole world – was written by Adrian Tchaikovsky, who is fast on his way to becoming one of my favourite authors; Salvation’s Fire continues with Justina Robson, whose work I hadn’t read before.

…The fantasy world here is probably best described as “Legend of Zelda except society makes sense”. Humans share their world not with Tolkien-issue elves and dwarves but with the (formerly) winged Aethani, the water-dwelling Shelliac, forests full of ethereal Draeyads (some of which are now eternally on fire), some spider people (a Tchaikovsky special!), and most prominently, the Yorughans….

(19) LOST IN TRANSLATION. If alternative history with John Adams battling giant snakes is SF/Fantasy, then this is a good thread — starts here.

(20) NOT GENRE, JUST WEIRD. The 41st Pasadena Doodah Parade steps off Sunday, November 18.

Known as the twisted sister of the conventional Rose Parade, the Occasional Pasadena Doo Dah Parade began as a grassroots event in 1978 to gain national attention for its eccentric and, often, irreverent satire. The parade which has spawned numerous off-beat replicants across the country was even highlighted in last year’s Wall Street Journal. It was also named by Readers Digest as “America’s Best Parade,” and was recently featured in the book 50 Places You Must Visit Before You Die.

[Thanks to Mike Kennedy, Joel Zakem, Cat Eldridge, John King Tarpinian, JJ, Chip Hitchcock, Martin Morse Wooster, Carl Slaughter, Reuben, and Andrew Porter for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Ingvar.]

Discover more from File 770

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

84 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 11/16/18 A Pixel May Not Scroll A Human Being, Or Through Inaction, Allow A Human To Be Scrolled

  1. Cat Eldridge: I suspect OGH might well have a fit if they started being much longer than they are now…

    Or a cow. He could have a cow, man. That’s also a possibility.

  2. The earliest shared-world fiction I’m aware of is Coventry, which obsessed some LA fans in the decade before I joined LASFS, and the damage it had done to relationships was still reverberating (so much so that it had to be discussed in secret). (The link is to a long Fancyclopedia 3 article.)

    …Players in Coventry converted their true-life identities into fictional role-playing personae. Rich Brown provided a concise explanation of what Coventry actually was: “Coventry wasn’t actually ‘played’; it was written. Basically, people wrote stories about their characters in the setting of Coventry. The ideas would be talked-out for pre-approval, just to be sure they didn’t conflict with what had gone on before.”

    Two caveats — this fiction was published in fanzines, not professionally, and while I don’t know of any earlier instances, I don’t make any claims about this being the first.

  3. Mike Glyer on November 17, 2018 at 3:38 pm said:

    The earliest shared-world fiction I’m aware of is Coventry, which obsessed some LA fans in the decade before I joined LASFS, and the damage it had done to relationships was still reverberating (so much so that it had to be discussed in secret). (The link is to a long Fancyclopedia 3 article.)

    Fascinating – I can see how it could have been addictive. Were the stories themselves any good?

  4. (10) It might be worth mentioning that Goldman dabbled briefly in SF with his final novel, Brothers, in which the older brother spy character from Marathon Man gets involved in some mad-scientist shenanigans. I would call it somewhat interesting but not particularly good.

  5. @OGH: (regarding Coventry): Back at my first con in the late 90s, I went to a fanhistory panel and heard allusions to this, I think. Fascinating (as my Patronus might say).

  6. What about Doctor Who? A huge amount of novels, short stories, audio plays, and comic strips have been produced for it since 1963.

  7. I don’t recall if it’s been mentioned (it probably has, but I’ve been traveling all day and just skimmed this thread), but surely hundreds of people have written Sherlock Holmes stories. If that’s not shared-world (or appropriated-world(?)) I don’t know what is. Does it only count as shared-world if ALL the authors, including the first one, agree to share? (Not being snarky; that’s a real question.)

    Also, I think I have a copy of Medea: Harlan’s World if anyone wants it… (she says, as she gradually gets rid of her dead-tree library).

  8. I got 5/7 on the BBC quiz too, thanks to it not having all sorts of questions about ministers with or without portfolio.

    The Cthulu-verse is, I think, both a shared world AND a bunch of related alternate ‘verses. “Vellit Boe”, f’rex, certainly uses the background, city, and some characters. “Laundry Files”, of course, takes it up to 11.

    I’ve read several of the stories from Serial Box and enjoy them all. Particularly “Tremontaine”, at some points of which I genuinely wondered what was going to happen to one of the main characters for quite some time till I remembered it’s a prequel, and I’d already read the other books! It’s that good. And being a prequel, it’s a good entry. I also like “The Witch Who Came in From the Cold”, which has two dramatically opposed groups of witches in Cold War Prague; the polarity of witches is orthogonal to their Cold War allegiance. And “Bookburners” is also swell, going from basic “Small international Vatican team has to neutralize dangerous artifacts worldwide” to… something way bigger as the seasons go on. Everything from SB also comes as audio books.

    Also read “Whitehall” (straight historical — liked it, but it only ran one season), “Born to the Blade” (also one), and am only a little into the YA “Remade”, which is much better than most YA, so can’t comment.

    They start new stories regularly — two of the upcoming SF ones look interesting.

    Lots of fabled SF/F/H names write for them. And some of them are free!

  9. @Cassy B (re Sherlock) IMO, the essence of a shared world is that it is actively shared, including in its creation; I don’t think writing in the universe of someone who isn’t even around to comment counts, even if lots of people are doing it (especially as most are doing it ~independently). I think your term “appropriated” applies to both Holmes-fic and Cthulhu extensions.

  10. Andrew Porter: #1: Lets honor people for what they’ve done, not for the color of their skins or where they were born or currently live.

    The problem is that when the people who are honored are consistently white, year after year, it starts to look like they’re being honored for the color of their skins, in addition to their accomplishments.

  11. (3) JUST PINING FOR THE FJORDS. First it sounds like the content’s just moving but then it sounds more like they will not have any more new content, really. That’s a shame. Still, I’m on their e-mail list, so presumably whatever they do will still make its way to me. 🙂

    /Bookmarks since subscribing does nothing

  12. @Chip: “I think your term “appropriated” applies to both Holmes-fic and Cthulhu extensions.”

    Disagree on Cthulhu; other people were playing in that sandbox while HPL was still around, with his consent. (Clark Ashton “Klarkash-Ton” Smith and August Derleth, for instance.) That’s rather different from people publishing new Holmes stories once ACD wasn’t around to object.

    They may fall into the same category now, given that the original creators are all deceased, but there’s a substantial difference in how they started.

  13. Casey B: Surely hundreds of people have written Sherlock Holmes stories. If that’s not shared-world (or appropriated-world(?)) I don’t know what is.

    By this definition, though, anything that anyone has written fanfiction in could be considered “shared world”, because there are at least two authors writing in the same world. I think it’s useful to distinguish between a “shared world” that involves collective development of one canon – which could be collaborative or intergenerational but implies all involved are working with/under a single authority- and a “shared world” where creators are playing in the same sandbox, but authority and appeals to canon don’t come into it and you can have multiple, transformative takes on the same thing.

    Of course, that falls apart when you start looking at multigenererational retcons and rewrites of e.g. Star Wars or the big comic universes. So, who knows where I’m going with this…

    @Lurkertype I’ve got Tremontaine and Born to the Blade on the TBR, but it sounds like I need to get in on Witch Who Came in from the Cold too… and yes, some of the announcements for next year (Ninth Step Station!) sound REALLY exciting 😮

  14. Beyond the lack of shared characters (which I agree is not a requirement), the reason I don’t think the Cthulhu Mythos really qualifies as a shared universe any more is that the events and timelines don’t match up. Historical domain characters play different roles in different stories. Heck, they can’t even agree on the date the world ends! 🙂

  15. JJ: The problem is that when the people who are honored are consistently white, year after year, it starts to look like they’re being honored for the color of their skins, in addition to their accomplishments.

    It looks to who that they’re being honored for being, say, white? The founders of this country were almost all white. Do we honor them for their accomplishments or for the whiteness of their skins. I’d say the former.

  16. Andrew Porter: It looks to who that they’re being honored for being, say, white? The founders of this country were almost all white. Do we honor them for their accomplishments or for the whiteness of their skins. I’d say the former.

    That’s a shamelessly strawman argument, but nice try.

    The identity of the founders of the U.S. is a historic fact that does not change. The Guests of Honor at World Fantasy Convention are a contemporary set of people who change on an ongoing basis.

    That the people who keep getting selected, on an ongoing basis, are almost exclusively white, makes it look to me and a lot of other people like the GoHs are being chosen for both the color of their skin and their literary accomplishments.

  17. @Xtifr: “the events and timelines don’t match up.”

    I could say the same for the Halloween franchise, which now has at least three competing versions of events. (Actually, I point to that franchise as the cinematic equivalent of an urban legend, for precisely that reason. Just as urban legends are notoriously fuzzy with hard facts, the Halloween movies have effectively canonized a rejection of such canon.)

    ETA: Oh, and Doctor Who has destroyed Atlantis in at least three mutually incompatible ways.

  18. @ Rev.Bob:

    The Godzilla movies did the same sort of thing. The eighties movies ignored all parts of the original series except for the first film. The Millennium series not only ignored the first series and the eighties series, but also each other (that is, every film in the Millennium series was a direct sequel to the first movie and shared no continuity with any other movie–unless specifically mentioned). And Shin Godzilla ignores even the first movie, creating its own continuity.

    We won’t talk about the American films.

  19. Pingback: Pixel Scroll 11/21/18 Never Pixel Or Scrollardy. Never Click Up, Never File In | File 770

  20. @Chip Hitchcock re (15) New Kilogram. You probably already got a good answer already, but the assumption is that a lab that makes standard weights (or that tests them) can accurately measure four quantities in a Kibble Balance: electric potential, current, force of gravity at that location, and velocity of a moving wire. “Accurately” means within about 50 parts per billion.

    Most researchers wouldn’t really do this; they’d use calibrated weights of one form or another. Only the labs that calibrated those weights would use Kibble Balances. That’s expensive, but it frees everyone from relying on copies (or copies of copies) of Le Gran K.

  21. Do you think we will ever see the day where all the special people just leave their sex and race and other hangups in the cloakroom and join a party simply for the fun that’s in it?

  22. @Greg Hullender
    the assumption is that a lab that makes standard weights (or that tests them) can accurately measure four quantities in a Kibble Balance: electric potential, current, force of gravity at that location, and velocity of a moving wire. “Accurately” means within about 50 parts per billion.

    “Force of gravity at that location” isn’t measured with a Kibble Balance. The best measurements of g are made (to the precision required above) by dropping a mass in vacuum, and setting up an interferometer with the bottom of the dropped mass being at the end of one leg of the interferometer. The rate of interferometric fringes can be measured very precisely (because you are essentially measuring time); if you know the wavelength of the interfermoter’s light source accurately (and you do), you can measure the acceleration of the dropping mass precisely, and from that, local g.

  23. Curtis, I don’t know, but as long as the white men are clinging so desperately to their own specialness, I don’t see them ever changing that and just partying with whoever wants in.

  24. Curtis: Do you think we will ever see the day where all the special people just leave their sex and race and other hangups in the cloakroom and join a party simply for the fun that’s in it?

    Perhaps, if the party ever starts being fun for everyone, rather than just fun for the straight white people who are running things.

    It’s easy not to have “hangups” about things when you’re not constantly on the receiving end of deliberate and unconscious biases, exclusions, insults, and slights which hinder your career and destroy your self-esteem, isn’t it?

  25. What does it say about me that I have just (very belatedly) noticed that the date format for the Pixel Scroll titles are in USAian format?

    And now that I have, it will be an ongoing reminder that (IMO) it is a weird notation. MM/DD/YY is not even the more sensible Little Endian (DD/MM/YY) or Big Endian (YY/MM/DD) which is the most logical as it allows for a straightforward sorting of dates. No, the American format is Middle Endian: month, then day, then… year?

    Does anyone else find it a strange date format, or do Americans not even think twice about it because it is the format they have known all their lives?

  26. @Soon Lee
    Most Americans don’t even think about date formats. (I normally use little-endian, but when I’m naming files, I’m probably going to use big-endian so they sort properly.)

  27. @Soon Lee–

    Does anyone else find it a strange date format, or do Americans not even think twice about it because it is the format they have known all their lives?

    Yes, it is the format we have known all our lives, and we can see that it is the format that has prevailed throughout our history, so, yeah, it seems perfectly normal.

    And yes, if we are online and interacting with people from other parts of the world, we have heard repeatedly about how strange it is. Indeed, “strange” has the virtue of being polite, and it is not uncommon to instead get a blunt “stupid”.

    My personal preference would be year/month/date, if not for the “It’s proof Americans are stupid, to do it their way” contingent. They cause me to, at least some of the time, take a certain glee in confusing them. 😉

  28. I use year/month/day when naming files. I am used to American style, but I agree that it makes less logical sense, and adapt readily to day-first style. When I’m giving a date to a mixed crowd I usually use letters for the month to avoid confusion.

  29. Soon Lee: What does it say about me that I have just (very belatedly) noticed that the date format for the Pixel Scroll titles are in USAian format?

    Not sure what it says about you. However, I’m reminded that there was a bit of an uproar when I started adding dates, just in its own right. Somebody was disturbed by that departure from the accustomed dateless format.

  30. Mike Glyer: I’m reminded that there was a bit of an uproar when I started adding dates, just in its own right. Somebody was disturbed by that departure from the accustomed dateless format.

    Oh, yes, back in The Year Of The Pup, there was only MM/DD dating in the Scroll titles. Once the year changed to 2016, Mike changed the format to MM/DD/YY to avoid confusion, and we had the usual Filer debate, this time about most desirable date formats.

  31. Well, according to my computer, “Today is Pungenday, the 36th day of The Aftermath in the YOLD 3184”. Frankly, I think that should settle it–any other opinion is worthless! 🙂

    (The “ddate” or “Discordian Date” program used to be standard on all Linux systems. At some point, the grumpy guardians of staid seriousness decided this sort of frivolity was unacceptable for a business system, and managed to get this tiny program ousted from the bundle of standard utility programs where it had been lurking, but it’s still available as an optional add-on for many flavors of Linux.)

Comments are closed.