Barkley — So Glad You (Didn’t) Ask #98, A Column of Unsolicited Opinions

“I Don’t Believe This Debt is Owed By Me…”; Why I Decided To Sue Dave McCarty, Part Deux

By Chris M. Barkley:

“Am I bugging you? Didn’t mean to bug ya. OK Edge, play the Blues!”

U2 lead singer Bono, finishing a political soliloquy against South Africa’s then apartheid policies during a performance of the song “Silver and Gold” during U2’s Rattle and Hum tour dates in Denver, Colorado, November 1987.

What has gone before:

  • On October 21st, 2023, I won a Hugo Award for Best Fan Writer in Chengdu, China.
  • My award, along with a host of others were shipped from Chengdu to Dave McCarty, the 2023 Hugo Awards Administrator, who resides in Chicago, Illinois.
  • The release of the 2023 Hugo Award Final Ballot results and Nomination Statistics raised concerns and controversy.
  • In late January, the Hugo Awards arrived at Dave McCarty’s home, but many were damaged. McCartty states that there is money from the Chengdu con runners to have the awards repaired and will be dispersed in a timely manner.
  • On February 14, 2024, “The Report on Censorship and Exclusion” by myself and Jason Sanford was published, highlighting irregularities in the nomination and voting processes overseen by Dave McCarty.
  • Since then, some awards have been sent out to recipients but there has been no definitive accounting of who has received them. The current status of my Hugo Award is unknown.

There is no room for feelings in a court of law. 

Forget what you’ve seen on Perry Mason, LA Law, The Practice or Suits. When it comes to the law you’re better off keeping your feelings under lock and key.

Because in a court of law, either civil or criminal, the only things that matter are evidence and facts. Not conjecture, hearsay, opinions or, especially, feelings. 

Contrary to a good majority of people who support the current administration, we are a nation whose foundation and purpose is bound by laws and legislation, not people. Or feelings.

I have had my fair share of time inside courtrooms, fighting parking tickets, creditors and bad landlords. And I have had my fair share of victories and defeats.

In the previous Cook County Small Claims court hearing on March 27, David Lawrence McCarty claimed he did not feel he owed anything on the claim against him. On April 22, I received an untitled email from Mr. McCarty with a PDF attached of a Cook County court document signed by him stating that officially notifying me that he was going to participate in the upcoming legal proceedings.

On the morning of the hearing, I felt somewhat apprehensive about appearing on the scheduled Zoom call, even though I knew what the likely outcome was going to be.

As I set up my laptop for the hearing forty five minutes before the hearing, I tried to connect to the court website but my phone indicated that there was no internet service. My partner, Juli, who works from home, said that she received a text message from our internet provider that confirmed the area wide outage.

I was feeling a bit anxious about this development because while I could have easily attended over the phone, I felt that doing so felt a bit too impersonal for my taste.

As my anxiety was about to spike, Juli suggested an alternative; rather than waiting to see if the service was going to be restored, I should go over and connect at her vacationing daughter and son in law’s home ten minutes away. I checked my watch and agreed.

I easily zipped through the suburban forests and arrived with twenty minutes to spare. As I entered I faced my next obstacle, an enthusiastic, overly friendly and energetic eight month old chocolate Labrador named  Chef.

Chef, being the boundless ball of dogwood he is, made a pest of himself as I set up the laptop. With ten minutes to go, I decided to put Chef outside into the backyard so he could find some wildlife to chase. Except Chef had other plans.

I had placed the laptop on the dining room table facing the living room, with the expansive springlike vista of their backyard as a backdrop.

Chef, wanting my attention and affection, jumped up onto the window ledge, looking over my shoulder as I frantically tried to connect to the Cook County website. When I finally did, I saw Chef, his tongue dripping sideways out of his mouth, loudly pawing at the window in the background. 

I sighed and reversed my position to the other side of the table, lest the judge mistake Chef as my legal counsel.

I logged in and was acknowledged by the recording clerk with five minutes  to spare. After receiving my case “line number”, I muted my microphone and waited to be called. At 10:35 a.m., Cook County Judge Maria Barlow called the court to order and began hearing cases. I witnessed a number of cases involving rent disputes, property damage, skip trace reports on delinquent defendants and other personal disputes.

And as time passed, my nervousness dissipated. Judge Barlow called cases and worked her way through the call list as efficiently as possible, allowing attorneys, plaintiffs and defendants to have their say but swiftly cutting off any attempts to obfuscate or deflect from the matter at hand.

I also saw ordinary people, also afraid, frustrated and nervous as I am, striving to make themselves understood.

Finally, forty minutes into the session, Judge Barlow called our line number. She addressed the both of us:

Me: Here, Your Honor. 

Judge Barlow: All right, good morning.

Dave McCarty: Good morning. David McCarty here, Your Honor. 

JB: All right, good morning. Mr. McCarty, it looks like you filed your appearance and Mr. Barkley, you filed the case. Did you all want to go to mediation or you want to set this for trial?

Me: I am willing to go to mediation.

JB: Okay, what about you, Mr. McCarty?

DM: I don’t believe that this debt is owed by me, so I don’t see what mediation would do.

Me: Your Honor, this has been a long-going issue between myself and the defendant, and this could be settled in five minutes if the defendant were to take my settlement offer.

JB: Well, he just said he doesn’t believe he owes the debt, so what do you want me to do, Mr. Barkley? Other than set a trial and listen to the testimony and make a determination.

Me: Well, I’m perfectly willing to go to trial then.

JB: All right. Are you all available Thursday, June 26th at 9:30? It needs to come in person.

DM: That date works for me. Chris is remote, though, so I’ll go with what works for him.

Me: Did you say June 22nd?

JB: The 26th, 26th.

Me: June 26th?

JB: The first day. Yep.

Me:9:30? 

JB: Yep. In person, though, room 1102. Does that work?

DM: That works for me, Your Honor.

JB: All right. Mr. Barkley, Mr. McCarty, you all need to come with all of your witnesses in person, room 1102. With you, you’re going to bring three copies of any documents you want the court to see. Any questions, Mr. Barkley?

Me: I have no questions at this time, Your Honor.

JB: Any questions, Mr. McCarty?

DM: No questions, Your Honor.

JB: All right, I’ll see you both June 26th, 9:30 in the morning, in person.

Me: Thank you, Your Honor.

JB: All right, you all have a nice one.

DM: And you as well. Thank you.

And in a little over two minutes, it was over.

I was somewhat relieved that I had made myself clear in my presentation (although I, like a good many people I know, HATE hearing their voice over headphones).

And so, after some extensive contemplation (and eight White Castle sliders and a large Coke Zero later), I decided to contact Mr. McCarty directly via email to clearly and directly make my intentions known.

At 5:23 p.m., Eastern Daylight Time, I sent the following:

24 April 2025


Circuit Court of Cook County – Case #202511033122

To: David L McCarty

From: Chris M. Barkley

To David L. McCarty, 

In court proceedings earlier today, you stated that you do not owe anything to myself, the Plaintiff in the case I filed against you on 5 February 2025.

In my filing, I contended that you are currently in possession of the 2023 Hugo Award for Best Fan Writer, which I was the recipient of on 21 October 2023, in Chengdu, Sichuan Province, the People’s Republic of China.

The 2023 Hugo Awards that were shipped to your home address arrived in Chicago, Illinois in late January 2024 and I have not received it yet. My filing puts the value of the Award at $3000.00.

In two court hearings, on 27 March 2025 and today, 24 April, you have refused arbitration and my verbal offers to settle this suit. Having failed to disperse my and other 2023 Hugo Award recipients has placed you in this somewhat precarious legal situation.

Cook County Judge Maria Barlow has set an in person trial for 26 June 2025, in Cook County Courtroom 1102 at 9:30 am, Central Standard time.

In the hopes of reaching an mutual agreement before the trial date, I am offering you the settlement in writing:

1) That you will send the 2023 Hugo Award for Best Fan Writer bearing my name to my stated address on the court documents within two weeks of the date of this settlement offer.

2) You will include the designated winning Best Fan Writer envelope and the card bearing my name, to the same address, also within two weeks of this settlement offer.

3) I also request that you disperse any other 2023 Hugo Awards in your possession to the appropriate recipients within two weeks of the date of this settlement offer, with a public declaration (on either a social or a public media outlet of your choosing) that this has been accomplished.

Upon verification of the items above, the civil suit against you will be remitted in its entirety and no further legal action should be necessary. 

Cordially,

Chris M. Barkley

Cincinnati, Ohio

I also posted this email as an open letter pinned onto my Facebook page and to many sf news and fandom pages as well.

It is my most fervent hope that Mr. McCarty has either read the email or any of the many posts circulating on social media. Because I am only asking to fulfill the many pledges has has made to deliver the 2023 Hugo Awards to their rightful recipients.

Watch this space… 

Pixel Scroll 4/25/25 Knowing I’m On The Scroll Where You Click

(1) MURDERBOT ACTOR Q&A. The actor who plays Ratthi is interviewed in “Next Big Thing: In Conversation With British Actor Akshay Khanna” at Grazia India.

British actor Akshay Khanna stars in Murderbot, a series about a security cyborg that is horrified by, but at the same time, drawn to humans.

Headlined by Alexander Skarsgård, the much-anticipated sci-fi comedy-thriller series Murderbot is all set to debut globally on May 16 on Apple TV+. Akshay Khanna, known for his work in the films Polite Society and Red, White & Royal Blue, speaks to us about stepping into the role of a scientist for the show, how he approaches sci-fi as a genre, and all the things that inspire him. 

GRAZIA: Murderbot sounds like an exciting project. Can you tell us what drew you to it?

AKSHAY KHANNA: I am such a massive nerd. Sci-fi is my favourite genre so when the audition came through, I pulled out all the stops, binged all the books, and scoured Reddit threads to get as solid a picture of the tone and universe as I could. It’s such a funny, brilliant series and I knew it would resonate with audiences. I knew I could fit in Martha Wells’ world, so I gave myself the best shot by taking up about 10 hours of my endlessly patient friend’s time obsessively trying to get the right take. It was well worth it…. 

G: How do you approach playing a character in such a unique genre?
AK: 
Sci-fi has a bit of a reputation of being quite dark, foreboding and serious. This show has a lighter tone – my character Ratthi is a free love space-hippie scientist, so I was able to let loose and have fun. …

(2) BARKLEY V. MCCARTY COURT HEARING. On April 24 another hearing was held by Cook County Small Claims Court on Chris Barkley’s suit against Chengdu Worldcon Hugo administrator Dave McCarty where Chris is attempting to get his 2023 Hugo trophy or $3000. McCarty has refused arbitration, and Barkley’s oral settlement offers, so now the judge has set the case for an in-person trial on June 26.

Barkley has published an open letter to McCarty on Facebook repeating the terms of his settlement offer.

1) That you will send the 2023 Hugo Award for Best Fan Writer bearing my name to my stated address on the court documents within two weeks of the date of this settlement offer.

2) You will include the designated winning Best Fan Writer envelope and the card bearing my name, to the same address, also within two weeks of this settlement offer.

3) I also request that you disperse any other 2023 Hugo Awards in your possession to the appropriate recipients within two weeks of the date of this settlement offer, with a public declaration (on either a social or a public media outlet of your choosing) that this has been accomplished….

(3) BODLEIAN’S ORACLES EXHIBIT. [Item by Susan de Guardiola.] F&SF references spotted at the Bodleian Library (Oxford) exhibit “Oracles, Omens and Answers”. It’s an interesting exhibit but unless someone is already in Oxford it’ll be hard to see, as it closes on April 27. (Full information here.)

Discover how people have sought answers to life’s big questions throughout history.

Drawing on material from across time and cultures – from oracle bones from Shang Dynasty China (ca. 1250-1050 B.C.E.) to an autobiography of Ronald Reagan’s White House astrologer – Oracles, Omens and Answers will explore the different techniques humans have used to unveil the past, understand the present and predict the future.

From palm reading and astrology to weather and public health forecasting, see how societies have turned to divination to ask questions that resonate with us today: on health, relationships, money and politics.

Step into the world of divination and uncover the ways that humanity has tried to confront the unknown and uncertain.

Note: This exhibition includes a large continuous projection of spider divination practice, including images of the spiders in action.

(4) NYTIMES EASTERPUNK. [Item by Daniel Dern.] The steampunk-themed lead photo in the New York Times’ “Bunnies, Bonnets, Brights and Blooms at New York’s Easter Parade” article is visible without needing a NYT account.

(DPD notes: The rest of the pix are mundane. Impressive, but non-Easterpunk. Here’s a “gift” link to the full article: “Bunnies, Bonnets, Brights and Blooms at New York’s Easter Parade”.)

(5) CROSSOVER THE MOUNTAIN. Animation Magazine explains what it means when “SpongeBob Joins the ‘Star Trek’ Crew in New Paramount+ Promo”.

… “Find Your Mountain on Paramount+” is the latest chapter of Paramount+’s award-winning Mountain of Entertainment™ brand campaign, and the new ad is the third in a series of star-studded live-action brand spots featuring unexpected mashups that showcase the personalized content experience on Paramount+. Previous promos have featured mash-ups of Yellowjackets x Survivor and Mean Girls Gladiator.

(6) BJO COA. John and Bjo Trimble’s daughter Lora has announced on Facebook a new address for Bjo.

They have moved mom to Skilled Nursing.

Ok peeps mom’s new address is

Betty Trimble
Cal vet Home west LA
RCFE, Room C138L, 11500 Nimitz Ave
West Los Angeles CA 90049
United States

(7) CASTING A SPELL. Although I couldn’t get it to produce numbers, Bill came up with a way to make NASA’s “Your Name in Landsat” feature, linked in yesterday’s Scroll, display “File 770”.

(8) GEORGE BARR (1937-2025). Fantasy and science fiction artist George Barr died April 19, 2025 at the age of 88 reports Steve Fahnestalk.

Barr was a seven-time Hugo nominee, five times for Best Fan Artist (winning once in 1968), twice for Best Professional Artist.

His early illustration venues included George Scithers’ Amra, Tom Reamy’s Trumpet and Locus.

His first professional illustration was the cover of the March 1961 Fantastic. He did many interior illustrations for Asimov’s Science FictionMarion Zimmer Bradley’s Fantasy Magazine, and Weird Tales

He was the 1976 Worldcon Fan Guest of Honor, and the 1994 Worldcon Artist Guest of Honor. During the 1994 appearance he memorably participated in a re-enactment of Bob Eggleton’s Hugo win after the absent winner impulsively flew to Canada to pick up his rocket in person.

Annette Lotz, a friend of the artist, called Eggleton after the ceremony and told him the news. She said he hyperventilated for a bit, then talked about flying up on the spur of the moment. When Lotz called him in the morning to see what he’d decided, Eggleton’s answering machine announced, “I’ve gone to Canada. I’ll be back Tuesday.”

Bob Eggleton’s impulsive trip to collect his Hugo delighted fans. He was publicly presented with his award at the start of the Masquerade by Barry Longyear and George Barr. Reenacting what he’d done the night before, Barr opened the envelope of nominees and read the name on the card, “What a surprise! — Bob Eggleton!”

Barr was born in Tucson, AZ, grew up in Salt Lake City, Utah, and later moved to Northern California. He is said to have been a talented pianist.

George Barr at the 1994 Worldcon. Photo by © Andrew Porter.

(9) MEMORY LANE.

[Written by Cat Eldridge.]

April 25, 1999X-Files’ “The Unnatural” episode

Scully: Mulder, it’s such a gorgeous day outside. Have you ever entertained the idea of trying to find life on this planet? 

Mulder: I’ve seen the life on this planet Scully, and that is exactly why I am looking elsewhere.

X-Files’ “The Unnatural”

Twenty-six years ago on this evening on FOX, the David Duchovny written and directed  episode of X-Files  titled “The Unnatural” first aired. It is not connected to the underlying mythology of series, and thus is one of their Monster of the Week stories. Well, there might be monsters here. Or not. Certainly not in the usual sense of monsters. 

There are many spoilers here. You’ve been warned. There’s coffee and cherry pie elsewhere… 

We’ve aliens (as in Roswell, really just like those ones), baseball and the KKK. Well, only the latter are the monsters here if you ask me as the aliens definitely aren’t. Aliens loving to play baseball? How can they possibly be monsters? 

We would have had Darren McGavin here too but he suffered a stroke after he was cast as one of the principal characters, but after the stroke, he was replaced by M. Emmet Walsh whom you’ll recognize as Bryant in Blade Runner. McGavin never filmed anything again though one credit is dated after his stroke. 

(He had been in two episodes here playing the same character, Agent Arthur Dales, “Travellers “and “Aqua Mula”. They had planned on him wearing the pork pie hat and the suit that Kolchak wore but the film company said, well, those words can’t be repeated here according to McGavin.) 

It had a notable cast, so I’ll list it: Frederic Lane, M. Emmet Walsh, Jesse L. Martin, Walter T. Phelan, Jr.  Brian Thompson and Paul Willson.

Reception for this episode is exceptionally good. Them Movie Reviews said of it that, “It is truly a credit to Duchovny that The Unnatural works at all, let alone that it turns out as a season highlight. There are any number of memorable and striking visuals in The Unnatural. The sequence where Dales discovers Exley’s true nature is one of the most distinctive shots in the history of The X-Files.”

While Doux Reviews stated “Think about it for a minute. This is an episode about baseball players in the 1940s. They are not only black in a time when being so could be life threatening, they are aliens. Our two heroes are, for the most part, nowhere to be seen throughout this hour. This story should never have worked. It did and it does on every subsequent re-watch. Written and directed by David Duchovny, this is an earnest hour of television. Duchovny took a premise that could have been silly and inane beyond the telling of it and chose to take the whole thing seriously. Because he does, we do as well.”

Audience reviewers at Rotten Tomatoes give the series as a whole an outstanding eighty-six percent rating. 

X-Files is streaming on Hulu. I really need to do a watch of it as I know that I’ve not seen all of it, so that alone would justify a subscription to that service. 

(10) COMICS SECTION.

(11) WINDYCON 50 CONREPORT. [Item by SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie.] SF² Concatenation has just put up an advance-post ahead of its next seasonal edition of a convention report of Windycon 50 in Chicago, USA.

Only three days after a national election widened the already factious divisions in the United States, we fans of SF met in a Chicago suburb for Windycon 50, the longest-running con in the area. Some attendees felt worried and threatened by the US Presidential election results.

At the opening ceremony, the co-chairs, Daniel Gunderson and Vlad Stockman, issued a call for unity and understanding. They quoted from a speech in Babylon 5 about the need to show each other kindness and love because “we are one.” Over the weekend, although the election was not forgotten, it also didn’t impose itself on any activities….

(12) THE CLASS OF ’25. Clarion West has announced the members of the Clarion West Class of 2025. The workshop will be conducted virtually this summer. They will be working with Maurice Broaddus, Carlos Hernandez, Diana Pho, Martha Wells, and the Clarion West staff. 

  • Aishatu Ado (Cologne, Germany)
  • Rida Altaf (Karachi, Pakistan)
  • Krushna Dande (Aurangabad, India)
  • Kehkashan Khalid (Karachi, Pakistan/Jeddah, Saudi Arabia)
  • Angel Leal (Texas, USA)
  • Ricardo Morales Bonilla (Mexico City, Mexico)
  • Plangdi Neple (Nigeria)
  • K.W. Onley (Maryland, USA)
  • Anaïs Ornelas Ramirez (Mexico City, Mexico)
  • Rukman Ragas (Colombo, Sri Lanka)
  • M.R. Robinson (VA, USA)
  • Victoria N. Shi (CA, USA)
  • Sonia Sulaiman (Wawiiatanong/Windsor Ontario, Canada)
  • Miguel Torhton (Mexico City, Mexico)
  • Travis Trusty (Los Angeles, CA, USA)

(13) EATING THE FANTASTIC. Scott Edelman invites listeners to pig out on pork belly with Jarrett Melendez in Episode 252 of the Eating the Fantastic podcast.

Jarrett Melendez

Awesome Con is always a blast, and not just because it brings back memories of the first comic book convention I attended a lifetime ago when I was only 15. But also because I get to chat with creators I’d never encounter elsewhere on my more science fictional con circuit. This time around I got to dine with and you get to eavesdrop on Jarrett Melendez, author of the graphic novel Chef’s Kiss, which was a 2023 Alex Award winner as well as both an Eisner Award and GLAAD Award nominee. The sequel, Chef’s Kiss Again, will be released in 2026.

As a cookbook author and food journalist, Melendez has written countless articles and developed hundreds of original recipes for Bon AppetitEpicuriousSaveur, and Food52. He’s written seven cookbooks to date, including My Pokémon Baking BookRuneScape: The Official CookbookPercy Jackson and the Olympians: The Official CookbookThe Official Wednesday CookbookThe Official Borderlands Cookbook, and others.

Melendez is currently working on Tales of the Fungo: The Legend of Cep, to be published by Andrews McNeel, plus Fujoshi Warriors, an action comedy comic miniseries, and a love letter to both fujoshis and magical girl anime and manga. Melendez has also contributed to award-winning and nominated anthologies, including Young Men in LoveAll We Ever Wanted, and Young Men in Love 2: New Romances.

We discussed how his loves of food and writing combined into a career, the way running comic book conventions gave him the contacts he needed when it was time to create comics of his own, which franchise inspired his sole piece of fan fiction, the comics creator whose lessons proved invaluable, how he knew Chef’s Kiss needed to be a graphic novel rather than a miniseries, the way he balanced multiple plot arcs so they resolved in parallel, the magical pig whose taste is more trustworthy than any chef you’ve ever met, his early crush on Encyclopedia Brown, how he cooks up recipes connected with franchises such as Pokémon and Percy Jackson, the traumatic childhood incident which became the catalyst for his upcoming graphic novel, and much more.

(14) RASPBERRY BERET. Jim Shull asks “Can Disney Studios Paris Be Fixed?” in an installment of his Disney Journey series.

Disney Studios Paris is transforming into Disney Adventure World. This episode explores the history of the park, its present and its future. And how Universal Studios Great Britain may impact DSP as it changes.

[Thanks to Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Mark Roth-Whitworth, Susan de Guardiola, Bill, Daniel Dern, Steven French, Kathy Sullivan, Teddy Harvia, Mike Kennedy, Andrew Porter, John King Tarpinian, and Chris Barkley for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Daniel Dern.]

Barkley — So Glad You (Didn’t) Ask #96, A Column of Unsolicited Opinions

Photo of the 2023 Hugo Award by Richard Man

“I Don’t Think I Owe Anything”; A Timeline of Why I Decided To Sue Dave McCarty

By Chris M. Barkley:

PROLOGUE…

On Tuesday, February 18th at approximately 4:20 pm Central Standard Time, a Cook County Illinois Sheriff’s deputy pulled up to a three story house in a northern Chicago suburban neighborhood. 

Four minutes later, the deputy logged that a Small Claims Court summons had been successfully delivered to the listed Defendant, David Lawrence McCarty on a civil charge of Breach of Contract.

The Plaintiff is myself.

The following account chronicles the how and why Dave McCarty became the first known person to be legally sued for his continuing retention of my, and possibly many others, Hugo Awards.  

THEN…

On the evening of October 21st, 2023, I was seated in the Great Hall of the Science Fiction Museum in the city of Chengdu, Sichuan Province, in the People’s Republic of China for the 2023 Hugo Awards Ceremony. And one of the happiest, and saddest, moments of my life were just about to occur…

  • In July, I was invited and flown to attend the 81st World Science Fiction Convention, at the expense of the Chengdu Worldcon Committee and the hosting fan group, the Chengdu Science Fiction Society. 
  • At the Hugo Awards Ceremony, I was the most shocked person in the auditorium when MY NAME was called in the Best Fan Writer category!
  • At the after-party, Dave McCarty had one of the long tables cleared and called for everyone’s attention. “Anyone who would like to have their awards shipped home, please step up!”, he shouted. The award was placed in a form fitting, custom fitted display box and the lid was closed. I had every reason to believe at that time that my award would be securely and safely shipped.
  • That was the last time I saw my Hugo Award, nearly sixteen months ago. 

[The rest of Chris’ column follows the jump.]

Continue reading

Chris Barkley Pursues His 2023 Hugo Trophy in a Small Claims Court Action Against Dave McCarty

Chris Barkley still doesn’t have his 2023 Hugo Award trophy. And now he’s taken the 2023 Hugo Administrator to court.

Barkley was one of the winners who opted to have the Chengdu Worldcon Committee ship his trophy to the United States. The awards were sent to Hugo Administrator Dave McCarty. However, as McCarty told Barkley in February 2024, all of the display cases and some of the awards were damaged in transit from China. The damage to Barkley’s Hugo display box was so bad that it was totally unusable, the award base needed to be tightened up, and there was a notable chip in the paint on the panda. He told Chris he could either have the award the next day, or McCarty could have it repaired and restored. Chris decided to go with the repairs. He still hasn’t received his, although Barkley learned some others have gotten theirs.

That conversation happened just before Barkley received the information revealed in “The 2023 Hugo Awards: A Report on Censorship and Exclusion” (co-authored with Jason Sanford), which was published later the same month, and may have something to do with McCarty’s subsequent failure to turn over Barkley’s award.

Barkley’s efforts to follow up having been fruitless, he decided to take legal action against McCarty. Today was the first hearing in Cook County Small Claims Court. Barkley told his GoFundMe supporters this is what happened:

A Statement Sent to Chris Barkley’s GoFundMe Donors,
27 March 2025

Dear Donors,

Today I can finally reveal the somewhat historic action that was formally taken last month with the indispensable  help of your generous contributions.

On February 5th, 2025, I traveled from Cincinnati, Ohio to Chicago, Illinois to formally file a lawsuit in Cook County Small Claims Court against David Lawrence McCarty in the amount of $3000.00.

The reason for doing so was simple; I filed on behalf of any 2023 Hugo Award recipients, including myself, who, as of this date, have not received their Hugo Awards.

This lawsuit, which, to the best of my knowledge, is the first time anyone has EVER sued to recover a Hugo Award. It was initiated as a last resort to call attention to Mr. McCarty’s lack of response regarding the status of any of the awards being repaired and/or to be delivered to the 2023 recipients.

This morning, in a case called via Zoom in Cook County Courtroom 1103, Case Number 20251103122 was called. I was present as was Mr. McCarty.

The judge addressed Mr. McCarty first, asking for a comment about the case brought against him.  

Mr. McCarty then said, “I don’t think I owe anything.”  

Whether Mr. McCarty was probably referring to the monetary amount of the case. But as far as I’m concerned, he may as well have been talking about his recalcitrant  attitude towards sf fandom and his failure to live up to the responsibilities he was entrusted with.

When I was asked for comment by the judge, I responded that I was willing to work with Mr. McCarty to arbitrate the situation, the judge stated that Mr. McCarty HAD openly rejected arbitration with his statement.

The judge then set another Zoom meeting date for the morning of April 24th to set a trial date. She then told Mr. McCarty that if he wished to arbitrate the case before that then, he could do so at Daley Plaza on the sixth floor.

At no time did Mr. McCarty and I exchange any direct dialog.

Mr. McCarty, through a documented series of actions, words and deeds, has demonstrated that he does not care for courtesy, diplomacy, equity or the Constitution of the World Science Fiction Society.

Mr. McCarty, in just five minutes, could have agreed to send out any remaining Hugo Awards owed to the 2023 Hugo Award recipients, including myself, and satisfied a major complaint of his stewardship as the Chengdu Hugo Award Administrator.

Instead, he has deliberately chosen to needlessly prolong this legal proceeding and keep the recipient, and myself waiting for their awards.

I have also decided that if there were any leftover funds, either from this GoFundMe or from a settlement from Mr. McCarty, they would be donated equally between the Trans-Atlantic and Down-Under Fan Funds, two well known fan-run charities that I have greatly respected over the years.

Today marks an opening salvo in what I hope is the last battle for holding Mr. McCarty accountable for his neglect and malfeasance.

As for myself, I will continue to champion the cause of the 2023 Hugo Award recipients, in a Cook County courtroom and in the court of public opinion as well.

Chris M. Barkley
Cincinnati, OH

Pass Along Funds Received by LAcon V

The Worldcon “pass-along funds policy” is a commitment to distribute at least one-half of a Worldcon’s surplus to the next three Worldcons that make the same promise.

Having agreed to that policy, once LAcon V was officially voted host of the 2026 Worldcon last August they were in line to receive pass-along funds. Chair Joyce Lloyd and Finance Manager Bruce Farr report these amounts have been received:

Chicago 8 — $18,000
Chengdu Worldcon — $60,000
Glasgow 2024 — $25,240

OTHER LACON V NEWS. The committee has responded to the LA-area fires and windstorm damage by putting off their first membership rate hike for another two months. As they announced on Facebook:

In keeping with the past practice of most Worldcons, LAcon V had planned to have our first membership increase this February.

Given that the past few weeks have been challenging ones for people throughout the Los Angeles community, we have decided to delay any membership price increases until May 1, 2025.

We will announce price increase information in the next couple of months.

Los Angeles residents have shown incredible resilience, supporting one another and persevering during these fires. We are proud to call this city home, and look forward to welcoming the science fiction and fantasy fandom world back to the City of Angels in 2026.

Pixel Scroll 10/19/24 Pixeling On The Other Side, Where Only Scrolls Hide

(1) BEAR APPARENT. “Ur Sid arrives at Cushing Memorial Library & Archives”. Sharon Lee tells fans a photographer was standing by. (OK, it was actually Curator Jeremy Brett.)

…Since the Bumpy Passage fell out of use many years ago, I created a travel pod so that Ur Sid could make his journey in the style to which he had become accustomed, and packed him carefully in a box.  He accompanied nine other boxes containing the Full Run of Lee-and-Miller, Lee, and Miller published works.

Well, today Ur Sid arrived at his new post.  Jeremy Brett, Curator of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Research Collection has kindly sent along photographs of this momentous arrival, which are posted below.

Right now, Ur Sid is sharing office space with Curator Brett.  Very shortly, he will be transferred to Collections Care so that a proper enclosure for Ur Sid and his belongings, including his travel diary, may be constructed….

(2) CHENGDU TWEETS. [Item by Ersatz Culture.] The official Twitter account of Chengdu, China recently posted some tweets of interest:

  • Yesterday there was a video commemorating the one-year anniversary of the Chengdu Worldcon.  A bit cheekily, there are a couple of shots from the Glasgow Worldcon around 1:15 in, that aren’t flagged up as such:  
  • Today there’s a video with Ben Yalow saying how happy he is to be back in Chengdu: 
  • There’s also a tweet asking for responses about SF experiences in Chengdu; as yet they haven’t had any replies.  

Incidentally, these posts followed straight after one criticizing a recent bill before Congress in the U.S. to fund “badmouthing China”, indicating this account seemingly isn’t just for doing local tourism promotion type stuff… 

(3) ICON 50 TO BE DELAYED TO 2026. [Item by Michael J. “Orange Mike” Lowrey.] On Friday at the opening ceremonies of ICON 49 in Cedar Rapids, it was announced that ICON 50, originally scheduled for October 2025, has been postponed to 2026, due to problems with money and with volunteer shortages. 

This follows the recent announcement that WisCon for 2025 will be a Wisconline, all-online event. 

(4) FIRST BITE. Adam Roberts has a funny take on a recent Guardian story:

Or if you prefer your news straight, here’s the link: “Reader stumbles on Dracula’s ancestors in a Dublin library”.

In a Dublin library once frequented by James Joyce and WB Yeats, beneath a turquoise and white domed ceiling and surrounded by oak shelving, Brian Cleary stumbled across something by Dracula author Bram Stoker he believed no living person had ever read.

Cleary, who had taken time off from his job at a maternity hospital after suffering sudden hearing loss, was looking through the Stoker archives at the National Library of Ireland when he came across something strange. In a Dublin Daily Express advert from New Year’s Day 1891 promoting a supplement, one of the items listed was “Gibbett Hill, By Bram Stoker”. He had never heard of it, and went searching for a trace. “It wasn’t something that was Google-able or was in any of the bibliographies,” he said.’

Cleary tracked down the supplement and found Gibbet Hill. “This is a lost story,” he realised. “I don’t think anyone knows about this.” The story follows an unnamed narrator who runs into three children standing by the memorial of a murdered sailor on Gibbet Hill, Surrey, which is also referred to in Dickens’ 1839 novel Nicholas Nickleby.

Together, the four walk to the top of Gibbet Hill. Distracted by the view, the narrator loses sight of the children. He takes a nap among some trees, and wakes to see the children a short distance away, before a snake passes over his feet towards the children, who appear able to communicate with and control the snake. Later, the children attack the narrator. The story culminates with the snake wriggling out of the narrator’s chest, gliding away down the hillside…

(5) LITERARY INCOGNITO. The Week features a list of “Jeff VanderMeer’s 6 favorite books that delve into the unknown”.

In his new sci-fi horror novel, “Absolution,” Jeff VanderMeer returns to the world of 2014’s award-winning “Annihilation,” which launched his Southern Reach Trilogy. Below, the best-selling ‘weird fiction’ author recommends six psychological expeditions into the unknown.

The six-pack includes:

‘A Perfect Spy’ by John le Carré (1986)

“The past is another country” may be a cliché, but not in the hands of my favorite espionage novelist. His masterpiece charts the entanglements, both professional and personal, that bring about the downfall of operative Magnus Pym. A stunning tale of betrayals, redemption, and, ultimately, a compassionate portrayal of a compromised life.

(6) CHARLIE JANE ANDERS ON ELECTION. At the 270 Reasons blog Charlie Jane Anders answers the question “Why Kamala Harris” — “Because we are close to reaching climate benchmarks we can’t come back from”.

Future generations will look back on 2024 as the moment when the United States of America made a defining choice about climate change. This November, we’re either going to renew our commitment to fixing this mess we created, or embrace denial and plunge the world into a nightmarish scenario.

Nobody much is talking about it, but this election feels especially important for a couple of reasons: first, we are dangerously close to reaching some climate benchmarks that we won’t be able to come back from easily, if at all. And second, we are now being faced with daily brutal reminders of the impacts of climate change on our world. As Kamala Harris herself said in a powerful 2023 speech, climate change is here and the effects are in our face everyday. 

The good news is, the past few years have seen some real advances toward clean energy and green infrastructure. Tax credits included in the Inflation Reduction Act are helping to make wind and solar power more affordable than non-renewable energy sources, and the subsidies in the bill are creating more jobs in the clean energy sector. But there’s much more work to be done…

And if you scroll down past the end of Anders’ article there is an index to other posts, including several by genre contributors Tomi Adeyemi, George Saunders, Daniel Handler (aka Lemony Snicket), and Beth Revis.

(7) PLEASE NOT TO CALL IT SF. This Washington City Paper interview with Tara Campbell perpetuates the cliché that if it’s well-written it can’t be science fiction: “Crossover Sci-Fi Author Tara Campbell Comes Home With a New Novel”.

WCPWhen hearing the phrase “speculative fiction,” most readers will immediately think we’re referring to either science fiction or fantasy, and there are elements of both in your novel. But this work leans strongly in to literary writing, with beautiful, sometimes even lyrical storytelling and far less of the extensive worldbuilding than we’d normally see in the aforementioned genres. How do you approach “speculative literary” writing?

TC: Before I stumbled upon the term “speculative fiction,” I used to say that I write science fiction for people who don’t think they read science fiction. But that was only an approximation of what I was doing, and I’m glad that more people are discovering the depth and breadth of fantastical writing beyond strict genre definitions. 

I love the way “speculative literary” opens up narrative by allowing us to go beyond the bounds of realism to get at emotional truths. If something feels surreal, why not try to capture that cognitive dissonance by portraying it as something palpably unreal? Certain parts of American culture are indeed surreal to me, like our relationship with guns, or our lack of reckoning with history, or our income inequality, and those areas of disconnect came out indirectly in stories about sneaking needles striking us everywhere from home to school to church, or screaming ropes howling in the darkest corner of a dusty barn, or sword fighting robots protecting the bunkers of the uber-wealthy….

(8) SECOND, JUST SAY, ‘I FORGOT’. [Item by Bruce D. Arthurs.] An interesting piece about a project to bring obsolete software back from the dead, using Thomas Disch’s Amnesia computer game from 1986. “Remembering ‘Amnesia’: Digital preservationists reboot classic video game” at Yale News.

You wake up naked in a hotel room. You don’t recall who you are or how you got there. Your clothes are missing. Someone knocks on the door.

So begins “Amnesia,” a text-only video game released in 1986, in which players inhabit the perspective of a man experiencing memory loss while staying in midtown Manhattan at the fictional Sunderland Hotel. Players must negotiate a series of puzzles to find much-needed clothes, leave the hotel, and navigate Manhattan’s busy streets. By gathering clues and avoiding innumerable pitfalls, they gradually discover that the protagonist has a fiancée he cannot remember, is being pursued by an assassin, and is wanted for murder in Texas.

A groundbreaking digital work of interactive fiction by the sci-fi novelist Thomas M. Disch, the game anchors “Remembering Amnesia: Rebooting the first computerized novel,” an exhibit on view through March 2 in the Hanke Exhibition Gallery at Sterling Memorial Library.

Drawing on materials from Disch’s archive at the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, the exhibit explores the author’s novel attempt to move video games into the realm of literary fiction. It also describes the efforts of the Yale Library’s Digital Preservation unit to preserve the game, originally stored and played on now-obsolete hardware, and restore it to life.

The revived version of “Amnesia” is available to play on three workstations — two located just outside the exhibit space and one in Bass Library — that emulate a mid-1980s computing environment….

(9) FIVE IS RIGHT OUT. Well, not always. PRINT Magazine’s Steven Heller interviews Arlen Schumer about his latest collection of essays on the famed TV show: The Five Themes of The Twilight Zone, in “The Daily Heller: Your Next Stop, The Twilight Zone”.

You declare in your new title that five themes exist in Serling’s portfolio. What are they?
With this book, I was inspired to curate what I thought were the best episodes of “The Twilight Zone,” collected in a framework that would separate my “greatest hits” of the series into distinct themes that would encompass the diversity—and similarity—of the best episodes by Serling and company. Of course, one can argue that there are more than just five themes of “The Twilight Zone” that the breadth of its 156 episodes would suggest, but I decided rather quickly on the following five, almost as if they suggested themselves: “Science and Superstition,” “Suburban Nightmares,” “A Question of Identity,” “Obsolete Man,” and “The Time Element.” (Of the five, “Suburban Nightmares” is the only one I coined that does not have a direct “Twilight Zone” connection; bonus points for recognizing that “A Question of Identity” comes from dialogue spoken by the protagonist of [the show’s] debut episode, “Where is Everybody?”)

(10) MEMORY LANE.

[Written by John King Tarpinian.]

Anniversary, October 19, 1953 Fahrenheit 451

By John King Tarpinian: On this day in history one of the most read science fiction novels was published. One of the few, if not only, novels of sci-fi on a majority of middle and high school reading lists.

Fahrenheit 451 is one of three books that as a young man made me think about stuff outside of my comfortable life. The other two were Dalton Trumbo’s Johnny Got His Gun and Robert Heinlein’s Stranger in a Strange Land, the three making up a trio of books that woke up my little brain.

Fahrenheit 451 was made into a movie by the French director, François Truffaut. It was his first movie in color and his only English-language film. Remember the French guy in Close Encounters of the Third Kind?  That was Truffaut.

Flatscreen TVs were in this book. Bluetooth was in this book. Most people know that Ray never drove a car, remember that in the book Clarisse was killed by a speeding car. Montag was a brand of paper; Faber was a brand of pencil. Beatty was named for the lion tamer, Clyde Beatty.

Bradbury’s book rails against censorship, in any form.

Lastly, Ray’s headstone reads “Author of Fahrenheit 451.”

(Use this link to see a parade of Fahrenheit 451 book covers from over the years.)

(11) COMICS SECTION.

(12) READING THE ROOMS. For the “Every Town Deserves a Library” episode of the Our Opinions Are Correct podcast, hosts Annalee Newitz and Charlie Jane Anders are joined by Ken Liu.

Science fiction and fantasy are full of wondrous libraries containing everything from powerful artifacts to some dang good reads. How does the idealized view of libraries in speculative fiction compare with the real-life libraries, which are under attack by would-be censors and culture warriors? Also, we talk to award-winning author Ken Liu about his brand new translation of the classic Daoist text, the Dao De Jing.

(13) JOY WILLIAMS Q&A. [Item by Steven French.] Joy Williams on why fiction should be ‘uncanny’ (and on reading Baba Yaga stories as a child) in the Guardian.

For many years, you’ve written about the climate emergency and environmental destruction. I wonder if your thinking about how to represent that in fiction has developed, and where you think it might go?

I’m always trying to convince myself that fiction will rise up and throw away the crutches that have been supporting it for far too long. The comfy story has got to change. It needs to be more uncanny, less personal….

(14) MICHELLE YEOH TREK – MARK YOUR CALENDAR. “’Star Trek: Section 31′ Movie Gets Premiere Date On Paramount+”Deadline has the story.

Paramount+ has set January 24, 2025 for the premiere of its upcoming movie Star Trek: Section 31, starring Michelle Yeoh in a reprisal of her Star Trek: Discovery role as Emperor Philippa Georgiou.

The announcement was made Saturday during the Star Trek universe panel at New York Comic Con. Yeoh made a video appearance during the panel, which featured cast members Omari Hardwick, Kacey Rohl and Robert Kazinsky, along with executive producer and director Olatunde Osunsanmi.

Star Trek: Section 31 will premiere exclusively Friday, January 24 in the U.S. and international markets where the service is available….

(15) YOU HAVE TO BE CAREFULLY TAUGHT. “As AI takes the helm of decision making, signs of perpetuating historic biases emerge” – the Arizona Mirror overviews the research.

…In a recent study evaluating how chatbots make loan suggestions for mortgage applications, researchers at Pennsylvania’s Lehigh University found something stark: there was clear racial bias at play.

With 6,000 sample loan applications based on data from the 2022 Home Mortgage Disclosure Act, the chatbots recommended denials for more Black applicants than identical white counterparts. They also recommended Black applicants be given higher interest rates, and labeled Black and Hispanic borrowers as “riskier.”

White applicants were 8.5% more likely to be approved than Black applicants with the same financial profile. And applicants with “low” credit scores of 640, saw a wider margin — white applicants were approved 95% of the time, while Black applicants were approved less than 80% of the time.

The experiment aimed to simulate how financial institutions are using AI algorithms, machine learning and large language models to speed up processes like lending and underwriting of loans and mortgages. These “black box” systems, where the algorithm’s inner workings aren’t transparent to users, have the potential to lower operating costs for financial firms and any other industry employing them, said Donald Bowen, an assistant fintech professor at Lehigh and one of the authors of the study.

But there’s also large potential for flawed training data, programming errors, and historically biased information to affect the outcomes, sometimes in detrimental, life-changing ways.

(16) TURNOVER TIME. “Earth’s Flipping Magnetic Field Heard as Sound Is an Unforgettable Horror”ScienceAlert lets you eavesdrop.

Approximately 41 000 years ago, Earth’s magnetic field briefly reversed during what is known as the Laschamp event. During this time, Earth’s magnetic field weakened significantly—dropping to a minimum of 5% of its current strength—which allowed more cosmic rays to reach Earth’s atmosphere. Scientists at the Technical University of Denmark and the German Research Centre for Geosciences used data from ESA’s Swarm mission, along with other sources, to create a sounded visualisation of the Laschamp event. They mapped the movement of Earth’s magnetic field lines during the event and created a stereo sound version which is what you can hear in the video. The soundscape was made using recordings of natural noises like wood creaking and rocks falling, blending them into familiar and strange, almost alien-like, sounds. The process of transforming the sounds with data is similar to composing music from a score.

(17) DOUG JONES VEHICLE. “’Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror’ – Doug Jones Stars in Unique Horror Remake [Trailer]” recommended by Bloody Disgusting. (And with a recommendation like that, you know what you’re in for!)

Eight years in the making, director David Lee Fisher’s new take on the horror classic Nosferatu has finally been unleashed, the film now available on Digital through Prime Video….

(18) THE (POD BAY) DOORS OF PERCEPTION. Six years ago someone shared the results of a thought experiment that asked what would happen “If HAL9000 was Amazon.com’s Alexa”.

[Thanks to Chris Barkley, Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Bruce D. Arthurs, N., Ersatz Culture, Michael J. “Orange Mike” Lowrey, Steven French, Kathy Sullivan, Teddy Harvia, Mike Kennedy, Andrew Porter, and John King Tarpinian for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Paul Weimer.]

Text of Glasgow 2024 Business Meeting’s Apology for 2023 Hugo Awards

At Glasgow 2024, the WSFS Business Meeting passed a resolution offering an apology to those people who were harmed by the Hugo Award results in 2023. Kevin Standlee published the text of the apology today on the World Science Fiction Society website. Linda Deneroff, Chair, WSFS Marketing Committee, has requested File 770 to publish it, too. The text includes a Chinese translation by Sophia Xue, who did all of Glasgow’s Chinese translations.  

The following resolution passed at the 2024 Business Meeting of the World Science Fiction Society:

BE IT RESOLVED, that the World Science Fiction Society apologizes unreservedly to the nominators and voters of the 2023 Hugo Awards for any failures in the administration of the 2023 Hugo Awards; and

The World Science Fiction Society apologizes unreservedly to all nominees, finalists, and winners of the 2023 Hugo Awards for any failures in the administration of the 2023 Hugo Awards as well as any harm which may result from those actions; and

The World Science Fiction Society specifically and unreservedly apologizes to R.F. Kuang, author of Babel; Congyun “Mu Ming” Gu, author of “Color the World”; Hai Ya, author of Fongong Temple Pagoda; Neil Gaiman, author/writer for The Sandman; Paul Weimer; and Xiran Jay Zhao for their exclusion from the 2023 Hugo Award and/or Astounding Award Final Ballots.

Sophia Xue has provided the following Chinese translation of the official resolution:

世界科幻协会为2023年雨果奖评选过程中的任何失误,向2023年雨果奖的提名者和投票者表示毫无保留的歉意;

世界科幻协会为2023年雨果奖评选过程中的任何失误以及由此可能造成的任何伤害,向2023年雨果奖的所有获提名者、入围者和获奖者表示毫无保留的歉意;

世界科幻协会尤其向以下个人表示毫无保留的歉意:匡灵秀(R.F. Kuang)(《巴别塔》作者)、慕明(顾从云)(《涂色世界》作者)、海漄(《尽化塔》作者)、尼尔·盖曼(Neil Gaiman)(《睡魔》作者/编剧)、保罗·韦默(Paul Weimer)、赵希然(Xiran Jay Zhao),因为他们被排除在2023年雨果奖和/或惊奇奖决选名单之外。

[Thanks to Linda Deneroff for the story.]

Pixel Scroll 8/14/24 File ‘P’ For Pixel

(1) CLARION WEST 2025 INSTRUCTORS. The instructors for Clarion West’s 2025 Six-Week Summer Workshop have been named: Maurice Broaddus, Malka Older, Diana Pho, and Martha Wells. It will be an online workshop running from June 22-August 2. Applications planned to open December, 2024. Scholarships available.

(2) ALL GLORY IS FLEETING. T. Kingfisher’s Chengdu 2023 Hugo arrived in pieces, but at least they all arrived at the same time.  

(3) PROCESS OF ELIMINATION. Zoë O’Connell created colored graphs to illustrate the flow of votes in the Hugo Awards automatic runoff process. Thread starts here on Mastodon.

Visualising the #Worldcon #Hugo2024 voting results.

Alternative Title: Why ranked voting matters.

As a quick explanation, the last placed candidate in each round is eliminated and their votes transferred to the next candidate on each ballot.

Here’s the graph for Best Fanzine. Two other finalists held the lead before finishing behind the winner Nerds of a Feather. (Click for larger image.)

(4) SLOWLY, THE STARS WERE GOING OUT… Variety reports the squeeze is on: “Paramount Television Studios Shut Down by Paramount Global Cost Cuts”. Last week, company leaders announced that they would reduce Paramount’s U.S.-based workforce by 15% in an effort to save $500 million in annual costs. Several genre/related projects will move from the Paramount TV studios brand to under the CBS Studios umbrella.

…All current series and development projects made under the Paramount Television Studios umbrella will move to CBS Studios

Paramount Television marked the second time Paramount Pictures tried to move into the TV business — separate from the storied shingle that was built on the Desilu production studio founded by Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz. That studio, which backed such TV treasures as “I Love Lucy” and “Star Trek,” eventually became the center of Paramount Studios after an acquisition by Gulf + Western, and would be inherited by CBS after its split from the company formerly known as Viacom Inc. in 2005….

… Under its aegis, the company produced “The Offer,” an insider tale of the making of the landmark movie, for Paramount+; and series based on Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan character for Amazon Prime Video. Other series it produced include “The Spiderwick Chronicles for Roku and a revival of the Terry Gilliam movie “Time Bandits” that is now a series on Apple’s streaming service….

(5) DID I MENTION, RESISTANCE IS FUTILE. “Warner Bros. Discovery pretty much wiped the Cartoon Network website” reports The Verge.

Warner Bros. Discovery has updated Cartoon Network’s website to remove basically everything and turn it into a page pointing to the Max streaming service. Before the change, the website let you watch free episodes of shows like Adventure Time and Steven Universe. The switchover appears to have happened on Thursday, Variety reports, and follows Warner Bros.’ announcement last week that it would be shutting down Boomerang, its streaming service for classic Warner Bros. cartoons.

“Looking for episodes of your favorite Cartoon Network shows?” reads a message that pops up on Cartoon Network’s website. “Check out what’s available to stream on Max (subscription required).”…

(6) A DISH OVERSERVED COLD. Sarah A. Hoyt is seeing so much “Vengeance” fiction she tried to apply the brakes at Mad Genius Club.

…No matter how angry people are, feeding on a straight diet of revenge fantasies will just make it worse and worse and worse.

Okay, so you’re not a missionary, and you just want to make money, what do you care if you’re making people crazier.

Because you’ll train yourself to write very bad fiction. And because a lot of it is very very bad fiction which no one really wants to read, no matter how furious they are.

Particularly because — trust me — it’s disproportionate and worse, it doesn’t make for a good story. Even worse, unless you are an experienced author who knows precisely how to convey how mad you are and how much these evil people deserve their comeupance, revenge is not an easy plot to write.

It seems easy, because it’s a strong emotion. And if you feel the need to see someone being sliced to little bits, and aren’t picky about who it is, particularly if the person being sliced up is entirely fictional….

(7) TED TALK.  I believe I missed this issue…. In 1964, Theodore Sturgeon wrote a story for Sports Illustrated: “How To Forget Baseball”. [Via Paul Di Filippo.]

Once upon a possible (for though there is only one past, there are many futures), after 12 hours of war and 40-some years of reconstruction; at a time when nothing had stopped technology (for technological progress not only accelerates, so does the rate at which it accelerates), the country was composed of strip-cities, six blocks wide and up to 80 miles long, which rimmed the great superhighways, and wildernesses. And at certain remote spots in the wilderness lived primitives, called Primitives, a hearty breed that liked to stay close to nature and the old ways. And it came about that a certain flack, whose job it was to publicize the national pastime, a game called Quoit, was assigned to find a person who had never seen the game; to invite him in for one game, to get his impressions of said game and to use them as flacks use such things. He closed the deal with a Primitive who agreed to come in exchange for the privilege of shopping for certain trade goods. So…

(8) ROMANTASY ON THE MATURE SIDE. The New York Times hypothesizes “Why Romantasy Readers Pine for 500-Year-Old ‘Shadow Daddies’”. “Disappointed by swipe culture and, perhaps, reality, some readers pine for the much (much) older ‘shadow daddies’ of romantasy novels”. Gift article link bypasses NYT paywall.

… With the arrival of megahits like “A Court of Thorns and Roses,” a series by Sarah J. Maas, romantasy has garnered a huge fan base. Many readers dissect characters like Feyre Archeron, the protagonist in “A Court of Thorns and Roses,” who is about 19 when she meets her 500-year-old “mate,” a mysterious faerie; they swap theories; and they rate sex scenes on a “spiciness” scale. Among them, there has been a recurring point of debate: Is it acceptable for a 19-year-old to date a 500-year-old?

Some say it is not only acceptable — it’s aspirational.

“I’ve made poor decisions with regular men,” said Asvini Ravindran, 31, a social media specialist who lives in Toronto and has a TikTok about books, including romantasy. “Why not make them with an immortal man with magical powers?”

Fans of the genre refer to such ancient love interests as “shadow daddies.”…

(9) THE EPONYMOUS RING. CBR.com answers the question “What Was the One Ring Made of in The Lord of the Rings?” Of course, some of you won’t need to read to the end because you remember.

The One Ring from The Lord of the Rings had many supernatural abilities; it could render its wearer invisible, extend the lifespan of those in its presence, corrupt even the noblest hearts, and most importantly, dominate the other Rings of Power. Yet its bizarre physical properties were just as significant. The One Ring was practically indestructible, as it did not bend, break, scratch, or lose its shine, even after spending thousands of years at the bottom of a river. The only way to harm the One Ring was to melt it, and even then, no ordinary fire or even the breath of a great dragon like Smaug would suffice; it could only melt when dropped into the lava of Mount Doom, where the Dark Lord Sauron forged it. Additionally, it could change its size and weight at will, an ability it used to slip on and off the fingers of its wearers….

(10) TODAY’S BIRTHDAY.

[Written by Cat Eldridge.]

Born August 14, 1965 Brannon Braga, 59. Brannon Braga was, not at the same time or always, the writer, producer and creator of the Next GenVoyagerEnterprise, The Orville, as well as of the Generations and First Contact films. He written quite a number of the Trek films —  GenerationsFirst Contact, Insurrection and Nemesis.

Those four films he’s written. Is that more than anyone else? I could look it up, but I figure I’d ask the great pool of Trek fans here instead. 

Brannon Braga

Confession time — I’ve still not watched The Orville. Now that it’s been canceled, shall I go ahead and watch all of it? Opinions please. 

He has written more episodes of the many Trek series than anyone else — four hundred and forty-four to date, many of course co- written. I really don’t think he’ll be writing any more as his last scripts were for Enterprise.

He was responsible for the Next Generation series finale “All Good Things…” which won him a Hugo Award at Intersection for excellence in SF writing, along with Ronald D. Moore. 

He was nominated at LoneStarCon2 for Star Trek: First Contact for the screenplay along with Ronald D. Moore, and the story by Rick Berman and Ronald D. Moore; Torcon3 saw him pick up two nominations for Enterprise stories — first for the “Carbon Creek” story along with Rick Berman and Dan O’Shannon, and the wonderful “A Night in The Sick Bay” with Rick Berman.

(Digression. Ok, I like Enterprise a lot. For me, everything there worked. And the Mirror Universe finale worked for me though it got a lot of criticism.) 

Aussiecon 4 saw him pick up only his non-Trek related Hugo nomination or Award. It was for writing FlashForward’s “No More Good Days” with David S. Goyer. 

There’s a great quote by him after he stopped being Roddenberry’s replacement as head of the Trek franchise: “It’s not an easy task. On the other hand, I have nothing to be ashamed about. We created 624 hours of television and four feature films, and I think we did a hell of a job. I’m amazed that we managed to get 18 years of the kind of work that everyone involved managed to contribute to, and it’s certainly more than anyone could have asked for.” (Star Trek Magazine

(11) COMICS SECTION.

(12) IN X-CESS. [Item by Mike Kennedy.] Just what we all need, another list of somebody’s opinion about “best of…“ The Hollywood Reporter gives us “Best X-Men Movies, Ranked”. And as you might expect, it’s more fun to pan than to praise.

13. X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)

Brett Ratner was never anyone’s first choice to direct an X-Men film. And from the film itself, and the stories that followed, it’s not hard to see why. The Last Stand smashes together Chris Claremont and John Byrne’s The Dark Phoenix Saga, widely considered to be the best X-Men story, along with the Gifted storyline from Joss Whedon and John Cassaday’s then-more recent Astonishing X-Men. The film doesn’t serve either story well, and it all too hastily kills off Cyclops (James Marsden), sidelines several mainstays like Mystique (Rebecca Romijn) and Rogue (Anna Paquin), and introduces a bunch of new characters audiences had been clamoring to see — Kitty Pryde (Elliot Page), Beast (Kelsey Grammer), Angel (Ben Foster) and Juggernaut (Vinnie Jones), none of whom get much time to shine (although Grammer’s Beast is a welcome addition).

Famke Janssen does well with what the film decides to do with the Phoenix, which is to make her into a kind of demonically possessed powerhouse, and Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen all remain stalwarts of the franchise. A third act that features Magneto lifting the Golden Gate Bridge and Logan professing his love for Jean, while she tries to incinerate him, are highlights, along with John Powell’s score. But all in all, there’s just something a bit too studio-mandated and manufactured about it.

(13) NEW ISSUE OF SF COMMENTARY. Bruce Gillespie has released SF Commentary 117, July 2024. Covers by Alan White and Dennis Callegari. Poems by Alan White. Articles by Janeen Webb and Cy Chauvin. Columns by Bruce Gillespie, Colin Steele, Anna Creer, Tony Thomas, John Hertz. Reviews by John Litchen and William Sarill.

Download from eFanzines or at Fanac.org.

(14) THAT’S ALL, FOLKS. R. Graeme Cameron accepted the Auora Award for Best Fan Writing and Publication for Polar Borealis, its fifth win, then announced on Facebook that he is recusing the publication from future Aurora consideration.

…The purpose of the Auroras is to celebrate the diversity of Canadian talent in as inclusive a manner as possible. Five is a good, solid number. It’s time to make room for others, especially the new talent coming along.

Therefore, I state for the record that I am requesting CSFFA to no longer consider Polar Borealis for nomination or ballot status from this date forward.

Not that I am adverse to winning further Aurora awards for other things….

…Main thing is for Polar Borealis to stop hogging the limelight.

 (15) AN ARCHITECTURAL TRIUMPH. You can take an online tour of the fabulous McKim Building that houses the Boston Public Library. It’s gorgeous!

…The McKim Lobby, from its Georgia marble floor inlaid with brass designs to its three aisles of vaulted ceilings, continues a grand procession into the heart of the building. The ceilings, clad in mosaic tile by Italian immigrant craftsmen living in Boston’s North End, bear Roman motifs and the names of thirty famous Massachusetts statesmen.

The mosaic ceiling tiles clad vault work by Rafael Guastavino, a Spanish builder who specialized in Mediterranean-style ceramic tile-vaulted ceilings that were lightweight, fireproof, self-supporting, and strong. Guastavino’s collaboration with Charles Follen McKim throughout a number of ceilings in the Central Library represented his first major American commission, the starting point for a company that would go on to construct vaults in over 600 buildings throughout the country….

(16) RINGS OF POWER RETURNS. “War is coming to Middle Earth,” begins the final pre-launch trailer before The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 drops on August 29.

(17) APPRENTICED TO A PIRATE. From six years ago. “How Sir Paul McCartney acts in film Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales.

Co-directors Joachim Rønning and Espen Sandberg explain all the details on Sir Paul McCartney’s transformation to a pirate.

[Thanks to Andrew Porter, John King Tarpinian,  Chris Barkley, Paul Di Filippo, Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Steven French, Kathy Sullivan, Teddy Harvia, and Mike Kennedy for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Andrew (not Werdna).]

Pixel Scroll 8/12/24 I Came Upon A Scroll Of God, He Was Pixeling Down The Road

(1) BEST NOVEL WINNER TESH INTERVIEWED. [Item by Nickpheas.] Front Row, the main BBC Radio 4 arts show includes an overview of the recent Hugo controversies and an interview with Emily Tesh following her Best Novel win: “BBC Radio 4 – Front Row, Emily Tesh and the Hugo Awards”.

This year’s WorldCon – the World Science Fiction Convention – took place in Glasgow and pop culture critic Gavia Baker-Whitelaw reports on the international gathering where the winners of the Hugo Awards 2024 were announced last night.

Emily Tesh on winning the Best Novel prize at this year’s Hugo Awards with her debut novel, Some Desperate Glory.

(2) SPREAD THE WORD. Maybe fans should have been told this was DNQ – then by now everybody would know it.

(3) BEAUTY SHOTS. Richard Man has received his 2023 Hugo Award trophy and has posted a gallery of beautiful photos of it on Facebook. They include close-ups of the based and its artistic panda sculpture. Here’s the first in the series.

(4) GLASGOW 2024 PHOTO TEAM. And you can see the Worldcon in all its glory in this gallery of “Worldcon Photos” at Flickr.

(5) LOST IN TRANSLATION. Glasgow 2024 apologized for problems at last night’s Hugo ceremony with onscreen cards in rendering Chinese names. One commenter thinks the apology underplays the extent of them.

(6) WEE, SLEEKIT, COWRIN, TIM’ROUS BEASTIE. Cora Buhlert, who is headed home at this hour, shared a “Brief Worldcon Update – and a Fannish Poem”. The title of the poem is “The Phantom of the Armadillo”. You might be able to guess what it’s about from the first two lines. See the rest at the link.

There’s a spectre haunting Glasgow,
a spectre by the name of Dave…

(7) DARKLIT PRESS. Publishers Weekly has compiled the available information about the meltdown in “A Grim Fate Befalls Horror Publisher DarkLit Press”.

A metaphorical bloodbath has occurred at Canada-based independent horror publisher DarkLit Press, with authors clawing back rights, publicly splitting with the company, and claiming royalties have gone unpaid. A year ago, DarkLit was announcing new imprints and developing its audio offerings, but its website and social media accounts have gone black, and the company is not listed in the Canadian Business Registry….

(8) CAMERON Q&A. “James Cameron Interview: Avatar 3, Alien: Romulus, Terminator Zero” in The Hollywood Reporter.

There has been a lot of conversation in the last few years about UAPs [Unidentified Aerial Phenomena] along with USOs — Underwater Submerged Objects — which you brought to the pop culture forefront with The Abyss. You’ve spent so much time on and in the ocean. Have you ever seen anything that you cannot explain?

I’ve seen some geological formations that were intriguing that I really wanted to understand better that I don’t think have been well observed before. I’ve photographed new species — things that were not immediately identifiable. But I’ve never seen anything that couldn’t be explained in the sense of some extraterrestrial phenomenon. Now, “belief” is a principle that I don’t have. I don’t believe things. I admit the possibility of things because the universe is infinite and obviously much stranger than we think, and much more complex than we think — that’s what makes science so appealing. But I don’t make broad statements like, “Well, I believe there must be extraterrestrial life; the universe is so big.” Yeah, it’s really big — and getting here would be a really, really big problem if there is even life out there, and if that life is intelligent. How are they crossing light years of space? I studied physics before I became a lit major, and people have no concept of the magnitude of that problem from a physics standpoint. I have a pretty good grasp of where physics was in 1972 — which basically is laughable at this point — but I keep up.

(9) MY ALIBI. There we go – Xiran Jay Zhao and George R.R. Martin are each other’s alibis for not turning in their next book.

(10) NOW WITH ADDED DRAGONS. Erin Underwood Presents brings viewers a“House of the Dragon, Season 2 Review – Here’s why it’s actually a good season”. (Did you have doubts?)

House of the Dragon, George RR Martin’s A Game of Throne’s prequel, enters its second season with the Targaryen’s internal succession war at its peak — and it’s tearing the Seven Kingdoms apart. Plus, there are so many DRAGONS. Check out my new review of season 2.

(11) TODAY’S BIRTHDAY.

[Written by Lis Carey.]

Born August 12, 1931 William Goldman. (Died 2018.)

By Lis Carey: William Goldman was a novelist, playwright, and screenwriter. He won two Academy Awards in writing categories—Best Original Screenplay for Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969), and Best Adapted Screenplay for All the President’s Men (1976).

But the work for which we best know and love him is The Princess Bride, both novel and film.

William Goldman. Photo by Bernard Gotfryd

The Princess Bride is, As You Know, Bob, the film adaptation of William Goldman’s “good parts version” of S. Morgenstern’s long political satire, The Princess Bride: S. Morgenstern’s Classic Tale of True Love and High Adventure, The “Good Parts” Version.

Except, of course, S. Morgenstern never existed, and Goldman only wrote the “good parts,” including “footnotes” referencing fictional bits of the politics, etc., of the kingdoms of Florin and Guilder, and the frame story of a grandfather reading the story to his grandson. The adaptation for the film was, fortunately, written by Goldman himself, and is remarkably true to the novel. A grandfather reads to his grandson the “good parts version” of Princess Buttercup; her true love Westley; Buttercup’s evil betrothed, Prince Humperdinck; and of course the giant Fezzik, Inigo Montoya, Vizzini the Sicilian, and assorted other people of questionable character.

Altogether, it’s a lovely package of wit, humor, fantasy, adventure and romance. With positive critical reception but only modestly successful at the box office, it has become a cult classic. Lines from the movie are happily quoted by fans who have seen it, and those who never have, because it’s just so darned quotable and engaging.

“Inconceivable!”

“You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.”

“Never get involved in a land war in Asia.” (Solid advice, that one.)

It’s a pure delight, and has a 96% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. You can watch it on Disney+, if so inclined.

(12) COMICS SECTION.

(13) PAGING THROUGH THE SF HALL OF FAME. David Agranoff’s new Postcards from a Dying World podcast episode is about “SF Hall of Fame #7 The Weapons Shop by AE Van Vogt”.

In 1970 Avon Books published a landmark anthology “Science Fiction Hall of Fame” featuring 16 classic short stories that represent landmark tales of the genre. The stories were voted on by the members of the new (at the time in the late 60s) organization Science Fiction Writers of America. In this series, I will be joined by a panel of different guests to break down these stories and talk about the authors in the book.

In this episode, I am joined by two experts on Philip K Dick. Wait a second I thought this episode was about AE Van Vogt. It is.. but the Canadian Golden Age author was a massive influence on PKD, so I was interested in introducing two Dickheads to Van Vogt. So joining me is the Total Dickhead blogger – Professor David Gill and author/publisher/editor Keith Giles of Quior Books.

(14) COMIC-CON PROGRAM BOOK IS FREE DOWNLOAD. [Item by Bill.] The San Diego Comic-Con’s program book is released as a PDF.  It contains much of SF interest.  Find it here.

(15) DISNEY LEGENDS AT D23. The star-power was turned up bright this past weekend at the D23 Expo in Anaheim.

Jamie Lee Curtis has always been legendary, but now it’s official: she was named a Disney Legend on Sunday during the D23 Expo.

Lindsay Lohan took the stage to queue up a montage of Curtis’ most memorable roles, telling the crowd, “I have been able to have the pleasure of working with Jamie Lee Curtis. And the magic of Jamie Lee Curtis is that she is timeless. Every character she plays is different, and she always brings something unique to the role. And I feel so blessed to have Jamie as a friend in my life, and I feel lucky to work with a woman that I admire so much.”

Jodie Foster surprised the crowd after Lohan’s introduction to further lionize Curtis, saying, “There are many things that my bestie Jamie and I have in common,” recalling their upbringing as young women in Hollywood.

“Here are many of the absolutely freaky things that you may not know about her: You probably don’t know she eats dinner at 3 or 4, and is asleep by 7:30. She gets up at 3 a.m., she saves the world and she online shops a little bit,” Foster continued.

“She is so thoughtful and so generous, such a supportive and kind cheerleader, that it just makes me want to punch her,” Foster said with a laugh. “Is that wrong?” Foster then presented Curtis with her own embroidered pair of Mickey Mouse ears….

…After a montage of Harrison’s most iconic work, Ford took the stage to an enthusiastic standing ovation. Referencing one of his most iconic “Star Wars” moments, he told the crowd, “I love you, too” (a more direct version of Han Solo’s famous response, “I know.”)

He continued, “I love the life you’ve given me. I love the people that I’ve had the opportunity to work with. Nobody does anything in this business for long. We work in collaboration, no matter what who we are and what we’re doing.”

Ford called himself an “assistant storyteller,” adding, “The stories are for you, about you, about us,” Ford said as he choked back tears. “To be able to work in that area is a privilege.”….

Angela Bassett was recognized for three decades of work with Disney, including her role in Touchstone’s “What’s Love Got to Do With It,” narration of National Geographic’s The Flood and the Disney+ docuseries “The Imagineering Story,” and, most recently, her Oscar-nominated performance as Queen Ramonda in “Black Panther: Wakanda Forever.”…

…“Titanic” director James Cameron was also among the honorees, recognized for his work on the “Avatar” film franchise, for which he’s currently in post-production for the third entry, with a planned fourth and fifth in pre-production. He’s also behind several documentaries made in partnership with National Geographic, including the Emmy-winning “Secrets of the Whales” and Emmy-nominated “Secrets of the Elephants.” He also executive produced the OceanXplorers series, due in fall 2024 from National Geographic….

…Ripa began her career as an actor on the soap opera “All My Children” and the sitcom “Hope & Faith.” She’s best known for her work on morning television as the co-host of ABC’s “Live,” which she’s appeared on since 2001….

…Bassett, Cameron and Ripa were joined by fellow Disney Legend honorees Jamie Lee Curtis, James L. Brooks, Harrison Ford, Frank Oz, John Williams, Miley Cyrus, costume designer Colleen Atwood, Disney Parks cast member Martha Blanding, the late Marvel comic artist Steve Ditko, animator Mark Henn, and imagineer Joe Rohde….

(16) FREAKIER FRIDAY. And once D23 is over, everybody goes back to work. “‘Freaky Friday 2’ Title Revealed as ‘Freakier Friday,’ Brings Back Lindsay Lohan’s Rock Band Pink Slip And Loads of Cameos”Variety has the story.

…“It feels like no time has passed,” Curtis told the ecstatic crowd.

Lohan revealed the two had stayed in touch over the years and said, “We’re very close.” To which Curtis replied, “It feels like we’re picking up where we left off.”

And with that, the trailer for Nisha Ganatra’s “Freaky Friday 2,” starring Curtis and Lohan was revealed…

(17) PRIDE OF DISNEY. A trailer has dropped for Mufasa: The Lion King – in theaters December 20.

Exploring the unlikely rise of the beloved king of the Pride Lands, “Mufasa: The Lion King” enlists Rafiki to relay the legend of Mufasa to young lion cub Kiara, daughter of Simba and Nala, with Timon and Pumbaa lending their signature schtick. Told in flashbacks, the story introduces Mufasa as an orphaned cub, lost and alone until he meets a sympathetic lion named Taka—the heir to a royal bloodline. The chance meeting sets in motion an expansive journey of an extraordinary group of misfits searching for their destiny—their bonds will be tested as they work together to evade a threatening and deadly foe.

(18) IS CONSCIOUSNESS DOWN TO QUANTUM EFFECTS. [Item by SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie.] Physicist Matt O’Dowd over at PBS Space Time takes a look at Nobel laureate Roger Penrose’s idea that the brain might enable consciousness through quantum effects: the brain might be a quantum computer, his rationalization being known as orchestrated objective reduction. Basically, we think – outside the box –  like quantum and not analogue computers.

Now, the arguments against this are that physicists currently entangle atoms in vacuums at very, very cold temperatures: conversely, brains are warm and wet. (We biologists like things warm and wet.) Subsequently, in the mid-1990s, an anaesthetist, Stuart Hameroff, suggested microtubules found in brain cells might have the macromolecule, the tubulin protein, Penrose was looking for as many anaesthetics work by impairing microtubule function.

The latest news is that a paper has been published showing that molecules in microtubules exhibit superradience and superradience (as you all know well?) is a phenomena arising out of quantum entanglement.

Now, just because a molecule exhibits supperradience by itself is not proof that the molecule can behave in an entangled quantum way, however it is at the very least corroborating evidence and so we can file this in the ‘interesting’ drawer.

Also, don’t be quick to rule out the ‘warm and wet’ problem just because physicists find it difficult.  In biology we think that photosynthesis (how plants harness sunlight’s energy) likely relies on quantum effects: it is possible that quantum coherence and electron tunneling are involved in photosynthesis. Quantum_biology is a thing.

Finally, let’s think of the SF implications of all of this. Given the number of microtubules in the brain and given the number of calculations quantum computers can do, then to get General Artificial Intelligence (that’s 2001 HAL level of A.I.) we would need a very, very large quantum computer and that seems a very long way off and is certainly not something we can do with conventional, analogue computers.  If this is so, then it may mean our getting a powerful A.I. capable of conscious, independent thought is unlikely…  This, some may say, could be good news. I keep on telling people that the machines are taking over.  But nobody ever listens…

That’s everything in a nutshell. Matt O’Dowd explains it with a little more detail (and fortunately with no heavy mathematical equations). You can see the 19-minute video here.

Nobel laureate Roger Penrose is widely held to be one of the most brilliant living physicists for his wide-ranging work from black holes to cosmology. And then there’s his idea about how consciousness is caused by quantum processes. Most scientists have dismissed this as a cute eccentricity – a guy like Roger gets to have at least one crazy theory without being demoted from the supersmartypants club. The most common argument for this dismissal is that quantum effects can’t survive long enough in an environment as warm and chaotic as the brain. Well, a new study has revealed that Penrose’s prime candidate molecule for this quantum activity does indeed exhibit large scale quantum activity. So was Penrose right after all? Are you a quantum entity?

[Thanks to Teddy Harvia, Mike Kennedy, Andrew Porter, Erin Underwood, Nickpheas, Bill, John King Tarpinian, Chris Barkley, Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Steven French, and Kathy Sullivan for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Jon Meltzer.]

Pixel Scroll 8/8/24 I Filed The Scroll, And The Scroll Won

(1) GLASGOW 2024 IN MEMORIAM LIST. The Worldcon In Memoriam 2024 was played today during Opening Ceremonies.

This is a listing of members of our community who have passed away since the last In Memoriam list was compiled for Pemmi-Con and Chengdu last year. This covers the period from July 9, 2023 to July 15, 2024. Any submission received after the 15th July was passed along to Seattle Worldcon.

(2) BIG HEART AWARD. The recipient was honored during Opening Ceremonies. “This award is given to those who go above and beyond in welcoming new people to fandom, and supporting the ideals of fandom.”

(3) SPECIAL COMMITTEE AWARD. Glasgow 2024 is giving a Special Committee Award to the game Dungeons & Dragons. The award is described as “an armadillo with a traffic cone on its head, and a resin die underneath it”. Okay. Photograph on Flickr.

(4) CHINESE VIDEO TOUR OF GLASGOW DEALERS ROOM. [Item by Ersatz Culture.] From the Eight Light Minutes publisher’s Weibo, a 47 minute video. See it at the link: 2024Worldcon  @八光分文化的微博 – 微博. I think there might be footage of other areas, but I only skim-watched bits of it.

(5) A NATION OF RIBBON CLERKS. Here are a couple examples of private edition ribbons people are handing out at Glasgow 2024.

Hugo, Girl! podcast is distributing this set. (Photo courtesy of Scott Edelman).

On behalf of Diabolical Plots:

(6) A CALL FOR GRACE. Caitlin R. Kiernan suspects their criticisms here will be “Falling on Deaf Ears”, a blog entry at Dear Sweet Filthy World.

…I made [two posts] to Facebook, and I will say up front, yes, both were inspired by the way I’ve seen George R.R. Martin slurred and mocked over nothing in the past couple of weeks. The most childish, mean-spirited, petty shit, and often from authors I thought I respected, who I would have imaged to be above schoolyard taunts. Generally, I usually miss the stuff, Writers bore me, and I tend to avoid them online….

[The second was:] We are all standing on the shoulders of giants. Don’t like that? Tough. We can do what we can do because someone was there before us. This is very true in publishing, maybe especially true in speculative fiction. And we should show respect to our elders (and that’s what they are), even when their poltics do not align with our own. You think you’d have as many opportunities had there never been a, say, George R.R. Martin? Really? We *owe* these people. They opened doors, and, you know, if they don’t fit *your* sensibilities, stop and think of all the reasons that might be. Jesus, did we forget how to cut folks some slack? I think we did. This is not about who was the most transgressive or progressive at some earlier point in history; this is about having the decency to respect those who have gone before. Egalitarianism is all fine and well, until it becomes an excuse to act like a shit.
Postcript: Fuck, I’m 60. Stop and try to imagine what it was like just getting publishers to buy stories about queer and trans characters when I began publishing in 1993…

…This is why I have never been part of this “community,” why I have never even really tried….

(7) MEANWHILE, ABOUT THOSE CHENGDU HUGOS. The Chengdu Worldcon Hugo Awards belonging to non-attending winners arrived in the United States in late January, but as Dave McCarty told Chris Barkley, all of the display cases and some of the awards were damaged in transit from China. They either needed to be repaired, or replacement parts made. There having been no word five months later, in June, Barkley started asking those waiting if they’d gotten theirs. Nope. Now there’s been some action – and the results are alarming. Here’s a Hugo just received by a Hugo, Girl! podcaster.

(8) CLARION WEST COMMENTS ON GAIMAN, DISCUSSES THEIR POLICIES. Clarion West has posted a statement about the allegations against Gaiman and more specifically about how they select instructors and respond to sexual harassment or abuse at the workshop. They issue a call for transparency and action in the SFF community as a whole. “Silence Does Not Lend Itself To Change”.

News of the allegations against Neil Gaiman began breaking as this year’s six-week workshop hurtled into its third week. As we emerge from the workshop and have time to process this news, our board and staff want to take a moment to recognize that a culture of silence and protecting prominent authors has been widespread in the SFF community, and that it often disproportionately affects the most marginalized and vulnerable in our society. The silence, and its impact, is not acceptable. 

This is an important conversation for everyone in the SFF community about protecting the most vulnerable in our industry from predation, and how to learn to listen to victims and make it easier for them to come forward without causing them further harm.

The Clarion West board of directors and our entire team are deeply invested in establishing a safe and harassment-free environment for those who participate in our programs. 

How do we do this? 

We believe that personal behavior is as important as professional standing and endeavor to make selections for instructors based on what we know of their personal and professional comportment. The process for instructor selection allows for concerns to be heard, both during selection meetings and privately. 

To address concerns around instructor behavior, Clarion West has had a written instructor policy against harassment or sexual misconduct with students for at least 25 years. This policy is given to every workshop instructor. Neil Gaiman received a copy of this policy when he taught for us in 2013. Organizers were not aware of accusations or inappropriate behavior by Gaiman prior to inviting him, nor were they made aware of any abusive behavior during his tenure. 

In more recent years, the organization has created and posted our Code of Conduct and an Anti-Harassment Policy publicly. We’ve made significant efforts to improve the process for students, staff, and community members to report harassment as well as the procedure for investigation and follow-up. The organization seeks to create transparency around the workshop and all programs. 

Clarion West takes any reports of misconduct among our community members seriously and is dedicated to improving the experience of writers in speculative fiction, especially those historically underrepresented in publishing. We pledge to continuously review and update our policies, investigate accusations thoroughly, and work toward maintaining safe and inclusive spaces.

If you have information to share, concerns or questions about our policies, or wish to report abusive behavior related to the workshop or other Clarion West programs, please contact us at report@clarionwest.org

(9) JEFF WARNER OBIT. Veteran conrunner Jeff Warner, who co-founded I-CON, has died. Michael Dauenheimer paid tribute on the convention’s Facebook page.

For those of you who weren’t fortunate enough to know Jeff Warner, he showed a life-long devotion to Science Fiction fandom. As a Stony Brook student, Jeff was one of the founding members of I-CON, helping to plan and run the first one on the SB campus in 1982.

He was also heavily involved with the Science Fiction Forum during his students years and continued to show concern and be involved when he could, attending reunions and staying touch with old friends.

Jeff was one of a kind. One of those unforgettable characters that you thought only existed in movies. He was definitely a people person and showed more “team spirit” than any athlete possibly could. When it came to conventions, Jeff tried to attend as many as he could, more often than not, volunteering to help them run. To him it was his passion to promote and foster Science Fiction fandom….

He will be greatly missed by many. He will not be forgotten.

Warner was briefly onscreen and is named in the credits of The People vs George Lucas (2010), a documentary about Star Wars fans. He was active as a File 770 contributing editor, supplying the titles of three Scrolls: Pixel Scroll 9/4 The Scrolling Stones, Pixel Scroll 12/28/19 Pixel Gadol Hayah Scroll, and Pixel Scroll 2/4/24 Pixel, Pixel, Scroll And Stumble. File Churn And Cauldron Double.

(10) COMICS SECTION.

(11) I GET MY SIDEKICKS FROM. [Item by Daniel Dern.] A CBR.com columnist granted a reader’s wish to give superheroes kid sidekicks: “Line it is Drawn: Superheroes Gain New Kid Sidekicks”. The image of Doctor Manhattan’s new sidekick Kid Manhattan image is obviously (to those of us with long memories etc) an homage to this Superman cover (per “Supergirl’s First Comic Appearance: Everything Fans Need To Know”.

(12) GOOD NEWS FOR FANHISTORIANS. Richard Graeme Cameron was happy to announce today that the audio department of the Special Collections Library at Simon Fraser University of Burnaby B.C. has offered to conserve and digitize the audio tapes of early VCON convention events. The other day Cameron had put out a plea for a collection that would take responsibility for them.

Simon Fraser University Science Fiction Society (SF3) was one of the three organizations sponsoring the first VCON back in April of 1971. The other two sponsors were the B.C. Science Fiction Association (BCSFA) and the University of B.C. Science Fiction Society (UBC SFFEN). Note that SFU fen contributed to ongoing VCONs for many years thereafter.

I am absolutely thrilled, in that at some point in the near future interested fen world-wide will finally be able to hear these treasured recordings from the past.

Precise details have yet to be worked out, but I am confident the tapes will be transferred well before the end of the month and conservation work begun.

(13) I CAN’T BELIEVE MY EARS. “Cate Blanchett says ‘no one got paid anything’ for ‘Lord of the Rings’” according to CNN.

Actress Cate Blanchett may have starred in the box office smash hit “The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring,” but, according to her, that money didn’t trickle down to the cast.

During an appearance on “Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen,” Blanchett played “Plead the Fifth” and was asked about the film for which she received the biggest paycheck.

“I think it’s probably ‘Lord of the Rings,’” Cohen suggested

“Are you kidding me,” Blanchett said as Cohen expressed surprised. “No. No one got paid anything to do that movie.”

When Cohen asked whether she “got a piece of the backend,” referring to the practice of big stars getting a percentage of the ticket sales, Blanchett said no.

“That was way before any of that,” she said. “No, nothing.”

Blanchett said she did the 2001 film for the chance to work with Peter Jackson, who directed “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy.

“I wanted to work with the guy who made [1992 horror comedy film] ‘Braindead,’” she said. “I mean, I basically got free sandwiches. And I got to keep my ears.”…

(14) ICONIC ANIMATION. One of the items in Heritage Auction’s “The History of Animation – The Glad Museum Collection Signature® Auction” running from August 16–19 is this cell from “The Jetsons Opening Title Sequence: Judy and George Jetson”.

It’s time to meet ponytailed “Daughter Judy” as daddy George gets her ready to zoom to class, in this iconic image from the classic opening sequence of this beloved animated series. This is an extremely rare original hand-inked, hand-painted 12 field two-level production cel setup with an original Jetsons sky view production background painting, gouache on board. The Jetsons originally ran on ABC-TV for a single 24-episode season in 1962-63…

(15) COLLABORATORS AND QUISLINGS. The UK’s Society of Authors is concerned about publishers licensing their catalogues to AI companies.

(16) SWIPER, DON’T SWIPE. And the Creators’ Rights Alliance has sent a warning to AI technology companies.

The Creators’ Rights Alliance (CRA) has today (7 August 2024) reaffirmed that its member organisations and the creators that they represent do not consent to their works being used to develop generative artificial intelligence (AI) by sending letters to AI technology companies.

The CRA, which represents over 500,000 creators through its member organisations, said that they ‘do not authorise or otherwise grant permission for the use of any of their works protected by copyright and/or related rights (including performers rights) in relation to, without limitation, the training, development, or operation of AI models.’

Download the full letter here

To date, generative AI models have been developed using vast amounts of copyright-protected work without consent, transparency over data sources or remuneration for rightsholders and creators. The copying of rights-protected works without authorisation is against UK law.

[Thanks to Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, Steven French, Dan’l, Ersatz Culture, Marnee Chua, Kathy Sullivan, Teddy Harvia, Mike Kennedy, Andrew Porter, John King Tarpinian, and Chris Barkley for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day Soon Lee.]