Crime Writers of Canada Awards of Excellence 2024 Winners

The Crime Writers of Canada have announced the 2024 winners of their annual Awards of Excellence.

THE PETER ROBINSON AWARD FOR BEST CRIME NOVEL

sponsored by Rakuten Kobo, with a $1000 prize

  • Loreth Anne White, The Maid’s Diary, Montlake

BEST CRIME FIRST NOVEL

sponsored by Melodie Campbell, with a $1000 prize

  • Amanda Peters, The Berry Pickers, Harper Perennial

THE HOWARD ENGEL AWARD FOR BEST CRIME NOVEL SET IN CANADA

sponsored by Charlotte Engel and Crime Writers of Canada, with a $500 prize

  • Joan Thomas, Wild Hope, Harper Perennial/HarperCollins

THE WHODUNIT AWARD FOR BEST TRADITIONAL MYSTERY

sponsored by Jane Doe, with a $500 prize

  • Nita Prose, The Mystery Guest, Viking

BEST CRIME SHORT STORY

  • Marcelle Dubé, Reversion, Mystery Magazine

THE BEST FRENCH LANGUAGE CRIME BOOK (FICTION AND NONFICTION)

  • André Marois, La sainte paix, Héliotrope

BEST JUVENILE/YA CRIME BOOK

sponsored by Shaftesbury Films with a $500 prize (Fiction and Nonfiction)

  • Cherie Dimaline, Funeral Songs for Dying Girls, Tundra Books

THE BRASS KNUCKLES AWARD FOR BEST NONFICTION CRIME BOOK

sponsored by David Reid Simpson Law Firm (Hamilton), with a $300 prize

  • Michael Lista, The Human Scale, Véhicule Press

BEST UNPUBLISHED CRIME NOVEL MANUSCRIPT WRITTEN BY AN UNPUBLISHED AUTHOR

  • Craig H. Bowlsby, Requiem for a Lotus

2024 GRAND MASTER AWARD

  • Maureen Jennings

Established in 2014, the Grand Master (GM) Award recognizes a Canadian crime writer with a substantial body of work that has garnered national and international recognition.

Maureen Jennings, a long-time Crime Writers of Canada member, is a prolific author of non-fiction, short stories and book series featuring Christine Morris, Detective Murdoch, and D.I. Tom Tyler. The Detective William Murdoch television series, set in Victorian era Toronto, was optioned in 2003 by Shaftesbury Films. Murdoch Mysteries are shown in over 120 countries and feature innovative crime-solving techniques, social justice subplots and surprise guest appearances.

April Showers Crime Fiction Awards Roundup

THE CRIME WRITERS OF CANADA AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE

The Crime Writers of Canada have announced the 2024 shortlist for their annual Awards of Excellence.

Winners will be announced on the Crime Writers of Canada website on May 29.

The Peter Robinson Award for Best Crime Novel

sponsored by Rakuten Kobo, with a $1000 prize

  • Robyn Harding, The Drowning Woman, Grand Central Publishing
  • Shari Lapena, Everyone Here is Lying, Doubleday Canada
  • Scott Thornley, Middlemen, House of Anansi Press
  • Sam Wiebe, Sunset and Jericho, Harbour Publishing
  • Loreth Anne White, The Maid’s Diary, Montlake

Best Crime First Novel

sponsored by Melodie Campbell, with a $1000 prize

  • Jann Arden, The Bittlemores, Random House Canada
  • Lisa Brideau, Adrift, Sourcebooks
  • Charlotte Morganti, The End Game, Halfdan Press
  • Amanda Peters, The Berry Pickers, Harper Perennial
  • Steve Urszenyi, Perfect Shot, Minotaur

The Howard Engel Award for Best Crime Novel Set in Canada

sponsored by Charlotte Engel and Crime Writers of Canada, with a $500 prize

  • Gail Anderson-Dargatz, The Almost Widow, Harper Avenue/HarperCollins
  • Renee Lehnen, Elmington, Storeyline Press
  • Cyndi MacMillan, Cruel Light, Crooked Lane
  • Joan Thomas, Wild Hope, Harper Perennial/HarperCollins
  • Melissa Yi, Shapes of Wrath, Windtree Press

The Whodunit Award for Best Traditional Mystery

sponsored by Jane Doe, with a $500 prize

  • Gail Bowen, The Legacy, ECW Press
  • Vicki Delany, Steeped in Malice, Kensington Books
  • Vicki Delany, The Game is a FootnoteCrooked Lane Books
  • Nita Prose, The Mystery Guest, Viking
  • Iona Whishaw, To Track a TraitorTouchWood Editions

Best Crime Short Story

  • M.H. Callway, Wisteria Cottage, Wildside Press (for Malice Domestic)
  • Marcelle Dubé, Reversion, Mystery Magazine
  • Mary Keenan The Canadians (Killin’ Time in San Diego), Down & Out Books
  • donalee Moulton, Troubled Water, Black Cat Weekly (Wildside Press)
  • Zandra Renwick, American Night, Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine

The Best French Language Crime Book (Fiction and Nonfiction)

  • Jean-Philippe Bernié, La punition, Glénat Québec
  • Chrystine Brouillet, Le mois des morts, Éditions Druide
  • Catherine Lafrance, Le dernier souffle est le plus lourd, Éditions Druide
  • André Marois, La sainte paix, Héliotrope
  • Jean-Jacques Pelletier, Rien, Alire

Best Juvenile/YA Crime Book

sponsored by Shaftesbury Films with a $500 prize (Fiction and Nonfiction)

  • Kelley Armstrong, Someone is Always Watching, Tundra Books
  • Cherie Dimaline, Funeral Songs for Dying Girls, Tundra Books
  • Rachelle Delaney, The Big Sting, Tundra Books
  • Clara Kumagai, Catfish Rolling, Penguin Teen Canada
  • Kevin Sands, Champions of the Fox, Puffin Canada

The Brass Knuckles Award for Best Nonfiction Crime Book

sponsored by David Reid Simpson Law Firm (Hamilton), with a $300 prize

  • Josef Lewkowicz and Michael Calvin, The Survivor: How I Survived Six Concentration Camps and Became a Nazi Hunter, HarperCollins Publishers Ltd.
  • Michael Lista, The Human Scale, Véhicule Press
  • David Rabinovitch, Jukebox Empire, Rowman & Littlefield
  • Bill Waiser and Jennie Hansen, Cheated, ECW Press
  • Carolyn Whitzman, Clara at the Door with a Revolver, UBC Press, On Point Press

Best Unpublished Crime Novel manuscript written by an unpublished author

  • Tom Blackwell, The Patient
  • Craig H. Bowlsby, Requiem for a Lotus
  • Sheilla Jones and James Burns, Murder on Richmond Road: An Enquiry Bureau Mystery
  • Nora Sellers, The Forest Beyond
  • William Wodhams, Thirty Feet Under

2024 Grand Master Award

  • Maureen Jennings

Established in 2014, the Grand Master (GM) Award recognizes a Canadian crime writer with a substantial body of work that has garnered national and international recognition.

Maureen Jennings, a long-time Crime Writers of Canada member, is a prolific author of non-fiction, short stories and book series featuring Christine Morris, Detective Murdoch, and D.I. Tom Tyler. The Detective William Murdoch television series, set in Victorian era Toronto, was optioned in 2003 by Shaftesbury Films. Murdoch Mysteries are shown in over 120 countries and feature innovative crime-solving techniques, social justice subplots and surprise guest appearances.

SPOTTED OWL

Friends of Mystery logo

The winner of the 2024 Spotted Owl Award was announced on March 28 by the Friends of Mystery. The award is for a mystery published during the previous calendar year by an author whose primary residence is Alaska, Washington, Oregon, Idaho or the Province of British Columbia. The winner is:

  • Breakneck by Marc Cameron

The runners-up were:

2. Dana Stabenow for Not the Ones Dead
3. Dana Haynes for The Saint of Thieves
4. Sam Wiebe for Sunset and Jericho
5. Jon Talton for The Nurse Murders
6. James Bryne for Deadlock
7. Haris Orkin for License to Die
8. Frank Zafiro for Hope Dies Last
9 (tie). Orlando Davidson for Baseline Road and J.A. Jance for Collateral Damage

PINCKLEY PRIZES

The winners of the 2022 and 2023 Pinckley Prizes for Crime Fiction, awarded by the Women’s National Book Association of New Orleans, honor three women writers. The winners receive a financial award of $2,500. This year the prize winners Douaihy and Rothchild participated at the 2024 Tennessee Williams Literary Festival.

2022 Pinckley Prize for Debut Fiction

  • Sascha Rothchild for Blood Sugar

2023 Pinckley Prize for Debut Fiction

  •   Margot Douaihy for Scorched Grace

2023 Pinckley Prize for Distinguished Body of Work

  •   Alafair Burke

2020 Arthur Ellis Awards

The winners of the 2020 Arthur Ellis Awards for Excellence in Canadian Crime Writing were named May 21. Presented by Crime Writers of Canada, the awards recognize the best in mystery, crime, and suspense fiction and crime nonfiction by Canadian authors.

The awards are judged by 21 volunteers from among the large body of award-winning writers, reviewers, booksellers, librarians, academics and avid crime fiction fans across Canada. 

Best Novel sponsored by Rakuten Kobo with a $1000 prize

  • Michael Christie, Greenwood, McClelland & Stewart

The Best First Novel with a $500 prize

  • Philip Elliott, Nobody Move, Into the Void Press

Best Novella sponsored by Mystery Weekly with a $200 prize

  • Wayne Arthurson, The Red Chesterfield, University of Calgary Press

Best Short Story sponsored by Mystery Weekly with a $300 prize

  • Peter Sellers, Closing DoorsEllery Queen’s Mystery Magazine

Best French Book

  • Andrée A. Michaud, Tempêtes, Éditions Québec Amériques

Best Juvenile or YA Book sponsored by Shaftesbury with a $500 prize

  • Tom Ryan, Keep This to Yourself, Albert Whitman & Company

Best Nonfiction Book

  • Charlotte Gray, Murdered Midas: A Millionaire, His Gold Mine, and a Strange Death on an Island Paradise, HarperCollins Publishers Ltd

The Unhanged Arthur Award for Best Unpublished Manuscript sponsored by Dundurn Press with a $500 prize

  • Liz Rachel Walker, The Dieppe Letters

The Arthur Ellis Awards are not named after a writer, but after the official pseudonym of Canada’s hangman and the trophy is a jumping jack type wood figure on a gallows, which must certainly be one of the more disturbing award trophies out there.

2019 Arthur Ellis Awards Shortlists

The 2019 Arthur Ellis Awards Shortlists for Excellence in Canadian Crime Writing were released on April 18. Presented by Crime Writers of Canada, the awards recognize the best in mystery, crime, and suspense fiction and crime nonfiction by Canadian authors. Winners will be announced at a ceremony in Toronto on May 23.  

The Arthur Ellis Awards are not named after a writer, but after the official pseudonym of Canada’s hangman and the trophy is a jumping jack type wood figure on a gallows, which must certainly be one of the more disturbing award trophies out there.

BEST CRIME NOVEL

  • Cape Diamond by Ron Corbett, ECW Press, 
  • Though the Heavens Fall by Anne Emery ECW Press
  • The Winters by Lisa Gabriele, Doubleday Canada
  • Kingdom of the Blind by Louise Penny, Minotaur Books
  • The Girl in the Moss by Loreth Anne White, Montlake Romance 

BEST FIRST CRIME NOVEL (Sponsored by Rakuten Kobo)

  • Cobra Clutch by A.J. Devlin NeWest Press
  • Operation Wormwood by Helen C. Escott, Flanker Press, 
  • Full Disclosure by Beverley McLachlin, Simon & Schuster Canada  
  • Why Was Rachel Murdered? By Bill Prentice, Echo Road, 
  • Find You in the Dark by Nathan Ripley, Simon & Schuster Canada 

BEST CRIME NOVELLA – The Lou Allin Memorial Award, 

  • The B-Team: The Case of the Angry First Wife, by Melodie Campbell Orca Book Publishers
  • Blue Water Hues by Vicki Delany Orca Book Publishers
  • Murder Among the Pines by John Lawrence Reynolds Orca Book Publishers

BEST CRIME SHORT STORY (Sponsored by Mystery Weekly Magazine) 

  • A Ship Called Pandora by Melodie Campbell, Mystery Weekly Magazine
  • The Power Man, Baby It’s Cold Outside by Therese Greenwood Coffin Hop Press 
  • Game by Twist Phelan Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine
  • Terminal City by Linda L. Richards, Vancouver Noir, Akashic Books, 
  • Wonderful Life by Sam Wiebe, Vancouver Noir, Akashic Books 

BEST CRIME BOOK IN FRENCH

  • Un dernier baiser avant de te tuer, by Jean-Philippe Bernié, Libre Expression 
  • Adolphus – Une enquête de Joseph Laflamme, by Hervé Gagnon Libre Expression 
  • Ces femmes aux yeux cernés by André Jacques, Éditions Druide
  • Deux coups de pied de trop, by Guillaume Morissette , Guy Saint-Jean Éditeur  
  • Rinzen la beauté intérieure, by Johanne Seymour, Expression noir 

BEST JUVENILE/YOUNG ADULT CRIME BOOK

  • Escape by Linwood Barclay, Puffin Canada
  • The House of One Thousand Eyes by Michelle Barker, Annick Press 
  • Call of the Wraith by Kevin Sands, Aladdin 
  • The Ruinous Sweep by Tim Wynne-Jones, Candlewick Press
  • The Rumrunner’s Boy by E.R. Yatscoff, TG & R Books 

BEST NONFICTION CRIME BOOK

  • Dying for a Drink: How a Prohibition Preacher Got Away With Murder by Patrick Brode, Biblioasis 
  • The King of Con: How a Smooth-Talking Jersey Boy Made and Lost Billions, Baffled the FBI, Eluded the Mob, and Lived to Tell the Crooked Tale by Thomas Giacomaro and Natasha Stoynoff, BenBella Books, Inc, 
  • The Boy on the Bicycle: A Forgotten Case of Wrongful Conviction in Toronto by Nate Hendley, Five Rivers Publishing
  • Murder by Milkshake: An Astonishing True Story of Adultery, Arsenic, and a Charismatic Killer by Eve Lazarus, Arsenal Pulp Press, 
  • The Real Lolita: The Kidnapping of Sally Horner and the Novel that Scandalized the World by Sarah Weinman, Alfred A. Knopf Canada 

BEST UNPUBLISHED MANUSCRIPT – aka The Unhanged Arthur (Sponsored by Dundurn Press) 

  • Hypnotizing Lions by Jim Bottomley, 
  • Omand’s Creek by Don Macdonald
  • The Scarlet Cross by Liv McFarlane 
  • One for the Raven Darrow Woods, The Book of Answers by Heather McLeod,

Derrick Murdoch Award

The 2019 Derrick Murdoch Award recipient is Vicki Delany. The Derrick Murdoch Award is a special achievement award for contributions to the crime genre. 

[Thanks to Cora Buhlert for the story.]