Review: Avatar: The Way of Water

By Craig Miller. [Reprinted by permission from Facebook.] It was back to the Directors Guild last night for a screening of Avatar: The Way of Water. Overall, I really enjoyed the film. Like the first Avatar movie, the story itself isn’t remarkable. It isn’t concepts you haven’t seen before. But that’s true for a lot of movies. And plays. And novels. West Side Story is Romeo and Juliet. It’s all in how you tell it.

And James Cameron tells it quite well. As with Avatar, Avatar: The Way of Water is a visual feast. Unlike the first film, there aren’t long sweeping pans lingering over beautiful, otherworldly vistas. The “beautiful” and the “otherworldly” are still there, but we’re seeing them incorporated into the action and storytelling.

At nearly three-and-a-quarter hours, the film is long though it doesn’t feel quite that long. And unlike a lot of sequels, it isn’t just a retelling of the first film but with bigger, meaner, or more bad guys. It’s new story. A continuation of what came before but taking us in new directions and to new locations. There’s a lot of storytelling going on, with longish sequences that don’t seem to be following the main story, but they pay off in the end. Though the film could certainly do with trimming.

There are a number of questionable things in the film but mostly they pass over you while you’re watching. (These are relatively minor. Like, in the first Avatar, was this the only spot on Pandora the upsidasium – oops, I mean unobtainium – was located? Weren’t there places where they wouldn’t have to go to war to get it? And what were even they going to use it for? They clearly had cheap and easy air and space travel.)

We saw the film in 3D and I’m not sure that added much to the enjoyment. Maybe it made the environment a little more vivid. The 3D wasn’t used for storytelling purposes. They didn’t talk about the format or projection at the screening but it seemed that some scenes were in standard 24 fps speed and others were 48 fps. Peter Jackson used 48 fps on The Hobbit and it gave the whole film an ultra-real “locker room interview” feel. Here, too, I found the faster filming speed sequences looked weird. And switching between the two filming speeds was jarring. I was thrown out of the movie because I was noticing a change to the images. I do not recommend seeing the film in that format.

But I do recommend seeing this film. Genny and I both liked it. (If you didn’t like Avatar, you probably won’t like this either. I think it’s actually somewhat better than its predecessor.)

There are three more Avatar films planned. Presumably the next one will be out sooner after this one than the gap between the first two films.

3 thoughts on “Review: Avatar: The Way of Water

  1. 3D – I don’t think Hollywood’s figured out how and when to use it. It was mind-boggling for Hubble 3-D. But the kaiju movie I saw a few years back… it was dreadful. And in one of the fight scenes, it appeared to be “oh, if three layers are good, nine will be great!!! Instead, we seemed to be trying to watch a battle in a sandstorm.

  2. I found it pretty but tedious. “Not remarkable” doesn’t do justice to the inanity of the story, or to the fact that literally everything is left unresolved. The villains are mustache-twirlingly ridiculous. The na’avi don’t have a shred of the alien about them aside from their physical appearance. They are indistinguishable from humans in their behavior.

    It all depressingly reminds me of seeing The Abyss many years ago, where instead of an interesting story about aliens, we got nothing but a stupid chase-the-bomb plot. It also reminds me of the endless sequences of pretty space clouds in Star Trek The Motion Picture. Movies are supposed to be telling a story, not stopping for a literal half-hour of “ooh, shiny”. It even reminded me a little of Terrifier 2, which is also over-long. It’s as if the directors love their babies so much that everything they film has to go on the screen.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.