Elliot Shorter, Follow-Up

Joel Silverberg reported online after visiting Elliot Shorter on May 4: “He looked SO much better than when we saw him last! He was awake, alert, and communicative. He recognized us, and we chatted for about 5 or 10 minutes. He is still very tired.” Shorter remains in the intensive care unit of Rhode Island Hospital.

Harry Potter Falls Off NYT Best-Seller List

The Toronto Star reports: “This Sunday’s New York Times will be Potter-less for the first time since Dec. 27, 1998, when Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (as series opener Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone was titled in the U.S.) made its debut on the paper’s bestseller list. The streak has ended with the dropping of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, published last July.”

Best-selling sf or fantasy novels rarely get any play from Hugo voters, but a lot of fans enjoyed the stories and even more were grateful to Rowling for inspiring many children’s love of reading. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban was a Best Novel Hugo nominee in 2000. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire actually won the award in 2001.

The ensuing controversy over a fantasy novel winning the Hugo (completely within the rules) does not seem enough to explain why another Harry Potter novel never made the final ballot. After all, every Harry Potter movie has been a Best Dramatic Presentation Hugo finalist: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone nominated in 2002, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets in 2003, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban in 2005, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire in 2006, and Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix in 2008.

Fanotchka Revival

The script of Andy Hooper’s faanish play “Fanotchka,” first performed at L.A.con III in 1996, has been formatted and posted on eFanzines by Lenny Bailes. Hooper’s pastiche of Ernst Lubitsch’s 1939 film Ninotchka, starring Greta Garbo and Melvyn Douglas, now receives its online premiere after appearing in Bailes’ fanzine Whistlestar. The text is superbly illustrated by Steve Stiles and Alan White.

Elliot Shorter Medical Update

Elliot Shorter had surgery on May 1 to amputate one of his feet, reports Linda Bushyager, based on a post in last Saturday’s Virtual Fandom chatroom. Shorter is suffering total kidney failure. He was in the ICU at Rhode Island Hospital, Providence RI at the time of the report.

Shorter’s many claims to faanish fame include being elected the 1970 TAFF delegate, actually writing (some of) a TAFF report and, in his younger days, chronically being mistaken for pro football player Roosevelt Grier. (And that just barely scratches the surface.)

Monrovia Couple in Good Company

Azusa Pacific University’s Media Relations people have been an enormous help in attracting attention to Diana’s book, The Company They Keep. Thanks to their press release about her Hugo nomination, a local paper sent reporter Evelyn Barge to interview the two of us for an article that appeared April 24.

I liked Evelyn’s well-written article very much, because most of the focus was on Diana and her book — and there was no taint of “crazy Buck Rogers stuff” at all.

Staff photographer Sarah Reingewirtz came by a couple days after the interview to shoot the pictures. She had Diana and I pose in our shared office: I was surprised that she was able to make our fannish mess appear so photogenic. She took another series of photos with me gazing profoundly at my Hugo rockets’ reflection in a mirror. Does it remind anyone else of Jan van Eyck’s use of the mirror in his “Arnolfini Wedding” portrait?

There was one error in the article, for which I am to blame: “But this year, the Monrovia couple have both of their names printed on the ballot, only the second time in the 55-year history of the Hugo Awards that a married couple have been nominated in the same year for independent projects.”

I remembered that in 1977 Kate Wilhelm got nominated for Best Novel and Damon Knight for Best Short Story. However, when the question was posed to the Smofs list, Mark Olson immediately pointed out the many nominations for independent work by two other couples, David Hartwell and Kathryn Cramer, and Kristine Kathryn Rusch and Dean Wesley Smith.

In 1989, 1990, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 David Hartwell was nominated for Best Editor, while he and Kathryn Cramer also were among the editors of Best Semiprozine nominee New York Review of Science Fiction.

Then, in 1993 and again in 1994, when Kristine Kathryn Rusch was nominated for the Best Editor Hugo for her work on The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, her husband, Dean Wesley Smith, also got a Best Semiprozine Hugo nomination for Pulphouse (edited in 1994 with Jonathan Bond).

Other couples may belong on the list. There are several instances where spouses co-edited a Hugo-nominated fanzine, and in the same year, one was nominated for Best Fan Writer. Did Charlie Brown do fanwriting outside of Locus? (Not that I recall.) Did Susan (Glicksohn) Wood write elsewhere than Energumen in the years it was up for the Hugo? (Probably, but the Internet is of limited help in researching fanzines published as long ago as 1972.) What about Teresa Nielsen Hayden, who was a fanwriter nominee in 1984, the same year Izzard was up for the Hugo? (Quite possibly – let’s find out.)

The newspaper headline remains true: “Monrovia Couple in Good Company.” A lot of good company… 

Best and Worst Endings

SF Signal: MIND MELD for May 1 poses the question “Which science fiction or fantasy book has the best ending? Which one has the worst ending?” to panelists Jayme Lynn Blaschke, Holly Black, Mark Chadbourn, L. E. Modesitt, Jr., Matthew Sanborn Smith, Paul Graham Raven, Gail Z. Martin, James Bloomer, Richard Novak, Jonathan McCalmont, Kate Elliott, Jay Tomio and me. Almost needless to say, there are spoilers….

LeGuin’s Lavinia

Ursula K. LeGuin’s reading in Seattle from Lavinia, her new novel, is discussed at length by Rick Simonson in Publisher’s Weekly:

To me, it’s fascinating (and inspirational) enough, alone, to see her keep at things, persistently, insistently. Lavinia is a brilliant recasting of Virgil’s Aeneid, done in a way that doesn’t take issue with [what] Virgil did 2,000 years ago, so much as it makes a large story even larger in spirit – and engaged imagination….

[Thanks to Andrew Porter for the link.]

Bill Mills Starts Virtual Fan Lounge

Bill Mills, encouraged by the success of last weekend’s Corflu Silver Virtual Con Suite, is launching a continuous Virtual Fan Lounge utilizing the same software.

According to Arnie Katz: “As with the Virtual Con Suite, the Virtual Fan Lounge will have live and re-broadcast video feeds when available and will feature slide shows of fannish photos, cartoons or other graphics when there’s no video to show.

“The first live video feed will occur on Saturday, May 3. The Vegrants invite you to join them for their meeting, which is likely to include music by Bill Mills and Teresa Cochran and discussions featuring some of the Vegrants. The approximate starting time is 8:00 p.m. PDT (but it wouldn’t hurt to check in earlier). The Virtual Fan Lounge will have a live feed from the club on the first and third Saturdays of every month.”

To visit The Virtual Fan Lounge go to LasVegrants.com. Select “Virtual Fan Lounge” from the menu. That will take you to a page of information about the chat room which includes a link to the Virtual Fan Lounge. Registration and sign-in is only required to participate,  not to read.

Update 5/2/08: Corrected registration requirement to match what it says at the site.

Looking for the Borrowers

Julia Eccleshare paints a depressing picture of the future of public libraries in an article for The Guardian

“They need more borrowers and yet, one of their biggest problems, in my experience, is that ‘borrowing’ is not a readily understood modern concept, however well-embedded it was in Carnegie’s day.”

Why are so many books never returned? (Or stolen, as they quaintly said in Carnegie’s day.) Eccleshare thinks this is a symptom of today’s free-access-to-everything society. But is a change in culture really to blame?

Theft has been the bane of public libraries since they opened. What’s more, science fiction writers and fans have done some of the pilfering, and been none too shy about admitting it.

Harlan Ellison told fans at a LASFS banquet in 1970 that as a boy he stole the entire Encyclopedia Britannica from the library one volume at a time, smuggling them under his shirt. He was only caught at the end when he tried to take the Worldbook and Gazeteer on the same day.

Then, my local library hosted a science fiction discussion group when I was in high school. The librarian told us that the book most often stolen from the branch was Mein Kampf. While she was out of the room, two of the members of the group agreed, yes, that’s how they’d acquired their copies. (Yipes!)

So has this long-term problem actually gotten worse? Or has the effect only been intensified by the real cause of the libraries’ plight, dwindling financial support for book purchases by public libraries? I would infer that to be the case after reading Jerry Pournelle’s observations on Chaos Manor that he could formerly rely on libraries accounting for thousands of hardcover sf sales, but no longer.

It would be interesting to know whether the suspected change in public behavior has really happened. It may simply be that libraries suffering thefts don’t have the same liberty to replace stolen books.  

[Thanks to John Mansfield and the CBA News for the links.]