2011 Prix Aurora Nominees

Finalists for the 2011 Prix Aurora were announced at Boréal on May 15. The full list appears after the jump.

Stunningly, nothing was nominated in the Best Fan Publications category, vacated by the administrators with the explanation, “No award will be given out in this category due insufficient eligible nominees.”

Really?

The country that gave us Mike Glicksohn, Chester Cuthbert, and Susan Wood hasn’t stopped producing all kinds of traditional fanzines and sf blogs. What about R. Graeme Cameron, Garth Spencer or that James Davis Nicoll fellow? What’s the story?

The presence of the word “eligible” makes the announcement more mysterious, not less. It’s sheer nonsense to think all the Canadian fanzines and sf blogs we know fail to qualify in some way, despite that being what the use of “eligible” suggests. Now if the real problem is that hardly anybody submitted a vote in this category, or the only nominee declined, or they didn’t get enough nominees and won’t run a category unless voters nominate at least three things (I observe that’s the number of nominees in the other three fan categories), wouldn’t the explanation be worded differently?

It’s not like anything is barred from competing that a fanzine fan might expect to see on the final ballot. The Prix Aurora category definition is at least as broad as the comparable Hugo category:

Best fanzine or fan newsletter or publication either in print or by electronic means, whose content significantly relates to Science Fiction or Fantasy, published by a Canadian at least once during the previous calendar year.

This category covers both paper and web fanzines.  It can also include on-line fan-run blogs or review sites.  We require that a significant amount of their content to be dedicated to Science Fiction and Fantasy genre-related topics such as books, movies, comics, gaming, filk or conventions.  They can not be ones that have commercial products for sale or be dedicated to a professional group or person.  It must be fannish in nature.

The rule obviously keeps the country’s most famous sf writer and a prolific blogger, Robert Sawyer, out of the fan category. How it has prevented all the rest of the Canadian fanpublishing community from being “eligible” is not so obvious.

Voting is open until October 15.

Click on the link for the full list of Aurora nominees.

Continue reading

Your 15 Bytes of Fame

Like a passenger liner when the gawkers rush to one side of the deck, the internet tilted toward Aidan Moher’s A Dribble of Ink blog the day he posted the 2011 Hugo nominees along with several pithy comments.

What he said about the fan nominees touched a few raw nerves:

Maybe I’m exposing my ignorance here, but beyond StarShipSofa, I haven’t heard of a damn one, nor am I familiar with any of the writers. My beef, obviously, is the lack of presence of blogs, bloggers and online writers. Where’re the Nialls (Harrison and Alexander)? Where’s Abigail Nussbaum or Adam Whitehead? No nod for SF Signal? Really?

Three of our Best Fan Writer nominees, James Davis Nicoll, Steven H Silver and Chris Garcia weighed in (this sentence wants to end “all on the same electric day” as they say in “Seventy-Six Trombones,” and I find myself powerless to prevent it.)

It’s a good rule of thumb that if people rush to defend something then that thing probably needs a defense. Which is to say, since the fans behind the Hugo rules changes explicitly claimed they were throwing open the gates to electronically-distributed fanac it’s reasonable to ask whether it worked. Bloggers James Nicoll and Frederik Pohl made their first appearances as finalists in the Best Fan Writer category last year, but Nicoll is the only blogger nominated this year (though Silver and Garcia are widely represented online in other ways). And why has the list of Best Fanzine nominees changed only slightly faster than the faces on Mount Rushmore? Keep that question in mind, it’s a good one, I’ll return to it in the next post.

A Hearing Problem: But I’ll begin where Moher began, with his provocative declaration “I haven’t heard of a damn one” of the nominees (besides last year’s Best Fanzine winner.)

Don’t most fans begin by using awards shortlists to find more of the kind of stories we like? After I read all the Asimov, Heinlein, Bradbury, Aldiss etc. on the library shelves, if I had money to buy books I’d look for writers identified as Hugo and Nebula Award winners, treating that as a seal of approval for the ones I didn’t already know. A lot of readers have done that.    

Yet once we come to regard ourselves as veterans of the sf field, something changes. We are less likely to welcome the Hugos and Nebulas as an introduction to unfamiliar talents and more likely to judge the shortlists on the basis of whether they validate our subjective opinions about the writers we already know.

This is no less true in the fan categories. When something we’ve never heard of gets nominated for an award in a field we purport to follow, that’s now considered an offense instead of an opportunity.

I’ve had these feelings myself. In 2008 Pixel took second place in the Fanzine Activity Achievement Awards. What? I’d never heard of it! However, I knew better than to get on my high horse and announce, “Dang it, I’ve never even heard of Pixel!” Fannish fanzines comprise a much smaller universe than the internet, much too small for anybody who purports to be a follower to get away with that sort of thing. Instead I said nothing and remedied my ignorance by reading all 15 issues at eFanzines. Dave Burton’s Pixel was, indeed, one of the very best fanzines, filled with excellent writing by Dave Locke, Eric Mayer and others. But for my need to supply a bad example here, I’d never have mentioned such a hideous gap in my knowledge of the field.

Isn’t it a better idea, when something that’s never been on our radar gets nominated for a top award, to call in the radar repairman? At least try to take it in stride.

There are still between 100 and 200 fanzines produced in magazine format by sf fans. There are probably twice that many blogs that deal with literary sf and fandom (I’m counting those by pro writers but not the media-focused and commercial ones). Very few fans have time to keep up with the whole universe of zines or blogs, let alone both. Unless someone is putting in that work, what can it really mean if he or she has never heard of an award nominee?

Dana Wynter (1931-2011)

Actress Dana Wynter, 79, who starred in 1956’s classic Invasion of the Body Snatchers, died May 5 of congestive heart failure at a hospital in Ojai, Calif. In 1994, the Library of Congress put the film on the National Film Registry. The film’s star, Kevin McCarthy, died in September of last year.

Born Dagmar Winter on June 8, 1931, in Berlin, she grew up in England and Southern Rhodesia, now Zimbabwe, where her father was a surgeon.

[Thanks to Andrew Porter for the story.]

Look for Aurora Nominees on May 15

The Prix Aurora Award nominees will be revealed at Boréal in Montreal on May 15.

Before that happens, the winners of the Prix Aurora/Boréal (given for work in French) will be announced. Its shortlist was already announced and voted upon:

The Prix Aurora/Boréal Awards ceremony is slated for Sunday, May 15, at the Hôtel Espresso (1005 rue Guy, Montréal), between 16:00 and 17:00. The master of ceremonies will be Alain Ducharme. Jean-Louis Trudel will present the Prix Aurora Boréal for Best Novel (in French) (as a CSFFA Director) and also the $500 cheque for Best Novel on behalf of SF Canada (of whose executive he is a member-at-large). Aurora nominee pins will be presented to the nominees on-site.

[Via Auroran Lights #4.]

Snapshots 63 Groats in a Guinea

Here are 11 developments of interest to fans:

(1) It was the brightest space explosion in history:

Astronomers suspect what we are seeing is an unfortunate star that drifted too close to a supermassive black hole at the center of its galaxy and was ripped apart by fierce gravity. The ionized gases released by the star’s destruction formed a swirling “disk of plasma” around the black hole, which blasted unimaginable beams of energy out into space. It’s these that we are continuing to see.

“Blasted unimaginable beams of energy” – you don’t often see a science journalist dipping a pen into E.E. Smith’s incandescent inkwell this way, though to be completely fair to Doc his prose was even more colorful – he’d have written, “ravening beams of coruscating energy.”

Still, it isn’t any wonder the tone of the article inspired David Klaus to comment, “R.I.P. for any planetary civilizations in a direct line within that galaxy. They just got blasted into gamma-ray death.”

(2) A Chaos Manor correspondent points out that when a German TV news channel reported the Bin Laden killing they made a little mistake:

Unfortunately, in its haste to offer a SEAL logo, someone at the station actually mustered the logo of the “Star Trek” Maquis Special Operations Seals Team VI–a bunch of nasty little 24th century terrorists.

(3) The Library of Congress opened its ”National Jukebox” website on May 10, which seems worth knowing even if there isn’t any stfnal content in the first 10,000 Edison discs and Victor platters. These old recordings are in themselves a kind of time machine:

The Library of Congress is flipping a switch Tuesday that will open a large chunk of the national archive of more than 3 million music and spoken-word recordings archive public streaming as part of a new National Jukebox project, a joint venture between the library and Sony Music that will give free access to thousands of Sony-controlled recordings long out of circulation because of commercial or copyright issues.

Some of the 10,000 titles streamable at the new National Jukebox website have been unavailable for more than 100 years, a significant chunk of them because of complex laws controlling ownership of sound recordings, which did not become subject to federal copyright laws until 1972….

“The only artist whose work has remained in print since it was recorded is Caruso,” added Matthew Barton, the library’s curator of recorded sound. “You’ve always been able to get Caruso, in whatever the current formats were. But he wasn’t the only star of the day, he wasn’t the only opera singer recording — but he’s the only one that has been consistently available from the rights holder.”

A lot of rarities here. For example, I listened to this recording of Sousa’s Band playing “Stars and Stripes Forever”.

(4) Naomi Alderman’s Borrowed Time was described on BBC Radio 4’s World At One as “the first Doctor Who book to be written by a literary novelist” (May 6 program, about 23 minutes in.)

Steve Green dryly comments: “[That] must come as a surprise to Michael Moorcock. To be fair to Naomi, she dismissed any distinctions between ‘literary’ and ‘genre’ in the subsequent interview. “

(5) Plans for a Do-it-yourself Dalek are posted in an article at The Telegraph:

While every Doctor Who fan knows that the robot mutants were created by the evil scientist Davros from the planet Skaro, these blueprints were road-tested by Sixth Formers at a school in North London.

An introduction to the plans, which would challenge even those with years of assembling Ikea furniture, noted that the pupils were able to construct a “magnficient black-and-orange specimen” in just two weeks, at a cost of £12.

The text of the cover letter originally sent with the plans appears in Letters of Note. I got a chuckle from one of the comments on the post:

I am just about old enough to remember the Radio Times Doctor Who 10th anniversary magazine that really did contain blueprints for a Dalek. Okay, I’m easily that old.

(6) The LA Times tells about a funding crisis facing the Allen Telescope Array, run by the SETI Institute near Mt. Shasta (CA), an enormous ear listening for any sign of intelligent life in the universe:

The search was based on the premise that alien races, like us, would use microwave transmissions and we might be able to hear them.

In 1993, Congress killed the funding. That could have spelled the end of the search, but large donors, including Hewlett-Packard executives and Paul Allen, co-founder of Microsoft, pulled out their checkbooks to keep it alive.

SETI researchers for years relied on borrowed telescope time to scan thousands of stars for a signal that could have been produced only by someone else out there. All that changed in 2008, when the 42-telescope array was built here with a $30-million gift from Allen, for whom it is named.

The array was intended to be a first step toward development of a full 350-dish array, which the institute predicted would catch a promising signal every few hours, and a serious candidate every six months. But the institute was unable to attract enough donations and grants to expand it.

(7) I’m glad to hear that “aerospace archeology” is one of the missions supported by the military at Cape Canaveral:

At first glance, Thomas Penders’ job with the 45th Space Wing may seem like walking a tightrope.

As an aerospace archaeologist and cultural resource manager at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station, Fla., he ensures the 45th SW can continue to be America’s premier gateway to space through unhindered development on the Cape. On the other hand, he has a responsibility to protect the Cape’s 5,000 years of history from that very development.

The two missions, however, go hand-in hand.

Mr. Penders has one goal in mind: to help ensure the 45th SW and the Air Force are stewards of the past while continuing their space mission. He must survey each of the Cape’s 16,000 acres before a construction project must be stopped because excavators have found a pre-historic migratory camp, a 150-year-old unmarked grave or part of a 50-year-old launch complex buried by vegetation.

(8) Loved this review of Ghost Stories stage play in Toronto:

Despite being a fairly faint-hearted fellow myself and, unlike my British counterparts, forbidden from drinking on the job, I strapped on my Medic Alert bracelet and bravely gave Ghost Stories a try. Disappointingly, the show didn’t quite live up to its horrific reputation and I remain unhospitalized. It’s a lark with a few skilled chills, but Toronto’s emergency rooms aren’t about to be inundated with cases of ghost-traumatic stress syndrome. Ghost Stories is set up as a lecture given by a skeptical professor of parapsychology – incidentally, a very similar conceit to local theatre company Unspun’s 2006 Fringe horror hit Minotaur. In his years of ghost hunting, Dr. Philip Goodman (Jason Blicker) tells us, he has interviewed only three men who have shaken his non-belief in ghosts, and their stories are the subject of the evening.

(9) The Penneys forwarded a Toronto Craigslist ad from someone seeking an investor in their Anti-Gravity propulsion engine. “After many years of research going through the full spectrum of quantum math, physics and beyond, we are at the point where we want to take concepts from paper into prototype. If this area of development interests you then please do get in touch.” Sounds like just the sort of thing Jack Aubrey would have squandered his prize money on.

(10) Classic old Star Wars fanhistory here:

For the documentary, the early convention footage was donated to filmmaker Tom Wyrsch by the estate of the late Bob Wilkins, host of the locally-broadcast Creature Features show, which ran from 1971-84 (Wilkins hosted until 1979). In it, Wilkins’ camera man captures rare 16mm images of Star Wars fandom in its infancy on display at the Space-Cons, emerging from the well-established Star Trek fandom juggernaut that exploded after the show’s cancellation in 1969.

(11) Rose Fox at Genreville watched live online coverage of the Hugo nominee announcement. She complimented the poise shown by the announcer as he named the Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form nominees:

I greatly admire the dignity with which the Admiral announced the fourth item.

“The Lost Thing,” of course, has already won an Oscar; will a Hugo be anticlimactic?

Well played, Rose. The “fourth item” was the nominee with Bradbury in the title — so it’s only right that it be followed by something “anticlimactic.”

Elsewhere in the same post Rose voiced some slight dissatisfaction:

I suspect there’s a list of people who get embargoed press releases. I am not on that list. I should find out how to get on that list.

Yes, it’s evident an embargoed press release was circulated ahead of the official announcement. I can’t speak from personal experience, just that the comments I’ve seen on the subject indicate that’s the case. But I wouldn’t say the subject is worthy of even the trivial amount of controversy I may generate by discussing it at all.

Ask yourself, how does any news reporter benefit from receiving the Hugo nominees in an embargoed press release? Let’s assume everybody behaves professionally and honors the guidelines for releasing the information, which in this case probably meant holding it until the end of the online announcement (as everyone seems to have done.)  Does the reporter really have the jump on anyone? No. Anything they do with the press release happens after an online announcement, doubtless echoed by any number of people on Twitter or blogs. And if the Worldcon is taking care of its business, after the list has been posted to the convention website. The only benefit of having an advanced copy of the list is that a reporter can ready the text (and comments, if any) for distribution at the moment the embargo is lifted, rather than having to begin the process at the moment the general announcement is made. It’s perfectly reasonable that Rose, a Publishers Weekly blogger trying to report the news in realtime, would want to be added to such a list. She’s to be congratulated for succeeding with the resources available to her.

All else is vanity, as they say. Who doesn’t want to be one of the well-connected people walking around with the advance list of Hugo nominees in his pocket (on paper, PDA or phone)? If there’s any controversy it’s not about reporting news. There’s too little support for the argument that a reporter who didn’t get an advanced copy has suffered any genuine disadvantage.

[Thanks for these links goes out to David Klaus, Isaac Alexander, Lloyd and Yvonne Penney, Steve Green, Chaos Manor and Andrew Porter.]

99 Days and Counting

Bloggers who ran the latest Renovation press release yesterday did not have to make any excuses about deviating from its official title “100 Days and Counting.” But I know my eagle-eyed readers won’t let a stale date pass without comment.

In fact, Ted White will probably want to know why I didn’t adjust it to “98 Days” — because when this is posted WordPress isn’t going to display a Pacific zone timestamp but some timezone in Laos. And why don’t you fix that, Mike, you may be asking. Well, I will have to try again. But you see, we’re on Laotian time as a result of my original attempt to update the default setting, which started on Greenwich time…

Getting back to the press release (whose full text follows the jump), the most interesting part is the roll call of all-star science fiction talent already committed to be on the program:

Renovation has also confirmed over 300 program participants. The list includes a wide range of leading science fiction writers, editors, publishers, critics, artists and fans. Notable writers who will be appearing on the Renovation program include Guest of Honor Tim Powers (whose On Stranger Tides is the basis for the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film), George RR Martin (whose fantasy series “A Song of Ice and Fire” has recently been made into a widely acclaimed HBO miniseries), Greg Bear, Greg Benford, David Brin, Lois McMaster Bujold, Cory Doctorow, Alastair Reynolds, Kim Stanley Robinson, Robert J Sawyer, John Scalzi, Robert Silverberg, Charles Stross, Harry Turtledove and Connie Willis. A strong presence from the comics and graphic novel community includes Paul Cornell (Action Comics, Captain Britain), Phil and Kaja Foglio (Girl Genius), Howard Tayler (Shlock Mercenary) and Bill Willingham (Fables). Major artists in attendance include Guest of Honor Boris Vallejo, Julie Bell, Bob Eggleton, Richard Hescox, Lee Moyer and John Picacio.

Continue reading

Twinkle Twinkle Little Bat

New York Times sports blogger Tyler Klepner just wanted to pass along an amusing story about how a Mets pitcher likes to nickname his bats after mythical weapons.

Unfortunately, reports the Gothamist, Klepner butchered the literary references and as a result the Times’ has been forced to print a correction giving a detailed explication of whose sword was called what and why in The Hobbit and Beowulf.

[Thanks to Janice Gelb and Steven H Silver for the link.]

E-Ditto 8

Eric Mayer begins one of his delightful essays in E-Ditto #8 [PDF file]:

Clark Ashton Smith had a way with words, mostly words I have never heard of.

Not only is the exploration of Smith’s rich fictional vocabulary well worth reading, I found it incredibly satisyfing that Smith’s purple prose would be discussed in an e-zine that graphically imitates Eric’s old dittoed fanzine, where the text is literally purple.

Open Signing on Nebula Weekend

More than 40 sf and fantasy writers will participate in a mass book signing as part of the Nebula Award Weekend. The event, which is open to the public, takes place on Friday, May 20 at 5:30-7:00 p.m. at the Washington Hilton, 1919 Connecticut NW, Washington, DC.

The list of those who have already indicated they plan to be at the book signing follows the jump.

[Thanks to Andrew Porter for the story, via Steven H Silver.]

Continue reading

Remembering a Library Opening

When the new Troy (MI) Public Library was opened in 1971, its librarian contacted many writers and public figures and asked them to send the children of Troy a letter to commemorate the event. She received dozens of responses. Among those who answered were America’s two most famous doctors at that time, Dr. Benjamin Spock and Doctor Seuss, and stfnal figures like Kingsley Amis, Isaac Asimov, Vincent Price, and the astronaut Neil Armstrong.

There was also a touching, insightful letter from E.B. White. Here is an excerpt. The full text is posted by Letters of Note:

A library is a good place to go when you feel unhappy, for there, in a book, you may find encouragement and comfort. A library is a good place to go when you feel bewildered or undecided, for there, in a book, you may have your question answered. Books are good company, in sad times and happy times, for books are people—people who have managed to stay alive by hiding between the covers of a book.

[Thanks to John King Tarpinian for the link.]

Update 05/09/2011: Corrected, oh, everything!