Seattle Worldcon’s Consultative Vote Draws Apathetic Response

Seattle Worldcon 2025’s consultative vote drew just a quarter the number of participants who turned out for Glasgow 2024’s inaugural consultative vote last year. Glasgow tallied 1260 ballots, Seattle only 343.

Seattle ran votes on two of the Constitutional amendments that received first passage at the Glasgow 2024 Business Meeting and are up for ratification – (1) the revisions to the Hugo Award categories for Best Professional Artist and Best Fan Artist, and (2) proposal to abolish the Retro Hugo Awards.

VOTING RESULTS. The results of Seattle’s poll are:

In the vote to amend the constitution so as to eliminate the Retro Hugo Awards:

Yes: 164
No: 167
Total: 331

In the vote to amend the Hugo Award categories for Best Fan and Professional Artist:

Yes: 124
No: 160
Total: 284

These consultative votes are not provided for in the WSFS Constitution, are not binding, and have no effect other than that the information will be known to those at the Business Meeting. The Seattle committee said, “The purpose of the consultative vote was to test whether this type of vote is feasible, in case the practice is someday adopted as a formal part of the WSFS decision-making process.”

Glasgow 2024 Consultative Vote Results

Glasgow 2024 has announced the outcome of “consultative online vote” it conducted that allowed the convention’s WSFS Members to offer a yes/no opinion on an amendment to the WSFS Constitution which received first passage at the Chengdu Worldcon Business Meeting. The proposal would create two new Hugo Award categories, the Best Independent Short Film Award and the Best Independent Feature Film Award. This change is up for official ratification at the Glasgow 2024 Business Meeting.

The “consultative vote” is not provided for in the Constitution, is not binding, and has no effect other than that the information will be known to those at the Business Meeting who will actually be voting whether to ratify the rules change. 

RESULT OF THE VOTE. The consultative vote was open for fifteen days ending August 5, enabling all WSFS members to express their view on this proposal: 

For the Consultative Vote by WSFS Members of Glasgow 2024: A Worldcon For Our Futures on the Proposal to add two additional Hugo Award categories for film: Best Independent Film, Short and Feature Length*

YES: 533 (42.3%)

NO: 727 (57.7%)

Total Ballots Cast: 1,260          

 (*) The full text of the proposal is available in the Agenda, item E.7, which can be accessed on the Business Meeting page

[Based on Worldcon social media.]