Pixel Scroll 1/9/16 To Flail Beyond the Sunset

(1) USE THE FARCE. Entertainment.ie says this Twitter spat between Emo Kylo Ren and Very Lonely Luke is what the internet was made for. Here are the first two tweets in the exchange —

(2) BEWARE FAUX SPOILERS. Will R., who says Hobotopia is a long-running web comic, and one of the nicest things in all of the Internet, draws attention to its ostentatious Spoiler Alert for what turns out to be a pretty obscure The Force Awakens spoiler.

(3) ACTION FIGURES. Here are your prototype action figures for the Ghostbusters reboot. There wasn’t much chance Mattel would repeat the mistake Hasbro made with The Force Awakens of leaving out the female characters, was there?

Amanda Kooser at CNET already has play suggestions.

The action figures come from toy company Mattel and will be 6 inches (about 15 centimeters) in height. That’s a pretty standard size for action figures, so you should be able to fold them into imaginative play along with your Star Wars and Star Trek collection. The crossover possibilities are endless. I can’t wait to see what a proton pack does against Kylo Ren.

(4) STABBY WINNERS. Reddit’s r/Fantasy group has chosen the winners of the 2015 Stabby Awards. Here are the top vote-getters in 3 of the 15 categories:

Stabby Award

Stabby Award

  • BEST NOVEL OF 2015 Shadows of Self by Brandon Sanderson
  • BEST SELF-PUBLISHED / INDEPENDENT NOVEL OF 2015 The Labyrinth of Flame by Courtney Schafer
  • BEST DEBUT NOVEL OF 2015 The Traitor Baru Cormorant by Seth Dickinson

Click on the link to see the rest.

(5) MEAN STREETS. Tobias Carroll at Literary Hub introduces a review by reminding everyone of the time Raymond Chandler mocked science fiction.

In a 1953 letter to his agent H.N. Swanson, Chandler indulges in a brilliantly entertaining, paragraph-long parody of sci-fi writing, which hits every trope and cliché of the genre. Oh, and he namedrops Google some 45 years before Larry and Sergey registered the domain.

Did you ever read what they call Science Fiction? It’s a scream. It is written like this: “I checked out with K19 on Adabaran III, and stepped out through the crummaliote hatch on my 22 Model Sirus Hardtop. I cocked the timejector in secondary and waded through the bright blue manda grass. My breath froze into pink pretzels. I flicked on the heat bars and the Bryllis ran swiftly on five legs using their other two to send out crylon vibrations. The pressure was almost unbearable, but I caught the range on my wrist computer through the transparent cysicites. I pressed the trigger. The thin violet glow was ice-cold against the rust-colored mountains. The Bryllis shrank to half an inch long and I worked fast stepping on them with the poltex. But it wasn’t enough. The sudden brightness swung me around and the Fourth Moon had already risen. I had exactly four seconds to hot up the disintegrator and Google had told me it wasn’t enough. He was right.”

They pay brisk money for this crap?

In the case of Adam Christopher, Chandler’s rivalry with science fiction gave rise to literary inspiration. In the acknowledgements to his new novel Made to Kill, Christopher writes that “what I really wished did exist was Raymond Chandler’s long-lost science fiction epic.” He describes himself as “amused” by “the way Chandler hated science fiction.” There are a handful of nods to Chandler’s infamous riff on the genre peppered throughout Christopher’s novel, including as its epigraph. Made to Kill can be read as a science fiction-laced detective story and as a way of using the detective story template to investigate more archetypally science fictional themes of memory and identity.

The setting of Made to Kill is an altered 1965: John F. Kennedy is president, the Cold War rages on, and American society has had an unsuccessful dalliance with incorporating robots into everyday life. The last survivor of this program, narrator Ray Electromatic, is the detective at the center of this novel, drawn into a conspiracy involving Hollywood stars, radioactive material, and Soviet spies. Ray makes for an interesting protagonist in a number of ways: as robots go, he has an unexpected moral compass, and the fact that his memory only lasts for a day does a good job of establishing him as a less-than-reliable narrator from the outset.

(6) YOU’VE BEEN WARNED. David Gerrold says he’s learned from (bad) experience to avoid feuds, as he explains on Facebook.

Here are 5 of his 10 points:

4) “Forgive and forget” does not apply here. Everyone in a feud, no matter what side they’re on, has already succumbed to self-righteousness, simply by being in the feud. Self-righteousness is terminal.

5) A really spectacular feud, if it goes on long enough, if it gets loud enough, if it gets ferocious enough, will not only destroy the participants, it will destroy the community in which the feud occurs. (I have seen this happen multiple times, where whole forums evaporated because the toxicity reached armpit level.)

6) Sociopaths and attention whores enjoy feuds. People who have not yet learned a modicum of restraint or self-awareness are the biggest victims.

7) Screechweasels and harangutans will outlast everyone and declare the victory of getting the last word. It’s a hollow victory, because most of the other participants will have walked away in disgust.

8) Reconciliation of any kind is almost always impossible — because there is always at least one person who needs to recap the past in one last attempt to prove the other side wrong.

(7) CALL FOR PAPERS. “Reframing Science Fiction”, a one-day conference on the art of science fiction, will be held in Canterbury (UK) on March 21. Keynote speakers: Dr. Jeannette Baxter (Anglia Ruskin University) and Dr. Paul March-Russell (University of Kent).

From William Blake and John Martin to Glenn Brown and The Otolith Group, artists have been producing works of art that are science fiction. And artists and their works have been incorporated into many works of sf.

Meanwhile, on countless book covers and in magazine illustrations, a visual language of science fiction has evolved: bug-eyed monsters; spaceships; robots and so on.

Art in the comic strip and the graphic novel has been the means of telling stories in visual form – whilst artists such as Roy Lichtenstein have made comic panels into art.

The call for papers (which opened some time ago) has a January 15 deadline.

We invite 300 word proposals for twenty minute papers on the intersection of art and sf across the media – painting, sculpture, drawing, collage, photography, film, performance, prose, dance, architecture and so on…

(8) ONE ISLAND’S OPINION. Colleen Gillard’s article “Why the British Tell Better Children’s Stories” in The Atlantic is high-brow click-bait.

The small island of Great Britain is an undisputed powerhouse of children’s bestsellers: The Wind in the Willows, Alice in Wonderland, Winnie-the-Pooh, Peter Pan, The Hobbit, James and the Giant Peach, Harry Potter, and The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. Significantly, all are fantasies. Meanwhile, the United States, also a major player in the field of children’s classics, deals much less in magic. Stories like Little House in the Big Woods, The Call of the Wild, Charlotte’s Web, The Yearling, Little Women, and The Adventures of Tom Sawyer are more notable for their realistic portraits of day-to-day life in the towns and farmlands on the growing frontier. If British children gathered in the glow of the kitchen hearth to hear stories about magic swords and talking bears, American children sat at their mother’s knee listening to tales larded with moral messages about a world where life was hard, obedience emphasized, and Christian morality valued. Each style has its virtues, but the British approach undoubtedly yields the kinds of stories that appeal to the furthest reaches of children’s imagination.

And it works – people are coming unglued in the comments.

(9) FX. Doctor Science formulates a TV production axiom in “How special effects eat characterization”. The Doctor’s last paragraph says it best, but you should read it there. Here is the first paragraph:

I don’t think this trend is mostly an artistic or marketing choice, even though that’s what people in Hollywood usually say. I think “more explodey” is driven by the need to justify budgets, and by the individual interests of the people who have to do it.

(10) UNEMPLOYED KAIJU. They won’t be needing any special effects for Pacific Rim 2 — it’s dead, Jim.

According to The Hollywood Reporter, the follow-up to director Guillermo Del Toro’s monsters-versus-robots epic is “off the table indefinitely” – and in its place, del Toro has entered talks with 20th Century Fox to helm a rather different sci-fi spectacular.

Del Toro is reportedly gearing up to take the helm on ‘Fantastic Voyage,’ a remake of the 1966 sci-fi classic which starred Raquel Welch and Donald Pleasance as members of a team who are miniaturized in a submarine and injected into the body of a dying scientist in order to save his life.

(11) CLASS. The Doctor Who spinoff Class will air on BBC America in 2016. It was already on BBC Three’s schedule in the UK.

The eight-part series is from young-adult author Patrick Ness, who is known for writing the “A Monster Calls” books. The series is exec produced by “Doctor Who’s” Steven Moffat and Brian Minchin and is a co-production between BBC America and BBC Cymru Wales. It is filmed in Cardiff in the U.K.

“I’m astounded and thrilled to be entering the Doctor Who universe, which is as vast as time and space itself,” said Ness. “I can’t wait for people to meet the heroes of ‘Class,’ to meet the all-new villains and aliens, to remember that the horrors of the darkest corners of existence are just about on par with having to pass your exams,” he joked.

(12) BESTSELLER SNARK. Diana Gabaldon zinged George R.R. Martin – The Hollywood Reporter has the quote:

When asked by a reporter whether her work on the Starz drama [Outlander] — she penned a season two episode — would interfere with her meeting the deadline for the ninth installment in her saga — in light of Game of Thrones’ George R. R. Martin’s recent announcement that, of course, his next book will be delayed — Gabaldon didn’t miss a beat. “No. Unlike George, I write no matter where I am or what else I’m doing,” she said, adding: “He admits it himself that he likes to travel and he can’t write when he travels. That’s just the way he works. Everybody’s got their own writing mechanism. When I began writing, I had two full-time jobs and three small children.”

(13) TENTACLE TIME. Matthew Dockrey, designer of Sasquan’s Hugo base, made news with his new piece of public art in Vancouver (WA).

A newly installed tentacle sculpture is seen on Main Street in Vancouver Wednesday January 6, 2016. (Natalie Behring/The Columbian)

A newly installed tentacle sculpture is seen on Main Street in Vancouver Wednesday January 6, 2016. (Natalie Behring/The Columbian)

A giant steel tentacle bristling with saucer-sized suckers is slithering from the sewer in Uptown Village at Main and West 23rd streets.

Does it belong to an enormous octopus? A sea monster? Is it the tail of a dragon?

The imagination reels with possibilities.

The sculpture, created by Seattle metal artist Matthew Dockrey, is Vancouver’s newest piece of public art. Called “The Visitor,” the 5-foot-tall appendage cradling a genuine city manhole cover was installed Saturday. It will be dedicated at a celebration at noon Friday by the Uptown Village Association, Arts of Clark County, Vancouver’s Downtown Association and the city.

Karen Madsen, chairwoman of the nonprofit Arts of Clark County, said the artwork selection committee had sought a piece that was whimsical and interactive and that would endure over time. The sculpture, which Dockrey specifically created for the site in front of the old Mission Theatre, fits within the Steampunk art movement, she said.

(14) THE FRONT. Cedar Sanderson has pulled together the Mad Genius Club’s considerable wisdom about cover creation for self-published books into one post.

First and most important: before you start designing a cover, creating art intended for book covers, or even thinking about a book cover, you need to look at book covers. A lot of them. Specific book covers to your genre is even better, as there are subtle cues you need to know and recognize, even if you aren’t doing your own covers. So first, before anything else, go to Amazon and search for your sub-genre (space opera, paranormal romance, werewolf stories, historical military fiction, whatever it is) and look at the top 100 selling books. Not the freebies (unless you are looking at what not to do). Make notes of elements you like, things you hate, and the consistent notes that many of the covers have in common. When you’re done with this, you are ready to begin.

(15) HUGO PREP WORK. Shaun Duke has posted a crowdsourced list – “The 2016 Hugo Awards Reading/Watching List (or, My Next Few Months)”.

Last month, I asked for recommendations for my annual Hugo Awards reading bonanza.  A bunch of you responded with books, movies, TV shows, cookbooks, and so on.  The form will remain open for the next month or so, so if you haven’t submitted anything or want to submit some more stuff, go for it!

So, without further delay, here is the big massive monster list of stuff I’ll be reading or watching for the next few months…

(15) IN THE REAR VIEW MIRROR. Doris V. Sutherland resumes her analysis of the comparative quality of Puppy and non-Puppy Hugo nominees in the past two races in “2014 Hugos Versus 2015 Sad Puppies: Novelettes” at Women Write About Comics.

Breaking down the above ten works, we have two stories from the 2014 Sad Puppies slate, four from the 2015 Sad Puppies slate, one from the Rabid Puppies and three that were not Puppy picks. In terms of numbers, this is a strong showing from the Puppies. In terms of quality, well…

Before I go on, I should—in the interests of balance—remind my readers that I generally liked the Puppy choices for Best Short Story; some had their flaws, but I felt that the only out-and-out dud was the Rabid slate’s “Turncoat.” Looking at the Puppy novelettes, on the other hand, I find myself decidedly unimpressed.

(16) ROCK ENROLL. NASA’s new Planetary Defense Coordination Office will coordinate asteroid detection and hazard mitigation.

NASA has formalized its ongoing program for detecting and tracking near-Earth objects (NEOs) as the Planetary Defense Coordination Office (PDCO). The office remains within NASA’s Planetary Science Division, in the agency’s Science Mission Directorate in Washington. The office will be responsible for supervision of all NASA-funded projects to find and characterize asteroids and comets that pass near Earth’s orbit around the sun. It will also take a leading role in coordinating interagency and intergovernmental efforts in response to any potential impact threats….

NASA’s long-term planetary defense goals include developing technology and techniques for deflecting or redirecting objects that are determined to be on an impact course with Earth. NASA’s Asteroid Redirect Mission concept would demonstrate the effectiveness of the gravity tractor method of planetary defense, using the mass of another object to pull an asteroid slightly from its original orbital path. The joint NASA-European Space Agency Asteroid Impact and Deflection Assessment (AIDA) mission concept, if pursued, would demonstrate an impact deflection method of planetary defense.

Even if intervention is not possible, NASA would provide expert input to FEMA about impact timing, location and effects to inform emergency response operations. In turn, FEMA would handle the preparations and response planning related to the consequences of atmospheric entry or impact to U.S. communities.

(17) AFRICAN SF. There are six African authors on BSFA Awards Longlist.

Sarah Lotz has been nominated in the Best Novel category for Day Four, the follow-up on her bestseller The Three.

Chinelo Onwualu of Nigeria has been nominated in the Best Non-fiction category for her essay “Race, Speculative Fiction And Afro SF”, published by the New Left Project.

The Best Short Fiction category features four other African nominations:

Unfortunately Samatar’s story won’t be eligible for the award as she announced hers is a reprint of a 2012 story.

(18) ANIMAL FARM. The extended trailer for Disney live-action movie The Jungle Book looks pretty good.

(19) WUV. Matthew Johnson contributed these instant classic parody lyrics in a comment.

Star Base… LOVE.”

Love, at Warp Factor Two

Beam aboard, we’re expecting you

Love, it’s a captain’s reward

Make it so, it warps back to you

 

The Love Base

Soon we’ll be plotting a different course

The Love Base

You’ll learn a new way to use the Force

Love

Won’t stun anyone

It’s fruity drinks ‘neath the double suns

It’s the Love

It’s the Love

It’s the Love

It’s the Love Base

[Thanks to John King Tarpinian, Brian Z., Will R., Standback, and Alan Baumler for some of these stories. Title credit goes to File 770 contributing editor of the day Brian Z.]


Discover more from File 770

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

143 thoughts on “Pixel Scroll 1/9/16 To Flail Beyond the Sunset

  1. Second! Because I’m up late burning through the last episode of Jessica Jones! Which is great, by the way.

  2. (8) ONE ISLAND’S OPINION.

    That is a very silly article – somehow manages to be insulting to both America and the UK at the same time. The implication that it is odd that the UK produces a lot of English language fiction and the implication that the US range of children’s fiction is inferior.

  3. Tonight’s read — The Crystal Cave, by Mary Stewart.

    Welp. This was the first bracket-inspired fill-in-the-classics-I-missed read to turn out to be a serious disappointment. Paper-thin characterization plus the kind of “all this was fated anyway” plot that, for me, tends to make the story feel like chesspieces being moved around a board, and drops the emotional stakes to practically nothing. Maybe putting fantasy in a relatively realistic historical setting was innovative for the time? But it’s a little hard for me to credit that when I just read The Corn King And The Spring Queen, which predated it by about 40 years.

    Probably not going to bother with the sequels. Oh, well.

  4. Well, I’m done with The Expanse for a bit. I’ve bounced off Cibola Burn pretty hard. The deadly words came to mind; I didn’t care about the characters and found Holden especially to just be annoying. Your mileage may vary, and I’m still watching the TV show which manages to entertain rather than annoy.

    Read the first chunk of Unforgettable by Eric James Stone (it was one of the Big Ideas on Scalzi’s blog). It’s about a man with a strange power; a minute after he leaves, you forget all about him. The idea is interesting, but I found some of the follow-on effects to be unbelievable.
    Specifically, Stone writes that not only will humans forget about the hero, but details of him will vanish from any film, recording, computer or other mechanical recording device after a minute also. For me, that was a “bridge too far” for the suspension of disbelief.
    I can conceive of having someone you just don’t remember. And it would be an interesting story twist to have a video record of someone who was at a party, say, that no-one could remember having been there, and that no-one recognized.
    But that’s just me. I’m a strange individual.

    As for 13) Tentacle Time, looks like I’ll be stopping in Vancouver next time I nip down to Portland. It’s always good to see some interesting sculpture and street installations. Although, a nagging voice is saying “I’ve seen enough hentai…”

  5. (16) Great – a new US agency with “Defense” in the title. They’re planning on invading an asteroid, aren’t they?

  6. I’m still fishing around in 2015’s short fiction (with a break for Rose Lerner’s latest historical romance, every bit as satisfying as expected); no story this week has grabbed me like Kai Ashante Wilson’s “Kaiju maximus®: ‘So Various, So Beautiful, So New'”. Most people here must have reflected that many video game scenarios would be emotionally traumatic for a real person to live through. This story is the second I’ve read (after Linda Nagata’s “The Way Home”) that places a deeply human protagonist in a game scenario and makes something remarkable out of it. Wilson’s character is a father caring for his children as they follow, through hardships, his wife, a monster-fighting superhero out to save the world. Love is written into the nature of superpowers in this world. Hard love… The title quote from “Dover Beach” might alert you that this is an overridingly melancholy story. It’s also complex and ambiguous, and I would call it award-worthy. I’m changing my reading schedule now because I need to read Wilson’s Sorcerer of the Wildeeps

  7. Kyra, that’s too bad. I love Mary Stewart’s first three (and the first half of the fourth) Merlin books. I’ve re-read them a lot.

    I’m sorry you won’t get to enjoy them as I do. 🙁

  8. Second Fifth!

    But more seriously, I hear Other Nigel on the Expanse novels. I think the TV show, has two things going for it: they can draw on the characterization of all of the novels to inform the actors, and second, there is More Avasarala. (Apparently, they’re looking to get permission form SyFi to allow her to swear the proper way in season 2).

  9. Congrats to Fishy on the completed sculpture! I’ll have to check that out when I’m in the neighborhood.

    And I love the TFA Twitter feud. Parody Twitter accounts are not usually my thing but that was pretty great performance art.

  10. The tentacle sculpture reminds me of John Stanley’s “Monster of Dread End.” It’s not quite the same type of grasping horror, but close enough.

  11. (2) I’ve been following “The Laugh-Out-Loud Cats” of HOBOTOPIA since the beginning some years ago. It has a TON of science fiction, comic book, and video game humor in it, as well as general internet culture. I won one of the original artwork in a contest (when it started, it was drawn on paper — alas, no more). It’s pretty gentle humor, and is always at least mildly amusing. Read it.

    (5) “Made to Kill” is a pretty good book.

    (8) Other than being poorly researched, cherry-picked, and insulting to two great countries and their children, there’s nowt wrong with it.

    (12) I don’t think that’s really a jab, although the reporter certainly tried to frame it that way for clickbait. She only said she has a different writing process, which is true of everyone. And agreed that publisher deadlines have no relation to writer deadlines — she’s done with a book when she’s done with it too.

    (13) Probably the best public art EVAR!

    If Syfy won’t allow Avasarala to cuss properly, I say go ahead and put it in and let them bleep it out. Other countries can get the Full Chrisjen, and we’ll all know what she’s saying anyway.

  12. I think having Avasarala in this first season was an excellent move, and I do hope they can manage to have her salty tongue if possible in Season 2.

  13. (10) UNEMPLOYED KAIJU.
    I HAZ SADNESS.

    (15) IN THE REAR VIEW MIRROR.
    Yet another datum that the slated works weren’t up to snuff.

  14. And it would be an interesting story twist to have a video record of someone who was at a party, say, that no-one could remember having been there, and that no-one recognized.

    Plotbunny!

    We called the man Forrest Gump. It wasn’t his name, of course – we didn’t know his name or anything about him, even though in the photos we appeared to be holding friendly conversations. Videos were rare – there were cellphone videos of events with him, but somehow there’d only be a few seconds of him before the videographer decided something else was more interesting. He wasn’t particularly striking, but neither was he ordinary – he didn’t have the blandness that you usually think of when someone is described as “forgettable”.

    … and I’m out.

  15. Paul Weimer :

    I think having Avasarala in this first season was an excellent move, and I do hope they can manage to have her salty tongue if possible in Season 2.

    I also love the way they threw a quiet little character scene in that everyone who HASN’T read the books will see as a character definition piece involving a metaphor, and everyone who HAS read the books will see as a big neon sign saying “Yeah, we ARE going to go there if we get to Season 3 or 4, suckers. Better be filming your friends when we roll THAT puppy out…”

  16. Heh, I love that they called it the Stabbie awards. Some really great books showed up in their nominating process and it’s cool how some authors dropped in to interact with those who nominated them.

  17. Re Unforgettable: I recall a classic short story (maybe Bradbury?) about mutants whose mutation makes them superior but also renders them forgettable as a defense mechanism. The narrator is talking to a man who is the former world boxing champion, but everyone has a hard time remembering that he existed despite the records and his great performances. As they talk, the boxer is watching another mutant in the World Series game on television. That one has been the best pitcher in the world for several years, but fans don’t even remember him as the best on his own team. The boxer sees the pitcher following the same path as he did; at the end, the pitcher deliberately handicaps himself by throwing a homerun ball.

  18. @lurkertype Jealous of your original LOL Cats artwork. We have one he did from the hobo names series but it’s just a postcard.

  19. @Rev Bob,

    I thought he was Cane from Does a Bee Care?

    (18) On my phone the first line is just

    ANIMAL FARM. The extended trailer for Disney

    and I got wondering who green-lit a f’ed up sequel to Charlotte’s Web.

  20. Did Zelig get inserted into actual footage? I can’t tell from wikipedia. I have heard people use “Gumped” to mean “digitally inserted where they don’t belong”, though, and it’s something people know about even if they successfully avoided the film.

  21. @Jamoche:

    Yes, Allen and Gordon Willis used bluescreen to insert the character in archival footage. This was about a decade before Gump.

  22. @Shao Ping: It’s the only sensible thing to do with Del Toro. I like pretty much everything he does, but the time to have much reaction beyond “I imagine I’ll like it, if it happens” is when there’s a hard schedule for release.

  23. The eight-part series is from young-adult author Patrick Ness, who is known for writing the “A Monster Calls” books.

    Best known, surely, for the Chaos Walking books? A Monster Calls is just one book he wrote, based on an idea by Siobhan Dowd, who died horribly early at the age of 47. The film is due out this year, so it may well end up being his most famous book, but it ain’t a series.

  24. (1) USE THE FARCE

    The full exchange is brilliant. There’s a haiku which is too spoilerific to quote, but endangered my keyboard.

    I wonder when the unofficial internet spoiler embargo will end?

  25. Mark on January 10, 2016 at 2:36 am said:

    I wonder when the unofficial internet spoiler embargo will end?

    It’s too soon, man. It’s not even a month yet.

  26. So I finally got around to reading The Watchmaker of Filigree Street and now I know why everyone wants a mechanical octopus as a pet. I also now want a mechanical octopus.

    As well as that, it’s a very decent first novel. I thought the plotting was perhaps a little rushed towards the end but the characters and the fantastical elements were very appealing.

  27. @Vasha: Thanks for those comments on Wilson’s Kaiju maximus® . I’d read the story and didn’t know what to make of it at all. I liked the personal and family dynamic, but the story itself felt opaque. If I understand you correctly, it’s a well-known video game scenario? That’d definitely explain what I was missing.

  28. @Peace

    Yeah, I think a month is the minimum. I just checked and my local cinema is still running it on two screens, so it must still be getting people in.

  29. Re Pacific Rim, let’s be honest, when the screen wasn’t full of massive mechs punching monsters in the face, the film was utter bobbins.
    100 million dollars and thousands of hours spent on effects
    50p and 5 minutes spent on the script.
    But… a remake of Fantastic Voyage..that’s completely unnecessary.

  30. ULTRAGOTHA, I’ll admit that a large part of my reaction to the book is due to a personal preference on my part — it tends to be really hard for me to get into an explicit “everything is fated / I am but a tool of destiny” plot. I find it difficult to care about a character that lacks so much personal agency, and even though I know that Merlin isn’t going to die in the first book of a trilogy about Merlin, if the character also knows it, to me it kind of lets the air out of all the scenes where he’s being threatened … it changes it, for me, from “ooo, how is Merlin going to get himself out of this one” into “well, obviously Merlin is just going to get out of this one.” This kind of thing also made it impossible for me to get into Susan Cooper’s much-loved “The Dark Is Rising” books. There are ways to approach a predestined plot that I can appreciate (if the predestination is questionable, if the character fights against it, if it isn’t a guarantee that things will play out in a particular way, etc.), but a straight-up “fate commands you to go HERE now” plot is a big stumbling block for me.

    To be fair, there were other things in “The Crystal Cave” that I didn’t like, but I think that was the one that really was the kicker for me.

    Can I ask what it was that you did like about it? I’d honestly like to know!

  31. @Kyra:

    Ergh. I do not like “The Dark is Rising” sequence. Too much, as you say, predestination.

    And too many memory wipes to suit me. I prefer it when characters remember what has happened and understand why things have changed. Otherwise it’s just rohypnol frolics.

  32. Stories like . . . Charlotte’s Web . . . are more notable for their realistic portraits of day-to-day life in the towns and farmlands on the growing frontier.

    There were lots of intelligent animals on the frontier?

  33. @Hal Winslow’s Old Buddy, The story you are thinking of is Nobody Bothers Gus by Algis Budrys.

  34. I finally saw Episode VII only last night, so yeah, I’d say it’s still well in the spoiler zone. And I’d think it would be common courtesy to not to drop spoilers unROT13’d or outside spoiler warnings well past the date of the video release, really.

    Honestly, there isn’t going to be an arbitrary line to cross where it will be definitively okay to talk about the thing and the other thing generally without warning, and it certainly isn’t going to be this soon. Us middle-aged fans can’t just drop everything and queue on opening night to see things, even if it were physically possible for everyone to see it at once. If you need to talk about the movie, do it in a spoiler thread. Is that such a hardship?

  35. (1) USE THE FARCE

    Okay, very funny.

    I do take exception to Luke’s initial comment, though. Capes are *great* for cold weather.

  36. (3) ACTION FIGURES.

    At lest one person responded to that tweet by asking “Where’s Rey?”

  37. @NelC

    No hardship at all, that’s why I didn’t spoiler. I think that reasonable people will keep up the good work on un-spoilering for a long time to come. What’s quite remarkable is that the bits of the internet that are usually total %s about spoilers are still being fairly restrained, and I wonder how long it will last.

    Incidentally this article contains a) Calvin & Hobbes meets Star Wars and b) spoilers.

Comments are closed.