Pixel Scroll 12/27/23 So Have You Looked Up And Seen How Pixels Twinkle Against The Midnight Sky? 

(1) UNFORSEEN INTERSECTION. Maya St. Clair draws a fascinating comparison between a current bestseller and Heinlein’s controversial classic in “Fourth Wing Review: Starship Troopers (for Girls!)”

…Criticisms of Starship Troopers’ themes, while hyperbolic, were not entirely off-base. In Heinlein’s world, the ideal military life is violent, abusive, and deindividualizing; death is and should be omnipresent at every stage of training. For example, there’s the basic training exercise in which

“… they dumped me down raw naked in a primitive area of the Canadian Rockies and I had to make my way forty miles through mountains. I made it [by killing rabbits and smearing fat and dirt on his body] … The others made it, too… all except two boys who died trying. Then we all went back into the mountains and spent thirteen days finding them…. We buried them with full honors to the strains of ‘This Land Is Ours’… They weren’t the first to die in training; they weren’t the last.”

Through the eyes of Johnnie, we experience an intensity of life that makes civilian existence seem anemic, even pathetic….

…With all that being said, it feels wrong to mention Fourth Wing in the same breath as Starship Troopers. Putting aside the fact that Fourth Wing is a poorly-written work whose prose has been critiqued to death by many people before me, the two books seem to represent opposing moments in publishing history. Heinlein, for all his faults, was writing “up” for an audience of teens, treating them as adults and including them in the sphere of “adult” science fiction, with complex worldbuilding and (relatively) sophisticated themes. Sixty years later, Fourth Wing and its team (author Rebecca Yarros and Entangled Publishing) represent a publishing world moving in the opposite direction: creating books for adults in an actively juvenile style, and cultivating an audience of adult readers who no longer demand that published books have good writing at all so long as they check necessary boxes of sensation and eroticism.

But thematically and content-wise, the two books are as close as one could possibly get. Fourth Wing, like Starship Troopers, sells a military coming-of-age story in which mass death is a part of the allure (“brutally addictive,” says the cover blurb). Someone on Reddit puts the death count of Fourth Wing at 222 cadets, plus an untold number of civilians — though it’s widely considered a “fluff” read. Its primary audience (and the primary audience of most mainstream fantasy now) is female, young, progressive, and would probably be aghast at being compared to grimdark bros, Heinlein apologists, or men in general. And yet here we all are, hooked on the same stuff….

(2) ICONIC LE GUIN COVER ART OFFERED. The estates of Carol Carr and her husband Robert Lichtman are in the news: “Original cover art for Le Guin sci-fi novel goes on sale” at Bay Area Reporter.

…First published in paperback by Ace Books, the novel sported cover art by award-winning artists and biracial couple Leo and Diane Dillon. Their painting featured profiles of the book’s protagonists in the left bottom corner looking off into the distance. Surrounding the pair is a blue and white celestial-like scene with what appears to be a brown planet and a spaceship hovering above.

(Leo Dillon, of Trinidadian descent, died in 2012. He was the first African American to win the prestigious Randolph Caldecott Medal for illustrators of children’s books, while the Dillons were the only consecutive winners of the award, having received the honor in 1976 and 1977.)

The Dillons’ original 17 and 1/4 by 13 inches acrylic painting is now being offered for sale for the first time at the Antiquarian Booksellers’ Association of America global book fair taking place in San Francisco in early February. The asking price is $20,000.

“It is literally unique. This is it, the original and not a print,” said Mark Funke, a rare bookseller who lives in Mill Valley where his business is also located.

Scouting out shops in the East Bay several years ago looking for new material to sell, Funke had received a tip about the sale of various items from a home in the Oakland hills. It led him to receive an invite from the executor of the estate to come to the house.

To his amazement, Funke had stumbled onto the archives of three individuals involved in the world of science fiction writing. One was the late Terry Carr, an editor at Ace Books who published the works of Le Guin and other sci-fi authors and died in 1987. While most of Carr’s personal papers had gone to UC Riverside, Funke found several boxes still in the house and acquired them….

… Funke is now handling its sale on behalf of the Carr and Lichtman Estate. He will have it available on a first-come, first-served basis at his booth at the book fair.

“I am pricing it high for the artists but, I think, reasonable for it being Le Guin’s most famous novel. She won awards for it, and it ratcheted her up to the greats of science fiction,” said Funke. “It’s got very topical content; this idea of the planet Gethen and ambisexual individuals. I just think it is fascinating and a very active topic in today’s discussion.”

In a statement to the B.A.R. about the sale, the executor for the family estate said, “The Carr-Lichtman family has treasured this artwork for over 50 years and now it is time to find a new owner who will cherish this remarkable work of science fiction publishing history for the next 50 years.”…

(3) KORSHAK COLLECTION NEWS. The Korshak Collection announced on Facebook

We have partnered with the University of Delaware for an academic illustrated catalog of the Korshak Collection. We don’t want to give away all of our surprises, but the catalog will include a foreword by New York Times bestselling author Neil Gaiman and entry by Pulitzer prize winner author Michael Dirda, as well as an interview with the Hugo Award winning artist Michael Whelan. We are so grateful for this partnership and all of the outstanding contributions that have made this project possible.

(4) MCU UK. James Bacon recommends David Thorpe’s account of his time as a creator for Marvel UK: “In Review: The Secret Origin of Earth 616 By David Thorpe” at Downthetubes.net.

… This is a fascinating book, and, for Captain Britain fans, a definite buy. For comic fans interested in Marvel UK, of great interest. Yet it is also an excellent autobiography, a very readable and personal exploration of a comic fans desires, aspirations and progression to be a writer and an insight into how Marvel UK was, and offers real honesty when it comes to a comics career that took an interesting turn that saw David Thorpe’s work in the industry elsewhere. The story is brimful, and includes how another comic related moment saw him turn to a very successful career beyond comics, one that arguably has made a real difference to the world….

… David Thorpe came up with the concept of Earth 616, and he describes it as a Stan Lee styled “Hoo Boy” moment when he heard Mysterio say “This is Earth dimension 616. I’m from Earth 833.” to Spider-Man in Spider-Man: Far From Home and that is something that any comic reader can appreciate, many of whom have imagined themselves as writers….

(5) IN FELLOWSHIP THERE IS STRENGTH. “Board Game Cafe Workers Went on a Quest for a Union and Won” reports the New York Times.

A golden glow illuminated the employees huddled inside a Hex & Co. cafe on the Upper East Side, a haven created for board game enthusiasts to gather for fantastical quests.

Meticulous campaigns were second nature to these workers — how many times had they infiltrated an obsidian castle or vanquished a warlock? They had been immersed in this particular adventure for months, navigating a labyrinth governed by strict rules and made harrowing by unfamiliar tasks and tests. Now they gathered to plot their final triumph: unionization.

On that Tuesday in September, Hex & Co. workers confronted their bosses with a demand for recognition. Less than two months later, they voted to join Workers United, the same group that has been organizing workers at Starbucks stores across the United States. The workers at the three Hex & Co. locations across New York City were just the first employees of a board game cafe in the city to unionize. Workers at the Uncommons and the Brooklyn Strategist followed this month.

All the stores fall under the ownership of either Jon Freeman, Greg May or both, and they pleaded with their employees not to unionize, saying that a union would wipe out the “flexible and open-door atmosphere we have tried to foster.”

Teaching board games is a far cry from swinging a miner’s pick or working numbing hours on an assembly line. In fact, many of the cafe workers said they hung out at their workplaces in their off hours. But in the end, complaints over dollar-an-hour raises and bands of unruly children reigned: Among the 94 employees who voted, only 17 dissented….

…Only 10 percent of American wage and salary workers were union members in 2022, a historical low, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The food-service sector’s membership rate was less than 4 percent. But this fiscal year saw the most representation filings since 2015, according to the National Labor Relations Board.

Young workers “are willing to take risks, because they feel like their future is at stake,” said Kate Bronfenbrenner, the director of labor education research at Cornell University.

After slogging through a recession and a pandemic, many found themselves earning minimum wage while corporate profits soared, she said….

(6) AI AS SEEN BY THREE SFF AUTHORS. The River Cities’ Reader tells fans how to access the “Virtual Event: ‘Speculating Our AI Future,’” with Cory Doctorow, Ken Liu, and Martha Wells on January 11.

Designed for those fascinated by, or terrified about, the rise of artificial intelligence is invited to a January 11 virtual event hosted by the Rock Island and Silvis Public Libraries, when Illinois Libraries Present’s Speculating Our AI Future finds bestselling science-fiction writers Cory Doctorow, Ken Liu, and Martha Wells in discussion on the promise, perils, and possible impacts that AI will have on our future, as well as AI as portrayed in contemporary and future science-fiction writing.

The Speculating Our AI Future panel discussion with Corry Doctorow, Ken Liu, and Martha Wells will begin on January 11 at 7 p.m., participation in the virtual event is free, and more information is available by calling (309)732-7323 and visiting RockIslandLibrary.org, and calling (309)755-3393 and visiting SilvisLibrary.org.

Cory Doctorow, Ken Liu, Martha Wells.

(7) GRAPHIC EXAMPLES. Sam Thielman hits the high notes in a review of “The Year in Graphic Novels” for the New York Times.

Good graphic novels tend to appear in bookstores seemingly out of nowhere after years of rumors, scattershot serialization, “process” zines and snippets posted to social media. As literature, long-form comics are uniquely resistant to editing. As visual art, the cartoonist is in the weird position of having no access to the final product until it’s presented to the public. So it’s frankly miraculous when we get as many good comics as we do. This year there were remarkable new books from established masters and freshman graphic novels from brilliant young artists. Better still, a gratifyingly thick stratum of our 2023 stack was devoted to making us laugh. It’s a rich conversation, and one that promises to continue into next year and long beyond.

From the moment you open it, Daniel Clowes’s MONICA (Fantagraphics, 108 pp., $30) announces its ambition. Against the weird hellscape of its front endpapers, the title spread depicts the world at its lifeless, churning, brightly colored beginning. Then all of time (so far) goes by in a whoosh on the next two pages — the dinosaurs, Jesus, Hitler, Little Richard, Sputnik — alongside the copyright boilerplate and the names of the editors and publicist. In Clowes’s smooth lines and precise hues, the rest of the book borrows styles from war, horror and romance comics to tell the story of an ordinary woman trying to give her life some meaning. Is such a thing even possible? Could the attempt destroy everything?…

(8) EVA HAUSER (1954-2023). Past fan fund winner (GUFF) Eva Hauser died December 23 at the age of 69. Here is an excerpt from Jan Vaněk Jr.’s tribute on Facebook:

I am sad to announce that the 1992 GUFF delegate died on Friday 22nd. Eva Hauser[ová] travelled from Prague, still-Czechoslovakia to Syncon ’92 in Sydney, and then to Melbourne and back.

If you were there (despite the small attendance, the trip report reads like the Who Is Who of a golden age of the Australian fandom, and a testimony to their hospitality. Even though so much, and many, have already been lost in time, like tears in rain…), you may remember; and then you will understand why Eva is so much-lamented and widely eulogised from many different communities she was a part of….

(9) TODAY’S BIRTHDAY.

[Written by Cat Eldridge.]

Born December 27, 1951 Charles Band, 72. We have come tonight to honor a true film genius in Charles Band. He entered film production in the Seventies with Charles Band Productions. Dissatisfied with distributors’ handling of his movies, he formed his own company in the early Eighties. At its height, he would release an average of two films a month, one theatrically and one on home video. 

So what are you going to recognize out of his hundreds of films? 

Most of his films paid the cast next to nothing, were notoriously lax on safety measures according to State officials who fined him considerable amounts over the years and he paid screenwriters, well, guess. 

Trancers, also released as Future Cop, the first of a series, which I’ve seen and liked, had Tim Thomerson and Helen Hunt in the lead cast. Supposedly the detective here is homage to Bogart’s various detective roles.

As producer, he did Metalstorm: The Destruction of Jared-Syn.  Richard Moll who is in the cast and he shaved his head for his role here. The Night Court producers liked the look for Moll, so he continued shaving his head for the show.

Now he also produced a lot of more frankly sleazy SF such as Slave Girls from Beyond InfinityGalactic Gigolo, and Space Sluts in the Slammer, and the post-apocalypse zombie films, Barbie & Kendra Save the Tiger King and Barbie & Kendra Storm Area 51

His autobiography has a title that’s every bit has as over the top as most of some of film titles are, Confessions of a Puppetmaster: A Hollywood Memoir of Ghouls, Guts, and Gonzo Filmmaking

One final note. His entire financial house of cards collapsed in the late Eighties and was seized by various banks who in turned sold the assets off to MGM, so you’re likely to see one of his films streaming just about anywhere these days. 

(10) STORIES YES AND NO. Rich Horton reaches back to 1970 to tell Black Gate readers about “No More Stories — The Capstone to Joanna Russ’s Alyx Sequence: ‘The Second Inquisition’”.

“No more stories.” So ends Joanna Russ’s great novelette “The Second Inquisition.” But in many ways the story is about stories — about how we use them to define ourselves, protect ourselves, understand ourselves. It’s also, in a curious way, about Joanna Russ’s stories, particularly those about Alyx, a woman rescued from drowning in classical times by the future Trans-Temporal Authority….

(11) CORE TELEVISION. [Item by Olav Rokne.] Now, I don’t agree with everything in this article (for one thing, Foundation is execrable.) But it is an interesting look at what Apple+ is doing in SFF and why so much of it works. “The Best Sci-Fi Shows of 2023 All of Have One Shocking Thing in Common” at Inverse.

For All Mankind isn’t the only sci-fi show pushing the limits of the genre on Tim Cook’s dime. The Apple CEO has been quietly funding some of the best science fiction TV in recent memory, ranging from the centuries-spanning Isaac Asimov adaptation Foundation to the mind-bending near-future of Severance to the globe-trotting Godzilla spinoff series Monarch: Legacy of Monsters — to name just a few.

And while it’s hard to say what exactly defines an Apple sci-fi show, Inverse spoke to several showrunners and producers who all agree the tech giant brings a unique, futurist perspective to the genre that — when combined with endless cash — helps explain why, all of a sudden, it seems like the best science fiction television is all coming from the same company that sold you your iPhone….

… One thing you can say about pretty much any show or movie on Apple TV+ is that it probably looks gorgeous. While many Netflix productions have a certain flatness to them that can make it feel like the streamer has been cutting corners, Apple is pouring a lot of money into the look (and star power) of its original series — it helps to have a trillion-dollar cash pile, even if Amazon and Disney are still outspending the MacBook maker….

(12) MARATHON FAN. SYFY Wire understandably wants us all to know “How to Watch SYFY’s Twilight Zone New Year’s Marathon 2023-2024”.

Just as you can count on our planet making a full rotation around the sun every 365 days or so, you can also rest assured that SYFY will use the key of imagination to unlock its annual New Year’s marathon of The Twilight Zone. The honored tradition of airing Rod Serling’s groundbreaking anthology series won’t be going anywhere anytime soon. In fact, the 2023-24 edition is super-sized, with the marathon spanning a total of three whole days — starting Saturday (December 30) and ending Tuesday (January 2).

Who needs to smooch someone at midnight when you’ve got Jason Foster (Robert Keith) teaching his wicked family members a lesson they’ll never forget in “The Masks”? Fittingly enough, the classic episode — which revolves around a collection of vain and greedy individuals ordered to wear hideous masks until the stroke of midnight — will air about 40 minutes before the ball drops. If someone offers you a grotesque party favor along with that glass of Champagne, you might want to turn it down….

(13) CHINA’S MIXED SIGNALS ON VIDEO GAME PLAYING. “Will China Ease Its New Video Game Controls? Investors Think So.” The New York Times says, “After a market rout, gaming companies like Tencent and Netease rally on signals that regulators might apply proposed curbs on users less harshly than feared.”

 …The events of the past several days underline the push-and-pull forces in Chinese policymaking. The country’s top leaders have acknowledged they need to stabilize the economy, which has been slow to recover from being virtually locked down during the Covid pandemic. But the government’s tight control of how companies do business continues to inject uncertainty into the markets.

China’s National Press and Publication Administration, which issues licenses to game publishers and oversees the industry, unveiled a proposal on Friday aimed at effectively reducing how much people spend playing games. The plan took the industry by surprise, and investors dumped tens of billions of dollars in company stock.

The regulator issued a statement on Saturday stressing that the draft rules aim to “promote the prosperity and healthy development of the industry,” and said it is “listening to more opinions comprehensively and improving regulations and provisions.”

Then on Monday, the agency announced that it had licensed about 100 new games, after licensing 40 others on Friday. And a semiofficial association affiliated with the agency said that the additional game approvals were “positive signals” that the agency supports the industry.

The new regulations would cap how much money users could spend within games on things like upgrading the features of characters or procuring virtual weapons or other things used by the characters. It would also ban rewards that companies use to entice players to return. The proposal did not specify a spending cap…..

… The industry is still reeling from earlier restrictions first imposed in 2019 aimed at what the government deemed was an online gaming addiction among minors, as well as a broader crackdown against tech companies. Regulators also stymied publishers by not issuing any new game licenses for an eight-month stretch that ended in April 2022….

(14) CHART YOUR COURSE. Archie’s Press offers interesting “Outer Space” prints.

Outer Space is so huge, there’s really no way to wrap your head around the entire thing. This makes it all make sense.

(15) VIDEO OF THE DAY. [Item by Dann.] A tale of old Japan.  A tale as old as time.  A beleaguered hero looking to avenge past wrongs.  Western forces looking to control a local government.  A beauty of a beast.

When the culture and government deny any usual path to survival, much less happiness, our hero seeks unusual opportunities instead.  Learning the secrets of steel.  Surreptitiously learning the secrets of the sword.  All of them.

Eventually, our hero sets out on a path of vengeance leaving rivers of blood along the way.  Companions are found, whether or not our hero desires their companionship.

Each character is well-developed with unique strengths, flaws, and motivations.  Even the villains have a compelling story to tell.

Blue Eye Samurai is not to be missed.  And The Critical Drinker knows why.  Go watch the “The Drinker Recommends… Blue Eye Samurai”.

[Thanks to Andrew Porter, John King Tarpinian, Chris Barkley, Dann, Olav Rokne, Michael J. Walsh, James Bacon, Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Steven French, and Mike Kennedy  for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Cat Eldridge.]


Discover more from File 770

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

27 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 12/27/23 So Have You Looked Up And Seen How Pixels Twinkle Against The Midnight Sky? 

  1. It’s a most excellent evening to be in a warm apartment listening to a novel, this time it’s Linda Nagata’s Edges, the first of her Inverted Frontier series.

    So far I’m very impressed with both the novel itself and the narrator, Nicole Poole who I do not believe I’ve heard before. It’s akin to the work of Alastair Reynolds, a Good Thing Indeed.

  2. Sf author in the news https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2023/12/26/north-carolina-toddler-opens-family-christmas-presents/

    The parents of a 3-year-old son in North Carolina discovered this scene of torn-up paper and unwrapped presents under their tree at 3 a.m. on Christmas after their toddler decided to investigate what Santa had brought. (Katie Reintgen)

    Katie and Scott Reintgen were awakened at 3 a.m. on Christmas by their 3-year-old son, who had a loud and terrifying request for the gift he had just unexpectedly unwrapped: He needed scissors.

    “He wanted to open up his Spider-Man web shooters, so, naturally, he needed scissors to cut them free,” Scott Reintgen, 35, told The Washington Post. “That’s when we realized something had gone terribly wrong.”

    “There was the cold realization that all the effort you put in the night before had suddenly been undone, but mostly, it was just such an unbelievable thing to see,” said Reintgen, a sci-fi and fantasy writer who is the author of “A Door in the Dark,” a New York Times bestseller.

  3. (1) 222 cadets die? I’m sorry, that sounds like what I’ve read about the wrong-headed violence of Russian army hazing of recruits.
    (3) I want to find out if non-academics can buy/afford that catalog. After I saw the show at Chicon…
    (5) Huzzah! Cheers for them. The US was 24%, about, unionized in the early seventies. Then Raygun and the right went after it…. A dozen years or more ago, I looked at the NLRB website, and there were rules such that it was almost impossible for computer professionals to unionize (carefully written by the companies, and anyone thinking of developers getting hundreds of thousands, and options, knows nothing of the 90% of us.
    (12) Seems to me that if they’re going to stream Twilight Zone, there’s one that would be appropriate: He’s Alive.
    (15) I’m not into seeing all the gore, but this does sound worth checking out.

  4. The Sci-Fi marathon of the Twilight Zone has two major problems.

    First those are edited episodes. Sometimes minor edits, sometimes not so minor. They were originally made to fit more commercials in when they ran in a half hour and they never been restored to their full length.

    Second and somewhat obviously given what I just said these episodes are hacked intto pieces with commercials.

    So want to enjoy every episode in their unedited original version? Go subscribe to Paramount+ and just indulge yourself. A month subscription is $11.95, a very reasonable amount I’d say.

  5. Why doesn’t someone bring me a comfy recliner, a bigger-screen TV (the current one is a mere 40 inches) (says the woman who previously lived with a 13 inch CRT TV so old that…no, we’ll skip that), my favorite, and a supply of warm buttered rolls? Oh, and a side table.

    That’s not asking too much, is it?

  6. @Lis Carey
    Last time I visited my sister (2019) she’d rearranged her bedroom so the bed faced the very large screen TV, and the cats appreciated it (they liked to be on the bed with her).

  7. @P J Evans–My TV is in the living area, and Cider and I curl up on the couch to watch TV. Another improvement that could be made–the couch is fake leather, and very slidy, which Cider and I both have some issues with, sometimes.

    When I want to watch in bed, the computer gets drafted for streaming duty.

  8. (1) That’s an interesting comparison… I know one thing that many readers can’t accept in “Fourth Wing” is the ridiculous number of deaths that occur at the war college — as it seems over-the-top and wasteful. (It is! When I read it, I accepted it as an exaggerated and over-the-top part of the story.)

    However, I am annoyed at the digs at the readership of “Fourth Wing” in that article. Can’t people just enjoy a book? No, we’re told that they no longer care about good writing and just want books that have certain tropes. That applies to some fans. But fans are no monoliths — not even when they’re women. Do people not realize that readers can enjoy “Fourth Wing” but also see its flaws? Or that these same fans often enjoy so-called “acceptable” books as well?

    Also, would you write this sort of stuff about male readers who enjoyed a guilty pleasure book? I can point to bad writing in lots (and lots) of fantasy novels aimed at dudes.

    (9) Oh, yes. Re-Animator. 🙂 I remember it well. 🙂

  9. Lis – that’s not enough. I had a friend outside of Chicago who had a house. First time visiting, I take one look at the living room – at a 45 degree angle to the house, a fireplace facing where you step down into it, and something like a 60″ tv over the fireplace.

    I told him “you know what that looks like.”

    He said, “Of course. Lt. Uhuru, open hailing frequencies!”

  10. Lis Carey. Wouldn’t your recliner have a cup holder and fold out tray? A side table seems superfluous?

  11. @bookworm1398–Do recliners have them now? I suppose they must! I’ve heard rumors it’s not the 1990s anymore. (Last time I had a recliner.)

    @mark–You’re right, of course, but this place is already so much larger than my former place, a 250sqft studio apartment. The 60 inch TV would fit, but not the fireplace.

  12. The sublime RE-ANIMATOR was directed not by Charles Band, but by the late, great Stuart Gordon. GHOULIES was directed not by Charles Band, but by Luca Bercovici.

    Is it that hard to visit IMDB.com and get the credits right?

  13. Sam Hamm says Is it that hard to visit IMDB.com and get the credits right?

    Occasionally, well more than occasionally, the individual, well me, with memory issues mixes up things as they forget what they looked at within a few minutes of looking at it. So now it’ll be corrected shortly.

  14. I would trust the credits on IMDb only has far as I had conformed then myself again the original credits on the thing itself, and even those get credits wrong in occasion.

    No, I’m not going to check whether they have finally fixed my go to example for wrong credits on IMDb that stuck around for many years.

  15. (1) Fourth Wing and its category – “romantasy” – both made me slightly queasy., the way you feel after eating too much cotton candy. The book’s a real page turner, but I wish I had those hours back.
    Nevertheless, “adult readers who no longer demand that published books have good writing at all so long as they check necessary boxes of sensation and eroticism.“ is a complaint as old as the hills, equally applicable to Dracula and Lady Audley’s Secret, both of which are still read.

  16. @Msb
    I’m glad I’m not the only one who thought of “sensation novels” when I saw “sensation” mentioned in that sentence. Maybe that’s why the criticism gave me a bad vibe.

    The criticisms of sensation fiction looked down on both the authors and their readers. There was also a sense of moral panic in many of the criticisms. As if the critics felt a need to protect the readers (especially women) from themselves.

  17. (1)

    Johnnie Rico’s family are not peaceniks. They simply do not see the benefit of military service. At the end of the book, Rico’s father ends up joining the federal service and ends up as the platoon sergeant for Johnnie after he gets his commission. His father views military service as proof of a person’s ability to think beyond their individual comfort and consumption of goods.
    The military training in Starship Troopers is not abusive. It is purposefully designed to pose realistic threats so that recruits will gain the experience needed to survive and succeed in the event that they do experience combat.
    She references cadets in Starship Troopers attending “frequently ceremonies that reinforce their privileged status as witnesses of death”. I’ve read the book many times. There is exactly one “ceremony”. There isn’t anything positive or “privileged” about it.
    Lastly, Ms. St. Clair confuses the military ability/willingness to commit acts of violence with an actual desire to commit those acts. From Starship Troopers:

    War is not violence and killing, pure and simple; war is controlled violence, for a purpose. The purpose of war is to support your government’s decisions by force. The purpose is never to kill the enemy just to be killing him…but to make him do what you want him to do. Not killing…but controlled and purposeful violence.

    I’ve not read Fourth Wing and can’t comment on the accuracy of her description of the contents of that book. Her representation of Fourth Wing does not mesh well with the text of Starship Troopers.

    Regards,
    Dann
    The most cogent reason for restricting the interference of government is the great evil of adding unnecessarily to its power. – John Stuart Mill

  18. 1) having been trained by many years of Starship Troopers Discourse (which, to be fair, is never not entertaining on one level or another) I was pleasantly surprised by both that article and the comments. The novel they compared it to, if the accompanying art is indicative of the text, sounds just godawful, though.

    7) I’m not exactly au courant on graphic novels(or movies. Or books. Or music. Or…) and I have pretty basic dudebro tastes, but some of the graphic novels I’ve read and enjoyed the most this year are: (note: I read them this year, I’m not saying that they were published this year)
    Dark Nights: Death Metal
    DCeased
    DC vs. Vampires

    9) That makes me miss drive-ins because those were exactly the sort of movies you catch on a double-bill. I miss them for other reasons too, but those are not germane.

    12) When I was single, I used to take time off to watch SyFy’s Twilight Zone marathon. I’d fall asleep watching it, wake up to it still going, it was my own weird little holiday.

  19. You didn’t provide any context for the Bonestell artwork which appeared in the item about 2023’s graphic novels. It was in a separate post which I sent to you, showing the remarkable similarity between the end-papers in one book, and Bonestell’s artwork from LIFE Magazine’s “The World We Live In” series, published in the early 1950s.

    Also, did no one one contact Heritage Galleries or Doug Ellis about the Dillon painting, which IMHO should go for a lot more than $20K?

  20. Quatermain: drive-ins. The last time I remember going to one, we saw a triple feature: Destroy All Monsters, Where Eagles Dare, and Inga (g, r, and x). Let me note that the movie that had the most plot, character development, etc… was Destroy All Monsters.

  21. I used to fawn over that Dillons painting every time I went to visit Robert and Carol. It was a present to Carol and her first husband Terry, who had commissioned the the art for his Ace Specials line of books. The original is quite beautiful, resembling the fine art paintings of Gustav Klimt. Knowing my admiration for the painting, Carol hung one of my own humble pieces of art on the wall next to it knowing, rightly, that I would be raised up by the proximity.

    Robert and Carol were good friends to my wife and I for most of the last 45 years and I miss them both more than I can say. And I agree with Andy, it should be worth more than $20,000, but it is a fair market price.

  22. (15) Blue Eye Samurai is very good, as is Pluto, also on Netflix. The title refers not to Mickey’s dog or the now-demoted planet but to the god of the underworld, and the story revolves around robots and their recently established rights, a situation not everyone is happy about.

  23. I have not read Fourth Wing, but any time someone refers to a popular fiction book — even a popular fiction book I happen to dislike myself — as evidence that People These Days Are Obviously Dumb And Stupid Now, I roll my eyes so hard I can see my brain.

  24. Re: Drive Ins
    I recall vividly seeing Elvis Presley in “Blue Hawaii.” My family and I went to the drive in. The scratchy sounding, clunky audio device hung on the car window, and we watched the film. It started to rain toward the end, and we gave up and started to leave I remember seeing the wedding scene at the end, with the clear, blue sky behind them through the rain as it washed down the window.

    The car had to navigate so navigate over the rows of artificial hillocks, and then either to the right or left to hit the exits). The people in the film looked like they were melting in the rain. It was very surreal. I’ll always remember Elvis that way!

  25. A friend just posted on the Book of Faces that reading Fourth Wing was an absolute thrill for her. She regretted not stopping off at the local store to purchase the next book in the series.

    There’s something for everyone.

    Re: drive-ins. We still have an operating drive-in about an hour away. We used to take the kids for the double feature. The plan was for them to watch the early feature and then to fall asleep so we could watch the second, generally more adult-oriented* movie. That was our plan.

    Please don’t laugh at our plan.

    The drive home at that hour would not be wise for me these days.

    *Meaning PG-13 or maybe R-rated and clearly not meant for 6-12 year-olds. Not the other “adult”.

    @Jim Janney

    Thank you for the recommendation. That sounds interesting.

    Regards,
    Dann
    We must always take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented. – Elie Wiesel

  26. Lady Audley’s Secret is a delightful book, and quite well written. It’s funny, observant, clever. And, yes, the plot is extremely implausible. Highly recommended.

    I won’t comment on Fourth Wing as I haven’t read it, and it doesn’t seem my thing. And I don’t particularly want to trash anyone for getting enjoyment from reading. Still, I seriously doubt it will last as long as Lady Audley’s Secret. Which is no shame — few books do! And more power to anyone who likes it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.