Pixel Scroll 8/15/24 Have Spice Suit, Will Travel

(1) SFWA ON ITS THIRD PRESIDENT THIS SUMMER. Chelsea Mueller today resigned as Interim President of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers Association. Mueller had been in office only since the beginning of August, as SFWA’s VP becoming the organization’s Interim President upon the resignation of SFWA President Jeffe Kennedy on August 1. Anthony W. Eichenlaub, SFWA Secretary, is stepping up as the new  Interim President. Mueller’s and Eichenlaub’s statements are excerpted in the File 770 post “Mueller Resigns as Interim SFWA President; Eichenlaub Takes Office”.

To learn why the organization is in a crisis SFWA members must read the Forum. Those outside can get only a very general idea from social media posts like M L Clark’s statement on Bluesky.

Author Jenny Rae Rappaport his urging SFWA members to sign a Petition for bylaws amendment to forbid NDAs. The supporting statement follows. The wording of the amendment is at the link.

In the last several years, SFWA has begun requiring its Board members, employees, and key volunteers to sign non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) to ensure confidentiality. However, recent events have shown that these NDAs cause more problems than they solve. Because the NDAs are overly broad without clear limits or expiration dates, they leave employees, Board members, and volunteers uncertain about what they can and cannot say without potential legal repercussions. Even more concerning is that these NDAs have created distrust between SFWA membership and the Board, and an environment where the perception exists that bad actors can mistreat others and violate SFWA’s bylaws with impunity.

There is no legal requirement for SFWA as a 501(c)(3) to use NDAs, for either its legal or tax status. Many nonprofits, both inside and outside California, function perfectly well without using NDAs, either trusting that people will follow the laws about disclosure of personal, financial, and medical information, or using individual confidentiality agreements with the details of what information needs to be kept confidential spelled out.

Accordingly, in the interests of greater transparency for the organization, we, the undersigned members of SFWA, petition for the following change to the bylaws:

(2) INDUSTRY REACTS TO GAME HUGO WINNER. PC Gamer marvels that “Somehow, Baldur’s Gate 3 isn’t done winning yet: It’s just claimed the most prestigious award for science fiction and fantasy writing”.

….A special videogame category was added in 2021 to recognize the increased impact of videogames amidst the early days of the Covid-19 pandemic, but it was a one-off: No game-related Hugo was awarded in 2022 or ’23.

In 2023, however, Worldcon voted to make the Best Game or Interactive Work a permanent category for 2024—wouldn’t you know it, just in time for the Baldur’s Gate 3 behemoth to smash through the walls like the Kool-Aid Man and run off with it. BG3 beat out Alan Wake 2 (yet again), Chants of Senaar, Dredge, The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, and Star Wars Jedi: Survivor for the big prize….

“The Hugo nominees and awards have determined my reading list since forever, so it’s a huge honor to be standing here,” Larian boss Swen Vincke said during his acceptance speech (via Polygon). 

“Videogame writing is often underestimated. It is very very very hard work. For Baldur’s Gate 3 we had to create over 174 hours of cinematics just to be able to respect the choices of the players and to make sure that each and every single one of them would have an emotional story that was reflecting their choices and their agency. It takes a very long time, it takes a very large team … It takes a lot of perseverance and a lot of talent. So I’m very happy for all of them and for all of the team back home that we can get this, and very grateful to the fandom.”

Vincke isn’t kidding when he says Larian wanted to ensure Baldur’s Gate 3 was as reactive as possible to player choices: The studio recently revealed that the game’s rarest ending has only been unlocked by 34 players—and remember, this is a game that’s sold well over 10 million copies. (For a little added context, 1.9 million Baldur’s Gate 3 players were turned into a cheese wheel. Which is fine, really: No one has as many friends as the man with many cheeses.)…

(3) ELLISON FOUNDATION HAD IRS CHARITABLE STATUS REVOKED. The IRS has revoked the 501(c)(3) charitable status of The Harlan and Susan Ellison Foundation after it failed to file the required Form 990 for three straight years. Douglas J. Lane provides detailed coverage of the Foundation’s creation, activities, and status in his blog post “For Want of a Form”:

On Monday, August 12, 2024 the Internal Revenue Service updated its monthly list of 501(c)(3) organizations for whom it was revoking charitable status based on failure to file Form 990, Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax, for three consecutive years. 

Among the organizations freshly listed was EIN number 873507738, The Harlan and Susan Ellison Foundation.

The revocation of charitable status puts the Foundation and its president, J. Michael Straczynski, in a tricky spot, as it makes the organization fully taxable. They cannot receive tax-free donations or offer deductions to donors. Under California law, they will also not be able to distribute charitable funds. There are other ramifications, and while reinstatement is possible, it comes with a swath of requirements.

It’s critical to say at the outset of this account of the public-facing facets of the Foundation: I ascribe no malicious intent or nefarious purpose to anyone involved in any of the events that led to this revocation, and no impropriety is indicated by anything that has occurred. Indeed, Joe Straczynski speaks in a caring and sincere way about the place the Ellisons have in his heart, and how he wants to carry out their wishes. The Foundation has a laudable vision. But malicious intent and carelessness are two different things, and it’s clear a severe breakdown occurred somewhere along the way that resulted in opacity where transparency was required, creating a situation in which warnings were missed and the Foundation was positioned for a catastrophic setback that was wholly avoidable…

Lane also posted the information today at The Harlan Ellison Facebook Fan Club, leading to this series of comments from J. Michael Straczynski.

Thursday, August 15, 2024 at 10:21 a.m.

This is literally the first time I’m hearing this. We’ve had no contact from them directly or indirectly. If the forms were not submitted that’s strictly a paperwork issue and that’s on us. I need to find out what happened on the attorney side. This will be fixed and as per this the status will then be reinstated once we’ve sent in the forms.

Thursday, August 15, 2024 at 11:21 a.m.

Okay, last quick update for the moment. It looks like the notices were being sent to the wrong address/suite number. Also, as for the Packard, it was not sold, it was given freely to a member of this very forum in exchange for looking after it and maintaining it in Harlan’s memory. He can confirm this here if he so desires.

So bottom line for now: the paperwork fell through a crack between different offices over who was handling what, and the address (as noted in the link) was incorrect for the notices. I assumed all this was being properly attended to, while I was busy getting Harlan’s work back into print. That error was mine. The good news is that since this was apparently a comedy of errors on both sides, there should be no issue with getting this rectified swiftly by simply filing the paperwork.

Thursday, August 15, 2024 at 12:41 p.m.

Okay…I just heard from the business management firm we’ve been using and they confirmed that they hadn’t looked after this because they believed it was already being handled by others. They’re filing the paperwork as we speak and this will be rectified promptly.

Thursday, August 15, 2024 at 3:25 p.m.

This has now been officially resolved. We just confirmed with the tax dept that we never received any notices from the IRS. We sent in and they have now filed the returns with the correct address. After the IRS processes them, we will handle the paperwork to reinstate the Foundation which will apparently not be a problem. The IRS will update their records so no further notices are missed. The tax dept now has the Foundation on their schedule so they won’t miss it again anyway. Just to be on the safe side moving forward we are going to hire a nonprofit attorney on retainer to coordinate all of the moving parts so nothing falls through the cracks in future.

A colorful day but at least it’s ending better than it began.

(4) ANOTHER LOOK AT GAIMAN ALLEGATIONS. The Spinoff books editor Claire Mabey listened to the Tortoise Media podcast “Master: the allegations against Neil Gaiman” and distilled the information into a timeline with explicit details of the encounters described by survivors in “The New Zealand allegations at the centre of a Neil Gaiman podcast investigation”.

(5) AMERICAN NON-IDOL. I don’t know that any of the many ways John Scalzi restates the basic point in his 3,600-word post really feels like it stuck the landing, but the oft-repeated message makes sense: “Please Don’t Idolize Me (or Anyone, Really)” at Whatever.

In the wake of the various recent allegations involving Neil Gaiman, people have been both very sad that someone who they looked up to as an inspiration has, allegedly, turned out to be something less than entirely admirable, and are now looking to see who is now left that they can rotate into the spot of “the good dude,” i.e., that one successful creative guy who they think or at least hope isn’t hiding a cellar full of awful actions. One name I see brought up is mine, in ways ranging from “Well, at least we still have Scalzi,” to “Oh, God, please don’t let Scalzi be a fucking creep too.” Which, uhhhh, yeah? Thanks?…

…Every person you’ve ever admired has fucked up, sometimes really badly. Everyone you’ve ever looked up to has secrets, and it’s possible some of those secrets would materially change how you think about them, not always for the better. Everyone you’ve ever known has things about them you don’t know, many of which aren’t even secrets, they’re just things you don’t engage with in your day-to-day experience of them. Nevertheless it’s possible if you were aware of them, it would change how you feel about them, for better or for worse. And now let’s flip that around! You have things about you that even your best friends don’t know, and might be surprised to learn! You have secrets you don’t wish to share with the class! You have fucked up, and lied, and have been a hypocrite too!…

Oh, God, this is where Scalzi starts admitting to terrible, terrible things. No. I feel pretty confident I live a tolerably ethical life. Part of the reason for this is that I have what I think is a decent operating principle, which is: If I’m thinking of doing something, and Krissy called me right then and asked “what are you doing?” and I would be tempted to lie to her about it, then I don’t do that thing….

(6) GET READY FOR FANTASTIC FEST. “Fantastic Fest 2024 Lineup Featuring Terrifier 3, Never Let Go, More Unveiled”Deadline has details.

Fantastic Fest, the country’s largest genre film festival, has unveiled the feature lineup for its 19th edition, taking place at the Alamo Drafthouse South Lamar in Austin, TX, from September 19th- 26th.

Featuring 28 World Premieres, 23 International and North American Premieres, and 15 U.S. Premieres, the fest opens with the world premiere of James Ashcroft’s The Rule of Jenny Pen, a new thriller starring John Lithgow and Geoffrey Rush. Lionsgate’s horror thriller Never Let Go will be presented during the opening night gala, with director Alexandre Aja, star Halle Berry and the team from 21 Laps in attendance. Meanwhile, opening night will also feature the world premiere of Terrifier 3, the latest film in Damien Leone’s horror franchise, centered on the horrifying Art the Clown.

(7) AURORA AWARDS VOTING STATISTICS. Clifford Samuels has posted the “Final results for the 2024 Aurora Awards” at the Canadian Science Fiction and Fantasy Association website. The direct link to the statistics is here.

(8) SIMULTANEOUS TIMES. Space Cowboy Books of Joshua Tree, CA brings listeners Simultaneous Times episode 78. Stories featured in this episode:

“When You See A Dragon, You Run” by Jenna Hanchey, read by the author

“The Darling Murders” by Jonathan Nevair. Read by Jean-Paul Garnier

Music by Phog Masheeen. Theme music by Dain Luscombe.

(9) TODAY’S BIRTHDAY.

[Written by Lis Carey.]

Born August 15, 1933 Bjo Trimble, 91.

By Lis Carey: Bjo was born in Holdenville, Oklahoma, in 1933, discovered sf fandom in 1952. She was serving in the US Navy, at the Great Lakes Naval Station, and saw an announcement in Astounding Science Fiction about the science fiction convention that weekend in Chicago—the 10th Worldcon, the one we now call Chicon II, though at the time it had no official name. The largest Worldcon ever at the time, with 870 members, it was a great place for a smart and friendly young woman to meet people and make connections in fandom. Her new acquaintances included Robert Bloch, Willy Ley, August Derleth, and Harlan Ellison.

Bjo Trimble attends the 2024 Peabody Awards at Beverly Wilshire on June 9. Photo by Jon Kopaloff.

When it was discovered that she was an artist and cartoonist, she was recruited to provide illustrations for fanzines, sealing her fate. She claims to have met her husband, John Griffin Trimble, under Forrest J Ackerman’s piano, during a particularly crowded party. He was serving in the US Air Force, and they traded Stupid Officer Stories.

But as we all know, this was mere prelude. Bjo was active in LASFS (Los Angeles Science Fiction Society), and organized a fashion show for Solacon (the 16th Worldcon). In 1960, she started Project Art Show, which brought the first modern, organized art show at a science fiction convention to Pittcon, the 1960 Worldcon. Bjo continued the project, bringing art shows to Worldcons and other conventions. By 1969, Project Art Show had become The International Science-Fantasy Art Exhibition” (ISFAE), and was judging and awarding prizes, as well as organizing the art shows.

But in 1968, Bjo started turning her attention to a new fannish interest–Star Trek. Bjo and John Trimble were active in the letter-writing campaign credited with getting the show a third season, after it was initially canceled after its second season. They also helped convince NASA to name the first of the Space Shuttles Enterprise, although that was a test vehicle never intended for space flight.

Bjo was a major contributor to the Star Trek Concordance, containing cross-referenced details on every character, setting, event and device in every episode of the original Star Trek, and, in later editions of the book, its animated incarnation, and the Star Trek films. Originally self-published, it got a mass market publication by Ballantine Books in 1976, and an updated edition by Citadel Press in 1995. On the Good Ship Enterprise: My 15 Years with Star Trek, her memoir of her experiences in Star Trek fandom, was published in 1982.

Bjo was a Guest of Honor at Dragon Con, which was also the 6th North American Science Fiction Convention, in 1995. Bjo and John Trimble were Fan Guests of Honor at ConJosé, the 60th Worldcon. Bjo, or Bjo and John, were also honored at many Star Trek and other science fiction conventions.

 In addition, Bjo and John Trimble were Baron and Baroness of the Society for Creative Anachronism’s Barony of the Angels, from September 2008 to January 2012. That’s at least fandom adjacent, right?

 Sadly, John in April 2024, but Bjo is still with us. Her contributions to fandom will remain.

(10) COMICS SECTION.

(11) MUTANTS DESERVE AWARDS. The Walt Disney Studios has a “For Your Consideration” website for the X-Men ’97 series.

(12) PAGING ALL READERS. “Book Bars Gain Momentum Around New York”: Eater tells you where to find the ones in New York City.

A flurry of book bars has recently opened that prioritize solo time as much as low-key conversation, offering a fun alt-combo to record bars and libraries. These spaces for reading, drinking, listening to music, and chatting with other book lovers (or not) are a post-shutdown pivot from social distancing. And while the throwback staple had started to revive just after the pandemic, their openings have gained momentum around the city.

Like wine bars and cocktail bars, the focus in book bars is less on needing labor to make complicated dishes as the case may be in a full-fledged restaurant. Instead, the business relies on easier-to-procure revenue streams: booze, books, and sometimes, ready-made snacks, like olives, nuts, and tinned fish. But book bars, owners say, are less about practicality than about creating a community, a third place that’s conducive to reading and chatting while enjoying a drink…

(13) PURINA HOBBIT CHOW. “What’s on the Menu in Your Fantasy World?” at Gastro Obscura.

FOOD AND FANTASY HAVE LONG gone hand in hand. Our oldest myths and fairy tales abound with ravenous monsters and enchanted apples, while modern fantasy literature has brought us the second breakfast-savoring hobbits of The Lord of the Rings and the sprawling medieval banquets of A Song of Ice and Fire. Fantasy fans rally around official cookbooks from the worlds they love, as well as unofficial recreations and fanfiction that explores the diets of their favorite characters.

(14) THE TREES THAT GREW THE POOH-STICKS. BBC Countryfile invites readers to “Discover the real-life Winnie-The-Pooh locations that inspired the famous children’s books by AA Milne”.

Ashdown Forest in East Sussex is perhaps best known as The Hundred Acre Wood, the beloved setting of arguably the most famous children’s books ever written, Winnie-the-Pooh, published in 1926, and The House at Pooh Corner (1928)….

…Today, the 6,500-acre heathland and woodland 36 miles south of London, is a rare and protected area, providing habitat for endangered flora and fauna. In this gentle, ancient landscape, we can enjoy its literary, cultural and environmental history; we can be twitchers, walkers or pub-goers….

(15) NOW LEAVING ON TRACK 9-3/4. “Back to Hogwarts pop-up coming to Grand Central Terminal with spellbinding interactive activities” reports AMNY.

For the first time ever, Warner Bros. Discovery will be hosting a Back to Hogwarts pop-up in New York City. From Aug. 30 through Sept. 1, “Harry Potter” fans can gather at Vanderbilt Hall at Grand Central Terminal to celebrate the start of a new school year at Hogwarts.

In the “Harry Potter” universe, all students board the Hogwarts Express and return for a new year on Sept. 1. Warner Bros. Discovery hosts global celebrations in cities like London, Paris, Rio de Janeiro, and Tokyo, uniting fans worldwide with digital activities, in-person gatherings, and watch-alongs, plus huge celebrations at “Harry Potter” destinations such as the Wizarding World of Harry Potter at Universal Studios.

At the New York pop-up, guests can expect to find magical performances, LEGO building activities, an interactive “Harry Potter: Quidditch Champion” experience, and a Butterbeer toast, courtesy of the flagship Harry Potter New York store. On Sept. 1, there will be a ticketed event with a live 11 a.m. countdown, marking when the Hogwarts Express would leave Kings Cross station in the series.

Though all of the events are free to attend, “Harry Potter” fans must sign up for a timed-entry ticket, which will be available starting Aug. 19. To make sure you don’t miss it, sign up and opt into email communications from the Harry Potter Fan Club by Aug. 17. On Aug. 19, an email will be sent including a link to the ticket site ahead of release at 12 p.m. EST. 

(16) NOT A ROLLING STONE. SAILING, MAYBE. [Item by SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie.] Today’s Nature has Stonehenge on the cover. There’s a Nature News item here.

The history of Stonehenge poses many challenges, not least of which is where all of the stones came from and how they were transported to the site. The Neolithic structure is made up of two main types of stone — sarsens sourced some 25 kilometres away near Marlborough, and bluestones that originated in Wales. The largest of the bluestones at the site is the six-tonne Altar Stone, but it is an anomaly: it did not come from Wales. In this week’s issue, Anthony Clarke and colleagues reveal that the Altar Stone probably made a remarkable journey of some 750 kilometres from Scotland. The researchers analysed two fragments from the stone and discovered a striking similarity to the Old Red Sandstone of the Orcadian Basin in northeast Scotland. The team suggests that the stone could have been transported by sea, indicating that there might have been a significant level of societal organization within Neolithic Britain.

The original research by Anthony Clarke and colleagues link above is to “A Scottish provenance for the Altar Stone of Stonehenge”.

(17) UPLIFTING HUMANS. [Item by SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie.] In a series of stories and novels, David Brin explored the idea of species uplift where by a technological civilization genetically manipulates a non-sentient species into full-blown sentience: a process called ‘uplifting’. Brin’s series has a climax in the Hugo-winning The Uplift War (1986).

Last weekend, while folk in Glasgow were preparing for the Hugo Awards ceremony, Isaac Arthur posted one of his monthly ‘Sci-Fi Sunday’ videos. While in David Brin’s stories the humans appeared to be the exception in the Galaxy who evolved sentience naturally whereas every other civilization seems to have been uplifted with the original uplift being made by some ancient and now extinct civilization. Conversely, in Isaac’s video, he explores the notion that humans were uplifted by an alien race.

Now, it has to be said that Isaac himself does not subscribe to the idea of humans being uplifted (he makes that clear both at the video’s beginning and end), but explores the concept hypothetically.  Included in the mix is a slightly more sober idea that the Earth might have been subject to panspermia and specifically directed panspermia… As well as a brief dive into Eric von Daniken which, mercifully, he looks at purely through an SFnal lens… “Were Primitive Humans Uplifted By Aliens?”

Many believe humanity’s climb upward may have been assisted by outsiders. Is this possible, and if so, what does that tell us about our own past… and future?

[Thanks to John King Tarpinian, Chris Barkley, Cat Eldridge, Clifford Samuels, Christian Brunschen, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Steven French, Kathy Sullivan, Teddy Harvia, Mike Kennedy, and Andrew Porter for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Daniel Dern.]


Discover more from File 770

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

29 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 8/15/24 Have Spice Suit, Will Travel

  1. Good evening all good Filers!

    We had really cool weather today here. I had a medical appointment and I got to wear one of my favorite heavy black fox t-shirts as we had thunderstorms just a few minutes before I left for it and the temperaturewas in the sixties.

  2. A filksong (to the tune of the lugubrious spiritual “Were You There” for a birthday BNF:

    Were you there when I published my fanzine? (Were you there?)
    Were you there when I published my fanzine? (Were you there?)
    Sometimes, a LoC from Bjo Trimble. (Trimble.)
    Were you there when I published my fanzine? (Were you there?)

    Hooray for Bjo–who is decidedly not lugubrious!

  3. (5) In Australia it’s easy! Anyone good at sport: role model. Anyone playing sport at first-grade or representative (ie state or national) level: hero. Winner of championship or world-class medal: idol. Special consideration may be given for voluntary support activity, such as washing team uniforms, fundraising, cutting up oranges for after-practice snack, etc.

  4. Everone, This is Scroll Number 5 (again)

    A little book of Pratchett in my life, a little book of Jemison by my side
    A little book of Kuang is all I need, a little book of Tolkien is what I see
    A little book by Cixin of the sun, a little book of Murderbot all night long
    A little book of Dune and here I am
    A little book of SF makes me a lensman

  5. Shrinking Violet on August 16, 2024 at 12:06 am said:

    (5) In Australia it’s easy! Anyone good at sport: role model. Anyone playing sport at first-grade or representative (ie state or national) level: hero. Winner of championship or world-class medal: idol. Special consideration may be given for voluntary support activity, such as washing team uniforms, fundraising, cutting up oranges for after-practice snack, etc.

    I’d be warned before I moved here but you aren’t exaggerating – if anything your underplaying how sports mad Australian culture is. Fourth in the Olympics medal tally and people here want to know how come Australia wasn’t third. If the country ever gets the idea that writing science fiction is a sport then the Hugo Awards would be in real trouble.

  6. (1) earlier in the year there were various people offering as a solution to the ongoing habit of Worldcon to be in crisis that the WSFS should be a more conventional organisation with a President and maybe full-time staff etc etc. Can we agree that this is not away to avoid a crisis?

  7. @Camestros: A different kind of structure gives a different kind of crisis. For continuing variety of crises change the structure often

  8. Can we agree that this is not away to avoid a crisis?

    SFWA and the Nebulas have a much better record the past 20 years of avoiding problems than the WSFS, Hugos and Worldcon. The groups serve different purposes for different audiences, but overall I’d say the SFWA way of doing things has proven more resilient and capable than how WSFS is run.

  9. I remember when the magazines had ads for “Crisis of the Month Club”. As an introductory offer, they would send you 10 crises for $1. And then after that, for $2.99 a month, they would send you a list of six crises. You’d select the one that would distress you the most, fill in the appropriate circle on a bingo card, and mail it back in, and in two weeks a brand new crisis would arrive at your door.

    My favorite was when you would throw a homemade ice cream party, and three people would bring ice but no one would bring rock salt. Oh, the hand wringing!

  10. Archaeologists seem to have dismissed glacial transport as the means for getting big stones to Salisbury Plain – probably why it’s not really being mentioned in the discussion of this finding – but as far as I can tell Geologists still think it’s a reasonable possibility. See, for example, this paper from June this year.

  11. My comment as a full SFWA member and volunteer (Indie Author Committee, part of the Indie Author Meetup Crew) on the SFWA issue is–organizations need to take a look at how they’re doing things every ten years or so and make adjustments in processes. Things change. Situations change. Successful organizations adapt to changes.

    SFWA’s overdue since the last big shakeup was in 2009, but I’m confident it’s moving in the right direction. The stresses brought on by Covid upheavals haven’t helped.

  12. @Camestros

    Starbucks has gone through 4 CEO’s in 2 years. And they make a butt-ton of money. So, that may not help.

    @Joyce

    Sounds reasonable

  13. @ja
    And their current president just took over after they fired the last one for not being aggressive enough in fighting unions. Which are started by workers, and legal in most US states.

  14. My recollection of the Star Trek letter-writing campaigns is that Bjo led two of them: one after the first season and one after the second. I wrote a letter to the network for the first campaign, but was disappointed enough in the second season to deter me from writing to save the show a second time.

  15. Mostly c4c, but alas to clickety box!

    3) I’ve some familiarity with this issue as I audit non-profit veterans organizations. A form 990 is a requirement for every non-profit organization. Any competent paid tax professional should have had this on their list of annual tax-related duties. There is an electronic “postcard” version for organizations with less than $50k in annual income/revenue that is easy-peasy.

    I’ve seen all good pixels scroll their heads each day…

    Regards,
    Dann
    The true delight is in the finding out rather than in the knowing. – Isaac Asimov

  16. (1) If mct yesterday(?) hasn’t been seen, a) I’m a full member of SFWA; b) not onblusky, and canot log on to the SFWA site… and since all employees have quit, I assume that includes the webmaster, I don’t expect that to be fixed real fast. Given that, and having been on the boards of a 501(c) 3 (PSFS) a 501(c)4 WSFA, I can imagine no concievable reason that NOBODY can give us the slightest idea of WTF is going on, other than personal enmity (well, can think of one, but I will not mention it here, as that would lead to screaming, yellng and accusations).
    (5) Well, since he asked, I’d be glad to talk about my personalo issue with Scalzi, who I accuse of taking zerro responsiility for collateral damage…
    Birthday: and I hope Bjo had a very happy one.
    (12) We want some in the DC/Baltimore area!
    (16) Sounds to me as though someones made a major treaty.
    (17) Good one

  17. @CamestrosFelapton – is WorldCon continually in crisis? I can think of two crises in the last decade or so – the Puppy campaigns and the Chengdu Hugos.

    I agree btw that a permanent structure and a staff wouldn’t prevent or solve such crises – doesn’t mean they’re necessarily a bad idea but not for crisis prevention. The Puppy campaigns were external, would have happened regardless of structure, and the worldcon community handled them quite well with the pre-existing No Award mechanism and then EPH introduction.

    The Chengdu Hugos malfeasance was a failure of culture, which, as SFWA and RWA among many others demonstrate, happens regardless of structure, and lack of governance mechanisms to remedy it (such as automatic voiding of the results once malfeasance was substantiated and re-running of the awards). And perhaps a naivete that there is not a site eligibility pre-condition that local laws do not conflict with the worldcon constitution because in that situation of course local laws have precedence. For instance, in a jurisdiction which classifies all LGBTQIA+ content as obscene, local organisers are going, reasonably, to be unwilling to make an award to such a work when it could create legal trouble for them.

    Either way those issues can be fixed in the constitution without a change of over-arching structure. The disadvantage of the floating structure is that there’s limited mechanisms for a quick decisive response, but if its a cultural problem at or near the top that’s unlikely to happen anyway. The advantage is that there’s an automatic changeover of personnel and decision-makers in the next year.

  18. @Camestros: I too was warned before I migrated, and I thought, “Nah. Can’t be any worse than Canadian sports fans.” Holy moly, was I wrong! Aussies have that easygoing, knockabout larrikin image, but there’s a couple-or-three things about which the nation is in collective deadly earnest, and sport is top of the list. I too would fear for the Hugos if they were run like an NRL game.

    Which brings me to my next point, and an attempt to stay on topic. Giving of oneself to slavish worship of anyone, be they a fullback who can kick a field goal from anywhere, or a brilliant SF content creator who’s received worldwide acclaim? Asking for disappointment! Asking for it! Human beings do whatever they feel they can get away with.

  19. the 10th Worldcon, the one we now call Chicon II, though at the time it had no official name.

    Sure it did. It was the TASFiC, the “Tenth Anniversary Science Fiction Convention.” That was the name.

    https://fanac.org/conpubs/Worldcon/Chicon%20II/1952%20-%20Chicon%202%20-%20PR%201.pdf#view=Fit

    https://fanac.org/conpubs/Worldcon/Chicon%20II/Chicon%20II%20Program%20Book.pdf#view=Fit

    Sadly, John in April 2024, but Bjo is still with us.

    Possibly should be fixed even though the meaning is clear.

    But as we all know, this was mere prelude.

    This incredibly undervalues Bjo’s influence and impact and importance as a fan artist/cartoonist, of which she was perhaps the leading one of her day. She was everywhere, the Rotsler of her time, admired by all for her art and constantly spoken of for it. This is like reducing Harry Warner, Jr. to being the author of a couple of books and mentioning his letters of comment in a passing sentence.

    It tosses the importance of 1950s fandom under the bus for a retrospective, ahistoric, viewpoint.

  20. Pingback: Pixel Scroll 8/20/24 Something Pixel This Way Scrolls | File 770

  21. @peer: “Everone, This is Scroll Number 5 (again). . . .”

    (wild clapping) LUVS IT! 😀

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.