Pixel Scroll 1/19/16 That Wretched Hive of Scrolls and Pixelry

(1) LE GUIN’S PROTEST. Ursula K. Le Guin’s letter to the editor in The Oregonian concisely explains the injustice of allowing Ammon Bundy and company to continue occupying a federal wildlife refuge.

Federal land: The Oregonian’s A1 headline on Sunday, Jan. 17, “Effort to free federal lands,” is inaccurate and irresponsible. The article that follows it is a mere mouthpiece for the scofflaws illegally occupying public buildings and land, repeating their lies and distortions of history and law.

Ammon Bundy and his bullyboys aren’t trying to free federal lands, but to hold them hostage. I can’t go to the Malheur refuge now, though as a citizen of the United States, I own it and have the freedom of it. That’s what public land is: land that belongs to the public — me, you, every law-abiding American. The people it doesn’t belong to and who don’t belong there are those who grabbed it by force of arms, flaunting their contempt for the local citizens.

Those citizens of Harney County have carefully hammered out agreements to manage the refuge in the best interest of landowners, scientists, visitors, tourists, livestock and wildlife. They’re suffering more every day, economically and otherwise, from this invasion by outsiders.

Instead of parroting the meaningless rants of a flock of Right-Winged Loonybirds infesting the refuge, why doesn’t The Oregonian talk to the people who live there?

Ursula K. Le Guin

Northwest Portland

Think Progress has a story about the letter with more comments by Le Guin.

Le Guin told ThinkProgress that the letter was printed unchanged, and she “got a pleasant note informing me it was to be published,” but nothing more from the paper or the author. A request for comment to the Oregonian’s public editor went unanswered as of publication.

The science fiction author is not alone in wanting the ranchers to return Malhuer to the public. Most Western voters, according to a recent poll, disagree with Bundy and do not want the states to take over public lands.

“We have been going out to the Steens Mountain area, on and near the Wildlife Refuge, for 45 years — first to teach summer classes at the field station, later just to be there in the grand high desert country,” she said. “We spend a week every summer on a cattle ranch very close to Refuge lands. I am proud to consider the family who own the ranch and the local hotel as friends, and I have learned a great deal from them. The Refuge Headquarters is a quiet, fragile, beautiful little oasis that is particularly dear to us.”

(2) WHAT IF BOOK FESTIVALS PAY WRITERS? Claire Armitstead’s opinion piece in the Guardian argues the burden of paying writers to attend book festivals would have unintended side-effects: “Book festivals are worth far more than fees”.

Philip Pullman became cheerleader for a growing band of refuseniks last week when he resigned as president of the Oxford literary festival because it didn’t pay speakers. Thirty more writers immediately picked up the chant, with a letter to the trade journal the Bookseller calling for all authors and publishers to boycott festivals that expected writers to appear for free.

…Edinburgh is one of the biggest festivals and an honourable exception to the no-pay rule, offering the same flat rate to all its contributors. But it’s not unusual to hear writers grumbling that this is tokenism, and no recompense for the hours (and expense) of travelling. So what is a reasonable return? Should it be calibrated to audience size, or offset against book sales? Or should it be a flat rate – only bigger than it currently is?

There are now more than 350 literary festivals in the UK, which adds up to a whole heap of calls on writers’ time and energy – and one argument is that if they can’t afford to pay contributors they should simply shut down. But small festivals do more than simply put writers on stage; they support local bookshops and create a buzz around books. They circulate flyers publicising authors and their work. They are part of the great reading group boom that has bolstered book sales by turning reading into a social activity.

…So while I have every sympathy for hard-pressed authors, I feel they need to be careful what they wish for. The logic of the marketplace – in book festivals as in every other arena – is that, were fees to become obligatory, the haves will end up having more, while the have-nots will find themselves banished to outer darkness. It would mean the end of a golden era of access to books and the people who write them. And that would be impoverishing for all of us.

(3) OXFORD MAY PAY WRITERS. Philip Pullman and other protesting writers have made the Oxford Literary Festival consider paying authors.

In a statement issued on Tuesday morning, the Oxford literary festival said that it “recognises and understands the strength of feeling in the literary community regarding the payment of speaker fees to authors and writers and we are sympathetic to this cause”.

But, adding that it is a registered charity that receives no public funding, with no full-time staff, supported by a team of 40 unpaid volunteers, the festival said that “for every £12 ticket sold, a further £20 in support has to be raised from our generous sponsors, partners and donors in subsidy”. The festival’s current supporters include FT Weekend and HSBC.

“We have of course been aware of the debate regarding author payments for some time, but given the limitations of the tight budgets we run to (the festival’s last audited accounts show a loss of £18,000 in 2014) paying each speaker would require an additional 15% in costs or £75,000 for the 500 speakers across our 250 events planned for 2016,” said the festival.

Once this year’s event in April is over, organisers have nonetheless said that they “will meet with all interested parties to discuss how to achieve payment of fees for all speakers – while safeguarding the presence of our record levels of unknown writers for 2017 and beyond”.

(4) ONE LORD A’LEAPING. Middle-Earth political science student Austin Gilkeson lectures on “The Illegitimacy of Aragorn’s Claim to the Throne” at The Toast. (Traffic to the post is hyped by the GIF of a flaming Denethor hurling himself from the promontory of Minas Tirith.)

After the War of the Ring and Denethor’s death, Gondor did embrace Aragorn as its new king, partially because he’d arrived at the head of an army of the Dead. But while “commands a terrifying ghost army” is a fantastic qualification for fronting a Norwegian black metal band or a community Halloween parade, it’s less than ideal for ruling a vast and diverse country of the living.

Even worse, Aragorn’s supposed suitability to rule is directly tied to his pure Númenorean blood….

Given that the Númenoreans ruined their civilization to the point that it was personally destroyed by God Himself, the Gondorrim probably shouldn’t have been so quick to crown a long-lived, pure-blooded Númenorean like Aragorn. They’d probably have been better off elevating Pippin Took to the throne. Hobbits at least dally with the good things in life: hearty food, heady ales, fireworks, and weed.

(5) EVERYMAN HIS OWN NUMENOREAN. Stephen Hawking issued another warning that humanity may wipe itself out in years to come.

Cheery physicist Professor Stephen Hawking says that mankind could be wiped out by our own creations within the next 100 years.

Answering audience questions at this year’s BBC Reith Lectures, he said that our rush to understand and improve life through science and technology could be humanity’s undoing.

He has previously suggested that colonising other planets will be the only way that the human race can survive, but he warns that we may lose Earth to some kind of major disaster before we have a chance to properly do so.

“Although the chance of a disaster to planet Earth in a given year may be quite low,” he explained, “it adds up over time, and becomes a near certainty in the next thousand or ten thousand years.

(6) SFWA KICKS IN. Science Fiction Writers of America has begun donating to some non-members’ crowdfunded self-publishing efforts.

Beginning in January, SFWA will be making small, targeted pledges to worthy Kickstarter projects projects by non-members, designating them a “SFWA Star Project.” Projects will be selected by the Self Publishing Committee, coordinated by volunteer Rob Balder. Selections will be based on the project’s resonance with SFWA’s exempt purposes, and special preference will be given to book-publishing projects in the appropriate genres.

Funds for these pledges will come from the SFWA Givers Fund, from a $1000 pool approved by the Grants Committee in December. When a pledge results in receiving a donor reward such as a signed book, these items will be auctioned off at fundraising events, to help replenish the Givers Fund.

The first two Star Projects are:

SFWA President Cat Rambo also blogged about the initiative.

Over the past few years, I’ve been helping with the effort to open SFWA doors to professional writers publishing outside the traditional structure, to the point where we are the only writers organization (I believe) to accept crowdfunded publications as membership qualifying material. The Star Project effort ties in nicely with that and it’s gratifying to see SFWA continue to expand to match the changing needs of professional F&SF writers.

(7) BETTER THAN THE FILM. Rachael Acks has a completely entertaining and THOROUGHLY SPOILERY review of SyFy’s theatrical release 400 Days. You’ve been warned. And it’s safe to read the first paragraph, where nothing is given away  –

400 Days is the first theatrical release film from a company (SyFy) that’s been cranking mediocre to howlingly (we hope intentionally) funny terribad movies out onto its cable station for years. Getting in to movie theaters is a big deal, a major investment, but doesn’t necessarily guarantee a movie’s actually good, right? Let me tell you, I’d rather watch a SyFy offering any day than Transformers 4. But is this Syfy going legit, so to speak?

(8) RSR INDEXES ARTISTS. Rocket Stack Rank has now added exhibit and viewing tools for a wide number of creators eligible in the Best Professional Artist and Best Fan Artist categories. Gregory N. Hullender says, “The value we’ve added here is that we’ve gathered together hundreds of online images and set up a lightbox so people can riffle through them quickly.”

The drawback to the Best Fan Artist exhibit is that it features only semiprozine cover contributors at the site, and a link to eFanzines’ cover index where one can see some artwork in fanzines produced as PDFs. I will be the first to agree there are technical barriers and questions about permissions in the way of indexing art from PDFs (in contrast to semiprozine covers which are already available online) – however, RSR needs to figure out how to present fan art on a level playing field.


  • January 19, 1990 — Natives of a small isolated town defend themselves against strange underground creatures in Tremors, seen for the first time on this day in 1990.


  • Born January 19, 1809 – Edgar Allan Poe

(11) CONRUNNERS COULD USE MORE FANS LIKE THIS. Icelandic strongman Hafthor Bjornsson, known for his role as “The Mountain” on HBO’s Game of Thrones set a Guiness World Record for being the fastest person to carry two refrigerators 65 feet.

(12) CLEVELAND THANKS THE FANS. In response to a club’s charitable work, “Cleveland celebrates Star Trek’s roots with thank you to The Federation”.

Cleveland City Councilman Martin Keane will present a resolution of appreciation at 7 p.m. PJ McIntyre’s, on Lorain Avenue in Kamm’s Corners, is hosting a celebration from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.

According to the resolution, the 60-member Cleveland chapter, named the USS Challenger — named to honor the crew of the ill-fated space shuttle Challenger — has raised $15,000 for local charities, and has conducted annual drives for food for local food banks; supplies for local animal shelters; Toys for Tots campaigns and supported March for Babies, Heartwalk and Laura’s Home.

Given that the reporter pointed to another Cleveland/Star Trek connection — did you know Majel Barrett was a native of suburban Shaker Heights? — it’s a pity no one told her that Roddenberry previewed the show for fans at the 1966 Worldcon in Cleveland.

(13) LOVECRAFT LETTERS. Heritage Auctions will take bids on a parcel of 10 handwritten letters by H. P. Lovecraft at its Rare Books Auction #6155 on April 6. The letters to aspiring author Frederic Jay Pabody are full of writing and publishing advice.

Lovecraft recounts recent visits with his “literary friends” R.H. Barlow and Adolphe de Castro, the suicide of Robert E. Howard, other “weird” fiction authors, the nature of good marriages and bad marriages, religion (or the lack thereof), Atlantis, some splendid passages about the nature of “seriously artistic” weird fiction, and his repeated inveterate hatred of typewriters.

One highlight from the letters includes a hand drawn map or, as Lovecraft calls it, a “rough Mercator’s Projection chart” of Kusha, a land associated with the myth of Atlantis.

Another letter, displaying Lovecraft’s somewhat morbid sense of humor, describes his short story “The Haunter in the Dark”, in which he kills off a character based on his friend and fellow writer Robert Bloch, as “a kind of revenge.”

In both ‘The Dark Demon’ and ‘The Shambler from the Stars’ Bloch has a figure modelled more or less after me come to a hideous end. Well- I’ve survived other fictional deaths – Long having left me as a charred cinder on the floor of my apartment over a decade ago in “The Space-Eaters.” In a recent unpublished mss. Kuttner kills off Bloch, himself, + myself under thin disguises… slaughter de-luxe! I am decapitated – but my head is later found with its teeth buried in his carotid artery. Nice, wholesome ideas the boys have!” (December 20, 1936).

(14) BUGS. Kudos to Black Gate’s John ONeill for turning today’s entomological headline into a beautiful genre blog post – “I Don’t Mean to Alarm Anyone, But We’ve Discovered Giant Insects on Monster Island”.

(15) PEOPLE OF EARTH. TBS has given a series order to People of Earth, a comedy starring Daily Show alum Wyatt Cenac as a skeptical journalist investigating a support group for alleged alien abductees.

In the series, from Conan O’Brien and Greg Daniels (The Office) and formerly known as The Group, Cenac’s Ozzie Graham slowly becomes sympathetic to the survivors’ stories and eventually comes to suspect that maybe he is an abductee, as well.

The cast includes Ana Gasteyer (Suburgatory), Oscar Nuñez (The Office), Michael Cassidy (Men at Work), Da’Vine Joy Randolph (Selfie), Brian Huskey (Veep) and Tracee Chimo (Orange Is the New Black).


[Thanks to Will R., Brian Z, Cat Rambo, Jim Reynolds, and John King Tarpinian for some of these stories. Title credit goes to File 770 contributing editor of the day Kurt Busiek.]

213 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 1/19/16 That Wretched Hive of Scrolls and Pixelry

  1. @RedWombat: whodathunkit?! And the beaver dams also reduce downstream flooding! My dad always liked to fish for trout behind beaver dams; I wish he was still around to tell him about the wolves.

    @Aaron: You seem a’ight to me.

    @Matt Y: But they weren’t Mary Sues! They were Gary Stus, which is TOTALLY DIFFERENT.

    @The other Nigel: He started getting whiny and reactionary in Scalzi’s comments shortly thereafter — about the time Puppidum started up. Scalzi never Malleted him, BTW; Brad just stopped showing up because so many people kept politely pointing to actual sources that didn’t agree with his counterfactuals. It was more fun for him to go where people agreed with him and didn’t ask for any of those pesky facts (which have a liberal bias). Many of us observed this.

    I think Paul Dini outright said that TT was canceled b/c in the executives’ words, “too many” girls watched it, and “girls don’t buy toys”.

    Which we know is untrue (and knew that for years) but at least we’re making a tad bit of headway now with more people wanting Badass Rey rather than Darth Emo. That boy is qrsvavgryl n guebjonpx gb gur lbhgu bs uvf tenaqsngure.

    If only Neelix had left Voyager instead of Kes. We still wish that here in 3650.

  2. @Lenora, Oops I am really sorry. I just didn’t think where I was.

    I think cover design can sometimes save a book. If you look at Janny Wurts Mistraith books for the US/UK editions, you can see where the UK cover designers ‘fixed’ things up to suit their Commonwealth audience(including me).

  3. Catching up on Pixel Scrolls:

    @Greg Hullender: “[about a cover, summing up with:] If it gets nominated, I think it’d be up to the committee to figure it out.”

    . . . keeping in mind the Hugo is for an artist, based on work from the year in question – not a single piece of artwork! Hopefully people are nominating based on more than “I like the one cover so this is the best artist of the year.” Hopefully they look up an artists to see other work in the year in question, and then consider who to nominate.

    Anyway, thanks for doing this Greg/RSR, as it sounds like a useful resource. I hopefully (!) will get to look over the artwork this weekend! Yay blizzard? :-/

    I also plan to look over some artist blogs that I follow, to see who out there I’m already familiar with and may want to nominate. Some are artists who do web comics, or artists they’ve linked to, or random artists that I stumbled across or was linked to. I “read” (view; it’s mostly art) a surprising number of artist blogs. Not all are Hugo-worthy, perhaps. Some are pros, some are fans, and some I may not be sure of, or may have both pro and fan work, and I do mean fan, in a few cases.

    Example: Michael J. DiMotta may be a pro (methinks he is?), but his “#epicwars” piece is an amazing fan love letter to SFF animation, comics, TV, movies, etc., unpublished as far as I know (I need to look into this), and he keeps adding to it. Part of it serves as his blog banner; occasionally he posts the whole thing so folks can see the latest version, but usually he posts parts of it to show what he’s added. If what he’s doing with this isn’t fannish, I don’t know what is, even if he’s just posting it to his tumblr (as many artists these days seem to post cool unpublished stuff to their blogs/tumblrs).

  4. @Tintinaus: I’ll beat my drum again, and hope it isn’t too annoying. One doesn’t have to “scope much of the fan art.” That’s why we try to get a large nominating pool, and then it aggregates into a good short list that’s manageable for the voters. You can’t scope most of the novel or short fiction each year, either. 😉

    @JJ: I’m a bit of a traditionalist, I guess. A purely designed cover, much as I may like it, as much as it may be a work of art, isn’t what I go for in covers or in nominations. But then, I’m familiar with some artists (cover and otherwise), but I’ve never heard people talk about cover designers (naming names, being able to recognize a designer’s work, etc.) like they talk about artists they like.

    It doesn’t help that cover designers don’t tend to have art in conventions, I don’t know whether they do anything but covers (but other artists usually do), designers aren’t always credited, their work is a bit opaque to some of us (e.g., I can’t know at a glance how much a photograph was altered, whether that it’s a combination of several unrelated photographs, etc.).

    And here I parade my ignorance, but I doubt it’s an uncommon one. If I love a designed cover, though, in the future I’ll try to pay more attention to who’s responsible and try to keep this in mind for the Hugos.

  5. BTW this is bugging me. When I said “hopefully people do X” I’m not trying to say that’s the only way to do it, and hopefully (!) it’s not taken that way.

    People categories are tougher than work ones, IMHO. There are many paths, etc. There’s no “best single piece of artwork Hugo,” that’s why I said I hope folks check out more than a single piece by an artist (if the artist has more than one; many have web sites!). Which may sound like a contradition, as I’m not feeling super-coherent, unfortunately.

  6. @Kendall:

    Super-coherence sounds like a nifty power, but I find myself unable to articulate precisely what it would do.

  7. RE: RSR Indexes Artists

    There’s another gorgeous 2015 cover for Victo Ngai, on Barsk, which was released at the end of December. Author Lawrence M. Schoen says:

    The cover art is by Victo Ngai, a Society of Illustrators NY Gold Medalist (she actually has a stack of gold and silver medals), and depicts her conception of one of the artificial “vents” that occur within the rainforests of the islands of Barsk. Specifically, a shaft visited by Pizlo, a young boy whose very existence is outside the strictures of Barsk culture.

  8. @Rev. Bob: LOL. (bowing)

    @JJ: I didn’t care for the cover for Barsk, but thanks for the Thom Tenery links. I like his work a lot! I thought Dark Orbit‘s style looked familiar; I didn’t realize it was by the artist from A Darkling Sea. I’m making a note of him to consider, so thanks.

    That’s a slightly odd font for the title on The Floating City. The F has this cool kinda trailing off thing at the bottom, but the T ends in a different, more defined design. I don’t care for the top of the C. Overall it feels like an odd, inconsistent font to me. But interesting nonetheless, else I wouldn’t notice it – almost looks like a combination of fonts. (The cover art is interesting: a new take on the hooded/cloaked figure. BTW I haven’t heard of this book…off to investigate.)*

    I really love a good cover. 🙂

    * ETA: Never mind; I have heard of this book – just forgot the name.

Comments are closed.