(1) NANOWRIMO SITE VANISHES. [Item by Dan Bloch.] Earlier this week NaNoWriMo shut down their website without any notice. People are commiserating on Reddit.
What a freaking waste. A huge, passionate and vibrant community founded on conquering the impossible, brought down by gross mismanagement and a refusal to listen to the community that gave it life.
I’ve been sad about this for a long time, but it’s definitely hitting home today, especially seeing the posts from people freaking out about losing their site data, since NaNoWriMo NEVER officially announced the shutdown on official channels to warn them.
We meant nothing to them, even in the end. Good riddance.

The Wayback Machine’s latest Nanowrimo.org screencap was May 27.
NaNoWriMo (National Novel Writing Month) announced in March that the organization was shutting down. They offered a lengthy explanation in “The State of NaNoWriMo – A Community Update – March 2025” on YouTube.
This followed in the aftermath of a controversy that erupted the previous September when they issued an equivocal statement about using AI – and it did not go unnoticed that NaNoWriMo is sponsored by ProWritingAid, a writing app that advertises AI-powered technology, including text rewrites – leading Zriters Board members Daniel Jose Older, Cass Morris, and Rebecca Kim Wells to immediately resign.
(2) EXTRA CREDIT READING. Two sff news periodicals posted today:
- Jason Sanford’s Genre Grapevine for May 2025 at Patreon; and
- David Langford’s Ansible® 455, for June 2025.
(3) IGNYTE AWARDS VOTING OPENS JUNE 9. Public voting on The Ignyte Awards will begin June 9.
The Ignyte Awards began in 2020 alongside the inaugural FIYAHCON, a virtual convention centering the contributions and experiences of BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and People of Color) in Speculative Fiction. Founded by L. D. Lewis and Suzan Palumbo, the awards were an attempt to correct representative gaps in traditional spec lit awards and have grown into a coveted and cherished addition to the awards landscape. The Ignytes seek to celebrate the vibrancy and diversity of the current and future landscapes of science fiction, fantasy, and horror by recognizing incredible feats in storytelling and outstanding efforts toward inclusivity of the genre.
(4) SAVE WHEEL OF TIME. Did a show ever have so many spokes persons? “Wheel of Time fans band together to save show after cancellation – petition gets over 50,000 signatures” says Radio Times.
Following the cancellation of The Wheel of Time after its third season, a petition has quickly racked up signatures from fans hoping to save the Prime Video fantasy show.
The petition, titled Save The Wheel of Time, has already got over 53,700 signatures and counting, with fans calling for the story to be finished and arguing that it “deserves to be told in full”.
The petition points not only to the third season’s strong critical and fan reception, but also to reported viewing figures, arguing for the show’s continuation by putting it in comparison with other fantasy shows The Rings of Power, House of the Dragon and The Witcher….
(5) FUTURE TENSE FICTION. The Future Tense Fiction story for May 2025 is “The Shade Technician,” by Harrison Cook, about urban heat and its health effects, as well as the privatization of critical infrastructure.
The response essay “The Limits of Heat Resilience” is by physician and heat researcher Pope L. Moseley.
Extreme heat is pushing up against our physiological limits. We can’t adapt our way out of the problem—we need to confront it directly.
(6) JOHN SCALZI Q&A. CollectSPACE starts their interview with an anecdote about the author’s research: “John Scalzi reconned Apollo 11 moon rock before turning it to cheese in new novel”.
…”I went to the Armstrong Air and Space Museum very specifically so I knew what the layout of the place was, so I could see the moon rock there for myself and so when I wrote about it, it would be reasonable to what is actually there,” said Scalzi in an interview with collectSPACE. “They had no idea.”
Had the docents approached him and asked why he was interested in the moon rock, they might not have believed him anyway. In “When the Moon Hits Your Eye,” released today (March 25), it is Virgil Augustine, the museum’s (fictional) executive director, who comes to realize what has happened, however impossible it might seem…
Then they follow with more conventional questions about the new book.
collectSPACE (cS): Was there a particular moment in your life that it just struck you, or how do you come up with the idea of writing a book about the moon turning into cheese?
John Scalzi: It was something that had been just rolling around my brain for a while, simply because it was just such an absurd idea that it almost felt like a challenge. You know, was this something that I could make something out of?
cS: Did you search to see if anyone else had written a book about the moon turning to cheese?
Scalzi: I didn’t, but if someone did, it wouldn’t have necessarily stopped me because there are so few super original ideas. you just accept that most of what you’re doing is not about what’s original, but what you can bring to that particular topic that nobody else has.
There are lots of children’s books about the moon being made of cheese, but they’re all picture books, so I felt that this was a pretty safe subject. Also, as soon someone mentions the topic, people are like, ‘Oh, it’s like Wallace and Gromit,’ because they go to the moon and it is cheese [in “A Grand Day Out With Wallace and Gromit” released in 1989].
This was something I was reasonably confident had been unexplored territory in the adult literature format, and certainly in the manner in which I did it, which was to structure it around a lunar cycle, rather than just one or two main characters….
(7) THE ONLY ONE WHO COULD INTERRUPT HARLAN WAS – HARLAN. Edwin L. Battistella reminisces about his introduction to parenthetical phrases in “What I learned from reading Harlan Ellison” at the OUPblog.
When I was in high school, I went through a Harlan Ellison phase….
…Stylistically, what stood out most was his use of parentheses. In the essays, Ellison used them all the time. In a random four-page section I count six parentheticals, some as long as a paragraph. Elsewhere, I found a couple that went on for more than half a page….
…Ellison used the parenthesis to amplify his outrage, to underscore his smart-alecky awareness, and even occasionally to poke fun at himself.
For a time, Elision’s style left a mark on me as a writer. I began including (what I thought were) pointed, witty asides in my essays and correspondence. I got away with it in high school, less so in college, and finally my wife convinced me to give it up. It was, she said, “too cutesy” and “distracting.”
Every now and then, I miss parentheses and trot a pair of parens out, but for the most part I’ve given them up. The style worked for Ellison, who managed to never be too cutesy and whose distractions were interesting, but I could not pull it off….
(8) BREATH MINT OR CANDY MINT? Chris Winkle argues “Why Literary Fiction Is a Genre” at Mythcreants. Here are a couple of excerpts. You’d need to read the article to see him make his case.
…In any widespread discussion of literary fiction, two contradictory ideas are bound to make an appearance. Some people advocate for one or the other, while others embrace both simultaneously. Let’s look at these two competing ideas.
- Literary fiction as the best fiction. Under this definition, any book of any genre can be considered literary fiction if it is good enough. This means that literary fiction is simply a prestige label given to a wide variety of books we admire. Let’s call this the prestige definition.
- Literary fiction as a distinct style of fiction. Under this definition, literary fiction has specific characteristics that distinguish it from non-literary books. These characteristics include realism, slow and detailed prose, and experimental style or form. Let’s call this the style definition.
You might think these two definitions would be at war with each other. Conceptually, they are. But while individual literary fans may take one side or the other, the community as a whole isn’t interested in resolving this contradiction. In fact, these definitions coexist by design.
That’s because both definitions are needed to send a bigger message: that literary fiction entails specific characteristics, and those characteristics are superior. Meaning, a book of any genre supposedly becomes better by adopting literary fiction conventions. That’s how it “transcends” its genre and becomes literary instead….
… This is why publishers already treat contemporary literary fiction like a genre. It’s a specific type of fiction that appeals to a specific audience of fans. Business-wise, that’s what a genre is. It’s used to match books with the readers who are inclined to purchase and enjoy them.
However, literary books don’t fit everyone’s idea of what genres are. The prestige definition is only partly responsible for this. I think a greater factor is that we love our favorite genres, so we want them to be more coherent and meaningful than they are. And when we assign meaning to them, it’s easy to make that meaning too restrictive. For instance, if we associate genres with a specific type of setting or plot, then literary books, which are distinguished by characteristics such as prose style, may seem like the odd group out….
(9) JOHN BOARDMAN (1932-2025). By Gary Farber. I was sorry to read Ansible’s report today: “John Boardman (1932-2025), US fan active since 1950 in cons, clubs and APAs, and treasurer of the 1967 Worldcon, died on 29 May aged 92.”
John was among the first fans I met in NYC fandom in the early 1970s; he and his wife Perdita lived within a long walk’s distance from my childhood home in Midwood, Brooklyn, and at the time I was first invited to the Lunarians, the NYC science fiction club that put on the annual Lunacon science fiction convention, the club met at their home, until months later when Perdita, fed up with the way fans left half-filled cups and dirty plates all over their large house, announced that she wouldn’t put up with it any more, and that the club would have to find a new meeting place.
For a time, that was Frank and Ann Dietz (Frank’s second wife) house in Oradell, New Jersey, and then we met at the Lunacon hotel in Manhattan; my memory is a bit shaky at the moment if we were using the Statler-Hilton that year or the Commodore.
John was a true character. Known to some as “the Jerry Pournelle of the left,” he was a professor of physics at Brooklyn College, a leftist, a bit deaf and thus very loud, very opinionated, and thus the parallels to Jerry. John was a founder of Diplomacy-by-mail fandom with his fanzine Graustark, a mainstay of parts of NYC fandom, a bit of a blowhard, but unforgettable.
He was always hale and hearty, speaking with a vibrant and booming voice, one you could hear as soon as you entered a party he was at, always ready for a good argument.
Among other bits of personal history, from his Wikipedia page:
“Boardman earned his BA at the University of Chicago in 1952 and his MS from Iowa State University in 1956. He then attended Florida State University to begin his doctoral studies. However, he was expelled in 1957 due to his involvement with the Inter-Civic Council and more specifically for inviting three black Florida A&M exchange students to a Christmas party.”
Also see Fancyclopedia’s entry on John Boardman.

(10) ALF CLAUSEN (1941-2025). “Alf Clausen, Emmy-winning ‘Simpsons’ Composer, Dies at 84” reports Variety. He died on May 29.
… Clausen won two Emmys and another 21 nominations for the long-running animated Fox series. He began scoring the antics of Bart, Lisa and company in 1990, during its second season, and is believed to be the most-nominated composer in Emmy history with a total of 30 nominations overall.
He also won five Annie Awards, also for “Simpsons” music. His long tenure with Matt Groening’s irreverent creation made him one of the most respected creators of animation music in TV history. His nearly 600 original scores for the series are also believed to be a record for the most written for a single TV series in America….
Clausen conducted a 35-piece orchestra every week, something producers insisted upon from the beginning. His unexpected firing in August 2017, a cost-saving move by Fox and “Simpsons” producer Gracie Films, resulted in a firestorm of protests from fans around the world….
Six of Clausen’s pre-“Simpsons” Emmy nominations were for “Moonlighting,” including two landmark episodes: the black-and-white “The Dream Sequence Always Rings Twice” and the “Taming of the Shrew” sendup “Atomic Shakespeare.”…
… He scored nearly 100 episodes of the late 1980s puppet sitcom “Alf” (and when asked about the title, he would often quip, “no relation”)….
(11) TODAY’S BIRTHDAY.
[Written by Paul Weimer.]
May 30, 1922 — Hal Clement. (Died 2003.)
By Paul Weimer: If hard science and physics could be considered “characters” in science fiction, Hal Clement is certainly the person who was able to make them so. Mission of Gravity is the premier look at this, giving an extremely weird and strange, and yet possible high gravity world. Do the characters he populates this world with work as individual characters? Not really, but what you read Clement for is the puzzles and the logic behind the hard science that makes a high gravity-distorted world like Mesklin (the planet of Mission of Gravity) possible in the first place.
Another novel in this vein that doesn’t get much play or notice, but I ironically read before Mission of Gravity, is The Nitrogen Fix. In this book, Earth’s atmosphere has changed, radically, with the free nitrogen and oxygen in the atmosphere having combined into a toxic and unbreathable mix of nitrogen oxides, carbon dioxide and water. Did the aliens who have come to Earth change and terraform Earth for their own purposes? In the end, the transformation of Earth’s atmosphere is a puzzle that is solved, and makes sense, with a big heaping sense of irony to it all.
Although shared worlds are not a big thing anymore, back in the 1980’s, they were all the rage. I didn’t mention it back when I wrote on Ellison (way too much to write about him) but even Harlan Ellison did a shared world, Medea. His shared planet had a bunch of writers very interested in building a realistic planet and solar system. Clement not only provided an essay on worldbuilding the astrophysics of Medea in the book, but also contributed a story.
Once again, hard science as a character in Clement’s work. That’s what it means to me.

(12) COMICS SECTION.
- Curses! suspects what a book club is really about.
- Half Full gives a compliment at a signing.
- Jerry King questions book marketing.
- Reality Check thinks a writer is busy.
- Rhymes with Orange has a monster problem.
- Tom the Dancing Bug completely redoes the comics page.
(13) MEMORIES. Steven Thompson, son of famous comics fans Don and Maggie Thompson, tells a great anecdote about the late Peter David on Facebook. It has to do with how Peter made a tribute panel to Don Thompson a terrific memory.
(14) JON DECLES PROFILE. File 770 commenter Jon DeCles – the pen name of Don Studebaker – was interviewed in 2017 by The Press Democrat about the loss of his house in a fire: “Valley fire survivor starting over with prized cuckoo clock that escaped the flames”.
It’s nearly two years since the Valley fire vaporized the Cobb Mountain home of Don Studebaker, a highly literate high-school dropout, science-fantasy writer, stage channeler of Mark Twain, devotee of ancient Greek gods, co-creator of the documentary-worthy Berkeley literary commune of Greyhaven and a decadeslong student of the nearly infinite subtleties and elements of ritual significance of the Japanese tea ceremony.
The 75-year-old Studebaker has no earthly idea when he’ll be able to call in a crane to set a new modular home roughly where the old, conventionally constructed house was. But already he contemplates special placement of the clock.
“The cuckoo is going to be the pièce de résistance,” beamed the gray-bearded, blue-eyed and kinetic Studebaker from alongside the fish-pond porch of the residence off State Route 75 that he dubbed the Rhinoceros Lodge and references fleetingly on his website home.pon.net/rhinoceroslodge. The 1950s country home was devoured along with those of 11 immediate neighbors by the historic south Lake County inferno of Sept. 12, 2015, that killed four people downhill from Cobb, charred more than 76,000 acres and destroyed nearly 2,000 buildings.
Studebaker lost almost everything he owned, but not his German cuckoo clock.
One day in June 2015, three months before the Valley fire, he’d decided for no particular reason that it was time to seek repair of the musical timepiece his wife purchased for him while on an international book tour at least two decades earlier….
… Had it not been in the shop, the clock surely would have burned in the fire that surged down Cobb Mountain toward Middletown that Saturday afternoon two years ago. …
(15) SHAKEN NOT STIRRED, DEEP UNDERGROUND. [Item by Steven French.] A complex of tunnels built after the Blitz is set to become an immersive spy museum and will also feature one of the deepest underground bars in the world: “London tunnels that inspired James Bond creator will become spy museum” reports the Guardian.
During his time in military intelligence, Ian Fleming, the author of the James Bond novels, regularly worked with Winston Churchill’s spy organisation based 30 metres below ground in a labyrinth of tunnels in central London.
The Kingsway Exchange tunnels complex, stretching out across 8,000 sq metres beneath High Holborn, near Chancery Lane underground station, hosted the Special Operations Executive (SOE) and is said to have inspired Q Branch in Fleming’s novels.
So it seems appropriate that plans to breathe new life into this long-abandoned second world war subterranean network will include a permanent exhibition about the history of military intelligence and espionage.
The Military Intelligence Museum is to collaborate with the London Tunnels company, developing the complex to showcase its original artefacts, equipment, weapons and documents in a modern hi-tech experience at the proposed new £220m London tourist attraction, which is planned to open in 2028.
(16) FEEL FREE TO STEP ON THAT BUTTERFLY. Dete Meserve’s op-ed for Space.com asks “Could time travel tourism be the next space tourism?” I admit it – I clicked.
…Up until recently, physicists believed that time travel to the past was impossible because it required unusual matter or extreme warping of spacetime. However, physicist John D. Norton has developed a new model based on Einstein’s theory of general relativity that shows time travel is mathematically possible.
His model does not rely on strange matter or intense space-time distortion, but uses a simple space-time shape that allows paths to loop back in time. This work suggests that time travel could occur under more ordinary physical conditions than previously thought.
The classic understanding of time travel centers on a fundamental problem: paradoxes. If travelers could alter even minor details of the past, the cascading consequences would either rewrite the present or eliminate the traveler’s own existence — the infamous grandfather paradox. This seemingly insurmountable obstacle led physicist Stephen Hawking to propose his Chronology Protection Conjecture, which essentially argues that the laws of physics themselves forbid backward time travel by preventing the formation of closed timelike curves.
However, groundbreaking research by Dr. Fabio Costa and Germain Tobar at the University of Queensland challenges this assumption. They’ve developed a mathematical model showing that closed timelike curves do not automatically create paradoxes. Their revolutionary model suggests that while time travelers can move and act freely in the past, the universe itself maintains consistency—events would self-adjust to prevent any logical contradictions from occurring.
This revolutionary finding has profound implications. If Norton is right — that time travel won’t require exotic materials — and Costa and Tobar are correct — that time travel doesn’t alter the future — it opens the door for time travel technology to evolve beyond fictional ideas of secret inventions or unpredictable glitches in the universe. Instead, it could follow the trajectory of other breakthrough technologies—gradually becoming accessible, eventually commercial….
(17) VIDEO OF THE DAY. The Blasters and Blades podcast features author Sharon Lee speaking about a Liaden Universe® novel she co-wrote with Steven Miller: “Episode 578: Ribbon Dance by Sharon Lee”. The book was released in 2024.
Today we were graced with the presence of Sharon Lee, one of the nicest ladies we’ve interviewed! We had Jana S Brown (aka Jena Rey) on as a co-host, and together we produced a kick butt interview about Sharon’s love of reading and speculative fiction. And we talked about her Liaden Universe. This was a fun interview, so go check out this episode. Lend us your eyes and ears, you won’t be sorry!!
[Thanks to Mike Kennedy, Andrew Porter, John King Tarpinian, Bill, Dan Bloch, Joey Eschrich, Chris Barkley, Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Mark Roth-Whitworth, Steven French, Kathy Sullivan, and Teddy Harvia for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Daniel “Tin Pan Alley” Dern.]
Discover more from File 770
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Good evening. The Pixels are happy so the weather must have been splendid across the multiverse today. They’re now sleeping as I listen to the third novel of V.E. Schwab’s A Darker Shader of Magic series while enjoying a warm slice of apple pie with vanilla ice cream.
I’ve done enough Scroll birthday items that Cat and Mike can reuse some now as they come up 🙂
I am nothing if not prolific (I had two book reviews this week, too)
8) my main complaint about “literary fiction” are those who think it’s the only kind that matters and anything else is philistine crap for senseless masses. Personally, I find it “boring privileged navel-gazing.”
4) I don’t really have a dog in this fight, because I never managed to get into The Wheel of Time, neither the books nor the TV series. Though I feel for those who enjoyed the show.
That said, just before reading this Scroll, I came across a video on YouTube by a self-published SFF author I had some interactions with on a forum for self-published authors years ago. I didn’t agree with his approach, but he didn’t seem like a jerk.
I didn’t really think of him in years and his once very active YouTube channel has mostly gone silent. However, he posted a video again and was grinning ear to ear, because The Wheel of Time has been cancelled. Because The Wheel of Time TV show was supposedly bad and woke and emasculated Rand Al’Thor character in favour of the female characters. And all modern entertainment is like that, which is why no one cares anymore, yada-yada-yada.
Now I sympathise with being frustrated when your favourite book series finally gets adapted as a movie or TV-show, only to take massive liberties with the plot. Isaac Asimov’s Foundation series was extremely important to me and the TV adaptation is a complete disaster, which has next to nothing to do with the books. I’m pretty sure the Wheel of Time fans got a more accurate adaptation than us Foundation fans. However, if Foundation were to be cancelled, I still wouldn’t cheer and I certainly wouldn’t make a video about it, because there are a lot of talented people working on the show and many of the issues seem to be due to the streaming service interfering with the writers.
(11) Hal was such a wonderful person – a great writer, a great speaker and a great panelist. I have a photo of him with my toddler son, at a convention’s childrens’ program.
First Peter David, now John Boardman. What a week. sigh May they rest in peace.
OT for here, but Chris Barkley’s 28 May article (his #99) on his first viewing of Star Wars has aged off of the current article list, and if anyone here can answer my question in the comments there, I’d still like to know. It was on the relative timing of Chris’s viewing in DC and the expedition that the Cincinnati Fantasy Group jointly made to a special screening in Cincinnati at about the same time, Had Chris missed a Cincinnati pre-release screening for some reason, or did the screening that CFG saw jointly somehow come later?
11) For many years Hal Clement would come to Balticon with a suitecase full of fossils and he would spend about an hour or so with the Children’s Program showing off the fossils and allowing the kids to touch and handle them. It was always a highlight.
(8) Guess I get to defend the “prestige definition” of literary fantasy in my File 770 article Pursuing The Ghost Of Literary Fantasy.
Check it out!
For NESFAns, Hal Clement will always be Harry Stubbs, local high school science teacher. I always remember him at cons with a big SLR camera hanging around his neck, whistling aimlessly. He was the only person we allowed in the art show with a camera — because he was an artist as well. He was always very humble.
(1) Sounds like the runners finally cut their losses. One of my daughters, morganhazelwood.com, the one who got me back into writing, was into it heavily, and she said a lot of folks were really pissed off. There they were, busting their butts to make 50k words in a month, and then “oh, sure, you can use it…”
She was involved, with a lot of others, at going for 50k words this month, but not on nanwrimo. (I mention her website, with 10 years of content on writing, beta readers, querying, and on, all good.)
(7) And I’m one who thought he was brilliant (yes, he was).
(8) Hello, I brought this up years ago here, and several regulars jumped on me. (shrug) I agree, completely, except there’s two more criteria for lit-fic: it must take place between, um, the Roaring 1920s and present day, past or future is not allowed. and the other is nothing major must change, other than possibly a relationship, but certainly not politics, or…
(9) FUCK! (Pardon my French…) I didn’t know he was still around. Met him once or twice, back in the day. Damn, another mainstay, gone. I remember being at one or two cons, back then, and him and other standing at midnight on Sat, and leading the con suite in God Save the Queen. (No separate filk rooms back then, and even… AUTHORS… hung out in the con suite.
Birthday… Hal Clement. (Aka Harry Stubbs). I miss him. There was a period we ran into each other at con after con, and he was a gentle man (two words). And taught prep school science. And Hal and Harry were pro and fan guest of honor at one (or more) cons.
(16) Now, what strikes me on this is one of the arguments against FTL is that you’d travel in time… and if you can, than this suggests FTL, without using exotic matter.
(17) Listened to the whole podcast. The guy doesn’t seem to have ever gone to a con, or understand the difference between commercial cons and Real SF Cons. But, yeah, Sharon was very nice.
rlewiston777 – link is screwy. Goes to Flash Mobs in Wired.
Still exhausted. To much so to do more than just read the scroll.
@ mark
Thanks. Here’s a better link:
Pursuing The Ghost Of Literary Fantasy
For now, this is the right link for John Boardman on Fancyclopedia (new server, some issues).
https://fancyclopedia.org/index.php?title=John_Boardman
The Wiki article on Boardman does include his fannish life.
Rob, rlewiston777, thanks Some I don’t agree with – hated Piranisee, but Walter Jon Williams, and early Amber (got tired of the series), and Patricia McKillip.
But how about literary sf? Zelazny, again – Lord of Light, Creatures of Lifght and Darkness? Brunner, Stand on Zanzibar? And, for that matter, I’d love to get your opinion on my Becoming Terran, where I was trying to be literary, and tell a story.
(8) He forgot the most important idea: it’s a marketing category.
(11) I have to disagree with Paul slightly: Hal Clement did create one great character – Barlennan in Mission of Gravity. (Even if he’s not a very alien alien.)
As James Davis Nicoll said, in admiration, Clement could get a story from a phase diagram. And Harry was an incredibly nice guy.
@Patrick McGuire: I was unaware of the CFG screening until after I had returned from Disclave.
That’s because I had fallen behind in my membership dues and for a few months around that period of time and I was not going to any meetings around then.
Of which I have no regrets about them or now because I never would have had my unique experiences and fantastic memories of seeing Star Wars for the very first time.
Chris B.
(11) My feeling is that Hal Clement in Mission of Gravity expresses the spirit and character of explorers and scientists better than just about anything.
(16) Norton came up with his model as a teaching device, designed to impress upon students that they need to be careful with those good ol’ space-time coordinates and not assume the default meaning. I suspect it’s not going to help the nascent Time Travel Tourism Industry much as not only is the model matter free but the space-time is not temporally orientable, so there’s no ‘forward’ time direction. (I should say I know John D Norton the physicist as John D Norton the historian and philosopher of science whose website covers not just relativity theory but Quantum Stuff, probability theory and all kinds of other goodies: https://sites.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/jdnorton.html)
1) Well, I did NaNoWriMo for over twenty years, so, yeah, I’ll miss it. But, while NaNoWriMo the concept had (still has) a lot going for it, NaNoWriMo the organization got a lot of stuff wrong, over the years. The AI sponsorship deal was the last straw for me, and for many others, it seems. It is a pity – besides offering much-needed mutual support and solidarity for the aspiring speed-writers, the organization did a lot of work promoting literacy in general.
But an organization that’s built on a voluntary community… can’t function if it goes against the values of that community. Turning off the website without notice is, sadly, the sort of high-handed, arbitrary decision that put people off.
8) I’m reminded of my time as an acolyte of the Evil Editor; specifically, of the time when he gave examples of genre, based on the question “Will Elizabeth say yes?” Went something like “If the genre is romance, Elizabeth will say yes. If the genre is horror, Elizabeth will say no, and will spend the rest of the book being pursued by her rejected suitor and his axe. If the genre is literary, Elizabeth will say yes, but will die of cancer.”
(9) In the filk department, John Boardman was an important figure in APA-FILK and had one of the biggest collections of verses for “Old-Time Religion.” His one-sided feud with Leslie Fish (I don’t think she ever responded) was amusing. He had lots of opinions, many of which annoyed me and some that were factually wrong, but he always offered supporting arguments.
1) I participated in NaNoWriMo for a decade. I enjoyed the experience, but for me is was much more about the local writing community than the organization. I stopped using the website other than for registering when they re-vamped the forums and made them almost unusable back in…2019? Since then the organization seemed to undergo a process of enshittification, but usually when an organization (NaNoWriMo the org) enshittifies their product (NaNoWriMo the event), it is to the benefit of someone. I have no idea who this was supposed to benefit.
4) Sorry to see WoT cancelled. It wasn’t my favorite genre show (and I gave up on the books after #7), but it was high-quality work and I would have watched another season.
7) Harlan would have loved programming in LISP.
8) Every argument I have read on the merits of literary fiction vs. genre fiction feel like both sides are experiencing Sour Grapes. There are no “gatekeepers” on either side of the argument, who have any real power. At least, not since about 1990. Case in point: Both Stephen King and Harlan Ellison have stories in the “Best American Short Stories” series, which is overwhelming literary fiction. And more and more every year, literary fiction authors are experimenting or embracing genre fiction.
The entire conflict seems to be driven by (a) genre writers who feel belittled by “the establishment”, and (b) literary writers who are jealous of the attention – and sales – genre fiction receives. Any random good-but-not-great self-published fantasy author probably has more sales than many prize-winning literary writers. And that same self-published author is quite unlikely to win one of the myriad literary awards. So there is symmetry in the universe.
In closing: Harrumph!
Chris Barkley: Thanks! From my fairly brief time in Cincinnati and the CFG, I remembered you and I remembered Star Wars, but the details have all gone. As you say, it all worked out. For both of us, since I certainly could not afford Disclave that year and am not sure I even would have seen Star Wars in its first run if not for the free showing that CFG went to.
@Steven French: I see that Space.com is maintaining its reputation.
@John Winkelman: Preach it! There may be less interesting things to say about a work of fiction than what genre it’s marketed as, but not many.
8) If we’re going to discuss what is “literary,” it’s worth taking a look back at the entire history of literary production, as well as how various audiences have divided that production, especially along social-prestige lines, and how producers have addressed those audiences. And the audiences can overlap–it’s a bit of a cliche that many literature teachers read, say, mysteries for pleasure. Just as many SF/F readers read mysteries or historicals–or poetry or mainstream fiction.
One thing Winkle gets right is the role of the marketplace. Booksellers recognize that their customers want to find particular products, so, like all retailers, they organize their stores to accommodate their shoppers. And bookstore geography is not organized primarily along prestige lines (though there might be a section of “classics”) but along lines of established commercial categories, which are in turn maintained by both writers and publishers.
Last week I took a walk through our Barnes & Noble and saw the expected layout**: various genre sections: fantasy, SF, crime & mystery, romance, manga (!), and general fiction. That last is actually all the titles that don’t easily fit into one of the others, so that’s where you find Jane Austen, Dickens, Hemingway, Amy Tan, Dan Brown, and everything that isn’t being marketed to a narrower audience segment.
There’s an old Marty Feldman sketch, “Ticket Agency,” in which a Marty is seeking a particular kind of theatrical experience. He asks the agent, “Do you have any plays with giraffes”? (There aren’t any, so I think he finally settles for “naked ladies playing football.”) I confess that my thinking about “genre” has been influenced by that sketch.
** I hadn’t been there for a while, so I was surprised to find “Fantasy” with its own section of 8 bays of shelves, separate from SF with 4, and manga with 12.
Temporal tourism has been the subject of several sf stories but the first title that springs to mind is Up the Line by Robert Silverberg.
Hal Clement was a wonderful person. He took up studying Welsh in his later years to keep his mind sharp. He also painted and exhibited at convention art shows under an alias.
1.) I participated once in Nano, in order to break through an issue with an overly critical internal editor. After that, the timing of my projects never fit Nano, in part because November was always a busy time at the day job. I’m grateful for that early version of Nano (around 2007? 2008? Somewhere in there) because it was what I needed to learn how to break through that critical voice. I just was never able to participate in the activities around Nano because, again, day job, so it never became a big priority for my writing.
8.) My perspective on litfic may be somewhat different because I’m more interested in contemporary and classic regional litfic, with a focus on the Pacific Northwest. That puts me right out of the majority of current litfic which is (as always, no matter what the genre) centered more in other regions. And heck, John Steinbeck (Nobel fiction prize winner) dabbled in genre back in the day. Litfic has always been more about the use of language and the development of characters as far as I’m concerned. But that’s litfic as style, not litfic as genre, which has specific tropes like any other genre.
Hal Clement–I met him at Lonestarcon II, when my then-young son attended one of his geology workshops for kids. I remember him being soft-spoken and gentle, and really good with the kids.
Here’s a filk about Canadian lit fiction
https://youtu.be/IhjO-sAvLm8?si=v3ebOTbyXLsYevVu
(1) I don’t understand why this needed an organisation at all. To me it is just something you do. There’s no need of an organisation for something like ‘Talk Like a Pirate’ day, people just do it.
@Stuart Hall: Yes. I didn’t realize there was an organization until the last couple of years
Steve Wright, no, no, no. She doesn’t die of cancer, she dies of consumption.
@mark: if she dies of consumption, it’s historical fiction. If she dies of consumption but has a sister, it’s Regency.