“I’m in. All the way! Tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock…”
– Will Reeves, Episode Four
Episode 4: “If You Don’t Like My Story, Write Your Own.” Written by Damon Lindelof and Christal, Directed by Andrij Parekh.
Episode 5: “Little Fear of Lightning.” Written by Damon Lindelof & Carly Wray, Directed by Steph Green.
Episode 6: “This Extraordinary Being.” Written by Damon Lindelof & Cord Jefferson, Directed by Stephen Williams.
As I entered
the middle passage of the Watchmen mini-series, I was literally on pins
and needles wondering if Damon Lindelof and company were going to serve up more
narrative curve balls. Needless to say, I was NOT disappointed…
In the fourth
episode, we are introduced to Lady Trieu (Hong Chau), the mysterious
Viet-American billionaire who swept up Adrian Veidt’s assets after his
disappearance. In the opening moments, she commits a rather shocking piece of
extortion (that was chillingly reminiscent of some of the shenanigans they used
to pull on J.J. Abrams’ Fox series, Fringe) just before a spacecraft
crash lands on their property.
Angela (Regina King) finds her hijacked car but unfortunately for her, so does
Laurie (Jean Smart), who impounds it and finds her grandfather’s fingerprints
inside. What Laurie doesn’t find are a bottle of pills in the glove compartment
that he apparently left for Angela to find. Angela takes them to the only
person she truly trusts, Looking Glass (Tim Blake Nelson), so they can be
independently analyzed by his ex-wife.
of the evidence of her grandfather’s stay in her police hideout, Angela spies a
masked vigilante tailing her. She gives chase but her prey proves to be a bit
too slippery for her to catch.
It turns out
there’s another connection with the car that leads Laurie, Petey and Sister
Night directly to the immense Millenium Clock project complex. They meet with
the mysterious Lady Trieu and her daughter, Bian, who both pledge their full
cooperation in the investigation. Trieu also passes along a message to Night from
her grandfather in Vietnanese, which she coldly deflects.
Trieu and Will
have a plan in motion; they want Angela to be a part of it, but Will insists
that his granddaughter must figure out what’s going on on her own. Otherwise,
he reasons, she won’t accept the truth directly from him. Trieu disagrees,
saying family entanglements may endanger their agenda. Will reaffirms that he
is in, no matter what may come.
Adrian Veidt continues to test the limits of his virtual prison by catapulting
the corpses of his clones slaves up in the air to an unknown void…
gave us the inside story on how Wade Tillman (Tim Blake Nelson) became the
sardonic Looking Glass, the human lie detector. When the infamous giant squid
was teleported into New York City in 1985, Tillman was a teenager working as a
Jehovah’s Witness in neighboring Hoboken, New Jersey amusement park when it
happened. While he survived the attack, he was psychologically traumatized.
As a Tulsa cop,
he uses his keen powers of observation to interrogate suspects and solve
crimes. But those powers are of little use in his personal life; he’s divorced,
lives alone, has trouble connecting with people on a personal level and seems
to spend a great deal of time studying and/or living in fear of the next “squid
attack’ from another dimension.
Wade is also
under pressure at work; Chief Crawford’s murder remains unsolved and Laurie
Blake has taken control of the force for the forseeable future. She is also
pressuring Wade for information about Angela, whom she strongly suspects knows
more about the murder than she’s telling.
One of those
things is a bottle of pills that Angela desperately wanted analyzed. His ex-wife Cynthia informs Wade that the pills
are Nostalgia, a pharmaceutical memory aid that has been outlawed due to its
dangerous side effects. (It also turns out to be a drug that was invented and
marketed by Lady Trieu’s corporation!)
identity is market research consultant and his public service hobby is helping
people who are still traumatized by the 1985 attack or the infrequent “squid
drops” that keeps the populous on edge.
When Wade meets
Renee (Paula Malcolmson), a new member of the support group, he is initially
smitten with her until he spots a clue that indicates she may be a member of
the 7th Kalvary. He trails her to a warehouse but turns out to be a trap; Wade
is confronted by Senator Joe Keen, Jr. (James Wolk) who is seemingly using the
7th Kalvary as a front for his presidential aspirations. He offers Wade a
choice, either watch a video revealing the truth about the ‘alien invasion” or
have his life ruined by his operatives.
Keen also wants
Angela served up to Laurie and out of the way while the 7th Kavalry’s plan,
involving an elaborate teleportation system, goes operational.
In deep despair
over his newfound knowledge, Wade tells Angela about Nostalgia in the presence
of one of Laurie’s surveillance bugs and she openly admits her grandfather’s
involvement in Crawford’s death. When Laurie immediately moves in to arrest
her, Angela swallows all of Will’s pills…
powerful trebuchet and wearing a primitive pressure suite, Adrian is launched
into the air…and onto an airless moon. He rearranges the numerous corpses of
his clone servants into a distress message that may (or may not) be observed by
an orbiting satellite. But just as he rejoices in triumph, he is pulled back
into his virtual prison by the Game Warden, who arrests him, promising “no
mercy” in violation of the rules of confinement.
In Episode Six
we take a deep dive into the life of Angela’s grandfather, William Reeves
(Jovan Adepo) via the Nostalgia pills she ingested during her arrest. He was
the little boy who rescued a child from the Tulsa massacre. In 1938 New York,
that child grows up to be his wife, June (Danielle Deadwyler).
inspired by watching silent movies a distant relative, the famed US Marshal
Bass Reeves, to become a policeman. But, unlike the movies, life proves to be
more complicated. Hired in a move to mollify black activists, he encounters
racism from his fellow officers and the public at large.
catches wind of a conspiracy run by the KKK and some NYPD officers in his own
precinct, he’s nearly lynched and warned not to “mess in white people’s
dons a dark hood and becomes Hooded Justice, the first of the many masked
vigilantes of the Watchmen universe.
himself with white makeup (in a similar manner as Angela does with her Sister
Night identity), he continues to investigate the Klan and their insidious plans
to kill or destroy the lives of African-Americans.
Will heeds a
call to join the Minutemen, a group of masked adventurers sanctioned by the
authorities, but is disheartened when their leader, Captain Metropolis (Jake
McDorman) belittles his pursuit of racists in favor of criminal masterminds.
later into his police career, Will discovers that the Klan is testing a mind
control device on black movie audiences in order to cause widespread riots and
mayhem. When he discovers their warehouse, he brutally murders the Klansmen,
takes a prototype of the device and burns the base to the ground. In doing so,
he becomes the very antithesis of the fictional movie version of Bass Reeves,
who once intoned, “There will be no
lynching today! Trust The Law!” to moviegoers.
efforts have a price; June, bitterly aware of his vigilante activities, leaves
him and takes their young son back to Tulsa.
shows Angela exactly how Chief Crawford was killed; Will, using a modified
version of the mind control device, forces him to hang himself…
And when Angela
awakes from her coma, she is surprised to be in the company of, and treatment,
of Lady Trieu…
of re-watching HBO’s Watchmen (and what will make it eminently so in the
future) is seeing the various references to the past of the origin comic AND
our own past intertwined with narrative. I can pluck three from Episode Six
Bass Reeves was quite real, the first black deputy U.S.
marshal west of the Mississippi. His exploits were so remarkable that they may
have inspired Fran Striker and George W. Trendle in the creation of the Lone
Ranger in 1933. In a fairer, better world, Bass
Reeves would be a better known and loved than a fictional white character.
newsstand owner recounts the origin of Superman in Action Comics to Will
Reeves, who almost instantly connects with the tale of an alien baby sent to
another world to escape his planet’s destruction.
Fred T., the
racist grocery owner who clashes with Will early on in his policing life, could
be modeled on the life of Fred Trump, the father of our current chief
executive, who was also known to be a not very pleasant person.
Another thing I
found admirable about Watchmen was Damon Lindelof’s dedication to making
this production as diverse as possible. A majority of the writers (ten of the
fourteen) were people of color and three women directed episodes.
Besides being a
top-flight piece of entertainment, Watchmen is also a reaction against
the willful erasure of the more violent aspects of American history, race
relations, colonialism, political hegemony and policing. Heady stuff, to be
sure. But so was Alan Moore’s source material.
clear to me after six episodes that the narrative strands of the main
characters; Angela Abar, Laurie Blake and Adrian Veidt, are slowly being drawn
Of the three, I
feel emotionally invested in Angela’s story the most; she is learning about her
family legacy in a very hard way. Her neat and tidy life of black and white,
good and evil has been upended in the most unusual manner. And while she has
acted in her own self interests in the protection of her family and herself, we
can see the toll it’s taking on her through the sheer acting prowess of Regina
King. Jean Smart and Jeremy Irons may delight us by chewing the scenery around
the edges of the story but Ms. King’s performance is the living, beating heart
of this epic. And I hope the Emmy Award nominators remember that going into the
Also, I must
highly commend the original score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, which I
neglected in my previous review of the first three episodes. It’s a
fantastical, electronic wonderland that invokes thrills, whimsy and dread in
all the right places.
Watchmen also features a remarkable number of
period pieces from several musical eras, from the Inks Spots, Eartha Kitt and
Billie Holiday to Devo, Howard Jones and the Beastie Boys. A weekly updated
list of the music being used can be found at:
As for me, I
don’t know how Damon Lindelof and company are going to pull off this feat of
narrative derring-do in the final three episodes.
In an interview published online in Gen Mag (which can be read here) before Watchmen’s
premeire, Damon Lindelof made the following statement: “I envision myself
holding two stacks of plates each in my outstretched arms and we’re putting
plates on both sides to find the perfect balance, but in finding that balance,
plates are fucking breaking, man. You can’t play this game and not break stuff.
But I hope when plates break, it’s not irreparable. Talk to me in a few months
and then we’ll have a conversation about whether it was worth it.”
In three more
weeks we’re all going to find out if this ambitious, audacious and totally
unauthorized endeavor is going to pay off. Stay tuned…
2019 Windycon Fan Guest of Honor Speech: An Apocryphal Story, 43 Things I Learned Being In Fandom and Mean Comments From File 770 Readers
By Chris M.
Barkley: Good Morning.
I’m Chris Barkley.
A word of warning: At one point during this speech, I will be making a partisan political reference that may offend some of you. The rest of you can laugh. Don’t worry, you’ll know it when you hear it. Viewer discretion is advised…
I am very
honored to be Windycon’s Fan Guest of Honor this year. Ever since I was asked
to be Windycon’s Fan Guest of Honor nearly a year and a half ago, I felt like I
was asking to host Saturday Night Live. Because when you think about it,
conventions are very much like live television. There’s a lot of spontaneous
action and unpredictable stuff going on, sometimes all at once. Well, ok, here
the sketches are also longer and it would help if they were better written.
And as a
“reward” I am obligated to regale you with some musings and philosophical
insights I have gained in my many years in fandom.
I also note that in some circles, I have what is quaintly known as a “bad reputation”. Well, I can tell you that Joan Jett was speaking directly to me when she sang:
And I don’t give a damn ’bout my bad reputation
Oh no (No no no no no no)
Not me (Me me me me me me)
I was born in
August of 1956. Dwight David Eisenhower was the President of the United States.
Some weasel from California was the Vice-President. (And NO, this isn’t the
political comment you’re waiting for. Patience.)
became an elementary school teacher who specializes in reading. My father was a
mechanical engineer for General Electric’s jet engine division. So, it stands
to reason that their oldest son is an avid fan of science fiction (and under
certain conditions, fantasy).
were one thin dime apiece. Penny candy actually cost a penny. There were only
three broadcast television networks. Rock and Roll, the bastard child of rhythm
and blues and jazz was poised to take over the world.
And, aside from
the racism, marginalization of minorities, lynchings, rampant, sexism, homophobia,
the Cold War, governmental malfeasance and the imminent threat of nuclear war,
it was a great time to be alive in the most prosperous nation on the planet.
Not that I’m
perspective as a 63-year-old African American, with forty-three years and five
months plus in fandom, I have seen a lot, done a lot and survived all of the
cultural and political forces that were lined up against me since my mother,
the late Alice Barkley and my father, the late Erbil Augustus Barkley, gave
birth to me on a sweltering August summer evening at Jewish Hospital. (PS: I’d
like to take a moment to thank them for the free circumcision. A very cool
gesture for that era.)
and ten months after my birth, my best friend, Michaele Jordan (no, not THAT
Michael Jordan, Michaele Jordan the fantasy novelist my other official, big
sister) and I discovered fandom on the back page of the July 1976 issue of Analog,
which ran, for the only time in its history, an announcement of a science
fiction convention just a few miles away from where we resided. It was held at
a run of the mill hotel called the Quality Inn in Norwood, Ohio. The convention
was called Midwestcon 27.
“We should go
to this convention,” I recall saying to her, most emphatically.
kidding?”, she replied. “It’s probably just for professional writers. They
would just throw us out.”
“Well,” I said,
“you can sit at home if you want, I’m going to go there and find out.”
And so we went.
It changed the course of our lives forever. Going to Midwestcon 27 introduced
us to an entirely new world of people, opportunities and social interactions
that resonate to this very day.
The end. Thanks
for coming, you’ve been a great audience, Chicago…
NO! WAIT! Just
conventions, Windycon hold a very special place in my heart; I’ve been
attending a semi-regular basis since the early 1980’s. I have also attended the
four worldcons that Chicago has hosted since I got into fandom and happily
served on the staff of three of them.
digression is an Apocryphal Story about Chicago that happened at Chicon 2000,
which was held in downtown Chicago.
BUT, in order
to do that, I need to digress further and tell you another story about the late
(Oh, so you
knew him, too?)
I first met
Harlan in 1978 at Kubla Khan 5 in Nashville, Tennessee. Like countless other
people, I found him to be a brilliant writer of fiction and essays, a dynamic
personality and above nearly all of his other talents, an amazing and brilliant
One story he
shared with the audience at that convention was been burned into my synapses
forever was an incident he had experienced at Chicago’s O’Hare Airport. Harlan
had just finished doing his ‘business” in a washroom when he noticed out of the
corner of his eye that a middle-aged patron was leaving without washing his
greatly offended Harlan since, if anything, he was a real stickler for health
“Hey! You”, he
said in his loud, nasally, faux-Brooklyn accent. “You forgot to wash your
The man in
question turned and said something incredibly rude about Harlan’s parentage and
proceeded to walk out into the terminal.
Enraged at this
person’s intransigence, Harlan burst out of the restroom and trailed behind the
man screaming at the top of his lungs, “UNCLEAN, UNCLEAN! DON’T TOUCH HIM! HE
DIDN’T WASH HIS HANDS!”
And he did
this. All the way to this person’s departure gate.
Now, I told you
that story to tell you this one: For Chicon 2000, I was promoted from my regular
duties in the Worldcon Press Office to serve on Chairman Tom Veal’s staff AND
as the Fairmont Hotel liaison. It was a very important position, which I shared
with my ex-wife, in that both the Masquerade and the Hugo Award Ceremony were
being held there.
I was finishing my “business” in the restroom, when I noticed out of the corner
of my eye, a middle-aged fan was leaving without washing his hands.
immediately flashed back to Harlan’s story. My first thought was, I am NOT
Harlan Ellison. And then my second thought was, “What would Harlan do?”
So, within a
few seconds, I screwed up my moral courage and, in my even tempered,
faux-midwestern black accent, I spoke up and said, “Excuse me, but you forgot
to wash your hands.”
The fan whirled
around and shouted, “YOU’RE NOT MY DAD!”
say, I was taken aback. But fortunately, my skills as a radio talk show host
and a standup comedian kicked into high:
“You see this?”
I pointed to the bright blue COMMITTEE ribbon hanging on my convention badge
and stated with absolute authority:
here at this convention, this ribbon says I AM YOUR DAD!!”
The fan sighed,
turned and washed his hands.
I’ve learned a
LOT of things in my time in fandom. I would now like to pass along some of the
more profound life revelations that have occurred to me over time, one for each
year that I have been in fandom:
being polite costs you nothing and may gain you new friends.
Reading is the
best gateway to other worlds and other points of view.
I am convinced
all fascists and Nazi sympathizers were once involved in Home Owner
Associations. It’s the only possible explanation for their actions.
appropriation is like porn, I KNOW it when I see it.
challenge the past in order the forge the future.
When you are
making policy or changes in your life only three factors matter; Is it true, is
it necessary and most importantly, is it vital?
Try and learn
at least one other language in your lifetime. For example, Welsh, Irish,
Scottish or Australian.
that taxes pay for civilization. And that those who don’t pay their fair share
are welchers and cheats.
Buy a copy of the Constitution of the United
States. In this day and age you never know when you may have to invoke it,
especially to people who haven’t read it.
Public radio has saved my life and sanity for
decades. And it can do the same for you!
BUT, if you
love your NPR station and donate your car to help out, would that be considered
autoeroticsm? Asking for a friend…
Occasionally, you may be asked to take a stand
and make your voice heard. And yes, you will be afraid to do it. But the alternative,
of silence and token assent, is much, much worse.
Congratulations, you’re working on a
convention. Here’s a big piece of advice for you con-runners. To preserve our
sanity at Chicon 2000, my friend Bridget came up with a simple working mantra
we repeated every morning: There will be a convention. There will be rooms at
the convention. Some will be right. Some will be wrong. And then IT WILL BE
you more grounded and humble than owning a pet. Pro Owner Tip: If you own a cat
(or vice versa), consider emptying an entire bag of cat food into their litter
box. That way, you just skip the middle process altogether and get on with your
By the way, cat
dandruff is a first world problem.
Never, ever, annoy writers. Especially the
good ones. Not only will they say nastily adroit things at you, you may become
a victim of embarrassing situation, imprisoned or murdered in a book, play or
screenplay with the name of said person so barely disguised, EVERYONE will KNOW
Speaking of writing,
NEVER give in to censorship, either in your works or in the defense of others.
Free speech does not mean being free from consequences. But either everyone has
the opportunity to express themselves or no one does.
Unless you are the author or editor, DON’T
WRITE, HIGHLIGHT, ANNOTATE OR SCRIBBLE YOUR NAMES IN BOOKS! Well, at least in
the books that I want to buy. It’s so damn annoying!
When you write,
write for yourself. You should welcome criticism of your writing. But do not
make the fatal mistake of pandering to appeal the masses. If you can satisfy
your own standards of what you like to read, others will see it as well.
Also, KEEP WRITING. You’ll get better at it.
Also: READ! As much as possible; fantasy and
sf for sure but try to be as diverse as possible. Don’t confine yourself to
literary bubbles and for god’s sake, don’t denigrate anyone else who reads,
even if they’re reading something you don’t like. If they read and comprehend
and understand what they are reading, there’s a chance, a hope really, that
they can understand what is truthful from what is fantasy or propaganda.
You have never
known true fear until you see a full-grown Great Dane take a baby chick in its
mouth and start running around the yard like a seven-year-old on a playground
with their mouth full of Halloween candy. And unfortunately for you, are are
trying to catch a three-year-old Great Dane who can run twice as fast as any
NFL or Premier League defender. (PS: Yes, I eventually caught the dog and
safely freed the chick. But she has yet to lay a single egg. I don’t blame
Do you know where your water come from? Do you
know where the wastewater goes? Find
out. And then pledge yourself to not wasting a drop of it again in your
Music is my friend. Music is my life. No
matter what you listen to, enjoy it and let it massage your brain and
imagination. And if you actually make music, I envy you because that is one of
the greatest gifts of all.
at a convention or not (especially not) if you see something is amiss, if a
person is being bullied or harassed, do something or say something. Render
assistance in any way you can. Is anyone here familiar with the lyrics to the
alternative rock anthem “How Soon Is Now” by The Smiths? One part of the main chorus
has always touched by heart every time I hear it:
I am human and I need to be loved
Just like everybody else does
Because that should be the core
of our values in fandom and in life.
Fan writing is much cheaper than therapy.
Han Solo’s Rules for Life: Get In. Sit Down. Buckle Up. Hang On.
Chris Barkley’s Rules for Hitchhikers: See the Han Solo Rules for Life.
Leading into: If you don’t use your car’s turn signals, YOU GET WHAT YOU DESERVE!
I think everyone should take a CPR and Emergency Aid course whether it’s offered by the Red Cross or any other agency in your community. I was once employed to be a caretaker for a disadvantaged person and I took an exhaustive, seven-hour course covering nearly everything and anything that might happen to you. Let me tell you something, it was a real eye opener to find out how many things could go wrong with the human body on a daily basis with the introduction of an infection, virus or pathogen. At this very moment in Los Angeles, the partner of a friend of mine named Genny is fighting off an extremely debilitating disease called Guillain-BarréSyndrome, which struck her suddenly and without warning. The treatment is long and extensive but there is no cure. You should do it because the life you save may very well be a family member, a friend or your own.
If you want to be loved, start by loving yourself first.
This past Monday was Veteran’s Day. I would be remiss if I did not remind everyone that at this moment, there are thousands of men, women, members of the LGBTQ, transgendered, non-binary communities and otherwise, are out here serving in our armed forces. And sooner or later, they too, will be veterans. It has been estimated that more than 20 percent of the service personnel who served in Iraq and Afghanistan suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. And thousands of others are suffering from debilitating injuries while serving. And don’t forget that there are still living veterans of World War Two, the Korean War, the Vietnam War, the Lebanon deployment, Desert Storm and Shield and the invasion and occupation of Iraq. As they protected us, we need to do everything we can to help them. Find out what your local, state and federal representatives are doing for veterans. If you find out they aren’t, then vote their asses out of office and vote for candidate who will.
Failure is part of life. Don’t be afraid to fail. Success is fine but unless you fail, you don’t learn anything and you never progress as a person. And more importantly, you mustn’t be afraid to fail. In a book that was just published last week, You Are AWESOME, How To Navigate Change, Wrestle With Failure and Live an Intentional Life, author Neil Pasricha points out that one of the main things that hold people back from their full potential is the inability to tell the difference between truth and the narrative lies we keep telling ourselves such as, “ I’ll never learn this”, ”I’m going to be stuck in this job forever” and the always deadly, “Other people are better off than I am”. Your life does not have to be a runaway, non-stop train of doom and gloom. I know because I’ve been there myself and I got off that merry-go-round, with the help of my good friends and beloved partner. You can do it, too. My advice is to stop, take a deep, metaphorical breath and try and find out what you are capable of doing or achieving. Then go for it. If you can do that, you have just taken your first steps to self-discovery.
Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood should be mandatory viewing. For the current ‘president of the United States. As part of his sentencing conditions. If he objects, the ONLY alternative should be Paw Patrol. (CHASE! MARSHALL! SKYE! ZUMA! TRACKER! ROCKY! RUBBLE!) Just Sayin’. Period. Full Stop.
Be woke, aware and informed. Try and understand why people come to different conclusions than you. As actor-philosopher Edward James Olmos once said, “There is only ONE race; the human race.”
On the other hand, don’t take yourself TOO seriously. Don’t be a drag in the consuite.
If someone likes something you loath, don’t rain on their parade. Let them enjoy it. Don’t post that comment on Facebook or Instagram. Just walk away. Knowing that you haven’t ruined someone’s day.
I attended a lecture in 1995 at the University of Kentucky in which Stephen King imparted some very pertinent advice to young people: “If an adult tells you NOT to read something, make it your business to go out, find it, read it for yourselves and make up your own mind about it. Don’t ever depend on some ‘well meaning’’ adult with an agenda to tell you what to read, make up your mind for you or dictate how you should lead your life.” Best. Advice. EVER!
Always try to meet your heroes. It’s better to find out that they are just as human and fallible as you are. And maybe even more so if they truly believe they belong on the pedestal people have placed them on.
Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. once wrote in his novel Mother Night: “We are what we pretend to be, so we must be careful about what we pretend to be.” He also said, “There is love enough in this world for everybody, if people will just look.”
Three more things: I know that we’re all here to have a good time and celebrate with our friends and guests of honor. But remember, as bad as things are here in America, our problems don’t begin and end with our country. Hong Kong. Brexit. Bolivia. Chile. The immigration crisis in Central America and Africa. South Sudan. Spain and Catalonia. The Philippines. Myanmar. Iran, Iraq and Syria. Hell, in comparison to those places we are living in paradise. When you leave here this weekend, don’t forget that.
Whenever possible, Be Kind. And always carry a towel.
And finally, let me leave you with these wise words, “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has.” Margaret Mead.
And lastly, I want to dedicate this speech to the
memory of the late Frank Johnson, a fellow member of the Cincinnati Fantasy
Group who died earlier this year. His very last convention was last year’s
Windycon. I’d like to think he would have enjoyed this speech.
Thank you for attending and listening to me ramble
or a while. Be good to each other and have a great convention.
Who Watches The Watchmen? – Part One: Episodes 1-3
By Chris M. Barkley:
WATCHMEN by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons, 12 Issues, September 1986 –
October 1987, omnibus edition DC Comics/Warner Books, 1987.
“This city is afraid of me…I have seen its true face”
It is widely regarded that Jack Katz’s The First Kingdom
(1974) and the late Will Eisner’s A Contract With God and Other Tenement
Stories (1978) should be credited as being among the first great, modern
Watchmen, by writer Alan Moore and artist Dave Gibbons is, without a
doubt, acknowledged as the first masterpiece of this literary form.
This psychological and sociological deconstruction of the
nature and mythology of superheroes has been a towering inspiration to nearly
everyone who has aspired to work in the comics industry since its publication
in the mid-1980’s.
I had the privilege of reading Watchmen in its
original twelve issue run when it was first published. I vividly remember being
very excited about reading this series. And I, as a jaded 30-year-old-reader,
had not been taken by surprise by a graphic novel or comic book since I was
nine years old and encountering the Fantastic Four and the Justice
League for the first time.
I was mesmerized as Ozymandias’ (Adrian Veidt) diabolical
plan to unite the world by making it fearful of a faked alien invasion played
out; the murder of a remorseful ex-hero Eddie Blake (The Comedian), the
relentless and brutal investigation of his and other murders by Rorshach
(Walter Joseph Kovacs), Doctor Manhattan’s (Jon Osterman) growing alienation
from humankind and the personal struggles of Sally Jupiter (Silk Spectre) and
Nite-Owl (Dan Dreiberg) and the eventual destruction of a good portion of New
York City and a massive death toll., .
And the plan worked. Or did it?
A nuclear war between the Soviet Union and the United States
was averted, and the surviving heroes, with the exception of Rorshach, agreed
to keep silent. Doctor Manhattan kills Rorshach to ensure his silence. But
knowing he might not be able to speak out, he cleverly planted a diary
outlining most of plot with a tabloid newspaper. We, the readers, were left
with an ironic, ticking time bomb waiting to go off…
Moore and Gibbon’s original contract with DC Comics
stipulated that if Watchmen went out of print, the publishing rights and
characters would revert back to them to do with them as they wished. But, not
only a critical success but a big moneymaker for DC. Moore, citing this and
other contractual disputes with DC, is totally estranged from the publisher and
has repeatedly refused to have anything to do with Watchmen. And I don’t
blame him a bit. If we were all moral and ethical people, we would boycott
anything and everything Watchmen-related.
Unfortunately, we are not very moral or ethical people. Are
WATCHMEN (Director’s Cut: 3 Hours 2 minutes, 4/4 stars,
2009) with Malin Åkerman, Billy Crudup,Matthew Goode,Carla Gugino,Jackie
Earle Haley, Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Patrick Wilson. Screenplay by David Hayter
and Alex Tse, based on Watchmen by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons, Directed by
“People’s lives take them strange places. They do strange things, and sometimes they can’t talk about them… I know how that is.”.
Laurie Jupiter/Silk Spectre II
The film rights to Watchmen were immediately snatched
up by renowned producers Lawrence Gordon and Joel Silver. They were the first
of many who tried, and failed, to make a movie out of Watchmen. Several
writers and directors were employed to give it a go, among them Terry Gilliam
of Monty Python fame, who exclaimed at one point it would be better as a
mini-series and at another said the graphic novel was “unfilmable”.
In 2005, Gordon and a new partner, Lloyd Levin, tapped
director Zach Synder, who had just completed the special effects historical
epic, 300, to try to bring it all together. Synder and new screenwriter
Alex Tse used elements of an earlier script by David Hayer, restored the Cold
War setting of 1985 and an element involving Doctor Manhattan working on an
energy conversion project backed by Adrian Veidt.
I saw the film when it premiered a decade ago but hadn’t seen
it since then. I remember being impressed with it and thought was a very good
adaptation. Looking back, I gave it three out of four stars (on the Leonard
Maltin rating scale) because as good as it was, I found the underlying themes
of the source material somewhat muted.
To re-acquaint myself with the film, I purchased a copy of
Zach Synder’s director’s cut (which has 24 minutes of additional footage) and
found it that it was a more satisfying experience. Sure, it features extended
action scenes but it also gives more nuance and character motivation to Laurie
Jupiter (Malin Ackerman), her mother, Sally (Carla Gugino) and Nite-Owl (Partick
Wilson). Their character arcs actually heighten the performance of Jackie Earle
Haley’s Rorshach, whose contrasting performance as the hard ass, uncompromising
vigilante burns even brighter. In a fairer world would he have been nominated
for an Oscar and aced the winner Christoph Waltz (for Inglorious Basterds)
for the award.
Synder and screenwriter Alex Tse received a lot of criticism
for changing a vital element of the original story; the conspiracy behind
faking the alien invasion. Instead, a subplot involving Doctor Manhattan and
Adrian Veidt developing a new source of energy derived from his superpowers and
Veidt framing him for a far more heinous crime, the utter destruction of
several major global cities. While I thought this was a brilliant way to set
the film apart visually from the graphic novel, other critics harped that it
was either still too faithful version or or disagreed with the choices
storywise. As for me, I think that; filmmakers have a better chance of
producing more interesting and innovative art when they bring their
perspectives and ideas to an adaptation than being a slave to the original
(To get an author’s first-hand perspective on how they viewed
an adaptation of their own work, interested readers may want to hunt down David
Mitchell’s essay on how his 2004 novel, Cloud Atlas, was handled by its
three directors. It was originally published in the 2012 movie tie-in edition
and, as of this post, is not available online.)
Watchmen was not the huge financial success Warner Brothers and DC
Comics had hoped for at the box office, earning $185 million worldwide against
an estimated budget of $138 million. Sales of various home video editions have
been moderately good. In bookstores and online, the graphic novel spiked in
advance of the film and did so again this past year upon the announcement from
HBO that a limited series was in the works.
Despite the failure of the film, DC embarked on a series of
prequel stories called Before Watchmen in 2012, featuring individual
characters from the novel.
Naturally, Alan Moore was very unhappy with these developments,
stating in a 2012 interview on the Seraphemera (Books & Music)
“All the nasty comments that I was making when I was angry–about the comics industry not having had an idea of its own in the last 40 years…it would seem that DC are really going that extra mile in trying to prove me incontrovertibly right.”
“What the comics industry has effectively said is, ‘Yes, this was the only book that made us briefly special and that was because it wasn’t like all the other books.’ Watchmen was something that stood on its own and it had the integrity of a literary work. What they’ve decided now is, ‘So, let’s change it to a regular comic that can run indefinitely and have spin-offs.’ and ‘Let’s make it as unexceptional as possible.’ Like I say, they’re doing this because they haven’t got any other choices left, evidently.”
WATCHMEN: White Rabbit, HBO, DC Comics, based on Watchmen
by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons, with Regina King, Jean Smart, Don
Johnson, Tim Blake Nelson,Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, Andrew Howard, Jacob
Ming-Trent, Tom Mison, Sara Vickers, Dylan Schombing, Louis Gossett Jr. and
“I’ve got a nose for white supremacy and he smells like bleach.”
Angela Abar/Detective Sister Night, Episode 1
Episode 1: “It’s Summer and We’re Running Out of Ice”, Written by Damon Lindelof, Directed by Nicole Kassell
Episode 2: “Martial Feats of Comanche Horsemanship”, Written by Damon Lindelof & Nick Cuse, Directed by Nicole Kassell
Episode 3:”She Was Killed by Space Junk”, Written by Damon Lindelof & Lila Byock, Directed by Stephen Williams
Which brings us to Damon Lindelof’s “remix” of the original
graphic novel for television.The veteran of high profile genre shows like Lost
and The Leftovers, he turned the job down twice before accepting. He
went in knowing that he would never get Alan Moore’s approval and that whatever
may come, the die-hard fans of the graphic novel (or the film for that matter)
would never be satisfied with the results.
Taking a deep creative breath, Lindelof took to Instagram and made the following statement: “I am compelled despite the inevitable pushback and hatred I will understandably receive for taking on this particular project. This ire will be maximally painful because of its source. That source being you. the true fans.”
He also said: “I’m a true fan, too. And I’m not the only
one. What I love about television is that the finished product is not the
result of a singular vision, but the collective experience of many brilliant
Among those brilliant minds is Watchmen’s original
artist, Dave Gibbons, who signed on with Lindelof as a visual consultant. His
contributions are immediately evident in costumes of the characters and the
style and feel of the production itself.
The story begins with one of the most stunning opening
sequencing in the history of television; a brutal recreation of the ransacking,
murderous rampage and destruction of the Black Wall Street of Tulsa, Oklahoma
in 1921. Emerging from the carnage, a young black child rescues an infant and
flees the burning city.
We then shift ninety-eight years into the future and thirty
four after the events depicted in the graphic novel. Loud rap music drones from
of a pickup truck late at night. The middle aged driver become apprehensive
when police lights signal for him to pull over and it appears he is a victim of
racial profiling. And as the officer questions the driver in an antagonistic
manner, it verifies these suspicions with one startling twist; the driver is
white and the Tulsa cop is African-American and wearing a mask. When the cop is
brutally assaulted and critically injured, it set in motion a series of events
that will range far across this alternate universe.
And what a strange universe it is. Over the course of the
first three episodes several several passing glances and easter eggs have
revealed the following observations and easter eggs:
That actor Robert Redford has been President for decades.
That African-Americans were granted some substantial reparations
from the government over the years.
There are no cell phones or the development of any social media
outlets. But electric cars seem to be a standard mode of travel.
Author/Attorney John Grisham was appointed to the Supreme Court and
Masked vigilantes were banned in 1977 but apparently many persist
in the practice.
A newspaper announces that Adrian Veidt (Ozymandias) has been
officially declared dead.
Tiny squids fall from the sky on an irregular basis, a stark
reminder that mankind is still living under a threat of an impending
A dramatization documenting adventures of the first vigilantes
called “American Hero Story” is being promoted on television (a clear call
out to the Tales of The Black Freighter comics in the original Watchmen
AND to Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk’s American Horror Story).
And Doctor Manhattan has been spotted on Mars, puttering around
building and deconstructing things on the surface and, presumably, keeping
an eye on Earth.
Tulsa’s police chief, Judd Crawford (Don Johnson) quickly
deduces that a white supremist group, the Seventh Kalvary, was responsible.
Three years earlier, the force and their families had been targeted in a
surprise attack that left them dead and the few that remained demoralized. In
response, the state government funded a pilot project that allowed officers to
mask themselves and detectives to don elaborate costumes to protect their
identities. Unfortunately, as the first episode amply demonstrates, this
habitually leads to the abuse of the civil rights of criminal suspects and
innocent civilians alike.
Our main protagonist, Angela Abar, is a survivor of the
attack and has adopted the guise of a mild mannered, civilian identity of a
local baker. But, when she’s alerted via pager to an emergency, she swiftly
enters the back room and, like Spiderwoman, the Green Hornet and countless
other heroes, transforms herself into Sister Night; with a nun’s habit and
balaclava clad, she is a total badass supercop.
Sister Night forcibly brings a suspect into Tulsa’s secret
police facility where he is subjected to an interrogation by Detective Wade
Tillman, aka Looking Glass (played a droll and sardonic Tim Blake Nelson), who
wears a reflective mirror mask. After conducting a very strange method that
seems imitate Bladerunner’s Voight-Kampff test, Tillman concludes that
while the suspect may not have been directly involved with the attack, he
definitely knows something. And Sister Night proceeds to beat the location of
the Seventh Kalvary out of him.
Meanwhile, at an undisclosed location, we spy a man (Jeremy
Irons) riding horseback through the countryside. (Although he isn’t identified,
I immediately suspected this regal looking rogue to be Adrian Veidt. And I was
right.) While he seems to be right at home, he gives the appearance of being
preoccupied with writing a play called “The Watchman’s Son” and recruiting his
servants, Miss Crookshanks (Sarah Vickers) and Mr. Phillips (Tom Mison) to help
him bring it to life.
At first, I thought these might be androids, but no, after
Mr. Philips is burned alive during the performance of the play, it’s revealed
that there are multiple copies of him and Miss Crookshanks, clones, doing his
bidding around the castle in various roles. And who knows, they might even be
clones of himself!
It also becomes evident that while Veidt lives in relative
comfort, he is not at liberty to leave the compound at any time. After another
one of his Philips clones expires in a grisly manner during one of his
experiments involving a primitive pressure suit and a trebuchet, it is evident
that the World’s Smartest Man is trying to escape. And the person who is
standing in his way is a mysterious character named “the Game Warden”, who
sends Veidt a written warning that he suspects his current activities may be in
violation of the terms of his imprisonment. And Veidt, being the person he is,
doubles down on his efforts.
Meanwhile, Sister Night and Chief Crawford lead a nighttime
raid on the Kavalry’s remote safehouse, which, like the first two episodes, are
thrillingly directed with precision and verve by Nicole Kassell. And while they
succeed in breaking up the gang’s current plan, they don’t gain enough
intelligence to know exactly what they’re up to.
Angela goes home only to receive a phone tip from a strange
voice who tells her knows who she is and proceeds to demands she drive to a
location in a field she knows well. Fearing that her identity and family has
been compromised, she drives there only to find Crawford’s body hanging from a
tree and a VERY elderly black man in a wheelchair (Louis Gossett, Jr.), proudly
claiming to be the murderer.
This man, who calls himself Will, also claims to be Angela’s
grandfather and to being 109 years old. Angela takes him to her bakery hideout,
handcuffs him and takes a DNA sample to be tested and later is shocked to find
out his claim is valid. Having kept Will out of the investigation of Crawford’s
death, she decides to formally take him into custody as a material witness. But
as she places him in her civilian car under the cover of darkness, a mysterious
craft swoops in with an electro-magnetic grapple and spirits Will, and her car
(!), away. A paper flutters down from the car; the tattered leaflet with the
words “Look After This Boy” scrawled on the back, the same note that was placed
in the pocket by the father of the boy who survived the 1921 Tulsa riots.
The third episode introduces the audience to a middle-aged
Laurie Blake (Jean Smart, who is equally snappy and ironically sad in her role)
the second Silk Spectre and daughter of Sally Jupiter and Eddie Blake. A hard-bitten
veteran of the FBI’s Anti-Vigilante Task Force, she also appears to be trapped
in a life she doesn’t enjoy very much. It is heavily implied that her
ex-husband, Nite-Owl, is languishing in prison for violating the 1977 federal
anti-vigilante act and Laurie feels guilty for receiving a get out of jail free
card in exchange for her services.
Enter Joe Keene Jr., a US Senator from Oklahoma (and an aspiring
Presidential candidate) who comes calling on Laurie to do him a favor; he has
arranged with the Bureau to send her to Tulsa to investigate the death of Chief
Judd Crawford, who he strongly suspects might not have been killed by the
Seventh Kalvalry but by a masked vigilante. .Should Laurie succeed and he
becomes President, he strongly suggests he just might pardon Daniel Dreiberg.
But Laurie doesn’t only pine for her ex-husband, in her spare
time from the investigation, she also records phone messages beamed directly to
Mars via special booths for her ex-boyfriend, Doctor Manhattan to “hear”.
As sad and lonely as Laurie seems, her demeanor in public is
sharp and professional. In her interactions with Angela, Wade and her nerdy FBI
partner Dale Petey (Dustin Ingram) she lets it be known that does not suffer
fools gladly and that she has read all of the reports, seen all of the video
and is as smart as a very sharp, venomous tack. And if anyone is hiding
anything, she’ll be the one to suss it out. Wade seemingly bows to her
authority but not Angela, who puts on a brave and defiant face. That’s because
she has plenty to hide at this point, including finding evidence that Chief
Crawford may have been on the take and is concealing her grandfather’s role in
And at the end of the third episode, as Laurie completes her
phone call to Mars that evening, pleading for a sign from Doctor Manhattan that
he might still care for her or the human race. As she is walking to her car, a
huge clue falls into her lap from the sky above. And as she looks to see where
it came from, she catches sight of Mars, glowing ominously in the distance. We
leave Laurie as she laughs maniacally at the night sky and the audience
wondering what the hell is going to happen next.
I must admit that I have been fairly overwhelmed by what
Damon Lindelof has done with this production of Watchmen. He clearly
reveres the source material but is totally unafraid in taking it in unexpected
and startling directions.
There has been some blow back from fans who have complained
at great length that Lindelof has made Watchmen too “political”, which
is laughable because a more discerning reader should have caught on to those
themes in the very first issue back in 1986.
Others have vociferously objected to Rorschach being held up
as a modern-day symbol of white supremacy. Well, those people thought he was
the “hero” of previous iterations of Watchmen, when in fact, he was a
damaged human being who was given the worst aspects of Batman, which were then
magnified to the nth degree. A nihilistic, psychotic and inflexible, Walter
Kovacs was the perfect character for other nihilistic, psychotic and inflexible
racists to glom onto as their object of adulation.
Furthermore, Lindelof and his crew of creators are daring the
audience to immerse themselves in a world where they may have to either root
for, understand or have empathy for people, especially police officers, who are
going about their jobs and lives in a completely aberrant and disgusting manner
as they try to grapple with forces and circumstances they are having a hard
Also, in an era where more television shows and films are
telling more diverse stories, it is utterly refreshing to see a gerne-oriented show
tackle racial and political issues head on for a mainstream audience. These are
exactly the sort of entertainment vehicles we need more of in these confusing
and turbulent times; confounding, controversial and profound, they excite the
intellect and stir meaningful conversations about who we are and what we should
This past spring, I stated that I was only going to list
HBO’s magnificent techno-horror miniseries Chernobyl as my lone entrant
on my Best Dramatic Presentation-Long Form Hugo award ballot. Well, I think may
have been a bit premature saying that; if Damon Lindelof and company can pull
it off this daring adaptation over the remaining six episodes, I’ll be
nominating Watchmen as well.
And from what I’ve seen so far, I’ll be VERY disappointed if
they don’t make it. But, after seeing the first three episodes of this series,
I have a sneaking suspicion they will stick the landing, in the biggest way
By Chris Barkley: Actor Anthony Daniels’ book tour in support of his newly published memoir, I Am C-3PO: The Inside Story, stopped at Joseph Beth Booksellers in Cincinnati, Ohio Wednesday evening.
brief question and answer period was highlighted by a question from a very
young fan who demanded to know why C-3PO interrupted the kiss between Leia and
Han in The Empire Strikes Back. (Answer: It was not his fault, it was in
event was attended by several hundred enthusiastic fans, with many of the
attendees in full cosplay mode. (Note: The author was dressed in chinos, a
dress shirt, a leather jacket topped off with an NPR baseball cap. DON’T JUDGE
famous co-star, R2D2 was also on hand to amuse, amaze and pose for pictures
[Photo of Daniels taken by Paul Glasser, all others by Chris
By Chris M. Barkley: If I had told you a month ago that legacies of three of the
biggest names in the fantasy and sf community would come under scrutiny and
that one in particular would have his name removed from two prestigious awards,
you probably would have looked at me oddly and thought I was crazy.
Well now, welcome to Crazy Town.
I, on the other hand, would not have been surprised as
much because of what had happened a year ago.
Tuesday, November 27 2018, was the BEST day of Linda
Fairstein’s life. Well, you could say it was the LAST best day of her life
because forty-eight hours later, it began to unravel.
Fairstein, an acclaimed and best-selling crime writer of many
years, awoke that day to find out that her peers in the Mystery Writers of
America had named her as a Grand Master, the highest award of their
organization could bestow. She was being honored for her series of 20 novels
featuring Alexandra Cooper, a sex crimes prosecutor.
When she found out, she took to Twitter, writing,“How is THIS
news for a thrilling surprise. I am Mystery Writers of America 2019
GRANDMASTER…..I’m pinching myself.”
But, almost immediately, prominent crime writers, with
novelist Attica Locke in the lead, were protesting the announcement. Locke
explained vociferously that Fairstein was directly responsible for the false
imprisonment of five innocent men.
Linda Fairstein’s previous occupation was a district attorney
for New York City. For nearly a quarter of a century she was the lead
prosecutor of the Sex Crimes Unit in Manhattan. In that capacity she became a
feminist icon for her tough stances on crime and advocacy for victims’ rights
Unfortunately, she was also responsible for personally
supervising the prosecution of the Central Park Five, a 1989 case in which a
jogger was brutally beaten and raped. The five Latino and black male teenagers
were arrested, questioned, tried and eventually convicted for the heinous
crime. They all claimed that the confessions they signed were coerced and that
they were innocent. In 2002, all of them were exonerated by DNA evidence, freed
and were given a substantial financial settlement from the city.
So, when the MWA reversed themselves, they released the
“After profound reflection, the Board has decided that MWA
cannot move forward with an award that lacks support of such a large percentage
of our members. Therefore, the Board of Directors has decided to withdraw the
Linda Fairstein Grand Master award. We realize that this action will be
unsatisfactory to many. We apologize for any pain and disappointment this
situation has caused.”
By this past June, Dutton, her current publisher, had dropped
her and activists on social media outlets called on the public to boycott her
books and anyone selling them.
Fairstein exacerbated her situation by not apologizing for
what happened or at least admitting that our judicial system failed these young
men miserably. But no; instead she doubled down and she stood by their original
convictions despite the evidence to the contrary, and hinted that if they were
not guilty of that offense, they were probably guilty of something else and absolutely
deserved exactly what they got. When HBO’s drama about the Central Park Five,
“When They See Us” was aired this past spring, it featured a less than
flattering portrayal of Fairstein.
When I heard about Linda Fairstein’s problems with the Mystery
Writers of America, I got into an semi-argument with a bookselling friend about
what should happen to her. He stated, unequivocally, that her actions in her
life should have nothing to do with her work as a writer.
And, In a fair and a just world, that would happen. But, as
we have seen repeatedly over the advent of the internet and social media
outlets, there are people out there who would vehemently oppose the most
harmless and innocuous you could come up with, including kittens. knitting and
I told my friend back then that while it was more than likely
that Linda Fairstein probably did deserve the MWA honor, people, her peers,
critics, and the public at large and the tidal forces of social interaction she
helped foment were going to deny her because of her past actions and her
adamant defense of them.
And the very same scenario has played out again, in high
definition no less, in these past few weeks.
When Jeannette Ng made her speech denouncing John W.
Campbell, Jr. at the Hugo Award Ceremony three weeks ago, it set off a tsunami
of arguments, retrospectives and reassessments of Campbell, the late Alice
Sheldon (best known under her pseudonym James Tiptree, Jr), Amazing Stories
founder Hugo Gernsback and other various literary luminaries of the past and
By sheer coincidence, I discovered Campbell the editor in
high school, several months after he died. My neighbor, Michaele, had a
subscription and loaned me her copies of Analog, which were among the
last he had edited. The stories were ok but what really caught my eye were the
strangely cranky editorials, which made me curious enough to want to meet him.
It was well enough that he had departed; had I gone back a few years and read
of his 1968 endorsement of George Wallace for President, that would have been
From 1937, for their first fifteen years or so, Campbell’s Astounding
Science Fiction magazine (and for the few years it existed, its fantasy
counterpart, Unknown) were the biggest influences in sf literature and
fandom at large.
But, along came Anthony Boucher and J. Francis McComas. And
Horace Gold. Cele Goldsmith. Frederik Pohl. Ian and Betty Ballantine. Joseph
and Edward Ferman. And Harlan Ellison. And many other editors and
publishers who followed in their footsteps. Like all good literary movements,
sf diversified, became more inclusive and expanded.
And Campbell himself? Not so much.
To be sure, he still was respected by authors and artists who
produced for him. And don’t forget that he was the first to serialize Frank
Herbert’s magnum opus, Dune, and, ironically, the very FIRST story by
one James Tiptree, Jr (who is waiting on deck, so to speak).
But Campbell was estranged from a number of major authors
such as Robert A. Heinlein, whom he had clashed with over ideological and
When the two awards were established in his name two years
after his death, John W. Campbell, Jr. was so well thought of and revered that
there was no virtually opposition from any of the sponsors; Conde Nast
Magazines (which later morphed into Dell Magazines) and the World Science
Fiction Society (as the administrator) for the Best New Writer and the Memorial
Award for Best Novel by late authors Harry Harrison and Brian Aldiss. (The Gunn
Center Conference of the University of Kansas formally took over the
administration of the Campbell Memorial Award in 1978).
Harrison wrote this of the awards in 1977:
When John died it was a blow to all of us. After the memorial service a number of his writers were talking, and out of the talk came the Astounding anthology, what has been called the last issue of the Campbell magazine. It was a good tribute to a good editor. There is another tribute I think of just as highly, the award for the best SF novel of the year presented in his name and memory. An award I am sure he would have loved because it instantly became involved in controversy when the first prizes was presented. How John enjoyed a good argument and a good fight! That this fight sprawled through the letter columns of Analog for some months would have cheered him even more.
(For those among you who are intensely curious about that
first recipient, the very first winner of the Memorial Award for Best Novel
award was Beyond Apollo by Barry Malzberg, a book whose plot and themes
probably would have turned his brain inside out. Don’t believe me? Check it out
In the wake of the events of the past three weeks, Campbell’s
grandson, John Campbell Hammond, has expressed some distress and disappointment
over the removal of his name from the two awards. Others have been more pointed
in their criticism, calling it a reactionary response of “political
correctness” or “erasure”.
Mr. Hammond may be saddened but at least he can be consoled
by the voters of the 1944 Retro-Hugos, which held his grandfather in some high
esteem because they awarded him in the Best Editor, Short Form category.
Here’s the thing; while he was a brilliant innovator in our
branch of literature, there is also no doubt that his views on women and race
were abominable. We can only speculate how much better things might have been
if he hadn’t been such a person. Looking back, it is quite evident that the
only thing holding up his reputation up for all these decades was white
privilege, willful or unknowing ignorance and racism.
And what’s happened to Campbell is not “erasure” but, as John
Scalzi elegantly put it on his blog, a “reassessment”. And part of that process
is a condemnation of your past actions.
Almost immediately in the wake of all of this, The Tiptree
Motherboard, the administrators of the James Tiptree, Jr. Award, were inundated
by requests that they change the name of their award, citing that Alice Sheldon
(the alias behind the Tiptree pseudonym) had committed the murder of her
spouse, the ailing and terminally ill Huntington Sheldon, and then committed
Where I had no doubt that removing Campbell name was correct
thing to do, I was equally adamant that Tiptree’s name should remain in place.
I am proud to state that I voted for Sheldon’s Hugo winning
novella, “Houston, Houston, Do You Read,” on my very first Hugo Awards ballot
back in 1977. At that time, no one knew “James Tiptree, Jr.” was other than a
as a damn good writer. Upon first reading, I found her short fiction to be
entertaining, intensely personal and incredibly enlightening. And I still do.
The bubble burst the very next year when, in her guise as
Tiptree, slipped up and revealed to several of her correspondents that her
mother had recently died. That led a few clever people to a Chicago newspaper
obituary and directly her real identity.
Sheldon continued to write, as Tiptree and “Raccoona Sheldon”
until her and her husband’s deaths in 1987. It was long rumored among her
friends and family that she and “Ting” had made a long-standing murder/suicide
pact if either became too ill for the other to care for. In her 2006 Hugo Award
winning biography, The Double Life of Alice B. Sheldon, author Julie
Phillips did not state conclusively that this was the case. Recently, Phillips
wrote on Twitter:
“The question has come up whether Alice Sheldon (James Tiptree, Jr) and her husband Ting died by suicide or murder-suicide. I regret not saying clearly in the bio that those closest to the Sheldons all told me that they had a pact and that Ting’s health was failing.
Ting’s son Peter Sheldon also said there was a pact, and that Ting was declining. Alli probably wanted to die more than Ting did. But the pact didn’t have to do with his blindness or disability. He was going, and they chose to go out together.”
Recently on the Tiptree Motherboard, Phillips elaborated
“Ting didn’t leave a statement, but all Ting’s friends that I talked to plus his son Peter were unanimous that it was a pact, and that Ting’s health was failing when it happened. The only one who cast doubt on that was the lawyer who talked to her on the last night, James Boylan. He didn’t know either Ting or Alli very well, and I have doubts about how well he understood what was happening. I’m planning to write up what I know, because I left too much room for doubt when I wrote the book.”
I got into a very brief argument on the Tiptree Motherboard
Twitter feed with a troll (with no previous history of posting) who stated
unequivocally that Sheldon was nothing more than a common murderer. I
countered that while John W. Campbell was a serial offender in life, Alice Sheldon
should not be condemned forever for one desperate and tragic choice.
Even moreso, the name “James Tiptree, Jr.” and the meaningful
and influential fiction that was presented under that name has transcended the
life of the author. I believe that the award cannot be what it is, a
celebration of the exploration of sex and gender roles in fantastic fiction
without that name attached to it.
On 2 September, the Tiptree Motherboard issued a lengthy
statement covering the controversy and stated that a name change was not in the
offing. Two days later they, issued the following clarification:
We’ve seen some people discussing this statement and saying we’re refusing to rename the award. Of course it’s easy to read what we’ve written in that way; our apologies. While this post focuses on the reasons why we have not immediately undertaken to rename the award, our thinking is ongoing and tentative, and we are listening carefully to the feedback we are receiving. We are open to possibilities and suggestions from members of our community as we discuss how best to move forward. You can contact us at email@example.com.
So, at least for the foreseeable future, The James Tiptree Award will remain as it is.
Our last person of interest is Hugo Gernsback, an immigrant
from Luxembourg who founded the 1926 magazine Amazing Stories, the very
first publication completely devoted to publishing science fiction (which he
originally dubbed “scientifiction”). Through it, he also created the “Science
Fiction League”, a club whose members published letters in the magazine and
corresponded with each other eventually met in person, thus creating the first
wave of sf fandom and conventions.
But before Amazing Stories, Gernsback was better known
as a publisher of all sorts of other publications. He was notorious for not
paying his contributors very much (or in some cases, not at all) and his
business practices were seen by many at the time as very shady or outright
As author Barry Malzberg once wrote:
Gernsback’s venality and corruption, his sleaziness and his utter disregard for the financial rights of authors, have been well documented and discussed in critical and fan literature. That the founder of genre science fiction who gave his name to the field’s most prestigious award and who was the Guest of Honor at the1952 Worldcon was pretty much a crook (and a contemptuous crook who stiffed his writers but paid himself $100K a year as President of Gernsback Publications) has been clearly established.
The very next year, the Science Fiction Achievement Awards
were first given out at the11th Worldcon in Philadelphia. And despite his
scurrilous reputation, people began to nickname this new award, “The Hugo”,
after him! And I have no doubt that this just tickled his fancy up to his death
at the age of 83 in 1967. The name became so universally used that by1992, it
was officially codified into the Constitution of World Science Fiction Society.
I am amused that some people are showing some genuine outrage
that the most prestigious award in sf is named after such a scoundrel. And not
because I think it’s a bad idea. Oh no, on the contrary, this might be a GREAT
idea whose time has come.
All these pundits have to do is come up with a name to
replace “Hugo Award”. Something that has a consensus of fandom behind it. A
name that can be protected legally by the World Science Fiction Society. And…
A name that will have to endure at the very least, four or
five years of committee studies and formal Business Meeting debates,
amendments, substitutions and serpentine votes.
To those who wish to embark on this fool’s errand, I wish you
all the luck on this Earth and all of its known (and unknown) alternate
versions as well.
In any event, fame and legacies are all fleeting and a fool’s
deepest desire. All that really matters in life in the long run are your
family, friends, memories and knowing that you tried to do the right thing and
the best you can under the circumstances.
My advocacy of new categories for the Hugo Award will
probably be my legacy. And I’m hoping for more. But It is my hope that my work
will not stand and that others will study, deconstruct, demolish and build on
the ashes of my efforts.
I hope a new Best Dramatic Presentation category is even more
expansive and inclusive. The Editing category should formally include
anthologies and author collections. Manga should definitely be included in the
description of the Comics and Graphic Story category. And a Best Translated
Novel award (or, at least a test of such a category) should be inevitable and
welcomed, not feared.
If I had to single out one of the greatest moments in my life
in fandom, I could tell you exactly when it happened, the night before the 2012
Hugo Awards Ceremony at Chicon 7.
My partner Juli and I were hanging out in the Hyatt Regency
bar overlooking Michigan Avenue when we were approached by a woman and her
partner. She said she sought me out to to thank me personally for working so
hard to establish the Best Graphic Story category in which she was a nominee
that year. I, in turn, congratulated her on the nomination and wished her the
best of luck.
And the next day, Ursula Vernon won her first Hugo Award for her graphic omnibus, Digger. She did not thank me on stage. She didn’t have to because she already had.
It is always better to give than to receive. And I have
always strived to create the possibility to give the highest award we have to
the most deserving creators. And that is all I have ever wanted.
I now KNOW which flatmate is the culprit who has been reversing
the direction of toilet paper in our flat. To preserve whatever goodwill we
have built up between the visiting fans and the Republic of Ireland, this
person shall remain unnamed. But the information has been forwarded to the
local Garda. And Interpol.
Speaking of which, I am very glad that none of the natives noticed
that the pants I purchased at Costco that I’ve been wearing during our stay
were manufactured by…English Laundry.
I was also informed yesterday that hurling was NOT a sport
involving professional vomiting. I was quite relieved to learn this.
I like “Airplane Mode” setting on my phone SO MUCH I’m keeping it
that way from now on! WooT!
Juli persuaded me NOT to wear my Wakanda University t-shirt over
my regular shirt today. Because technically, I’m on a diplomatic mission.
It’s TRUE: Fan Writing is cheaper than therapy! Just Sayin’…
On our last day in Ireland, I woke up thinking about baseball.
More specifically, baseball pitchers.
Of all the players who play baseball, it could be argued that the
pitcher is the single most important and the most vulnerable parts of the game.
Important because the game cannot function without them and vulnerable because
the human arm is not exactly designed to throw a baseball for any length of
The rule book on baseball pitch consists of only two words: Throw Strikes.There
are countless volumes of scholarly studies and critiques have been written on
how this might be accomplished.
Those pitchers who do manage to hang on for twenty years and
remain effective at some level are an extraordinary group of athletes who
deserved to be lauded and revered.
I am not exactly comparing myself to that elite group but I do
note that 2019 marks my twentieth year of being involved with and pitching (see
what I did there) my amendments, arguments and strategies to the World Science
Fiction Convention’s Business Meeting.
In the last few months before Worldcon 77, I had been evaluating
how I felt and what I should do next. And like a veteran pitcher at the end of
their career, I ultimately came to the conclusion that my arsenal has been depleted and I have
essentially lost my effectiveness to proceed any further in this capacity.
The past few years have not been easy for me; my mother and father
have died, the years long struggle to get a Young Adult Book category going was
draining on an emotional level, I had to abandon the attempt to attach Ursula
K. Le Guin’s name to the YA Award due to my doubts about winning any support
for it at the Business Meeting and my own impatience led to me offer an
amendment for a test of a Best Translated Novel even though the Hugo Study
Committee appointed by Business Meeting recommended it be discussed for another
I have been persistent, stubborn and tenacious in the past but
after twenty years of cajoling, persuading, compromising and grinding away
making legislative sausage, I was yearning for a new set of challenges and
And after the way things went down after the first two sessions of
the Dublin Business Meeting, it became quite evident that I had come to the
After the Business Meeting was officially adjourned
on Saturday, I made a point of going up and bidding a formal farewell to some
of the WSFS Business Meeting members I respect the most, Donald Eastlake III,
Linda Derenoff, Kevin Standlee and Vince Docherty, telling each of them that I
will not be offering any for proposals for future consideration nor would I
likely to be very active (unless I’m just there to vote on an issue that I
seriously support) at future sessions of the WSFS Business Meeting.
Here’s the thing: when I initially started getting
involved with the Business Meeting twenty years ago, I was doing it an everyday
fan who wanted to make sure that films, television shows and other forms of
media were given a somewhat level playing field when competing in the awards
After that, I found that I quite haphazardly
stumbled into being an advocate of change. My mission became seeking solutions
the inequities in the Editing Category and fighting to see the creators of
comics/graphic stories and young adult authors get the recognition they richly
deserve from our community.
I did so not to become more influential, to become a
fannish insider or be famous. I did this because I revere and honor the Hugo
Award and I wanted to see them stay fair, equitable and most importantly,
relevant to our times.
In order to achieve these lofty goals, I had to
become more of a public face for these ideas. In doing so I acknowledge that I
have, in some circles, I have been perceived as an ambitious social climber who
stepped on people’s toes and rubbed them the wrong way.
So as willingly as I have accepted the allocates of
what I have done, I also unflinchingly take the criticism. Let the literary
critics, historians and anthropologists hash out what happened because it
doesn’t matter to me right now and certainly won’t after I am dead and gone.
On August 25th, I will be turning sixty-three years
old. This past June, I celebrated my forty-third anniversary in fandom. Having
spent the first twenty plus years amassing friends and the latter twenty
becoming inadvertently well-known, I now take my leave.
To the members of the Business meeting and the SMOFs
mailing list I say this: I thank you for your advice and patience. Your
vigilance in protection of the Constitution and the Hugo Awards has been long
and admirable. But your seeming officiousness, proof of worthiness, over
reliance on years and years of committee studies are your weakness. These
things scare and alienate fans from engaging in the process. I implore you all
to be more intuitive and take more risks and chances, especially with those who
come before you for the first time.
I find it simply astounding (pun definitely intended) that the people who
champion a branch of literature that is dedicated to exploring and expounding
on scientific, psychological and emotional change, act in such a hidebound, conservative
manner and are seemingly determined to see that some fannish things remain the
To you, the members of this community who
contemplating going to the Business Meeting or are loath to spend any amount of
your precious Worldcon time attending these long, laborious meeting; if you do
not approve of what is happening at the World Science Fiction Convention or
with the WSFS Constitution and the Hugo Awards, there is no substitution for
GETTING INVOLVED!. There are a lot of things I regret; not learning how to
become a switch hitter in softball, learning to play a musical instrument or
becoming bilingual. But all of the time I spent in the Business Meeting was
well spent. So go down to your independent/used bookstore or online and get a
Roberts Rules of Order and jump into the action. If you don’t, you haven’t any
damned right to bitch about what is going on.
As for myself, I walk away proud of what I have
accomplished. I have left it all on the field as they say in the sports world.
In the last year or so, my activities in the Business Meeting have become too
much of a distraction to some of the more important things going on in my life
But don’t think that you won’t be hearing from me
any more, you’re not getting off that easily. I am going to be writing my File
770 column for the foreseeable future and on my Facebook page and my Twitter
account as well.And there are other long gestating writing projects outside of fandom that will occupy a
great deal of my time as well..
But the MOST important thing in my life is caring
for my three-and-a-half-year old granddaughter, Lillyann Virginia. She loves me
as the day is long and give her mine. Her wants and needs are more important
right now than anything I have ever done at the WSFS Business Meeting. Lillyann
is my future and she is yours as well.
The future is happening right now.
It always has been.
The day began in splendid fashion; the sun was
shining with a few fleecy clouds in the sky. Good flying weather. Juli and I
wished we had more time to see this wonderful country we have come to love
these past eight days but our time was up. We had packed our humongous suitcase
the night before so we were all set to depart.
Our flight was scheduled for 12:55 p.m. and United
Airlines told us before we left that while US Immigration and Customs had a
station inside the airport to aid passengers headed for America, we were advised to get to there AT LEAST three
hours before departure time.
Well, unless we are traveling to or from a major hub
domestically back in the US, Juli and I usually take this piece of advice with
a gigantic, choking grain of salt. Little did we know…
We said our goodbyes to our flatmates Peter and Anna
around 9:30 a.m. We walked around the corner to the transit station and
purchased two bus tickets to the airport. Our first mistake was not heading to
the main drag we knew very well to find the 747 bus route stop, but to wander
further into downtown Dublin to find another one.
As we walked along I spotted a bookstore. I stopped
to stare and then picked up my pace.
“What’s the matter?”, Juli asked.
“Just keep walking,” I said. I had to concentrate on
getting home, not shopping. Hard choices.
After asking directions (a few times, because,
accents, theirs and ours) we finally found the bus station. While we were there
we came across a few European fans headed to the airport as well. One woman had
a very interesting patch on her jacket that I really liked, so I asked her
permission to take a photo of it.
We were also approached by a tall panhandler with a
foreign (not Irish) accent came up asking for spare change. We kindly rebuffed
him because we had no Euros left (and he looked rather sketchy to boot).
After he wandered away, a well-dressed woman came
over and said, “It’s good that ye didn’t give ‘em anything.”
“Why is that?” Juli asked.
“Because most of them come over here and they
receive more benefits here than they do where they came from.’ she explained in
a patient but slightly irritated voice. “Most ’em are either drug addicts or
As the woman walked away Juli and I exchanged a
look; this was the first person we had come across since we arrived that had
shown any sort of negativity towards anyone who wasn’t Irish. I can only hope
that she was among the minority here.
The double decker 747 bus finally arrived around
10:30 and it was packed to the gills with travelers. We were among the last in
line. Juli was becoming worried. “I’m beginning to think we should have taken a
taxi,” Juli said. I tried to remain optimistic; we were still two-and-a-half
hours from our flight time. Still…
When it was our turn, the driver looked at our
tickets and said, “Sorry mum, these aren’t the right tickets.” Juli explained
that we had gotten them from the station and they were clearly marked for
transport to the airport.
“But mum,” he said with the resignation of a man who
probably dealt with tourists everyday. “these tickets are from a different company
altogether. I can’t take ‘em.”
NOW, I began to worry.
“But sir, we already paid fifteen Euros for these
“Can we exchange them for the right tickets inside
the station?“ I asked.
By this time, there were grumbling comments from
some of the passengers and the five people still waiting didn’t look all that
“All right,” the driver said, taking the tickets and
giving a small jerk of his head. I dragged our suitcase aboard and stood in the
main aisle with Juli. Somehow, all of the other passengers squeezed on board
behind me and the bus lurched out of the station. We were packed and there was
no stopping between there and the airport.
The bus arrived at Terminal Two around 10:45. Still
plenty of time, I thought. We made a beeline to the United check-in counters,
which were sandwiched in between the Emirates and American Airlines. Luckily,
there were only two people ahead of us and no one behind us.
About a minute later, several hundred people
arriving off of fleet of shuttle buses DID line up behind us. Timing is
everything. Sometimes it’s the ONLY thing.
We stepped up to the station and placed out bag on
the scale as the attendant checked our passports and printed out our boarding
passes. Our suitcase weighed in at 24.9 kilograms and even though I was lousy
at converting that weight to pounds (54.8951 pounds to be exact), I got a
sinking feeling we were over the weight limit.
“I’m sorry but your bag is too heavy,” she said in a
kindly, but reproachful tone. “You will have to take something out.”
Juli looked at me expectantly. Since I packed it, I
knew exactly what to pull out. I took the suitcase, unzippered the main flap,
reached inside and pulled out exactly what we needed to lighten the load; our
two Worldcon souvenir and pocket program books. I hoisted it back on the scale
and presto, 22.9 kg.
From there we took an escalator one level up to the
Irish security area. These was a line here, too; a serpentine one that
consisted of 13 long rows of stanchions and cloth tape that led to four
separate doors with guards motioning people through to another area.
Staying together, we were shepherd into the next
room where there were four more lines where bags and people were being scanned.
As we were inching through our line, I saw a familiar looking hat out of the
corner of my eye. I turned around and exclaimed, “Jo Walton?”
An lo and behold it was indeed my acquaintance, the
Hugo and Nebula Award winning author, in the company of fellow author Ada
Palmer (winner of the 2017 John W. Campbell Award and the victim of the
horrible closed captioning nightmare at the Hugo Awards Ceremony) and her
partner, Lauren Schiller.
After everyone was introduced to one another, Jo
exclaimed, “We’re off to Edinburgh!” Upon learning I was doing a con report for
File 770, Ms.Palmer pressed leaflet outlining her latest project, Worlds of Welcome, an international
effort to raise money for refugees in conjunction with the Refugee and
Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services (RAICES).
In an explanation on her website (http://www.exurbe.com),
Ms Palmer writes that RAICES main goal is, “… to help those in the camps on the US side
of the US-Mexico Border, by organizing
online auction of items donated by the F&SF community: signed books,
craft items, fanworks & merchandise, custom fiction, editors willing to
give query critiques, or members of underrepresented groups willing to give
sensitivity reads to in-progress fiction.
We hope the auction will run in October.
We are currently soliciting donations of items for the auction, and a
few more people to help organize it. If interested, please email us at: WorldsOfWelcome@gmail.com.”
for donations is September 30th and auctions will be held from October 1st
through the 15th.
As our lines moved apart we all wished each other
luck in making our respective flights.
After passing through the Irish security area, we
strolled into a brightly mall of duty-free shops, filled with stuff we could
not possibly get into any of our carry on bags. Following a series of American
flags with arrows, we arrived at the entrance to the US Preclearance – Customs and Border
Patrol (USCBP)…and found yet another, long and crowded passengers waiting in
line to have their carry on bags inspected. AGAIN!
It was now
12:15 p.m. We were close but I it was getting close to the time
to board our plane.
The lines were
so backed up that some of the immigration agents were paging over the
loudspeakers or shouting out cities and flight numbers, scrambling to go
through the lines to pull out passengers for flights imminently leaving for
Chicago, San Francisco and Philadelphia.
It was in this line that we saw Philadelphia area fans Joni and Todd Dashoff
and a new friend, Abie Eke, whom I first met at the descendants from African
Todd and I
passed each other so many times that when we finally made it through the
inspection and were respectively putting our shoes, I turned to him and said,
“I’m tired at looking at you, too!”
“I got tired of
looking at you when I first saw you here,” he retorted with a laugh.
“I’m beginning to think that the convention was just one big
practice session to wait in line at the airport,” Juli groused when I caught up
When we finally were called to a station to be
questioned, our inquisitor was a dead ringer for Nick Nolte with exceptionally
He asked the usual litany of questions; did we have
anything to declare, did we have any food or vegetables in our luggage or carry
on bags, did we do any work while in Ireland? We answered no to all of these
“Nick” then took our boarding passes and passports
and had us step onto a set of footprints a few feet in front of his station and
asked us to stare into a scanner as he compared our faces to the images on the
After a few moments of staring at our innocent
American faces, “Nick” gave a slight, laconic nod of his head said, “Thank you.
Enjoy the flight home.” And with that, we walked swiftly towards the United
On the way through the terminal, Juli said, “Look, a
dead people walker.”
It was indeed, several dozen yards of non-moving
walkway. “Yeah, that one is for zombies only!”
Juli just rolled her eyes and said, “Yeah, so
When we got to our gate it was just about 12:45 p.m.
but they had not started the boarding process. Apparently, when our boarding
passes were printed, and the delays in the lines were noted, our departure time
was adjusted as well, thank goodness.
Waiting in line were a virtual galaxy of fannish
stars; Jim and Laurie Mann of Pittsburgh, former Worldcon Chair Deb Geisler
from Boston, editor Scott Edelman from West Virginia and the Hugo Award winning
fanzine editors, Nikki and Richard Lynch from Maryland. Jim Mann told me that
there were probably between twenty and thirty fans from Worldcon headed home on
We settled into our assigned seats in the aisle and
across from each other. Juli sat next to a young couple, I sat next to two
We took off only twenty minutes late with a flight
time of 7 hours and forty-five minutes. Everyone around me pulled their shades,
once again denying me a view of the Atlantic Ocean.
After a while, I was pondering when I might try to
sleep in order to take the edge off some of the inevitable and dreaded bout of
When we reached cruising altitude, the deployment of
the beverage cart soon followed. I had a regular Coke since both Juli and I had
skipped breakfast during our various adventures earlier in the day.
After drinking it, the older gentleman spilled water
on his tray table, narrowing missing the paperback book he was reading. As I
helped him clean up the spill with my napkin, I got a good look at the book was
reading; a paperback copy of an Adam-Troy Castro novel, The Third Claw of
“Hey,” I exclaimed, “I know that writer!” The reader,
Sylvan Oppenheimer of Baltimore, was startled that I knew the author. And yes,
both he and his older brother Izzy sitting next to him attended the Worldcon
and had a wonderful time. Izzy also has good taste in writers; he was reading
one of James H. Schmitz’s Telzey Amberdon collections reissued by Baen Books.
Both men had gone to Worldcons before but this was their first time going
overseas to attend one. They both reported that they had a splendid time.
I tried to get in a few hours of sleep as we headed
westward, five hours into the past. It took me a day or so to recover coming
over and I had no doubt that my body’s circadian rhythm was going to take a
beating coming back. I picked up United’s in-flight magazine, Hemispheres,
and saw that the cover story was titled, “Three Perfect Days in Hong Kong.” I
thought about what was happening there at the moment; the citizens who were
being harassed and beaten on a daily basis for demanding their rights and
freedoms that were supposed to be guaranteed by law. I put the magazine back,
As I have grown older, I have come to dislike
watching movies or television shows up in the air. My usual routine is to
sleep, write or shifting my brain into iPod mode, recalling my favorite songs
just from memory.
On the other hand, Juli plunged right in and watched
two movies back to back; The Best of Enemies with Taraji P. Henson and
Sam Rockwell followed by The Hummingbird Project, a financial thriller
starring Salma Hayek, Jesse Eisenberg and Alexander
When I woke up, I got a look outside of Izzy’s
window; we were over land again, somewhere along the east coast. As we made our
final approach, I noted the overcast skies and some ominous flashes on the
We landed at Dulles twenty minutes late at around
5:45 p.m. and just in time; there were several lightning strikes near the
tarmac as we pulled into the gate.
All of our luminaries had departed by the time we
emerged into the terminal. When we arrived at our gate a short
distance away, the skies opened up a massive thunderstorm was in progress. More
lightning strikes closed down all of the ramps. I checked the radar at
weather.gov and saw that the current storm was going to pass through quickly but
there was another storm front fifty miles to the west and headed directly
While we were waiting, Juli pointed out that the
designation of a nearby gate, C-4, was problematic. Maybe they should ban that
gate number permanently, just as the 13th floor is conveniently omitted from
most hotels. Just sayin’…
As our flight was about to be called, I reached over
to my right to retrieve my fedora from the seat next to me, only to suddenly
stop when I realized I had almost picked up a orthodox rabbi’s wide brimmed
black borsalino. Fortunately for me, the rabbi was facing the other way and
never noticed the move. My hat was on top of my shoulder bag in front of me.
As the storm moved out, there was a rush to get as
many flights into the air as possible before the next storm front arrived. Our
flight was called and we were given the rare treat of actually walking out on
the tarmac to our plane, which had an old fashioned airstairs leading up to the
Just as we had gotten strapped into our seats, the
next storm front arrived with additional lightning strikes, once again closing
the gates before our luggage had been fully loaded onto the plane.
During the hour-and-a-half delay, we were served
repeated rounds of soft drinks, water and cookies. I checked my email and
Facebook accounts and was pleased to see that Jeannette Ng’s Campbell speech
was getting a lot of coverage in fannish circles and in the mainstream media as
We finally took off after the storm front passed and
we were finally on the last leg of our trip. When I remarked that this had been
one remarkable Monday so far, she corrected me; it was actually Tuesday! Did I
mention earlier that time travel was hard? It is very hard. On your brain.
Thankfully, the one-hour trip was unremarkable. The
landing in Dayton was a little rough but Juli and I exchanged a happy look as
we taxied to the terminal.
Our lone suitcase came down the luggage carousel
almost immediately. As we exited the building to flag down the shuttle, the
song playing over the speakers was Duran Duran’s 1983 pop hit, “Union of the
“Well now, situation normal,” I remarked dryly. Juli
gave me a ‘whatever’ eye roll.
The shuttle dropped us off at our car and we were
soon on our way down I-75. Darkness had fallen and the skies were clear. I
turned on the radio and the Reds were in the late innings of game with the San
Diego Padres, leading 3-1. The Reds ended up winning 3-2.
And when the final out was recorded, Marty
Brennaman, the Hall of Fame announcer of the Cincinnati Reds sealed the victory
with his most famous catch phrase, “And This One Belongs To The Reds!”
At that moment, we knew we were truly home again.
(These reports are dedicated to the memory of my
late parents, Alice and Erbil Barkley and also to the recent passing of our
dear and loving neighbor, Lillian Feld.)
M. Barkley: Author’s
Note: This column is being written on the day after our return from Ireland.
Because, time travel. AND jet lag.
I received a text from John and incredibly, Carole’s wallet was FOUND with
all of the contents intact. I immediately spread the news on the Dublin
2019 Irish WorldCon Community Group and on my own page. I hope the details
on who found it and where it was lost will be forthcoming. Needless to
say, there was much rejoicing in the land this day!
has a taxi service called FreeNow, which, I have come to discover, is
neither. I was considering filing a suit with the World Trade Organization
but HEY, Carole’s wallet was found, so forgetaboutit…
flatmates nor myself have turned on the tv since we’ve been here. And
we’re good with that.
flatmate Peter has sadly informed me that Hurling is a sport that does not
involve vomiting on a professional level. I told him I was very relieved
to hear this because the programmers at Fox Sports do not need any
I do regret
not getting to John Scalzi’s incredibly danceable DJ session Saturday
night. It probably would have annoyed him if I had pestered him all night
requesting Manchester (UK) bands like The Stone Roses, The Smiths, 808
State, Inspiral Carpets, Swing Out Sisters, Simply Red, Oasis, The
Chemical Brothers, Electronic, The Mothmen, The Mindbenders, The
Buzzcocks, Joy Division, The Charlatans, The Happy Mondays, New Order,
Elbow, The Fall, The Courteeners and The Drones but not Bauhaus. Don’t get
me wrong, they’re a great band, but from Northampton. Sorry.
people of color and of alternate and non-conforming genders dominated the
Hugo Awards for the umpteenth year in a row. Bravo. There must have been
much squealing of horror from the basements of cis-gendered nerd boys last
evening. White men had dominated fantasy and sf awards for decades so I am
not feeling too sorry that other folks are in the ascendance right now. I
am reminded of what Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was asked in
2010, “How many women would be enough on the Supreme Court?” She replied,
nine… There have been nine men there for a long, long time, right? So
why not nine women?”
I began the day solo because Juli had been hit with a double
play of a sinus infection and a migraine brought on by the raising and lowering
of the house lights during the Hugo Award Ceremony. As such, she remained in
bed for most of the day.
Both Juli and I had one big regret out trip; that we hadn’t had time to very
much sightseeing beyond the city. But, as I was walking about the city and
looking at all of the people from different countries, cultures and languages,
all working and living in this big, bustling cauldron of humanity felt like a
more worldly, more cosmopolitan city than my own home town. I was both humbled
and awed by the city of Dublin.
As I was crossing the drawbridge, I saw an older woman of
indeterminate heritage, sitting off to the right side of the walkway with a
dixie cup of with a few coins in it.. I stopped in front of her.
Several weeks ago, while looking through a grocery trash can
for losing lottery tickets (which could be redeemed for state lottery prizes),
I saw a gleaming flash coming from the bottom. I reached in and pulled out a
one Euro coin. My thought was that it was brought back to the US by a tourist
and was used to rub lottery scratch off tickets and was either accidentally or
deliberately thrown away.
But here I am, an American with an honest to god Euro and I
was going to an honest to god country in the European Union. Right there and
then, I vowed to make sure that this little Euro went home where it belongs.
And there I was on the bridge. I took that Euro and another
coin out of my wallet. I leaned over and she smiled and held her cup up. “ I
found this coin my country,” I said to her as I put the coins in her cup, “and
I am just returning it to its home.”
The woman gave me a broad smile and said something that was
unintelligible to me but to me it felt both grateful and heartfelt. I wish I
had given her more but the only thing I had left at this point in the trip were
a few American bills, which would have been problematic for her to exchange. I
walked on, hoping for the best for her. When I returned later, she was gone.
There was a Sunday session of the Business Meeting but I
decided to skip it for reasons that will become very clear in my final
I checked the schedule of remaining items and there was
nothing of interest as far as I was concerned. So I made a beeline for the fan
exhibit/dealer’s room. I had only been through the room once before and since I
had a limited amount of space and weight allowance for our one suitcase and I
wanted to buy at least one thing while I was in Dublin.
Joe Scilari, Edie Stern and Boston superfan Mark Olson were
manning the Fanac.org table and they proudly informed me that over 3500
pages of information had been uploaded to be archived, a tremendous success for
If you are unfamiliar with Fanac, their website says:
“This site is devoted to the preservation and distribution of
information about science fiction and science fiction fandom. There are
fanzines, photos, and all sorts of strange and wonderful information about
So, check it out sometime.
While making my way to the New Zealand bid table, I wandered
too close to the Chicago in 2022 table and was beckoned over by Dave McCarty,
who was sporting the most garishly red Grateful Dead shirt I have ever seen.
Mr. McCarty specifically called me over for the expressed
purpose of explaining, in passionate, excruciating detail, why the US Women’s
Soccer team was being wrongheaded in their approach to their lawsuit against
FIFA for equal pay.
I will not go into detail about what his arguments were (if
you were to contact him directly, I am quite sure he would be MORE than happy
to lay out all of the evidence for you) but I conceded that he may have a
point, which seemed to satisfy him (for now). And before you all label Mr.
McCarty merely a sexist “mansplainer”, I want you to know that he is the father
of a daughter and he desperately WANTS them to achieve to goal of being paid on
an equal basis as the men’s team.
I also had the good fortune of being present when Mr. McCarty presented his
lovely eight-year-old daughter, Mia, with her convention gift, a replica
version of Hermione Granger’s wand.
My next stop was the CoNZealand table where I checked on the
price for a pair of supporting memberships. One of the staff members (whose
name, unfortunately, I did not record) was utterly delighted to see my “Saint”
symbol button and told he about how she obtained a rare copy of the original
Leslie Charteris novel Meet The Tiger and how she was lucky enough to
get it autographed by the late Sir Roger Moore!
Speaking of which, I had my phone out to check on my Paypal
balance when I was approached by a fan named, wait for it…JAMES BOND, who
asked me for some help finding a program item on Dublin’s online Worldcon app,
“One moment please,” I said as I put my phone down and
reached into my crossbody bag for the printed pocket program book.
“Here you go. I’m analog today, not digital.” Mr. Bond got a
good laugh out of that remark. For the record, I did NOT expect him to
die…laughing. Just Sayin’.
When I finally got around to shopping the dealer tables, I caught sight of a
book that I was very interested in; Farrah Mendelsohn’s The Pleasant
Profession of Robert A. Heinlein, a deep, unflinchingly and critical
look analyzing his fiction and non-fiction and how he influenced science
While I was buying the book, I was reunited with my fellow File
770 reporter, Daniel Dern. We were also joined briefly by one of Dublin’s
Special Guests, Spider Robinson and his “driver”, writer and comedian Stephan
Herman. Spider had trouble remembering me until I reminded him that I had
scored some pot for him and his late wife Jeanne at the 1994 Worldcon in
Winnipeg, Canada. Ah good times. Also, yay for the statute of limitations.
Spider told me he had a fantastic time in Dublin and was very
excited to sit down with a local genealogist while he was there. “ I have
learned more about my family in that one hour than I ever did from the rest of
my family during my life,“ he gushed.
I went back to our flat to check on Juli around 3:30. She was
feeling well enough to go to the Closing Ceremonies at 4:30, but I wanted to
take a short nap myself.
This decision proved to be a bad idea because Juli, thinking
that I wasn’t getting enough sleep on this trip, let me sleep in until
We rushed to the auditorium but the ceremony was already
under way and we arrived in time to see George R.R. Martin and his partner
Parris McBride on stage, accepting a Committee Award from Chair James Bacon for
his contributions to Fandom and the Dublin bid in particular. I was saddened to
see Ms. McBride in a neck brace and I sincerely hope she recovers soon.
I was surprised and happy to see that Dublin had recruited
the creator of Artemis Fowl, Eowin Colfer, as the Host of Closing Ceremonies.
Soon enough, Mr. Bacon took to the stage to thank the convention committee, his
staff and volunteers and finally the fans who attended, to make it a memorable
experience for everyone.
Memorable? Indeed it was, But I can assure everyone reading
this that the Dublin convention will be studied, scrutinized and autopsied more
closely than any other recent Worldcon due to the cutoff of the sale of
attending memberships weeks before the start of the convention, the size of the
venue, the imposition of queuing lines by the owners of the convention center
and the confusion they caused between the staff, volunteers and the attending
fans. But, it’s Worldcon. It’s a certainty that things WILL go wrong and there
will be some embarrassments and obstacles to overcome. People may have
been angered over some incidents and inconvenienced by others but in the long
run, the only thing that matters is that everyone survived and no one died.
Having gone the 29 Worldcons now, I can attest to that).
After the gavel was symbolically passed to the New Zealand
bid via interpretive dance and acrobatics, Juli and I headed over the The
Drunken Fish for a celebratory dinner with Wyn, Liz, our flatmates Anna and
Peter and our Australian fans, Susan and Grahame. As usual, I ordered too much
food but, in the spirit of detente between the US and Ireland, I finished it
all. Except for the extra helping of kimchi someone passed my way. There
is only so much kimchi a person can take, I mean, c’mon man.
Wyn and Liz had been in country for nearly a week
before everyone else arrived and took an extended driving tour of Ireland,
visiting many castles along the way.
“Were any of the castles white?,” I asked Liz, who, thinking
of the ubiquitous American fast food restaurant chain, broke out into a
As a matter of fact, we did see a white castle,” said
Wyn in a very serious manner.
“Really?” I turned to Liz. “How was the food?” Liz collapsed
in uncontrollable laughter. Mission accomplished.
After dinner was consumed, we said goodbye to our dinner
companions The flatmate squad then called a cab and traversed over to the
southside of Dublin for a whiskey tasting at The Market Bar, the nicest looking
hole-in-the-wall that I have ever seen in my life. Since I don’t drink spirits,
I drank in the atmosphere and watched grown adults swoon over whiskey. Good
It took five tries but we were finally able to summoned a
FreeNow cab (which, as I noted above, is neither) and we made our way back
While the flatmates recovered by chatting about their
convention experiences, I began packing for the flight home, which was
scheduled for 12:55 local time tomorrow.
As always, United Airlines advised us to get to the airport
at least three hours in advance of the flight. Juli was particularly
worried about getting there early but hey, when we’ve flown in America,
the wait time was usually a bogus ruse to get us there and buy stuff while we
The John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer has been presented at the Worldcon since 1973, two years after Campbell’s death. The 47th winner was Jeannette Ng. Will there be a 48th? Many are responding to her acceptance remarks with a call to change the name of the award.
Although voting is administered by the Worldcon, the award belongs to Dell Magazines, publisher of Analog. It was named for him because Campbell edited Astounding/Analog for 34 years and in his early years at the helm he introduced Heinlein, Asimov, and many other important sf writers, reigning over what was called by the time of his death the Golden Age of SF. That cemented his legend as a discoverer of talent (regardless that in later years he passed on submissions from any number of talented newcomers incuding Samuel R. Delany and Larry Niven).
Jeannette Ng’s speech was exactly the speech our field needs to hear. And the fact that she devoted the bulk of it to solidarity with the Hong Kong protesters is especially significant, because of the growing importance of Chinese audiences and fandom in sf, which exposes writers to potential career retaliation from an important translation market. There is a group of (excellent, devoted) Chinese fans who have been making noises about a Chinese Worldcon for years, and speeches like Ng’s have to make you wonder: if that ever comes to pass, will she be able to get a visa to attend?
Back when the misogynist/white supremacist wing of SF started to publicly organize to purge the field of the wrong kind of fan and the wrong kind of writer, they were talking about people like Ng. I think that this is ample evidence that she is in exactly the right place, at the right time, saying the right thing.
… When Ng took the mic and told the truth about his legacy, she wasn’t downplaying his importance: she was acknowledging it. Campbell’s odious ideas matter because he was important, a giant in the field who left an enduring mark on it. No one disagrees about that. What we want to talk about today is what that mark is, and what it means.
… You can claim the John W. Campbell Award without revering John W. Campbell, or paying him lip service, and you can criticize him, based on what you see of his track record and your interpretation of it. The award is about the writing, not about John W. Campbell, and that is a solid fact. If a recipient of the Campbell Award can’t do these things, or we want to argue that they shouldn’t, then probably we should have a conversation about whether we should change the name of the award. It wouldn’t be the first time an award in the genre has been materially changed in the fallout of someone calling out the problems with the award’s imagery. The World Fantasy Award was changed in part because Nnedi Okorafor and Sofia Samatar were public (Samatar in her acceptance speech!) about the issue of having a grotesque of blatant racist HP Lovecraft as the trophy for the award. There was a lot of grousing and complaining and whining about political correctness then, too. And yet, the award survives, and the new trophy, for what it’s worth, is gorgeous. So, yes, if this means we have to consider whether it’s time to divorce Campbell from the award, let’s have that discussion.
Now, here’s a real thing: Part of the reaction to Ng’s speech is people being genuinely hurt. There are still people in our community who knew Campbell personally, and many many others one step removed, who idolize and respect the writers Campbell took under his wing. And there are people — and once again I raise my hand — who are in the field because the way Campbell shaped it as a place where they could thrive. Many if not most of these folks know about his flaws, but even so it’s hard to see someone with no allegiance to him, either personally or professionally, point them out both forcefully and unapologetically. They see Campbell and his legacy abstractly, and also as an obstacle to be overcome. That’s deeply uncomfortable.
It’s also a reality. Nearly five decades separate us today from Campbell. It’s impossible for new writers today to have the same relationship to him as their predecessors in the field did, even if the influence he had on the field works to their advantage….
…Ng’s assessment of Campbell is undoubtedly informed by Campbell’s personal politics and beliefs and those who have written about him. Campbell argued that African-Americans were “barbarians” deserving of police brutality during the 1965 Watts Riots, as “the “brutal” actions of police consist of punishing criminal behavior.” His unpublished story All featured such racist elements that author Robert Heinlein, who built upon Campbell’s original story for his own work titled Sixth Column, had to “reslant” the story before publishing it. In the aftermath of the Kent State massacre, when speaking of the demonstrators murdered by the Ohio National Guard, Campbell stated that “I’m not interested in victims. I’m interested in heroes.” While difficult to presume where Campbell’s beliefs would place him in modern politics, it is apparent that Campbell would disagree with many of the beliefs held by modern America.
Ng’s speech unsurprisingly caused backlash and outrage among some members of the literary community, with some claiming that Ng should have withheld from insulting the man whose award she was receiving.
…I was one of the people madly cheering this speech. I posted a meme on Facebook as she was still speaking: “Jeannette Ng is AWESOME!!!!!” Moments later, swept up in the moment, I posted another meme, “I’m just gonna say it: The Name of the John W. Campbell Award SHOULD BE F***KING CHANGED!”
To clamor atop a soapbox for a moment; NO, I am not advocating that the life and work of John W. Campbell, Jr. be scrubbed from history. But neither should we turn a blind, uncritical eye to his transgressions. When the winners of such a prestigious award start getting angry because the person behind it is viewed to be so vile and reprehensible, that ought to be acknowledged as well….
For a brief period a few years ago, my byline was prominently associated with the John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer. This was not because I’d ever won such an award, or even appeared on the ballot (I was never a nominee), but rather because I assembled anthologies for the purpose of showcasing new writers during their two-year window of eligibility, as an exercise in public awareness of writing that, despite potential merit, might not have received sufficient reviews to garner an audience among the Worldcon membership at large.
In that context, someone asked me to defend Campbell because of the acceptance speech given by this year’s recipient.
This was an uncomfortable request. The more I’ve learned about Campbell over the years, the more certain I’ve become that I wouldn’t have even wanted to share an elevator with him, much less try to sell him a story… and I say that despite having learned any number of his storytelling and editing techniques by way of hand-me-down tutelage….
Amazing Stories’ Steve Davidson was
mainly concerned that Ng’s remarks were bad for the brand – i.e., Ng mistakenly
identified Campbell as an editor of his magazine instead of Astounding/Analog.
…A couple of days ago we watched and updated our post covering the 2019 Hugo Awards; we were a bit surprised at Jeannette Ng’s acceptance where she made some connections between fascism in the SF field, fascism in the US and the events taking place in Hong Kong right now. Hong Kong is Ms. Ng’s home base and we are absolutely and completely in sympathy with her and the protesters who are braving arrest, and possibly worse, as they try to maintain their freedoms.
We entirely missed the misattributions of Ms. Ng’s speech; what she wanted to do was identify John W. Campbell Jr., the editor of Astounding Stories, as a fascist. She ended up naming Jospeph Campbell as the editor of Amazing Stories….
I am sure she is tired, chuffed, overwhelmed and, perhaps even a bit embarrassed over having misnamed Campbell and the magazine he was associated with in front of an audience and a community that knows this history without even thinking about it.
But the internet being what it is, disrespect for facts being what they are these days, I can not allow the idea that John W. Campbell – racist, anti-semite, fascist, misogynist, whatever – was associated with Amazing Stories to go unchallenged….
Ng has issued a correction:
Swedish Fan Ahrvid Engholm today
sent two fannish listservs copies of a complaint he has filed with the Dublin
2019 committee that Ng’s speech violated the convention’s Code of Conduct.
…One may wonder what a Code of Conduct is worth, if it isn’t respected by those who have all eyes upon them on the big stage, during the highlight of a convention, such as the awards ceremonies witnessed by thousands.
I therefore want to report, as a breach of the Code of Conduct during Dublin 2019, the intimidation and personal attacks in Jeannette Ng’s Campbell Award speech, of which the very lows are wordings like:
“John W. Campbell…was a fascist” and he was “setting a tone” she claims “haunts” us as “Sterile. Male. White.” glorifying “imperialists” etc.
“Everyone involved with Dublin 2019 is expected to show respect towards…the various communities associated with the convention. …Dublin 2019 is dedicated to provide a harassment-free convention experience for all Attendees regardless of…gender…race…We do not tolerate harassment of convention attendees in any form” /which includes:/ * Comments intended to belittle, offend or cause discomfort”
Most if not all would find being called a “fascist” offending, surely causing discomfort.
And it’s especially deplorable when the person belittled this way has passed away and thus can’t defend himself. It is reported that John W Campbell’s grandson John Campbell Harrmond was present at the convention that branded his grandfather a “fascist”. John W Campbell was the leading sf magazine editor of his era (of Astounding SF, not Amazing Stories as this far from well-founded speech said) and have many admirers who also have cause to feel offended. If you like Campbell, the claim he is a “fascist” surely splashes on you too – you’d be “fascist sympathiser”.
Ms Ng continues to harass whole categories of convention Attendees, those who are “male” and “white”. They are “sterile” and the negative “tone” claimed being “set” in the sf genre. It must be noted that the CoC is explicitly against slurs regarding race and gender. (And in these circumstances “white” indicates race and “male” gender.) The CoC further says it won’t be tolerated “in any form”, which surely must also include the form of a speech from a big stage.
It is too late now do do anything about this regrettable episode, but those making reports are asked to state what they would like to happen next. What I simply want is to get it confirmed that the event reported indeed IS a breach of the CoC, because that could be important for the future.
–Ahrvid Engholm sf con-goer since 1976 (of Worldcons since 1979)
Scott Edelman supported Ng in several comments, describing his deep unhappiness with some of Campbell’s opinions at the time the were originally published 50 years ago. He also quoted this anecdote from the autobiography of William Tenn / Phil Klass:
Damn it, why didn’t I pack a pair of blue jeans? I mean, blue colored blue jeans? It would have SO matched the shade of blue of my Samuel R. Delany t-shirt. Ah, so it goes.
The weather this morning was brilliantly good. And then came the rain squalls. I had such high hopes. Is this what makes the Irish, Irish?
In case anyone was wondering, my identifying pronouns at the Business Meeting were HE, HEY YOU and THAT GUY.
I am convinced that one of my three flatmates is a cultural saboteur; for several days now I have placed the toilet paper in the bathroom to roll from the top, only to turn late and it’s been reversed. I have vowed to discover who the culprit is BEFORE I LEAVE THIS ISLAND! Enough said.
Speaking of the loo, my first encounter with toilet in the apartment was startling to say the least. As I flushed, an epic Angel/Niagara/Victoria Falls torrent of water crashed into the bowl, scaring me out of my wits. I sure hope that’s all greywater and not the drinking sort.
Juli and I saw our good friends Robbie Bourget and John Harrold on
the tram this morning. They were headed to the Business Meeting to hear the
announcement of the Site Selection team of the winner of the 2021 Worldcon bid.
They looked remarkable happy at that moment so I suspect that they were either
not working or their jobs were completed and they were enjoying themselves…
The meeting started promptly and, as expected, Washington D.C. was
the overwhelming choice with 798 votes.
The 2021 Worldcon has been dubbed DisCon III and will be held from August 25 (MY BIRTHDAY, WooT!) to August 29. The Guests of Honor are author Nancy Kress, Baen Editor in Chief Toni Weisskopf, Uber Fan Ben Yalow, with Special Guests Malka Older and Sheree Rene Thomas. Co-Chairs Bill Lawhorn and Colette H. Fozard promised that an Artist Guest of Honor will be announced at a later date.
The runner up results in themselves were whimsical and amusing in
None of the Above 18
Minneapolis in 73 3
Tampere in 2032 in 2021 3
Peggy Rae’s House 2
Rapid City, South Dakota 2
Xerpes 2010 2
Any Country That Will Let Me In 1
Anywhere NOT in the United States 1
Beach City 1
Boston in 2020 Christmas 1
Free Hong Kong 1
Haimes, Alaska 1
Helen’s Pool Cabana 1
I5 in ‘05 1
James Bacon’s Living Room 1
Laconia Capital City, Laconium Empire 1
Malmo, Sweden 1
Port Stanley, Falklands 1
Ratcon in 2002 1
One of these days a joke bid is going to win and there’s going to
be trouble. I must also say that as an American, I was surprised that there
weren’t a lot more protest votes against the DC bid considering our, let’s say,
turbulent political situation at the moment. The mere thought of the current
president showing up unannounced is a logistical and political nightmare none
of us want. But, we’ll see, I suppose.
Worldcon 76 convention Chair Kevin Roche presented pass along checks of $10,000 (US) to the con-chairs of Ireland (James Bacon) New Zealand (Norman Cates) and Washington. This generous donation was done despite the pending litigation brought against Worldcon 76 by Jon Del Arroz, who filed a lawsuit alleging defamation after being banned from the event.
Mr. Roche promised that more funds would be distributed to current
and future bid when litigation has been concluded.
In other news, the group backing an amendment to establish a Best
Game or Interactive Experience category suffered a minor setback when the
members of the meeting voted to refer the legislation back to the Hugo Study
Committee for another year discussion.
This was done in spite of a fairly extensive 60-page report
compiled and written by the group sponsoring the category. I spoke to one of
those sponsors, Claire Rousseau and several others who were there to see the
outcome. They were all extremely upset that this proposal would not be
discussed in a formal debate for at least another year or more.
As a personal aside, I told them that I had been on the receiving
end of these sorts of setbacks on numerous occasions and while they may be
feeling disappointed right now, they should should remain vocal and more
importantly, persistent, if they feel they have a just cause.
Mark Richard’s advisory motion to also issue an award to translators of Hugo Award winning works was also soundly rejected by the attending members. After the vote Mr. Richard, was approached by Jo Van Ekeren and Joni Brill Dashoff with some helpful suggestions on how to make the proposal clearer and more palatable to the members who opposed it.
Profound disappointment does not even begin to describe how I felt
about this, but I will refrain from editorializing about this until my final
By a fortuitous coincidence, my final Worldcon panel, “Get Us Out
of the Twilight Zone: the Work of Jordan Peele,” was scheduled right after the
Business Meeting in the same room. My panelists were media critic and Abigail
Nussbaum (who won the 2017 Hugo Award for Best Fan Writer), Dr. Andrew Butler,
a distinguished film critic from the UK and Dr. Wanda Kurtcu, who organized the
POC meetup the previous day.
Looking through my bag, I could not find the placard with my name
printed on it, which we were supposed to keep and use at each panel. Luckily, I
found a folder filled with name placards and not only found one with a blank
side to write on, I also picked up an autograph as well.
Over the course of our hour, we took an in depth look at Mr.
Peele’s first two films, the Academy Award winning horror film Get Out
and Us, a more overtly ambiguous fantasy film. I believe that while Us
is a more ambitious movie, Get Out had an edge in being my favorite
because of its straightforward and take no prisoners narrative.
Doctor Butler had not seen the first season of the revival of The
Twilight Zone so when the other panelists and I discussed the episodes we
were a little diligent not to drop too many spoilers for him and the other
audience members. Doctor Kurtcu pointed out rightly that Twilight Zone,
like the original Rod Serling series and other shows like Black Mirror, darkly
reflect what is going on in the world today.
Ms. Nussbaum, like myself, were not really ardent fans of the
horror genre but it seems as though Jordan Peele has a true artistic vision to
express that is striving to transcend the usual boundaries of genre.
Towards the end of the session, an audience member said that Mr.
Peele’s next project was a reboot of the Candyman film franchise.
“All right,” I said. “We all know what to do. NONE of us should
say Candyman three times before the film is released.”
We appeared at the Press Room office a little before seven to pick
up a lanyard for Juli so she could attend the Hugo Award Ceremony. We were
delighted to find out that some of the press passes had not been claimed so now
she could sit with me in the designated area. (This is not unusual; when I ran
the Press Office, there were occasions where passes had not been picked up and
I issued them to late arriving reporters or convention staff members who wanted
a seat closer to the action.)
While we were waiting to be escorted to the press section, I came
across UK author Paul Cornell, who I had not been in close proximity to since
LAcon IV in 2006. I was particularly delighted to see him because he wrote one
of my favorite Doctor Who stories of the modern era, the Hugo-nominated
episode “Father’s Day”.
The Press section wasn’t that close to the action this year; it
was located in the first three rows of the upper balcony just to the right of
the center of the stage. What it lacked in proximity was made up for by its
height, which provided a sweeping view of the stage.
The first big surprise of the evening was the winner of the John
W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer, Jeanette Ng. Not surprising that she had
won the award, because she is an exceptionally fine writer and was favored in
this category. Oh no. It was because of what she said in her acceptance speech:
John W. Campbell, for whom this award was named, was a fascist. Through his editorial control of Amazing Stories, he is responsible for setting a tone of science fiction that still haunts the genre to this day. Sterile. Male. White. Exalting in the ambitions of imperialists and colonisers, settlers and industrialists. Yes, I am aware there are exceptions.
But these bones, we have grown wonderful, ramshackle genre, wilder and stranger than his mind could imagine or allow.
And I am so proud to be part of this. To share with you my weird little story, an amalgam of all my weird interests, so much of which has little to do with my superficial identities and labels. But I am a spinner of ideas, of words, as Margaret Cavendish would put it.
So I need (to) say, I was born in Hong Kong. Right now, in the most cyberpunk in the city in the world, protesters struggle with the masked, anonymous stormtroopers of an autocratic Empire. They have literally just held her largest illegal gathering in their history. As we speak they are calling for a horological revolution in our time. They have held laser pointers to the skies and tried to to impossibly set alight the stars. I cannot help be proud of them, to cry for them, and to lament their pain. I’m sorry to drag this into our fantastical words, you’ve given me a microphone and this is what I felt needed saying.
<do the hat thing>”
You can see that “hat thing” (eventually) on YouTube or the
streaming broadcast online.
I was one of the people madly cheering this speech. I posted a
meme on Facebook as she was still speaking: “Jeannette Ng is AWESOME!!!!!”
Moments later, swept up in the moment, I posted another meme, “I’m just gonna
say it: The Name of the John W. Campbell Award SHOULD BE F***KING CHANGED!”
To clamor atop a soapbox for a moment; NO, I am not advocating
that the life and work of John W. Campbell, Jr. be scrubbed from history. But
neither should we turn a blind, uncritical eye to his transgressions. When the
winners of such a prestigious award start getting angry because the person
behind it is viewed to be so vile and reprehensible, that ought to be
acknowledged as well.
I think work and legacies of film director D.W. Griffith and H.P.
Lovecraft have survived fairly intact since they have been deprived of their
privileged status. And that is precisely the point; for decades JWC’s white
privilege has given him cover to be adored by generations of readers, writers,
editors, fans and scholars. The time has finally come to call him out.
Jeannette Ng said out loud what people have been either thinking
and whispering for the past several decades. Rebecca Roanhorse’s speech last
year in San Jose alluding to her discontent was the tipping point. Ms. Ng just
picked it up and threw it over the edge. (Climbs off soapbox.)
Other momentous moments included Charles Vess double whammy for
Best Professional Artist and the Special Category addition for Best Art Book,
both for his meticulous and detailed art for the gigantic omnibus, The Books
of Earthsea: The Complete Illustrated Edition. Becky Chambers’ Wayfarers
won Best Series, a dizzying ascension for a writer who only had a draft
version of her debut novel five years. She tearfully thanked her supporters,
readers and the Hugo voters for making “room for her at the table”.
The Best Long and Short Form Dramatic Presentations went to
popular front runners; the former to the Oscar winning animated film Spider-Man:
Into the Spider-Verse and the latter by “Janet(s)” an excruciating funny
episode of NBC’s farce/philosophy seminar The Good Place.
There was a lot of criticism that the Lodestar Award (or, as I
call it, The Ursula K. LeGuin Memorial Award) either would not be very popular
at all or might suffer from “award fatigue” by Hugo nominators in general
reading community. Well, the statistics posted online after the ceremony show
that there were 216 nominated books on 512 ballots. So, as far as I’m
concerned, you can stick a fork in that theory, because it’s done.
Best Profession Editor went to the late Gardner Dozois. I must
report that I did not vote for him; he was a fine person, a marvelous writer
and one of the greatest, if not THE GREATEST, editor we are ever likely to see.
But, I note, he had won fifteen Hugos for editing between 1988 and 2004. Now
his estate has another award that he will never know of or enjoy. It’s fine for
us to honor the dead, but not at the expense of the living.
Best Novel went to Mary Robinette Kowal’s The Calculating Stars,
an alternate history story in which the 1950’s suffers a cataclysmic event and
the “space race” is reframed is an actual struggle for the survival of the
human race, led by women astronauts. I hope that this book, and its sequels,
will not only endure but inspire future generations of young adults and
A PDF of the voting results and nomination longlists are available
We headed to Martin’s after the ceremony and almost immediately
ran into Carole’s partner John. He told us that the wallet had not been turned
in yet and everyone is presuming it is lost for good. Credit cards have been
canceled and other friends have offered other help, too. Carole was there, enjoying herself and John
reassured us that she was feeling a lot better since that night. We were rather
concerned so it was nice to see that she was having a good time.
John also said, “Hey got get a drink at the bar. DC is paying for
all of the drinks on their tab!”
I feigned confusion. “Your mean DC Comics?” John gave me one of
those resigned looks he make after hearing a bad joke. “Go get a drink,” he
shouted over the din.
We got into the nearest queue but the DC tab had already been
tapped out so we had to resort to buying our own drinks. Hugo Admin Nichols Whyte sidled up to the bar
and in a burst of American generosity, we bought him two ciders, citing his
fine work for the con.
As we were ordering our own ciders our, I was accosted by an older
man standing next to me, whom I thought was a complete stranger. But it wasn’t;
Jerry Kaufman was a fan we had met previous at the Spokane Worldcon. “So,” her
said, “what are you proposing for the name change?”
Now it was my turn to be genuinely confused. “Excuse me?”
“I heard some people talking about it. It was your Facebook post.”
With that I sat down and whipped out my phone and checked the post
I had completely forgotten about from two hours ago. While it had not gone
exactly viral, it had several “likes” and who knows how many views.
While I sat and posed for a few pictures with my friends, I
suddenly realized that I was drinking this cider on an empty stomach, which
meant that I was going to be incredibly tipsy in the next five or ten minutes.
I told Juli about my dilemma and after some chit chat with some
friends in passing, we bade everyone good night. We stepped into a chilly and
damp night. The walk back was bracing and kept me on my feet as we walked back
to our apartment.
After fumbling to check the Facebook post and send my esteemed
editor a brief, spell check enhanced email, I fell into bed, and, according to
Juli, was asleep in two minutes.
P.S. DAY FIVE BREAKING NEWS! I am incredibly PLEASED to report that Carole’s wallet was turned in to the local police station today, WITH THE CONTENTS ALL ACCOUNTED FOR!!!!
Carole and John have already left Dublin for a tour but will be returning to the city on Friday recover the wallet.
Who’s says there are no Happy Endings at Worldcon? A big THANKS to the local citizens and the Dublin Garda for your diligence in this matter…
I have been hearing that these reports are being widely read
favorably reviewed. It’s been quite a while since I have tried to write, much
less report, on a daily basis. For this, I am quite grateful.
For those of you wondering, I usually get up before my partner and
flatmates to write. I make a scalding cup of tea, fire up the tablet and start
pecking away. It’s a little strange for me to have the BBC News playing in the
background instead of my usual source, National Public Radio but I have no
I also try to keep up with my beloved Cincinnati Reds while I’m
here. My birthday is on the 25th and all I want is for the team to break even
at the .500 mark. Also, Astrides Aquino IS REAL. If you’re a baseball fan,
google him. You will be astounded.
Many people have complained about the lines for events and the
size of the convention center. Well, this may not be the Worldcon we want but
it is the Worldcon we have. I have it on good authority that these restrictions
were imposed by those who run the center, not the Dublin Worldcon Committee. My
advice to attendees is to embrace to moment and enjoy the experience of a
Worldcon in this marvelous country.
When I made the decision to do a daily report, I quickly became
aware that I could not report on EVERYTHING going on, especially panels. So
what I am attempting to do is give you, the reader, an exciting personal
overview of what’s happening here and I hope it inspires those of you who haven’t been to a Worldcon
the incentive to attend and get active in fandom.
I am quite certain I am the only one here with a Justice League
animated series cap. At least, pretty sure.
As of this post, Carole’s wallet has not been found. We remain
hopeful that it will turn up before the convention ends.
Please, please, PLEASE, do not send me any saltpeter!!!!! I’m
The day began with the Main Session of the Business Meeting. I
won’t bore you with the details of everything that was argued over (and if you
ARE interested, a video of all of the sessions will be posted on YouTube after
I do want to report on one exception: one of the items passed on
from yesterday was a recommendation from the Hugo Study Committee for a minor change in the Graphic Story category
changing the title to Best Graphic Story or Comic, clarifying and expanding for
nominators what might be honored in the category.
There were objections from some of the BM members that the change
really was superfluous and not needed. As one of the originators of the
category, I spoke at the podium to state that speaking for myself, it was
always my intention to include “Comics” in the title.
Rene Walling, the 2009 Worldcon Chair was highly involved in the
establishment of the category and when there was a fierce debate about what the
title should be, offered the current title.
It was ironic that he rose to object to the name change because it
did not include manga. Mr. Walling, who was quite involved in the establishment
of the category and had persuaded his committee to invoke the Special Award
clause in the WSFS Constitution to award a Hugo as a test at the Montreal
Worldcon in 2009.
Mr. Walling made a compelling argument (including statistics and
chart) to include manga but his proposed amendment was defeated. When asked,
Mr. Walling was undeterred and told me that he hoped to re-introduce the
measure at the New Zealand Worldcon next year.
Mark Richards sense of the meeting proposal to advise future Hugo
Administrators to give translators of a winning work with a Hugo was introduced
at the meeting and will be taken up in the Sunday Session, time permitting.
After two and a half hours of making sausage (which is available
online on YouTube), the Business Meeting mercifully adjourned. Juli and I were
hungry and spotted a very nice Asian fusion place across from the Spenser Hotel
called J2. Juli had the chicken stir fry udon and I had the seafood udon soup,
with a side of calamari rings.
We were seated across from two writers from America, Troy Carrol
Bucher, a retired thirty-year veteran of the US Army and Nick Martell, a young
writer from Pennsylvania. Both have new novels coming out this month; Mr.
Bucher’s second novel is called Lies of Descent, an epic fantasy novel
from DAW Books and Mr. Martell’s debut book is The Kingdom of Liars, is
being published by Saga Press. Both men were excited to be in Dublin for the
Worldcon and were very engaging lunch companions.
On our way back to the convention center, we stopped at the
intersection right before a drawbridge. Waiting to cross on the other side the
street was super fan Mike Wilmoth. At this point, I want to point out that the
city of Dublin has clearly marked the streets with dire warning to LOOK BOTH
WAYS and LOOK TO THE LEFT and RIGHT. These warns are not for the natives but
the tourists, many of them Worldcon members who are not natives, so they are
not placed in dire straits by the unfamiliar surroundings. Mr. Willmoth bravely
glanced in all directions and upon seeing nothing in the immediate vicinity,
then boldly strode across the street just before the light turned green for the
rest of us.
“Way to go, Mike! That’s confidence, jaywalking in a foreign
country! WELL DONE, SIR, BRAVO”, I shouted at him. He accordingly cracked up. I
would have high-fived him but the crowd was too big.
My three o’clock panel was not exactly a panel but more of a
meetup. The official title was The People of African Descent Meetup. It was
moderated by UK based fan Russell A. Smith and the Dr. Wanda Kurtku of the San
Francisco Bay Area. I had some difficulty getting to Wicklow Room Five because
the crowd minders had declared the corridor leading to the room as filled to
capacity. The only way I got through was by frantically waving my Program
I neglected to count the number of people there but I would
guesstimate that there were at least twenty people of color all gathered
Now, I have to admit that I have never been a fan of the concept
of “safe spaces” mainly because I’m almost sixty-three years old and toughed it
out this far without it and getting quite curmudgeonly lately (but only because
I’ve been hanging out with David Gerrold too much, but I digress…)
But now, having experienced a “safe space”, in the company of such
fine, eloquent and intelligent people, I finally get it.
This is not an act of self segregation, as I had originally
thought and feared since I had first heard of the concept, but one of
representations, mutual acknowledgement and empowerment.
Mr. Smith pointed out an obvious example of how people of color
acknowledge each other in public, by eye contact, a knowing smile and a nod of
the head in passing. Not only has this happened to me on many occasions in the
United States throughout my life, but many times here during my stay in
We arranged our chairs into a circle, introduced ourselves and
gave a capsule history of the way we fell in love with fantasy and sf or how we
found our way into fandom and conventions.
My friend Maria from Baltimore and I were two of the oldest fans
in the room, she went to her first convention in 1974 and I in the summer of
1976. I casually dropped that the Dublin Worldcon was my 29th, a factoid that
drew a few gasps in the crowd.
We had people representing Europe, Africa, the US and the
Caribbean island nations. Also among us was one of the 2019 Hugo nominated
editors of FIYAH Magazine of Black Speculative Fiction (whose name I
unfortunately forgot to record). Several people chimed in that they’d given his
magazine their first place votes in the Best Semiprozine category which made
him extremely happy (and nervous, because he might be called upon to make a
speech Sunday evening).
When the group was asked how can we better support each other, I
spoke up and said please read this column on File 770.com and PLEASE
feel free to comment. I jokingly refer to myself as the Senior Black
Correspondent at File 770 and I was not quite sure that I was the only black
writer. My good friend Pablo Manuel Miguel Alberto Vazquez chimed in and said,
“Yeah Chris, you’re pretty much it.”
The hour we had together ended far too soon as far as we were all
concerned. We all signed a notebook with our email addresses for future
After standing in two queues and collecting two lanyards for the
Masquerade, Juli and I retreated to the apartment so I could finish writing up
Day Two’s events. At around 4:30 p.m., I suddenly felt very, very tired. So I
laid down for a quick nap, waking up around sixty minutes later feeling a bit
better, if not totally refreshed.
While Juli was taking some time to read, I left the apartment and
took a short walk to the East Restaurant attached to the Spenser Hotel to find
the File 770 meetup. I did this for two reasons; a) to prove to the
readers of this column that I was capable of FINDING a Filer meetup and b)
getting in my Fitbit steps.
The dinner meetup was in full swing when I got there and I was
meeting many of them in the flesh for the first time. Hampus Eckerman
introduced himself and told me that Juli and I had gone to the right place but
the Filers were tossed off of the third floor by the queue minders at around
6:30 and had moved to the Martin Hoare Memorial bar one floor down. Oh well.
Since I was trying to meet a self-imposed deadline for filing Day
Two, I bid them farewell after fifteen minutes but not before I took pictures
of the two tables, because, you know, pictures or it didn’t happen.
Juli had dinner waiting for me upon my return. As I wrote and
edited, she informed me that Memphis (Tennessee, not Egypt) had announced a bid
for the 2023 bid, headed up by Kate Secor and Cliff Dunn. She then read a
transcription of some of the Q & A from the Fannish Inquisition, which were
quite interesting and worth your while to look up.
Best of Luck kids; like all Worldcon bids, you’re going to need
On our way to the Masquerade we made the acquaintance of Stephan
Herman of British Columbia, a professional comedian who is moonlighting as a
joke writer for Dublin. Resplendent in a zoot suit jacket, he regaled us with
his various observations of the convention as we rode the tram.
I have posted pictures from the Masquerade on my Facebook page for
your viewing pleasure. (www.facebook.com/chris.barkley).
Usually, I have eschewed going to this particular item BUT since I am covering
the main events of this Worldcon, I felt obligated to go. And I was so glad I
Juli did not have a full pass for seating in the Press Area so I
went down to the on the main floor on my own which she was seated elsewhere.
Worldcon 76 Chair Kevin Roche was the Masquerade director and ablly
hosted by Ric Bretschneider.
I am not a noted critic of costumes per say, but I can tell you
that if there is a video of the show available, you should go out of your way
to see it. In particular, I want to draw your attention to the very final entry
of the evening, an awesome, show stopping display of technical skill, bravado
design and magnificently breathtaking execution. When it finished, there was NO
DOUBT in anyone’s mind which entry was the overall best in show.
No, I will not describe it. Look at the pictures on my Facebook
wall or google it. You won’t be sorry.
Although I did not stay for the entire “halftime show”, I was incredibly
entertained by Mr. Bretschneider’s
ingenious game show, PowerPoint Karaoke.
Each victim, er, ah, contestant, is placed on stage facing the
audience and viewing a screen displaying images, which are also projected for
the audience as well. The object of the contest is to make a cohesive narrative
from the random pictures which would be switched at any point of Mr.
The first victim, Hugo nominee Mary Robinette Kowal, made a
brilliant historical parody of the US Space program and never flinched at any
of the ridiculous images thrown at her. She received a resounding cheer as she
What Chris Garcia lacked in coherency, he made up in shouting and
goofy noises much to the delight of the crowd. The aforementioned Mr. Herman
also delivered a show stopping performance, combining comic timing and an outrageous
impersonation of a late night QVC television huckster selling lifestyle
After all that, it was downhill all the way. I was fast asleep as
soon as my head hit the pillow…
Correction: The author misspelled the name of Milk Willmoth’s name as Mike
Willmont. We honestly can’t regret it because it’s funny as hell. Just
(Note to Mike, leave the name “Milk” in there, let’s see
if he notices…?)