Pixel Scroll 9/9/20 The Worm Rider’s Digest

(1) DUNE TRAILER. A trailer dropped for the Denis Villenueve-directed Dune movie.

Beyond fear, destiny awaits.

(2) LIKE SANDS THROUGH AN HOURGLASS. The click industry immediately went to work deciphering the Dune trailer.

The Sandworm

Smartly, the Dune trailer saves the giant Sandworms of the planet Arrakis for the very end. In the reality of Dune, the Sandworms are responsible for the creation of the substance known as “the Spice,” which is basically why anyone wants to be on Arrakis at all. The Spice is created by the Sandworms, and dealing with the worms, and making peace with them is a huge part of what Dune is all about.

It’s unclear which Sandworm scene this is from the book, but the look and scope of the worm feel correct. These are mysterious creatures in the world of Dune, but they are not monsters. In some ways, the Sandworms are the most important characters in Dune, and this Sandworm looks exactly as it should. The Maw of the Sandworms seems a little more refined, but overall, these are the worms we’re looking for.

Water World

What’s an ocean doing in a movie called Dune? The footage of Paul on the shore of a vast sea with starships hovering in the sky takes place on his original home world of Caladan. Their move to Arrakis at the behest of the Emperor is like moving from Scandinavia to the Sahara.

“He thinks he’s going to be sort of a young general studying his father and his leadership of a fighting force before he comes of age, hopefully a decade later, or something like that.” Chalamet said.

Events are moving faster than he expects.

(3) OSCARS ADDING INCLUSION AND DIVERSITY REQUIREMENTS. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences on Tuesday published detailed inclusion and diversity guidelines that filmmakers will have to meet in order for their work to be eligible for a best picture Oscar, starting in 2024. Variety has a breakdown of the new rules: “Oscars Announce New Inclusion Requirements for Best Picture Eligibility”.

For the 94th and 95th Oscars ceremonies, scheduled for 2022 and 2023, a film will submit a confidential Academy Inclusion Standards form to be considered for best picture. Beginning in 2024, for the 96th Oscars, a film submitting for best picture will need to meet the inclusion thresholds by meeting two of the four standards.

All other Academy categories will keep their current eligibility requirements. For categories such as animated feature, documentary feature and international feature, that submit for best picture consideration, they will be addressed separately….

Adweek’s summary says:

The body that hands out the Academy Awards on Tuesday published detailed inclusion and diversity guidelines that filmmakers will have to meet in order for their work to be eligible for a best picture Oscar, starting in 2024. (Reuters)

To meet the onscreen representation standard, at least one of the lead actors or a significant supporting actor must be from an underrepresented racial or ethnic group, whether that means Asian, Hispanic, Black, Indigenous, Native American, Middle Eastern, North African, native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander. (NYT)

Alternatively, a film can meet the standard if at least 30 percent of all actors in secondary and more minor roles are women, from a racial or ethnic group, LGBTQ+, or people with cognitive or physical disabilities or if the film’s main storyline, theme or narrative focuses on one of these groups. (Variety)

Additionally, films seeking consideration must hire diverse creative leadership and department heads, maintain at least 30 percent of crew from the previously mentioned groups, offer paid internships to underrepresented groups, and ensure representation in marketing and distribution. (THR / The Race)

(4) NOT EVEN WITH A MASK. LA County has not entirely cancelled Halloween, only a lot of the activities traditionally associated with it. (Complete guideline here.)

Halloween Activities:

Not Permitted (gatherings and events are not currently allowed under the Health Officer Order)

Halloween gatherings, events or parties with non-household members are not permitted even if they are conducted outdoors.

Carnivals, festivals, live entertainment, and haunted house attractions are not allowed.

Not Recommended

Door to door trick or treating is not recommended because it can be very difficult to maintain proper social distancing on porches and at front doors, ensure that everyone answering or coming to the door is appropriately masked to prevent disease spread, and because sharing food is risky.

“Trunk or treating” where children go from car to car instead of door to door to receive treats is also not recommended, particularly when part of Halloween events, since it is difficult to avoid crowding and sharing food.

(5) HAUNTED DRIVE-THRU. That explains why, here in the land of the drive-in, folks will be able to pay to drive through Haunt ‘O Ween LA.

The experience will last between 25-35 minutes. We recommend guests arrive 10 – 15 minutes prior to their scheduled time slot during peak hours.

  • Pumpkin “Picking” (1 pumpkin per vehicle. Additional pumpkins available for purchase)
  • “Door to Door” Trick or Treating (enough candy for everyone!)
  • Video Op (sent to your email)
  • Immersive Installations (photo friendly environments)

(6) TENET & CO. The Guardian’s Alex Hess wonders “Why so serious? Tenet and the new wave of ‘science-based’ time travel movies” BEWARE SPOILERS.

Back in the good old days, time travel in the movies was a strictly no-strings-attached affair, a straightforward plot device to bewilder a couple of high-school dimwits or dispatch a killer robot on its mission. It was used to spice up action filmsadventure films, even romcoms – the only rule was that it shouldn’t be thought about too hard. The biggest conundrum it might cause was how to fend off the advances of your own unsettlingly attractive mum.

What John David Washington’s secret agent in Tenet wouldn’t give for such trivial problems. He not only needs to save the world from a supervillain armed with nuclear warheads and a time machine, but also get his head around the news that his nemesis can invert an object’s temporal properties at will, thus sending it hurtling backwards through a space-time continuum that is not as linear as he thought. Worse still, so do we….

(7) THE ETERNAL PEDESTRIAN CROSSING. Even Zombies can’t walk forever. “The Walking Dead Officially Ending With Season 11” promises Comicbook.com.

Oops, we lied! Actually, there’s going to be a spinoff.

The Walking Dead is officially ending after its 11th season. Season 11 will be a super sized season, offering the show a 24-episode farewell tour, with its airing beginning in the fall of 2021. The 24-episode run will span the fall of 2021 and the beginning of 2022. It is unclear whether it will be broken into three 8-part segments to two 12-part halves. The AMC zombie show began in 2010 with its premiere episode Days Gone Bye airing on Halloween. In the years which followed, The Walking Dead became a global hit, claiming the #1 spot on cable and spawning several spinoff shows, including two more new series which will follow its conclusion.

… Following the conclusion of the flagship Walking Dead series, a spinoff centered around Norman Reedus as Daryl Dixon and Melissa McBride as Carol Peletier will go into production. The Walking Dead showrunner Angela Kang will run the Daryl/Carol spinoff show. There will also be a Tales From The Walking Dead anthology series which will follow different characters in each episode, exploring pockets of the TWD universe which have been left undiscovered.

(8) SCOOBY ORIGINS. [Item by Martin Morse Wooster.] I thought these paragraphs from Harrison Smith’s obituary for “Scooby-Doo” co-creator Joe Ruby in the Washington Post, “Joe Ruby, TV writer and producer who co-created Scooby-Doo, dies at 87”, would be of interest to Filers.  “Silverman” is a reference to NBC president Fred Silverman. “Spears” is Ruby’s writing partner Ken Spears, Scooby-Doo’s other co-creator.  “Takamoto” is Iwao Takamoto, a Japanese American animator who drew the original sketches for the main characters.

Mr. Ruby said he considered a small, feisty sheepdog character before settling on an oversized, cowardly Great Dane inspired by actor and comedian Bob Hope.  The dog was originally called Too Much–the show was originally called ‘Mysteries Five’–before Silverman said he pushed for raising the character’s profile and renaming him Scooby-Doo, after hearing Frank Sinatra scatting ‘doo-be-doo-be-doo’ on a recording of ‘Strangers in the Night.’…

…Most persistently came questions about Shaggy.  Why did he have the munchies all the time?  Was he, as many viewers speculated, actually a stoner, a marijuana-loving emblem of the drug-infused 1960s?

By all accounts, the answer was no.  Shaggy and Scooby’s constant hunger was simply an attempt by Mr. Ruby and Spears ‘to insert certain idiosyncrasies into their characters,’ the animator Takamoto wrote in a memoir, My Life With A Thousand Characters.

‘And for the record,’ he added, ‘drugs of any kind were anathema to Joe Ruby; he hated them.’

I also learned that the idea for “Scooby-Doo” came from Fred Silverman, who wanted a cartoon like the 1940s radio show “I Love A Mystery” but with kids.

(9) MEDIA BIRTHDAY.

  • September 2013 — Seven years ago this month, Kamala Khan made her first appearance in Captain Marvel #14 before going on to star in the her own series Ms. Marvel, which debuted in February 2014.This Pakistani American Muslim teenager was created by G. Willow Wilson along with editors Sana Amanat and Stephen Wacker, and artists Adrian Alphona and Jamie McKelvie. The first volume of Ms. Marvel would win the Hugo Award for Best Graphic Story at Sasquan in 2015.

(10) TODAY’S BIRTHDAYS.

[Compiled by Cat Eldridge and John Hertz.]

  • Born September 9, 1900 James Hilton. Author of the novel Lost Horizon which was turned into a film, also called Lost Horizon by director Frank Capra. It is best remembered as the origin of Shangri-La. Many claim Lost Horizon is the first American book printed as a paperback but it’s actually Peal S. Buck’s The Good Earth. (Died 1954.) (CE) 
  • Born September 9, 1906 – Aileen Fisher.  A hundred children’s books, some ours.  Nat’l Council of Teachers of English Award for Excellence in Poetry for Children.  Natural history, fiction, poetry, plays; nonfiction including lives of Louisa Alcott, Jeanne D’Arc, Emily Dickinson.  “Poetry is a rhythmical piece of writing that leaves the reader feeling a little richer than before”.  (Died 2002) [JH]
  • Born September 9, 1915 Richard Webb. Captain Midnight on the Captain Midnight series when it began and which ran for two years in the Fifties on CBS. It was called Jet Jackson, Flying Commando when it was syndicated. He played Lieutenant Commander Ben Finney in the “Court Martial” episode of Star Trek. And in the Fifties, he was Lane Carson, the lead investigator in The Invisible Monster. (Died 1993.) (CE)
  • Born September 9, 1922 – Pauline Baynes.  Seventy covers, a hundred eighty interiors, for us; many others.  First to illustrate “Farmer Giles of Ham”; also The Adventures of Tom Bombadil, “Smith of Wootton Major”, other Tolkien including The Lord of the RingsNarniaRichard Adams, Hans Andersen, the Grimms, Kipling; outside our field, Uden’s Dictionary of Chivalry, winning the Greenaway Medal; religious books e.g. King Wenceslaus, the Nicene Creed; magazines e.g. The Illustrated London News.  (Died 2008) [JH]
  • Born September 9, 1929 Joseph Wrzos, 91. He edited Amazing Stories and Fantastic under the name Joseph Ross from August 1965 through early 1967. He was responsible for their move to mostly reprints and a bimonthly schedule while the publisher refused to pay authors for the reprints saying he held the rights to them without needing pay additional renumeration and leading to severe conflict with SFWA. With Hannes Bok, he edited in 2012, Hannes Bok: A Life in Illustration. (CE)
  • Born September 9, 1943 Tom Shippey, 77. Largely known as a Tolkien expert, though I see he wrote a scholarly 21-page introduction to Flights of Eagles, a collection of James Blish work, and under the pseudonym of John Holm, he is also the co-author, with Harry Harrison, of The Hammer and the Cross trilogy of alternate history novels. And early on, he did a lot of SF related non-fiction tomes such as Fiction 2000: Cyberpunk and the Future of Narrative (edited with George Slusser). (CE) 
  • Born September 9, 1946 – Anna Lee Walters, 74.  Pawnee (her mother) / Otoe-Misouria (her father).  Goddard alumna.  American Book Award, Virginia McCormick Scully Award.  Ghost Singer is ours; half a dozen nonfiction books; she is in many anthologies and journals.  [JH]
  • Born September 9, 1952 – Michael Dobson, 68.  Chaired Corflu 36 (fanziners’ con; corflu = mimeograph correction fluid, once indispensable).  Fanzine, Random Jottings (note, “FIAWOL” = Fandom Is A Way Of Life”).Three alternative-history novels (with Douglas Niles).  Nonfiction books may show SF color, e.g. Watergate Considered as an Organization Chart of Semi-Precious Stones.  Timespinner Press has a booklet for each day of the year.  [JH]
  • Born September 9, 1952 Angela Cartwright, 68. Fondly remembered as Penny Robinson on the original Lost in Space. She, like several of her fellow cast members, made an appearance in the Lost in Space film. She appeared in the Logan’s Run series in “The Collectors” episode as Karen, and in Airwolf as Mrs. Cranovich in the “Eruption” episode. (CE) 
  • Born September 9, 1955 Janet Fielding, 65. Tegan Jovanka, companion to the Fifth Doctor. The actress had a rather short performing career starting with the Hammer House of Horror series in 1980 where she was Secretary Mandy on the “Charlie Boy” episode” before landing the the Doctor Who gig through 1984. Her career ended in the early Nineties. She was part of the 2013 50th Anniversary The Five(ish) Doctors Reboot. (CE) 
  • Born September 9, 1958 – Frank Catalano, 62.  Book reviews in Amazing with Buck Coulson.  Half a dozen short stories.  Toastmaster at the first Baycon (i.e. the regional, not the Westercon or Worldcon, with that name) and at Dreamcon 10.  Fan Guest of Honor, Rustycon 4.  Fanzine, Syntactics.  [JH]
  • Born September 9, 1977 – Viktor Martinovich, Ph.D., 43.  (Various romanizations of this Belarusian name.)  Teaches at European Humanist Univ., Vilnius.  Bogdanovich Prize.  Paranoia is ours, I mean his novel by that title (see NY Rev Bks here), also Mova; several others.  [JH]

(11) COMICS SECTION.

(12) SECOND FANDOME. DC Fandome Part 2 takes place September 12. Explore the Multiverse. The schedule is here.

(13) AHH, NATURE! This video suggests the American Museum of Natural History in New York is hosting a Terrible Pun exhibit when its doors reopen this week.

(14) GONE MORE THAN A FORTNITE. Epic Games is still trying to get Apple to reinstate its Fortnite app on iOS devices. Late Friday, the gaming company filed a motion for a preliminary injunction against Apple’s blocking Fortnite on iPhones and iPads. “Epic Games renews legal request to bring Fortnite back to Apple store” at CNN Business.

The injunction brief says that more than 116 million gamers have played Fortnite on iOS, making it the game’s biggest platform, larger than its player base on Nintendo Switch, Xbox, PlayStation, PC or Android.

Filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of California, the motion says, “all Epic seeks is for the Court to stop Apple from retaliating against Epic for daring to challenge Apple’s misconduct.”

In a Saturday statement to CNN Business, Epic said, “today we ask the Court to stop Apple from retaliating against Epic for daring to challenge Apple’s misconduct while our antitrust case proceeds.”

Fortnite has been blocked on iOS since August, when Epic introduced a new way for players to buy in-game currency directly without paying Apple or Google their customary 30% cut of revenue. This move violated both Apple and Google’s app store policies, the tech giants said, and Fortnite was pulled from both iOS and Android devices. Epic then sued both Apple and Google, accusing them of monopolistic practices.

(15) FROM SOMEBODY’S GOLDEN AGE. The Bristol Board has a flock of excellent black & white illustrations by famed sff artist Edd Cartier.

(16) DECIPHERNG THE STICKERS. Kirby Kahler’s article is a neat bit of space history: “Walking through the doors of history: unlocking a space tradition” at The Space Review,

In July 2019, I had the unique opportunity to revisit the astronaut walkout doors at the Neil Armstrong Operations & Checkout Building (O&C) at the Kennedy Space Center for the 50th anniversary of Apollo 11. Fifty years ago, I was one of more than 3,500 journalists trying to get the “money shot” of the Apollo 11 astronaut walkout.

As I balanced on top of my camera case, I took as many pictures of the astronauts as possible as they walked purposely through those double doors before disappearing like magic into the transfer van on the way to the launch pad. I was 17 years old and was covering this historic event for a small Illinois newspaper. It was an experience that will change my life and soul forever. I covered Apollo 15 as well, and that mission was equally as exciting.

For the Apollo 50th reunion at KSC, I also took many photos of the famous astronaut walkout doorway and surrounding area as part of the NASA tour granted to a select group of “old space journalists.” There were no astronauts this time, just memories of the excitement and anticipation of seeing them walking through those iconic doorways. Those brave men and women were heading on the adventures of their lives, and they were taking us all with them.

This article is about investigating the O&C shuttle mission stickers that have been placed on the historic doorway, as noted in the photographs I took of the O&C walkout area. While many stickers seemed easy to identify, I noticed several immediately that could not be easily identified due to weathering and other issues.

(17) GROK AROUND THE CLOCK. Today I learned there is official Heinlein apparel. Shades of the Sixties!

(18) HERE THEY COME TO SAVE THE DAY. [Item by Mike Kennedy.] A group of mice genetically engineered to have greater muscle mass have retained that muscle during a trip to the International Space Station. Their regular, unmodified cousins who also went for the trip lost muscle and bone mass—just as happens for astronauts during their stay in weightlessness. Some of this mouse control group were treated with the “mighty mice” drug upon returning and rebuilt their muscle mass faster than untreated mice. “‘Mighty mice’ stay musclebound in space, boon for astronauts”.

…While encouraged by their findings, the couple said much more work needs to be done before testing the drug on people to build up muscle and bone, without serious side effects.

“We’re years away. But that’s how everything is when you go from mouse to human studies,” Germain-Lee said.

Lee said the experiment pointed out other molecules and signaling pathways worth investigating — “an embarrassment of riches … so many things we’d like to pursue.” His next step: possibly sending more “mighty mice” to the space station for an even longer stay.

(19) SHAT’S BACK. “William Shatner ‘The Thrill Is Gone’ feat. Ritchie Blackmore and Candice Night” on YouTube is a track from Shat’s new album The Blues, which Cleopatra Records will release In October.

[Thanks to JJ, Cat Eldridge, N., Mike Kennedy, Martin Morse Wooster, Michael Toman, John Hertz, John King Tarpinian, Contrarius, and Andrew Porter for some of these stories. Title credit goes to File 770 contributing editor of the day Daniel Dern.]


Discover more from File 770

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

75 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 9/9/20 The Worm Rider’s Digest

  1. (9) Happy birthday to Ms. Marvel. Kamala Khan got me into superhero comics again which I hadn’t read in a long time.

  2. The sandworm scene in the trailer reminds me a lot of Schoenherr’s cover for Analog (“Prophet of Dune”).

  3. Andrew (not Werdna) says Happy birthday to Ms. Marvel. Kamala Khan got me into superhero comics again which I hadn’t read in a long time.

    Disney+ has the animated Marvel Rising series which prominently features her. It also depicts her family rather well. Yes I subscribed — it’s got a lot of interesting viewing to say the very least.

  4. 3) I wonder, does Keanu Reeves get credit for being born in the Middle East, or for his paternal Hawaiian mixed descent?

  5. Question: is there a term for feeling an influential work is hackneyed because you came to it late?

    For me it was Bram Stoker’s “Dracula”. By the time I read it, I’d already seen many vampire movies, and read most of Anne Rice’s vampire series.

  6. David Shallcross: Thinking ahead about the Best Picture eligibility of a fourth Bill & Ted movie?

  7. (10) James Hilton’s Lost Horizon was remade in the early 1970s as a musical – a badly misconceived and terribly marketed movie whose abject failure marked the end of the Burt Bacharach/Hal David collaboration.

  8. @Soon Lee: It’s called “Hamlet-is-full-of-cliches-Syndrome,” I think.
    @Cat: Thank you. I have Disney+, so I’ll check that out.

  9. 3) It’s nice the paychecks will get distributed more evenly.

    I figure the Oscars will continue rewarding movies as shitty as Gone With The Wind, but differently shitty, so there’s no loss there.

  10. @P.J. Evans
    When I watched the trailer, I also immediately thought, “The Sandworm looks just like John Schoenherr’s Analog cover, so they got that right.” I also called out “Fear is the mind killer” seconds before Timothee Chalamet actually says it.

    Anyway, I wasn’t particularly interested in this adaptation of Dune, but the trailer looks actually better than I thought. And of the people who played Paul Atreides, Timothee Chalamet is probably the only one who looks at least vaguely the right age. Kyle MacLaghlan, much as I like him, was too old and I can barely remember the actor who played him in the bad Sci-Fi Channel adaptation of the early 2000s.

  11. Andrew (not Werdna) says to me Thank you. I have Disney+, so I’ll check that out.

    IMDB the series before you watch it to get the order as Disney+ has them listed out of order. The splash screen in their menu has the title names.

    Oh and the Groot and Rocket Raccoon series is a hoot.

    Now watching: a Midsomer Murders with the second Barnaby.

  12. Cough, cough.

    Cough, cough.

    Cough…

    Oh, heck, just going to sleep. With BiPAP so I can breathe. With dog so I won’t be too stressed to sleep.

    (Just to be clear, this is my normal asthma and breathing difficulty, not anything infectious. Just a bad night.)

  13. Sorry, I want to comment on something not in today’s File770. My thoughts on the puppies response to the Dragon Awards.

    When will these idiots realize that their books are not popular, especially with younger readers? The authors that the puppies hate have a lot of reserves at the Chicago Public Library. In the eight years since I retired from CPL the number of reserves on science fiction is so much greater than when I was working. Most of the 2020 Hugo Award nominees for a novel still have reserves on them, something unheard of in genre fiction for books that the library may have owned for over a year. There are over 300 holds combined on all the formats of Jemisen’s latest! And in all formats, CPL owns about 80 copies. (CPL never had to order so many copies of an SF novel when I was working.) Science fiction has never been so popular. And it’s all due to those diverse young social justice warrior whippersnappers.
    And Correia’s latest has zero reserves.

  14. <

    blockquote>Alan Ziebarth says When will these idiots realize that their books are not popular, especially with younger readers?

    Based on their Amazon rankings, I don’t think they’re popular with any age group currently. I think it’s fair to say that their books just aren’t selling worth crap. Not being on a major publisher certainly hurts most of the Puppies and makes it almost certain that any book they release won’t find many readers.

  15. Lis, I do hope you sleep well. If you like dark chocolate, ask Mike for my address and I’ll send you a Nordic nougat bar after I get your postal address. I bought a bunch off a friend who owns a Scandinavian import shop.

  16. I got a shower today, such are the small comforts of life currently. Because I can’t bend the knee less it spontaneously fracture getting in the bathtub is difficult and requires a home health aide be there in case I start to fall. (And I can’t dry myself properly as I can’t bend over, so she gets to do that.) Right now that means just once a week with washing up at the sink the other days. So a shower is a great luxury. And needed to make sure I don’t start building up staphylococcus on the skin.

  17. @Cat First Barnaby is best Barnaby!

    14) Epic’s lawyers don’t seem to be very good. This was an (ahem) epic miscalculation.

  18. So much good stuff today, starting with the brilliant title from Daniel (perfectly placed on the day of the Dune trailer by Mike).

    I haven’t read Dune for a long time, so I don’t remember all the scenes in the trailer, but what I do remember looks good. (And Mike Walsh, the January and March 1965 covers for Analog by John Schoenherr for “The Prophet of Dune” probably remain my two favorite sf illustrations ever.)

    Halloween. My neighborhood is a hotbed of trick-or-treating; we had 600 kids come to our door last year. Probably less than that this year, but I bet still a lot. We’re going to shut down, though, and not give any candy out.

    Time travel movies. Tonight, by coincidence, I watched Safety Not Guaranteed again. I really enjoy that movie. It stars Aubrey Plaza as a magazine intern out getting a story about a guy advertising for someone to time travel with. Mark Duplass is the guy. Jake Johnson and Karan Soni are the other two working on the story. And there are lots and lots of people in small roles. I had forgotten that Kristen Bell is one of them, so I was surprised when she answered the door. Lynn Shelton was another; I had not realized that she had just died, in May. She was feeling bad one day, they ran tests, said, “oh, my, you have leukemia,” and she died a few days later.

    I love a lot of G. Willow Wilson‘s work, but none as much as I love Kamala Khan. Kamala is just one of the most appealing characters I’ve ever read anywhere.

    Thanks for the Edd Cartier illustrations.

  19. 0) I understood that reference.

    6) If the title of that movie had not given away the premise to me, the title plus the name of the protagonist would have. I shall not worry about seeing it until I can do so at home – not just because of the plague, but even more because I shall want subtitles and rewind ability just to understand the dialogue.


    PIXEL
    AREPO
    TENET
    OPERA
    LEXIP

  20. The Dune trailer looks pretty (though not as pretty as David Lynch’s, for all its other faults) – but it sounds like it does the Hollywood thing of making the protagonist’s American accent two degrees heavier than anyone else’s.

    Other than that… “crusade” in place of “jihad” is a sensible choice, and I gather they’re doing it in two parts, which is probably right. I’ll be interested to see if they capture any of Frank Herbert’s cynicism about heroes this time.

  21. Several of the Marvel Rising cartoons, with Ms Marvel & Squirrel Girl and others, are available for free via the official Marvel HQ YouTube channel (which predates Disney+). There’s a bunch of other interesting stuff there too–Guardians of the Galaxy, Black Panther, and more.

  22. Meanwhile, very minor SF celebrity drama over on Mastodon as John Shirley made an account, popped up in someone’s mentions objecting to singular they and the use of “cis people”, and deleted his account a few hours later when it became clear the academic linguists weren’t done with him yet.

    I remember reading A Splendid Chaos back in the 1980s, but not especially fondly.

  23. @Sophie Jane – I much prefer the visuals of this one of the gaudiness of Lynch’s version.

    As for the cynicism, as a teenager I didn’t pick up on that until the second book, although thinking about it now, it is stated in the first book that Paul is taking advantage of a myth planted in the Fremen culture by the Bene Gesserit. On the other hand, he is the Kwisatz Haderach :).

    And Lynch of course went with it literally raining at the end of the movie, making Paul out to be more or less a god.

  24. @Cliff

    Yes, the Lynch version was enough under the influence of Star Wars to want a very good vs evil narrative. This time the popularity of Game of Thrones might take things in a more interesting direction .

    The planted legends are part of what I mean, plus the sense that Paul‘s leadership isn’t good for the fremen – one of the appendices talks about them being “afflicted by a hero” – and perhaps even a sense that the nobility of the Atreides is just as much a pragmatic choice as the Harkonnens’ villainy. In the end, it’s all about power.

  25. @1
    Dune adaptations have the virtue of presenting an opportunity to remove the less fortunate bits out of what is still a vital fable for our age. Stripped of the quirkier, dated material, I think Dune is very 21st century. Herbert was both of and before his time. Maybe that’s true of most of the sci-fi greats. Pohl, Brunner, Clarke…

    @8
    Wait…Scooby Doo was a parody of Bob Hope…whoa…

    @Alan Ziebarth, et al.
    I think sf has never been better. Never. Not only diverse, but various and abundant. Whatever kind of thing you want, there’s plenty of it. Around the turn of the millennium, a new pulp era started. Kristine Kathryn Rusch, among others, had been exhorting genre publishers to remember the kids, to engage a new generation on their own terms. Whether anyone heeded her advice, or it all just kind of happened, that was exactly the prescription the genre needed.

    And you can still get plenty of old school stuff like the pups and others want. How many novels can you read in a year? I am persnickety, and the sort of thing I most enjoy is probably the biggest “loser” in the new genre, but only as a percentage of output. There are probably 20 novels and 100 shorter works of keen interest to me published in any given year. That’s more than I can handle.

    It’s an embarrassment of riches, truly, to be a sci-fi fan today. Anyone who says different is just an embarrassment.

  26. Brown robin notes It’s an embarrassment of riches, truly, to be a sci-fi fan today. Anyone who says different is just an embarrassment.

    I’ll still hold that allot of the Puppy rage is simply that they don’t want to admit that they’re not popular. JdA may call himself an asinine title but that doesn’t mean the vast majority of genre readers even know who he is, or will be picking up one of his books. Arkady Martine on the other hand, and I use her as my example because he’s said Bad Things about her novel, Is well-known by the virtue of being within the establishment genre media. Her superb novel got the attention it deserved.

  27. Speaking of MS MARVEL and SQUIRREL GIRL, here’s a few more comic book series I recommend:
    MOON GIRL & DEVIL DINOSAUR, Marvel
    THE VISION (10 or 12 issue miniseries by Tom King), Marvel
    The Green Lantern (by Grant Morrison, up to like issue 12 by now), DC
    POWERS, Brian Bendis and Michael Avon Oeming. The extended-finale collection just popped up on Hoopla. However, to get this volume’s full impact, you should have already read the many preceding volumes…

  28. I thought about doing a series of blog posts about religion in SF (am still thinking, though it’ll have to wait until my current self-imposed task is done), and Dune was one book I’d like to talk about, in that context, precisely because it is so very cynical about matters of religion. In the Dune universe, spiritual forces are real and effective – and the people who know this reserve the knowledge strictly for their own little cabals, and fob the mass of the population off with carefully curated fictions, designed for the cabals’ own benefit. (The Bene Gesserit and their Panoplia Propheticus are the most obvious offenders, but far from the only ones.) It’s “Religion as Revealed Truth” versus “Religion as Tool of Social Control”, and the social controllers are winning hands down.

  29. @ Steve Wright

    In the Dune universe, spiritual forces are real and effective – and the people who know this reserve the knowledge strictly for their own little cabals, and fob the mass of the population off with carefully curated fictions, designed for the cabals’ own benefit.

    Indeed. Any group that will [rot13] cynag rzretrapl zrffvnu zlguf gb ranoyr gurve zvavbaf gb rkcybvg phygherf vf nobhg nf plavpny nf lbh pna trg. [/rot13].

  30. I’m torn between reading these little snippets about Dune, which make it interesting for the first time to me, and not wanting to read too much about it. I believe there are two copies of The Dune Encyclopedia in the house and not one copy of Dune of which I am aware, which might make this a unique household.

    @Daniel Dern: Here to second your recommendation of the Vision miniseries. I think the title is worth saying: “Little Worse Than A Man, Little Better Than A Beast”. I’m not reading comics like I used to, but of what I’ve read lately, it’s the single book-length work I’ve thought the most of.

  31. (6) Whatever you may think ‘cerebral sci-fi’ is, Prometheus and Alien: Covenant are the exact opposite of it.

    Aside from its numerous factual errors (e.g., Christopher Nolan did not invent the term ‘grandfather paradox’, which has been around for decades), Hess’s article mostly reveals he has a taste for pretentious, bombastic nonsense.

  32. Thanks for the good wishes.I’m somewhat better today.

    Cat, I am, sadly, a milk chocolate girl. I tried liking dark chocolate for a while, and it just didn’t work out for me. In this as in other things, I embrace my peasant roots. 😉

  33. John A Arkansawyer on September 10, 2020 at 7:47 am said:

    Here to second your recommendation of the Vision miniseries.

    This is why I’m glad that (a few decades ago) I learned to often pick comics based on author and/or artist. Tom King’s VISION miniseries will break your heart. As will his recent Mr Miracle miniseries (over at DC).

  34. Minor spelling correction re 19) – Ritchie Blackmore’s better half is Candice Night. Lovely lady: I met them briefly at their Marlborough College gig on their Under a Violet Moon tour. One of the support acts was a jolly old German Professor who played tunes on hollowed-out vegetables: I’m not sure if he was suggesting that this was an actual mediaeval practice or not.

  35. Oooo! I have nothing relevant or constructive to say, but —

    Now playing: “Hotel California” by the Eagles. And it’s even genre, or close enough.

    😉

    (Am I revealing my age too much?)

Comments are closed.