Pixel Scroll 11/27/18 Three Pixels And One Scroll Are Trapped In A File! Send Tick Boxes! If You Can’t Send Tick Boxes, Send Two More Chapter Fives!

(1) WHAT’S INSIGHT. The InSight lander, after yesterday’s successful touchdown, charged up its solar-powered batteries and tested its camera….

(This may be an old chestnut by now, but it’s a Martian chestnut!)

(2) ELVES AND MEN. Olga Polomoshnova considers partings beyond the end of the world in “Last Goodbye” at Middle-Earth Reflections.

Before proceeding, let us look at the fates of Elves and Men after death to understand why Lúthien’s and Arwen’s decisions caused such grief to their parents. The First Children of Ilúvatar were doomed to dwell in Arda as long as it endured. If Elves died (they could be either slain, or die of grief), they went to the Halls of Mandos and stayed there for some time. Then they, with a few notable exceptions, were restored to their bodily forms and returned to life in Aman. Therefore Elves could reunite with their kin and loved ones: even death could not part them forever.

(3) BOOKS OF THE YEAR. NPR’s “Guide To 2018’s Great Reads” – a general link — left-side picks filter for genre.

What would you like to read?

Use the filters below to explore more than 300 titles NPR staff and critics loved this year. (You can also combine filters!)

(4) GREAT WALL OF GOOGLE. “‘We’re Taking A Stand’: Google Workers Protest Plans For Censored Search In China”NPR has the story.

The project, code-named Dragonfly, would block certain websites and search terms determined by the Chinese government — a move that, according to a growing number of workers at Google, is tantamount to enabling “state surveillance.”

“We are among thousands of employees who have raised our voices for months. International human rights organizations and investigative reporters have also sounded the alarm, emphasizing serious human rights concerns and repeatedly calling on Google to cancel the project,” said the letter’s signatories, whose group initially numbered nine employees but has ballooned since its publication on Medium.

…The employees are not alone in expressing their dismay at reports of the new project’s development. In fact, they released their letter the same day that Amnesty International launched a protest of its own. The human rights organization announced it would be reaching out to Google staff to add their names to a petition calling on CEO Sundar Pichai to kill the project before it can even get off the ground.

“This is a watershed moment for Google,” Joe Westby, Amnesty’s researcher on technology and human rights, said in a statement Tuesday. “As the world’s number one search engine, it should be fighting for an internet where information is freely accessible to everyone, not backing the Chinese government’s dystopian alternative.”

(5) NYT NOTABLE. Naomi Novik’s Spinning Silver has been named a “2018 Notable Book” by the New York Times. (There is only one page for all the fiction selections, so this link does not go directly to the Novik entry.)

In her stunning new novel, rich in both ideas and people, Novik gives classic fairy tales — particularly “Rumpelstiltskin” — a fresh, wholly original twist, with the vastness of Tolkien and the empathy and joy in daily life of Le Guin.

(6) FOR GIVING. Nerds of a Feather has a nice roundup of recommendations in “Holiday Gift Guide: Games”. Here’s one —

Fireball Island (Mike):

If you are looking for a blast of nostalgia then Fireball Island from Restoration Board Games is the game you want under your tree. Vul-Kar has returned and is not happy. Players make their way around the island picking up treasures and snapping pictures.  You can try to steal the heart of Vul-Kar, but watch out for the rolling embers and fireballs that will make your adventure a dangerous one.  Featuring a bigger board than the original and some optional expansions, Fireball Island looks amazing on the table with its stunning 3-D board and shiny marbles.

Another installment covers “Holiday Gift Guide: Books and Comics”, and includes a Paul Weimer writeup:

Dungeons and Dragons Art and Arcana: A Visual History (recommended by Paul)

This the definitive work that shows the growth and evolution of the artwork used in the Dungeons and Dragons games over the last 40 years. It’s an amazingly deep dive into a look at the game, not just as its art, as filtered through the changing depictions of everything. From the first handdrawn maps of the original developers of the game, to the modern sleek art of today, the book’s art unlocks the evolution of the game through imagery and essays. While the book is mainly arranged by chronology, starting from the precursors of D&D in the 1970’s and running up to today, my favorite feature is “Evilution”, where the book breaks this format to show how an iconic monster or character, like, for example, the fearsome Beholder, has evolved across multiple editions. Features like this give a cohesive and complete view of how the art and the imagery of the game has evolved and changed over time. And, joyfully, the book has some of my favorite art in the game’s history, like “Emirikol the Chaotic”. Anyone vaguely interested in Dungeons and Dragons will love this book. It’s compulsively dippable back into anytime, to be inspired to write, dream, and of course, roleplay.


[Compiled by Cat Eldridge and JJ.]

  • Born November 27, 1907 – L. Sprague de Camp, Aeronautical Engineer, Writer, and Member of First Fandom, whose early career included many stories for Campbell’s Astounding and Unknown magazines. His time-travel alt-history Lest Darkness Fall is considered a classic. He and Fletcher Pratt co-wrote the popular humorous Incomplete Enchanter fantasy series and collaborated on the Gavagan’s Bar series. His later career turned mostly to fantasy, and he contributed more than three dozen stories to Robert E. Howard’s Conan universe. He wrote many nonfiction reference works for both science fiction and fantasy, as well as a biography of H.P. Lovecraft; his Time & Chance: An Autobiography won a Hugo Award for Best Nonfiction Book. By all accounts, his 60-year marriage with fellow fan and writing collaborator Catherine Crook was a great love, and the two of them were Guest of Honor at more than two dozen conventions. He was GoH at Worldcon in 1966, named SFWA Grand Master in 1979, was honored with a World Fantasy Award for Life Achievement in 1984, and received a Sidewise Award for Special Achievement in Alternate History in 1995. (Died 2000.)
  • Born November 27, 1951 – Melinda M. Snodgrass, 67, Attorney, Historian, Writer, Editor, Equestrian, and Fan whose Star Trek Original Series early Pocket Books tie-in novel featuring Uhura, The Tears of the Singers, is still considered one of the best, and is probably the reason that her unsolicited script for Star Trek: The Next Generation was accepted and made into the acclaimed episode “The Measure of a Man” – considered by many to be the first truly great episode of the series, and for which she received a Writers Guild of America Award nomination. As a result, she became the series story editor and script consultant for the second and third seasons of TNG. She also wrote scripts for the series Odyssey 5, The (new) Outer Limits, Sliders, SeaQuest DSV, and Beyond Reality, and for the TV movies Trapped in Space (based on Asimov’s story “Breaking Strain”) and Star Command. She is co-creator and co-editor, with GRRM, of the Wild Cards shared universe, which since 1987 has spawned more than two dozen novels and anthologies and more than 200 short fiction works; a TV series is in the works, for which she will be an executive producer. This year saw the release of the third volume in her Military SF quintology The Imperials (which JJ thinks is fantastic).
  • Born November 27, 1940 – Bruce Lee, Actor, Director, and Martial Artist from Hong Kong, best known for his martial arts adventure films – but he had a recurring genre role as Kato in the TV series The Green Hornet which, to my utter surprise, turns out to only have lasted for 26 episodes between 1966 and 1967. He also appeared in three episodes of Adam West’s Batman series, “The Spell of Tut”, “ Batman’s Satisfaction”, and “A Piece of The Action”. He died before having the opportunity to have a full life and career at the age of 32, due to cerebral swelling caused or exacerbated by reaction to pain medication. (Died 1973.)
  • Born November 27, 1960 – Lori Wolf, Forensic Chemist, Bookseller, Conrunner, and Fan who was a member of the Cepheid Variables fan club at Texas A&M and a past chair of the Fandom Association of Central Texas. She co-chaired two ArmadilloCons, served on numerous other convention committees, and managed the Hugo Award ceremony at Worldcon in 1997 and the Boucher Award ceremony at the World Mystery Convention in 2002. She left fandom too soon at the age of 43 after a battle with cancer. (Died 2004.)
  • Born November 27, 1961 – Samantha Bond, Actor from England who is best known for playing Miss Moneypenny in four James Bond films during the series’ Pierce Brosnan years, but her first genre role was as Helga in Erik the Viking, which was written and directed by Monty Python‘s Terry Jones. She had a recurring role as Mrs Wormwood in the Doctor Who spinoff The Sarah Jane Adventures, and provided voices for characters in the live-action marionette film Strings and in The Children’s Midsummer Night’s Dream.
  • Born November 27, 1974 – Jennifer O’Dell, Actor whose main genre role of note is three seasons as Veronica on Arthur Conan Doyle’s The Lost World, a series very loosely based on his 1912 novel. She had roles in two genre films, Sometimes They Come Back… for More and Alien Battlefield, and a guest part in an episode of Charmed.


(9) SPIDER PROLIFERATION. The Hollywood Reporter says “‘Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse’ Sequel and All-Female Spinoff in the Works From Sony”.

With just weeks to go before Sony unveils the buzzy animated movie, Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, Sony Pictures Animation is already putting the pieces together for not just a sequel but a spinoff as well.

Joaquim Dos Santos, known for his work on cartoon series Avatar: The Last Airbender and, more recently, Netflix’s Voltron series, has been tapped to direct the sequel. David Callaham, who penned The Expendables and worked on Wonder Woman 1984 as well as Zombieland 2, is writing.

At the same time Lauren Montgomery, who also worked on Voltron and co-directed animated movies Batman: Year One and Superman/Batman: Apocalypse for DC, is in negotiations to helm an untitled Spider-centric project that will gather the female heroes in the Spider-Man universe of characters in one adventure. Bek Smith, who wrote episodes of CBS show Zoo, will pen the script.

(10) NEXT YEAR’S LOSCON. Loscon 46, which will be held November 29-December 1, 2019, has unveiled its website.  There you can find out more about the guests of honor.

Howard Waldrop

Professional Writer Guest of Honor

Julie Dillon

Artist Guest of Honor

Edie Stern

Fan Guest of Honor

(11) WORD BUCKET BRIGADE. BBC tells about “The app that makes writing less lonely”.

If you see a writer in a movie, most likely she (or he) will be tapping on a laptop. But many young writers are doing it on mobile phones, and sometimes in teams….

(12) A GIANT RETURN ON CAPITAL. Another Netflix sff announcement: “Netflix to adapt Roald Dahl stories including Matilda and The BFG”.

Felicity Dahl, the author’s widow, said it was “an incredibly exciting new chapter for the Roald Dahl Story Company.”

She added: “Roald would, I know, be thrilled.”

Melissa Cobb, a spokesperson for Netflix, said: “We have great creative ambition to reimagine the journeys of so many treasured Dahl characters in fresh, contemporary ways with the highest quality animation and production values.”

(13) SHUTDOWN. Text and video on decommissioning a UK nuclear-fuel reprocessing plant — “Inside Sellafield’s death zone with the nuclear clean-up robots”.

Thorp still looks almost new; a giant structure of cavernous halls, deep blue-tinged cooling ponds and giant lifting cranes, imposing in fresh yellow paint.

But now the complex process of decontaminating and dismantling begins.

It is a dangerous job that will take decades to complete and require a great deal of engineering ingenuity and state-of-the-art technology – some of which hasn’t even been invented yet.

This is why.

Five sieverts of radiation is considered a lethal dose for humans. Inside the Head End Shear Cave, where nuclear fuel rods were extracted from their casings and cut into pieces before being dissolved in heated nitric acid, the radiation level is 280 sieverts per hour.

(14) PICKY EATER. The “‘Siberian unicorn’ walked Earth with humans” – if so, then the humans got out of its way!

A giant rhino that may have been the origin of the unicorn myth survived until at least 39,000 years ago – much longer than previously thought.

Known as the Siberian unicorn, the animal had a long horn on its nose, and roamed the grasslands of Eurasia.

New evidence shows the hefty beast may have eventually died out because it was such a picky eater.

…Weighing in at a mighty four tonnes, with an extraordinary single horn on its head, the “Siberian unicorn”, shared the earth with early modern humans up until at least 39,000 years ago.

(15) JEOPARDY! TONIGHT. Andrew Porter reports sff made another appearance on the Jeopardy! game show tonight.

  • In the category, “The Writer Speaks,” the clue was, “This ‘Space Odyssey’ Author: ‘I predict that a new species could well appear on Earth–what I call Robosapiens.”
  • No one could answer with the question, “Who is Arthur C. Clarke.”

(16) TRADITION OVER THRONE AT MEDIEVAL TIMES. Dave Doering writes, “I see that our boisterous battle and binging eatery has run into tougher times over historical recreations as this line from the Washington Post has it — ’Medieval Times has a queen for the first time, but the show is still stuck in the Dark Ages’.” Dave seems shaken up by this change. “First, it was the maiden market in Pirates of the Caribbean ride in Disneyland, now we have erased more history…”

The Dairy Queen used to reign supreme over the Arundel Mills shopping mall. But last month, a new ruler ascended the throne: All hail Doña Maria Isabella, who presides over a kingdom of knights and squires, horses and falcons, rotisserie chicken, middle-schoolers wearing paper crowns and Honda Odysseys in the parking lot of the fake castle it shares with a Best Buy next door.

History is being made at the same time it’s being reenacted at Medieval Times. It’s the first time a female ruler has presided over the equestrian jousting dinner theater experience in its nearly 35-year history in America. Gender equality and the #MeToo and Time’s Up movements are still making progress in politics and the C-suite, but at least here, in this version of 11th-century Spain, cultural forces have unseated a long-ruling monarch.

(17) BOOZE CONTINUES, CHOW ON HIATUS. The Franklin Avenue blog drew attention to a big change at the reopened (in 2015) Clifton’s Cafeteria, home to LASFS meetings in the 1930s — “Clifton’s Closes Its Cafeteria; Will Food Ever Return to the Downtown Landmark?”

Opened in 1935 as Clifton’s Brookdale, we visited the forest-themed eatery several times before new owner Andrew Meieran (who previously created downtown’s famed Edison bar) shut it down for what was supposed to be a brief renovation in 2011.

Cut to nearly five years later, and rebuilding Clifton’s became a labor of love for Meieran, who has kept the fun and the kitsch but added so much more to the place. Clifton’s finally re-opened in 2015.

Clifton’s original famous slogan, of course, was “Pay What You Wish, Dine Free Unless Delighted.” Perhaps not enough folks were delighted with the updated cafeteria. I asked Chris Nichols via Twitter what he knew about the shut-down cafeteria portion of Clifton’s, and he wrote back: “I also miss eating at Clifton’s. This just in from the owner: ‘food is definitely coming back— pretty soon if anyone asks.'”

(18) HAUNTED PAINTING. Heritage Auctions is taking bids on “Haunted Mansion Stretching Room Disneyland Painting Original Art”. Currently up to $3,009. Helps if you have a really tall living room.

“The Haunted Mansion” opened in New Orleans Square on 8/9/69. The Mansion boasted a population of 999 Happy Haunts. People rode in “Doom Buggies” in this ride. The “Ghost Host” of this attraction was the voice of Paul Frees. The tour of the Mansion begins in the famous “Stretching Room.” As the walls get larger, four portraits appear to grow and change right before your eyes. The four paintings were designed by original Disney “Nine Old Men” member and Disney Legend Inductee, Mr. Marc Davis. The Stretching Room portraits were hand-painted from 1969 to 1972. They would be changed over time. Eventually they went to prints. This is a rare original hand-painted Stretching Room painting on canvas. It is very large, measuring 11′ 2″ x 3′ 10″. A wooden pole is at the top, for mounting purposes. This is the Elderly Widow, sitting on her husband’s tombstone. One of the few original paintings from the Stretching Room that we have seen, that is hand-signed by Marc Davis. One of the single most identifiable pieces of Disneyland Park original artwork we have ever come across! A slight crease where the tracks to stretching device were. Minor scuffing and edge wear from normal use. Overall Good condition.

[Thanks to John King Tarpinian, Rich Horton, Cat Eldridge, Chip Hitchcock, Mike Kennedy, Martin Morse Wooster, JJ, Scott Edelman, Carl Slaughter, Rob Thornton, and Andrew Porter for some of these stories. Title credit goes to File 770 contributing editor of the day Randall M.]

29 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 11/27/18 Three Pixels And One Scroll Are Trapped In A File! Send Tick Boxes! If You Can’t Send Tick Boxes, Send Two More Chapter Fives!

  1. 7) I was always a fan of de Camp’s non-fiction, particularly his books Lost Continents (about the origins of stories about Atlantis, Lemuria, etc.), and Great Cities of the Ancient World (pretty much what it says on the tin, and with some great Roy G. Krenkel illustrations).

    And (re: Jennifer O’Dell) I had forgotten that there was ever a film adaptation of Stephen King’s “Sometimes They Come Back”, and had not the faintest idea that there had been [checks IMDB] at least two sequel films?

  2. Re: Scroll title.
    I suddenly have a “river crossing” puzzle in mind, involving readers and books…

    15) Shamefully, I would not have known that one. Clarke would have been one of my possible guesses, but only one of several.

    6) The Art and Arcana book is amazingly detailed. I found out from Matt Forbeck that there is a super deluxe version that was on sale on Black Friday on amazon, I can’t justify getting that on top of the one I have.

  3. 12) Sadly, I’ve lost the ability to enjoy Dahl’s work after learning about his anti-semitism and all around bigotry. And many of the excuses made by others on his behalf sound an awful lot like the way people minimize racism today.

    “Unfortunately for those looking to diminish Dahl’s bigotry, the author was not exactly a ‘private’ bigot whose comments were reported second-hand. The creator of ‘The Twits’ put himself on the record — many times — as being against Jews and other minorities.

    In an effort that was hushed up until today, Dahl’s world-renowned children’s books were heavily edited to remove content that expressed his contempt for women, blacks, the disabled, and other groups Dahl enjoyed marginalizing, often with over-the-top stereotypes.”


  4. 7) I always enjoyed de Camp’s non-fiction, particularly Lost Continents (about the underpinnings of stories about Atlantis, Lemuria, etc.) and Great Cities of the Ancient World (pretty much what it says on the tin, and with nice illustrations by Roy G. Krenkel).

    I had completely forgotten that there had been a movie of “Sometimes They Come Back”, the first(?) story in which Stephen King deals with the greasers who used to beat him up in high school. I had no idea that there had been [checks IMDB] two sequel movies.

  5. Andrew: One of the first things I noticed at Toad Woods last week was a poster stating that Yngvi was not a louse. I don’t know who to believe any more!

  6. (7) Thank you for remembering Lori Wolf. Lori was one of the most brilliant and friendly and just plain good people I’ve ever known in fandom, which is saying something. In order to really appreciate her, you had to pay attention and connect the dots, she was always doing so many things, and so well. Condolences to A.T. and all who were close to her.

  7. @Kip: It’s a mad house!

    In Brin’s “The Practice Effect” (if I recall correctly) one of the guards in the prison our hero finds himself in says something to the effect of “This place has been full of lice ever since we had Yngvi in here.”

    Just checked – it’s “But this place sure has been lousy since Yngvi arrived”

  8. The latest Longlist Anthology e-books have been made available to backers.

    It’s 5377 here. Kickstarter delays are getting out of hand!

  9. With regard to kaboobie’s comments on Dahl – well, yeah, he was a bigot and an all-around PITA, really. There’s a rather lovely example here of people – specifically, his then publishers – having Had Quite Enough of Dahl, and telling him so in no uncertain terms.

  10. @5: Good for Novik; not so good for the NYT, which lists only one other SFF work (and that’s borderline) in its 48 fiction selections.

    @7: I remember watching an episode or two of Green Hornet when it came out, and being bored; it seemed a weak and obvious attempt to ride the Batman wave.

    @7ctd: I remember de Camp as having a rigid posture that belied his quiet civility; I’ve wondered what it was like for him dealing with the petty-restrictions Heinlein and the boisterous Asimov when they worked together during World War II. He also had some repute as a debunker, although I’ve read little of his work in that line. (There’s also a story, ascribed to a number of locations, about him telling an importunate Scientologist “I knew L. Ron Hubbard when he was just a small-time crook.”) The Incomplete Enchanter wasn’t the first attempt at funny fantasy I’d come across, but it was the first that I thought worked — despite being much older than the others.

  11. @Chip Hitchcock: “I remember de Camp as having a rigid posture that belied his quiet civility; I’ve wondered what it was like for him dealing with the petty-restrictions Heinlein and the boisterous Asimov when they worked together during World War II.”

    I know Heinlein never wrote extensively about that time. Did de Camp or Asimov?

  12. @John A Arkansawyer:

    Asimov wrote at length (how else?) about that period in the first volume of his autobiography; during that period Asimov did de Camp a minor favor, which (per Asimov) de Camp repaid with decades of friendship.

  13. Chip Hitchcock: I’ve wondered what it was like for him dealing with the petty-restrictions Heinlein and the boisterous Asimov….

    You’re so widely read I’m assuming you’ve read the Patterson bio of Heinlein. Did we each come away from that with such a different idea of Heinlein? I mean, the Heinlein of the early Forties, not the fellow he became in the Seventies.

    In any event, I know the Heinleins and the DeCamps got together socially in later years, so I have tended to assume the two writers always got along fine.

  14. 7) One of the panelists at Tuscon turned me on to the Bruce Lee Podcast, produced by the family foundation and co-hosted by his daughter. Available whencever fine podcasts are appertained.

  15. 9) I was somewhat interested in “Into the Spider-Verse” from the trailer, but a little leery since neither Sony’s Spider-man iterations (except the first 2 Sam Raimi ones for me) nor Marvel animations have been anything to write home about.

    However, I saw several critics absolutely RAVING about it on Twitter last night, which has me much more excited to see it. And I just now saw that it currently has a perfect 100 on Rotten Tomatoes based on early reviews.

    Tangent: I recently signed up for AMC’s 3-movies-a-week for $20/month A-List deal (now that our local has the recliners and pick-a-seat-online options, I’ve been going more often!) and I can make reservations now for Aquaman and Spider-verse. I usually skip the bells-and-whistles screenings (3D/IMAX etc) and go for the regular ones because the extra isn’t worth the ticket markup for me. But there’s no markup with the A-List. So — which type of screening should I go for — IMAX, 3D, some combo thereof, or plain vanilla?

  16. Just finished VanderMeer’s Acceptance. Wow! I seem to remember reading good things about the trilogy on this site two or three years ago, and liking the sound of it, but it wasn’t until I broke a long reading drought a couple of months ago that I picked up Annihilation and I was hooked and the drought was over. I tore through it.

    I was somewhat disappointed with the majority of Authority; to me it came across as a second-rank Le Carre. Funnily enough, after finishing that one I googled VanderMeer and Le Carre to find that he was a big fan, particularly of A Perfect Spy, which I thought Authority was the most like. I guess the protagonist’s name of Control was something of a giveaway too. Anyway, the thing really picked up for me in the climax and there are stunning images from there that are still lingering in the imagination.

    So I started reading Acceptance, trying to read it slowly and savour the final instalment. Unfortunately last night I got a bit carried away, and finished it nearly in one sitting. I only just finished the last 40 or so pages this evening, and I have questions. Maybe I rushed and missed stuff, maybe I’m an insensitive reader, or maybe it’s not all intended to be knowable. I’d appreciate others’ thoughts:

    Vf gur Penjyre Fnhy be abg? Gjb punenpgref creprvir Fnhy’f snpr va vg, ohg bar frrf bayl fbzr fbeg bs nyvra yvsr sbez. Ohg evtug ng gur raq gur aneengvir oevatf Fnhy evtug gb gur gbcbtencuvpny nabznyl.
    Pbageby frrzf jnl gb varcg gb trg gur wbo, rira jvgu uvf zbgure’f uryc. V gubhtug V ernq n uvag gung gur qverpgbe unq vagraqrq uvz gb gnxr bire sebz ure. Qb lbh nterr? Jung jrer ure zbgvingvbaf.
    V qvqa’g dhvgr trg jung gur checbfr bs gur Nern K znpuvar jnf: gb znxr n cbegvba bs Rnegu unovgnoyr sbe gur rkgvapg enpr?
    Evtug ng gur raq, nf Tubfg Oveq naq Tenpr ernpu Gur Fbhgurea Ernpu, vg frrzf gb unir ntrq zhpu gbb dhvpxyl tvira gung vg’f abj ba gur vafvqr bs gur obeqre. Jung’f hc jvgu gung?
    Gurer ner uvagf gung gvzr vf aba-yvarne gbjneqf gur raq. Fnhy frrvat juvgr enoovgf orsber Gur Fbhgurea Ernpu hfrq gurz. Urael’f jerfgyvat jvgu Fnhy juvpu znl be znl abg or n cerpbtavgvba bs fbzrguvat’f jerfgyvat jvgu gur Qverpgbe va Naavuvyngvba.
    Sbe gung znggre, jub vf Urael?
    Vf Nern K ba Rnegu, ba nabgure cynarg be va fbzr bgure qvzrafvba?

    Actually, I probably have more questions, but maybe I’ll wait and see if people are still interested in talking about this.

    Also, I thought I learnt somewhere that Alex Garland only read the first of the books before writing his script, so after seeing the movie and then reading that book, I was surprised at how far the two diverged. But reading the other two, I now think there was much more imagery from all three in the movie than it at first appeared to me. (Eg the use of mirroring, which is only very subtly hinted at in the first, versus the mirroring and ‘refracting’ of the movie.)

  17. Also:

    Jung vf gur fvtavsvpnapr bs abobql hfvat gurve anzrf va Nern K? Naq nyzbfg vzzrqvngryl nsgre Tenpr unf punfgvfrq/guerngrarq Pbageby sbe qbvat fb, fur tbrf nurnq naq hfrf uvf erny anzr naljnl? Jevgvat vapbafvfgrapl, be zrnavatshy?

  18. Cliff: I agree with you that Authority was the weakest book of the three—I gave it three stars, and the other two five stars (on my personal list of books I read each year). The other two blew me away.

  19. Chip Hitchcock says I remember watching an episode or two of Green Hornet when it came out, and being bored; it seemed a weak and obvious attempt to ride the Batman wave.

    Though it was acknowledged by the network as an obvious attempt to ride the popularity of the Batman show, I’d say it stood just fine when judged on its own values. I think of it as being closer to the pulp tradition than the Batman show which was deliberately campy could ever be.

  20. @Cat Eldredge It could be; I wasn’t aware of the pulp tradition at the time, and that version of Batman was certainly the most twee I’ve ever seen. Memory suggests that version of Green Hornet was very understated by what I’ve read of pulp since (e.g., The Saint back when he had a troop instead of a smirk) — even allowing for the constraints of 1960’s TV — but I haven’t seen it since so memory has its limits.

    @OGH: actually, I haven’t read the Patterson; it sounded too much like hagiography. (I suppose I should get to it sometime.) My understanding of RAH may be unkind — I’ve read of his generosity to other writers — but I get the impression that he may have felt people not from military academies didn’t appreciate the seriousness of the job.

  21. @Chip Hitchcock: I enjoyed the first volume of the Patterson biography a great deal. It’s not quite hagiography and it’s not perfect. I hope to read the second volume soon.

    “I get the impression that he may have felt people not from military academies didn’t appreciate the seriousness of the job.”

    I’ve only known one academy graduate well, a Marine colonel who fought in Korea and Vietnam. I’m still mad at myself for never getting him my copy of Kenneth Brown’s brilliant play The Brig, which he was curious about because he’d worked in the institution it was based on.

    As you can guess from that, he and I had large political differences, but not so large as you might think once we’d passed the last millennium.

    He and I and about a dozen other friends–one of whom is likely lurking here–spent a social weekend at a mutual friend’s house. That weekend, my friend told a funny story about catching a Marine doing someone he shouldn’t have, not while on sentry duty. When he’d finished the story, someone asked him what happened to that Marine.

    I think I was the only person not surprised when he said, “I court-martialed him.”

    He knew when to end a story better than his audience did.

  22. John: yes, I think those relative ratings are fair. I suspect Authority would be more re-warding on a re-read, but as I get older I find I’d rather read new stuff than re-read.

Comments are closed.