The pushback against yesterday’s Mystery Writers of America announcement of Linda Fairstein as a 2019 Grand Master has led to cancellation of the award.
Linda Fairstein’s selection was protested by one of last year’s Edgar-winning writers, Attica Locke, who reminded MWA members that while Fairstein was working for the Manhattan District Attorney, her office supervised the prosecution in 1990 of the Central Park Jogger case, which ended in the conviction of five teenagers who were later exonerated of any part in the crime.
Prior to MWA’s action, Fairstein and Locke jousted on Twitter –
https://twitter.com/LindaFairstein/status/1067556116735897607
https://twitter.com/LindaFairstein/status/1067560623272271878
https://twitter.com/LindaFairstein/status/1067560789597392897
You ran the sex crimes unit. You asked for the case. You directed Elizabeth Lederer's work and crafted the prosecution strategy as well as the media strategy coming out of the prosecutor office. Books have been written, documentaries made. Your former office said you and YOUR 1/
— attica locke (@atticalocke) November 27, 2018
What I'm not going to do is let you pretend you played no part in the arrests and subsequent incarceration of five innocent (now) men. The civilized conversation you need to have is with yourself. 3/3
— attica locke (@atticalocke) November 27, 2018
Actually, I think the “good night” here is the sun setting on all the years you’ve gotten away with not being held to account for your actions in the court of public opinion. So to that… good night indeed.
— attica locke (@atticalocke) November 27, 2018
Today MWA withdrew the honor — “Mystery Writers of America Withdraws Fairstein Award”:
On Tuesday, November 27, Mystery Writers of America announced the recipients of Grand Master, Raven & Ellery Queen Awards, special awards given out annually. Shortly afterwards, the MWA membership began to express concern over the inclusion of Linda Fairstein as a Grand Master, citing controversy in which she has been involved.
When the MWA Board made its selection, it was unaware of Ms. Fairstein’s role in the controversy.
After profound reflection, the Board has decided that MWA cannot move forward with an award that lacks the support of such a large percentage of our members. Therefore, the Board of Directors has decided to withdraw the Linda Fairstein Grand Master award. We realize that this action will be unsatisfactory to many. We apologize for any pain and disappointment this situation has caused.
MWA will be reevaluating and significantly revising its procedures for selecting honorary awards in the future. We hope our members will all work with us to move forward from this extremely troubling event and continue to build a strong and inclusive organization.
The Los Angeles Times published a piece about the controversy on November 27 by Steph Cha, a novelist, editor and attorney, and a member of Mystery Writers of America since 2013 — “Writer Linda Fairstein’s past as a prosecutor overseeing the Central Park Five case causes award controversy”.
…The Five served six to 13 years in prison before their convictions were vacated following the confession of a serial rapist, confirmed by DNA evidence, in 2002. Fairstein has never apologized or changed her position on their guilt. (Nor has Donald Trump, who in 1989 took out full-page newspaper ads in New York City calling for the return of the death penalty after the teens were arrested.) Only four months ago, in a letter to the editor of the New York Law Journal, Fairstein maintained that “the questioning [of the Central Park Five] was respectful, dignified, carried out according to the letter of the law and with sensitivity to the young age of the men.”
… Her presence among us should be the scandal of every conference — it probably would’ve been earlier if there had been more crime writers of color when the Five were exonerated in 2002. But at some point, her background must have become old news, an uncomfortable thing the larger crime world has been happy to ignore. How many of us have been polite to her on accident because the rest of us were polite to her on purpose?
Tacit approval is one thing, of course; the Grand Master Award is another. Mystery Writers of America has made a lot of fuss about diversity over the last few years, and I do believe that the mystery community has made some meaningful strides toward inclusion. But we’re apparently still at a place where the board of Mystery Writers of America thinks calling the white prosecutor who oversaw the conviction of innocent black boys “Grand Master” is a good idea. It’s also worth noting that the Edgar Awards banquet will take place in April, almost exactly 30 years after the Five were wrongfully arrested and imprisoned….
Attica Locke’s comment on MWA’s action was:
Thank you ?@EdgarAwards? for listening. — Mystery Writers of America Withdraws Fairstein Award | Mystery Writers of America https://t.co/sL3PgTTXL9
— attica locke (@atticalocke) November 29, 2018
Fairstein has not tweeted a response to the withdrawal.
[Thanks to Mark Hepworth and Andrew Porter for the story.]